Carly Smithson - Total Eclipse Of The Heart - Top 10

[justschr]

She's shouting! OMG this version is awful!

[DemonSlayer2121]

You always wanted to be a POP star? Be like Madona? Then why did you go all goth and do rock music...

[Li5021]

I love how she sings this song it even beats Bonnie

[cheetahtje4]

She has a powerfull voice, chapeau

[gatarharo]

I LOVE HER!!!!!!!!

[woolfallcrescent170]

we are the fallen rule!!!

[gotjumpedyet]

@woolfallcrescent170 MUHAHAHAH LOLOOL WE ARE THE FALLEN ............................AU­TOBOTS ROLL OUT

[bkcase]

she can hit high notes, but her pitching is very unstable....

[mariedodd]

I still think Carly was one of the all time favorites over the past 10 seasons! She should have made it to number one! She is one of the best performers AI ever had! Hope her career is going well. What a great talent!!!!!!!

Marie

[TheWOLFLORE]

0:54 ....SO CUTTTTTEEEEE!!!!!

[jaycewheeled]

Madonna? Kylie Minogue? Come on, as far as voice is concerned they can't stand the comparison (with all the respect to Madonna and Kylie, two great artist). I would like to hear them performing this song...don't think they nailed it like Carly did.

[YutaBaby07]

*Highfives Carly* Virgo buddies! :D

[saidik2898]

She does,you are right,she looks very young.

[WeatherHunter]

And she didn't win!? Did she?

[TheMirex80]

WOW YOU HAVE A WONDEFUL VOCE.......WHEN YOU WANT YOU CAN SEE MY VIDEO....I SING THIS SONG.....YOU CAN ENTER MY NAME...MIRELLA REGINA........

[arturesteve]

Cool story about her name, she definitely does it honor!

[sweetdane22]

wow!amazing carly!i love her..my idol:-)

[thebeatleslover108]

she does remind me of kelly clarkson.... so amazing!!!!! and i love her irish accent so kool!

[tightmike14]

her voice is amazing. she should have won

[michellemoh75]

Love this!!!

[bewbewboom]

HER MOM IS HOT.

[mistyeyedlass]

wow. i love carly!

[xtinalamb]

OMG i just can't stop listening to Carly★ and I love her accent, so fucking sexy!! ♥

[Rotewwdlo]

sorry but i just hate her voice. :/

[ShaulHaShablul]

amykoto how old are you? if you got to live enough years you probably know that if in your childhood you wanted to be for example a fireman there is NO chance you'll end up as one.

[amykoto]

hahahaha!! She wanted to be like MADONA????? This is the proof of how much FAKE she is!!! Shamefull........

[SaiphMcKey]

@amykoto The only SHAMEFUL (one L) thing is when you criticise with incorrect spelling here. And MADONNA (double N), omg, her name should be known enough to you. What kind of critic are you! Sucker.

[viciouscanadianvixen]

@amykoto ...A LOT of people want to be like madonna and with good reason. it doesn't make them "fake" and it definitely isn't "shameful". madonna can't be duplicated, however, her achievements in the music industry can. i'm a HUGE madonna fan, however, vocally, she isn't spectacular-she just knows how to sell it and entertain to make people enjoy the music.

[arturesteve]

@amykoto Name me ONE artist who came to fame during the late 90's - 2000's who didn't dream to be like Madonna when they were young girls. Bitch, please. And learn how to write (don't bitch if English is not your first language, because it's not mine and I can still write it pretty decently) if you'd like your "criticisms" to be taken seriously. Thank you and get a life. PS: No matter how much you hate on Carly, Amy Lee's never gonna care about you or thank you for hating on her. PEACE.

[0503cat]

i love her curly hair,,haha so cute :D

[TheDistilledMan]

Always a mistake to cover Bonnie Tyler who sounded so distinctive because her voice was physically injured, whatever you do it's always going to be a let down comparatively.

[Neo2906]

man, what a briliant voice. can`t understand that...i think that was the perfect song for her voice. Love it !!!!

Greetz Neo

[gensexercises]

lol im a virgo and actually we dont have a sign.. or a planet.. lol

[starofelo]

I'm gunna be honest- I really really dislike this song. If I ever hear it I change it fast, I just can't stand it.

This version is the first version i've liked! I love it, love her :D

Whyyy did she not win?

[nikaledesma]

she didn't really quite nailed the song. the song is to way high for her. but love her big voice.

[Xchantal87X]

she sings it perfect

i ask myself what is she doing by idols

she dont have to learn to sing:P

[nikaledesma]

yeah she's one of the great singers in american idol ALL seasons.

[CavemanJesus4Life]

Wow Carly's mom looks hot, cos Im into older women, and she looks like Lucy Lawless.

Double whammy Mom & Daughter both look hot

[DelightfulDelirium]

Randy, not a single note was out of tune!! I loved her version of one of my fave songs and I loved that final bit <3 very powerful

[jackson4socks]

Randy needs his ears checked

[raulalalarcon]

she has such a great voice

[bummerboi2]

still a great singer xxxx

[OfficialTheresaCrall]

Good one!

[cbotten106]

Carly's voice on the studio version of this song is pure magic. Seek it out.

[WillowMayin]

loved it.... loved it better then when the person who wrote sings it

[casser26]

hahah "it was quite rediculous!" :P

[anjas1903]

to be honest I like it better then original..

[KenlovesJ]

She is very beautiful...i just can't find why people think she is such a great singer...this is video #3 that i have seen of her and she is not making a good impression...maybe she's one of the people that need songs to fit their voice. I wanna hear how she sounds with Fallen.

[cbotten106]

Really? I'd say you've given her more than a fair shot...time to move on.

[crazyenough1]

it sounds like the original,i just cant beleave it, breathtakeing...

[frazzler9]

no it doesn't... Bonnie has an incredible husky raspy voice.

[whysoserious908]

Damn, her mom looks like she could be her sister!

[gr187]

Her moms a milf..lol

[camillerocks]

I love you!

I love you!

I love you!

I love you!

[miciray]

Oh how I wish that Carly won Idols!! She is truly amazing!! GO CARLY!!!!

[kailuasprtsboy91]

lovee this performance... she has such a strong amazing voice... but i kinna agree with randy... this song was like... weirdly dark.

LOVEEEEE carly, but it was weirddd.. haha run at the end was amazing tho. disagree with randy on that one.

[mileyme4]

she rules at dis song!:D

[redrox4evr]

i live this its one of the best ever!!!!

[cln0rman]

Wow--she was flatting notes all the way through. Needs to pay less attention to melisma and more to pitch.

[dracXinXtheXbox]

great performance...

i just wish she hadn't gotten some of the words wrong

[jkcurry87]

Although her voice was faintly shakey at the start, I think this was one of her best performances. And honestly the last note wasn't really that bad. Just a tiny bit off. GREAT JOB CARLY!

[MusicAdd4ever]

Her highs are a lil weird, I think, but amazing performance!!!

[cbotten106]

Earth signs rule !