Those sexual innuendo puns have been floating around the british isles for centuries. There's also "the nun said to the vicar" for example. Hitchcock was a class act all the way.
Wow, Hitch 30 years young in this film!! People tell me I look a little like him, and I was born one year and one month to the day of his death. If I'm Hitch reincarnated, or even this generations version of Hitch, I need to take a moment as I have a lot to live up to!
@ TroyOi: You make a very valid point. I was gonna be immature, and say Mr. Hitchcock made the first 'that's what she said joke'. However your observation has humbled and put me in my place. Very nice!
You know, you can kinda see how Hitch would have been popular with the ladies back then with his wit and charm humor and obvious confidence (projected if not internal, at least).
Interesting reversal has taken place over the 8 decades since this was made. In 1929, obviously, this dialogue could not have appeared in a Hollywood movie, as it would never get past studio censors. Even if it could, it would offend too large a segment of the national audience. But Hitchcock COULD get away with making the jokes privately.
Today, these "politically incorrect" lines could easily be uttered in a Hollywood film, but to say them privately would invite a sexual harassment lawsuit.
@TroyOi Actually, since it was before the Hays Code really took off, there's a lot of double entendres 'allowed' (get it or you don't type of things I think?) , even in some live shows. But I completely agree.. how the society is upside and going down.
@wabtanker Actually the phrase has been traced back to 1928 appearing in The Saint novels as "the actress said to the vicar." According to wiki anyway.
Saw this for the first time on Paul Merton's programme about AH's early films last night and have now watched this video 20 times since. Anny is indeed adorable. I don't understand why AH says 'but you slept with men'...is he refering to the Alice White chararcter, Anny's 'private' life or what!!??
@RobS1972 He was just shocking/embarrassing her, putting words into her mouth before she could say what she really wanted to say! tsk tsk Mr. Hitchcock!
She can speak accented English, but the role she was playing was an British shopkeepers daughter. This film was originally to be a silent, but sound was just being incorporated into films at that time and the filmmakers changed to make it a talkie at the last minute. That's why the screen test to see if she sounded like an English girl. I assume they didn't think so since another actress' voice was used in the end.
I understand that she does not sound British but she never did a movie in English again.Other actresses have been able to work in a language other than the one they spoke most of their life.I love Ingrid Bergman.
"Hello! This is a demonstration of a talking picture. Notice, it is a picture of me and I am talking. Note how my lips and the sound issuing from them are synchronized together in perfect unison."
That's so funny. I can't stop laughing. Ondra was married to the famous German boxer Max Schmeling. She was an early women-filmproducer. Ondra Films produced comedy icons as Karl Valentin.
This is so funny! Anny Ondra seemed so nice, and she was such a beauty too! Alfred Hitchcock is my absolute favourite director and BLACKMAIL is one of my personal favourites of his. He was a true genius with a great sense of humor!
Yay, 1929 movie outtakes!
Sorry, I mean talkie outtakes!
Seems like it was NEVER too early for funny outtakes.
Atvishees 1 month ago
Mr Hitchcock had a kind of bastard sense of humour, LOL. We surely miss him.
Nostalgico80 2 months ago
0:23 love the way Hitchcock says that. Really makes it sound like his first experience with the 'talking picture'
AERicco 3 months ago
Amazing bit of local history for me, thanks.
dogsdinner20 3 months ago
Well, I am Czech as Anny "I slept with Alfred" Ondrak was, but to me her English here is good enough... or not?
uvitek1 4 months ago
lol is this the first gag reel in the history of talking pictures? <3 Hitch <3
filmidioten 4 months ago
It won't come out right.
terrinisawesome 5 months ago
@terrinisawesome that's what she said.
sosoRAMBO 3 months ago
Gotta love how Hitch's eyes keep going back to the cleavage ;-)
clevershark 5 months ago
Those sexual innuendo puns have been floating around the british isles for centuries. There's also "the nun said to the vicar" for example. Hitchcock was a class act all the way.
jazz4 6 months ago
@jazz4 And don't forget "said the actress to the bishop" :)
yurismir1 3 months ago
Hitchcock here reminds me a bit of Jackie Gleason.
Aqquila89 7 months ago
at 0:35 - say WHAT???
WSenator1 7 months ago
Its not the first, but it was the first recorded.
K3BACON 7 months ago
As the girl said to the soldier. Hehe
kyeboy100 7 months ago
Wow! Anny Ondra was godammed gorgeous.
If I were 80 years older...
Zongooo 8 months ago 3
@Zongooo Pictures of Anny made my life so wonderful...
mdumas43073 7 months ago
but you slept with men? lmao
payless1981 8 months ago
LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLOLOLOLOOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOOLOLLOOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLO ROFLMAO
jaypark97 1 year ago
haha nice
gucci89 1 year ago
Hmm, what i dont understand is they dubbed out her voice during her "talking era" films saying her accent was horrid.
That's horrid?
Id rather hear her voice than oh say joan crawford.
Wiesshund 1 year ago 3
=O
The world's first "That's what she said" That was pretty epic.
Morgotheenslaver 1 year ago 3
Hitch is so cool!
bashbrannigan 1 year ago 2
thats what she said.....awesomeness :D its probably been around long before that though....
FisherStarcraft2 1 year ago
"You have stand here in place or it won't come out right, the girl said to the soldier"
HAHA... Hitch made a funny!" :)
mattman2900 1 year ago
Wow, Hitch 30 years young in this film!! People tell me I look a little like him, and I was born one year and one month to the day of his death. If I'm Hitch reincarnated, or even this generations version of Hitch, I need to take a moment as I have a lot to live up to!
:)
mattman2900 1 year ago
@ TroyOi: You make a very valid point. I was gonna be immature, and say Mr. Hitchcock made the first 'that's what she said joke'. However your observation has humbled and put me in my place. Very nice!
Stephy71487 1 year ago
Wow 1929 the year of the Stock Market Crash!!!!!!
MrDeCorey 1 year ago
my hero...hitchcock he was peeking while saying those lines to her
playmaker2k 1 year ago 5
You know, you can kinda see how Hitch would have been popular with the ladies back then with his wit and charm humor and obvious confidence (projected if not internal, at least).
darkprose 1 year ago
Should have made a film out of this sort of back and forth....hilarious
bernlin2000 1 year ago
Interesting reversal has taken place over the 8 decades since this was made. In 1929, obviously, this dialogue could not have appeared in a Hollywood movie, as it would never get past studio censors. Even if it could, it would offend too large a segment of the national audience. But Hitchcock COULD get away with making the jokes privately.
Today, these "politically incorrect" lines could easily be uttered in a Hollywood film, but to say them privately would invite a sexual harassment lawsuit.
TroyOi 1 year ago 7
@TroyOi Nice observation!
darkprose 1 year ago
@TroyOi Actually, since it was before the Hays Code really took off, there's a lot of double entendres 'allowed' (get it or you don't type of things I think?) , even in some live shows. But I completely agree.. how the society is upside and going down.
MsDeath 1 year ago
@TroyOi
truly interesting, :D
Nikronius 1 year ago
"the tolking picthoia." I love the way Hitchcock speaks!
TheWritingWriter 1 year ago 8
Hitch looks mighty pleased with himself here :-) The cheeky monkey!
clandestineone 1 year ago 5
Her reaction was adorable
MACHZ3RO 1 year ago 5
Hitch and his incomparable sense of humor
rollo131 1 year ago 2
Wow, Alfred Hitchcock is the most amazing person in the world.
undeniability 1 year ago 6
That's what she said
Manojunk 1 year ago
Hahaha, awesome.
moofassa22 1 year ago
Michael Scott the First.
nahedh 1 year ago
Who disliked this video!!???
>:O
FeistyMongoose 1 year ago
Earliest ever that's what she said joke.
Bonzi77 1 year ago
I don't know, I don't think that counts
redconfetti 1 year ago
@redconfetti Oh it counts baby. It counts ;)
FeistyMongoose 1 year ago
Nobody ever thinks of Hitchcock having a sense of humor but he does.
DieZimtzicke 1 year ago
Steve Carell owes a big thank you to Alfred Hitchcock!
Aeolis7 1 year ago 5
I'm going to start saying "as the girl said to the soldier" instead of "that's what she said" from now on.
alfredofilms 1 year ago 26
@alfredofilms lmfao! I was just thinking the same thing! It sounds way more authentic and cooler than that's what she said :P.
TinaB1990 1 year ago
Legendary!
DTOblivion 1 year ago
The First Recorded TWSS, or in this case "as the girl said to the soldier".
outlawv 1 year ago 3
Hitchcock on set of "Lifeboat" in response to crew complaints about Tallulah Bankhead going commando:
“Who do we call? The costume designer? Makeup artist? Or the hairdresser?”
Stannnnnnnnn 1 year ago
My British parents use the expression, "that's what the actress said to the Bishop."
KindaGamey 1 year ago
I think "As the girl said to the soldier" needs to make a comeback!
productofthis 1 year ago 7
@productofthis I agree. Today's "As the choir boy said to the priest" is just wrong.
Rosvolainen 1 year ago
Awesome find, davepattern!
He over-enunciates a bit before the bit...
Still, hearing him say it - especially given the year was 1929 - is shockingly funny and surprising as Hell.
About 3 yrs. earlier, Mae West had been arrested on obscenity charges just for playing a prostitute in her Broadway play "Sex".
Glad to have found your posts!
Thanks!
SFGrrlWonder 1 year ago
Ondra is so adorable in this.
fluentinsilence 1 year ago
this guy just went from 99% percent badass to 100% badass!
NillumNaes 1 year ago 19
@NillumNaes That means this scene makes badass history....
Zlagie 1 year ago 4
Wow she wants to hitch Hitchcock's cock so bad
dogfish00 1 year ago
Team Tippi:P
edmame 1 year ago
I love how the crew loses their shit right after he that's what she saids. GRAMMAR
maniacNF 1 year ago
"As the girl said to the soldier." Wow, first "that's what she said" and even back then it sounded classier.
KANMistry 1 year ago 4
Holy crap this is cool!!!!!!!
tulsaroughnecks 1 year ago
lol whoops sorry
Shaunmccall101 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Terrible acting lol but was this clip just now discovered? It's on the front page of huffington post
Shaunmccall101 1 year ago
@Shaunmccall101 Uh, dude it was a sound test. As you can see by the title, which clearly says "sound test".
StarWarsFanSWF 1 year ago 5
@Shaunmccall101 testing 1-2-3 testing dumbass 1-2-3
productofthis 1 year ago
Good ol Hitchcock!
proceedapathy 1 year ago
Nnnnnnnnnnnthat's what she said!
dafones4real 1 year ago
still making people laugh81 years later!
CallumMack 1 year ago
A complete silent version of Blackmail exists. Where to find it though?
Dannypalin 2 years ago
"you have to stay standing here otherwise it won't come out right... as the girl said to the soldier" LOL Hitchcock INVENTED "that's what she said"!!
wabtanker 2 years ago 167
@wabtanker Actually the phrase has been traced back to 1928 appearing in The Saint novels as "the actress said to the vicar." According to wiki anyway.
dirtius 1 year ago
Comment removed
SuaveTito 6 months ago
Comment removed
SuaveTito 6 months ago
Saw this for the first time on Paul Merton's programme about AH's early films last night and have now watched this video 20 times since. Anny is indeed adorable. I don't understand why AH says 'but you slept with men'...is he refering to the Alice White chararcter, Anny's 'private' life or what!!??
RobS1972 2 years ago
@RobS1972 He was just shocking/embarrassing her, putting words into her mouth before she could say what she really wanted to say.
Insanitiki 1 year ago
@RobS1972 He was just shocking/embarrassing her, putting words into her mouth before she could say what she really wanted to say! tsk tsk Mr. Hitchcock!
Insanitiki 1 year ago
How many times have I watched this; I never tire. I love you still Anny.
leytonorienteer 2 years ago
Hitchcock is the man.
darkprose 2 years ago
Anny Ondra is adorable! And Hitchcock comes across as a funny playful man. Nice video :)
DukeAlba 2 years ago 2
Naughty man, Hitch. I love How Ondra licks her lips while looking at Hitch at the beginning. Naughty!
manferot 2 years ago 2
Anny Ondra was married to boxer Max Schmeling for 54 years until her death in 1987. Schmeling died in 2005 at age 99.
Giuseppe00XA 2 years ago 3
Cool! You know this has a page on IMdB? It counts as it's own movie.
666NO666 2 years ago 4
daft british humour lol
oscarelgy 2 years ago
Anny Ondra can speak English. We had Garbo in the USA who learned English well. Her accent is cute.
TaraMoriah 2 years ago
She can speak accented English, but the role she was playing was an British shopkeepers daughter. This film was originally to be a silent, but sound was just being incorporated into films at that time and the filmmakers changed to make it a talkie at the last minute. That's why the screen test to see if she sounded like an English girl. I assume they didn't think so since another actress' voice was used in the end.
edbermac 2 years ago 4
I understand that she does not sound British but she never did a movie in English again.Other actresses have been able to work in a language other than the one they spoke most of their life.I love Ingrid Bergman.
TaraMoriah 2 years ago
Uhh, Hitchcock just made a "That's what she said" joke....
OhNoItsAlbo 3 years ago 87
It's nice to know he was so jovial and relaxed around his actors when he was younger... :)
blofeld39 2 years ago
:-))))))
true czechoslovakian girl :-)
napajedla 3 years ago
Great clip!!!!!!!!
mattie0218 3 years ago 2
is it Alfred Hitchcook to the left????
anddav507 3 years ago
yes
ThatsGoodTellivision 3 years ago
awesome clip!
Roygbiv04 3 years ago 2
hitchcock looked a bit like graham moffat from the will hay films
j43ms 3 years ago
wow he looks young here
MostHauntedCharmedG 3 years ago
Well, he's 30 here... :)
Skawucheck 3 years ago
Notice how Mr. Hitchcock talks quite a lot like the man in the "Talking picture example." in Singin' in the Rain?
HitchcockMeteyard 3 years ago
"Hello! This is a demonstration of a talking picture. Notice, it is a picture of me and I am talking. Note how my lips and the sound issuing from them are synchronized together in perfect unison."
ac661 3 years ago 4
thats from singing in the rain!
SatineCharm 2 years ago
Excellent as well as funny. I agree: Anny Ondra should have been allowed to voice her own parts.
And I guess it goes without saying that she was incredibly beautiful.
abcstardust 4 years ago 4
Fascinating!!
053bss 4 years ago
That's so funny. I can't stop laughing. Ondra was married to the famous German boxer Max Schmeling. She was an early women-filmproducer. Ondra Films produced comedy icons as Karl Valentin.
cgnbooks 4 years ago
Married after 4 yrs after Blackmail ;) And yes, she had her own career so much wonderful, besides her men...
sexena1999 4 years ago 2
More other English movies besides Hitch with Ondra, please! :(
sexena1999 4 years ago
wow look how young hitch is
HitchcockFan16 4 years ago
Yes, it is a shame that Ondra's voice was dubbed (actually, spoken off-camera) during this filming.
She spoke English perfectly well and should have been allowed to play the part fully.
I've only seen stills of this screen test before. Thank you, dave, for this footage!
Holdenon3 4 years ago
More Ondra please!
xxxrobocop 4 years ago
Yet, despite this "sound test", Ondra's voice was dubbed in the actual film.....
fromthesidelines 4 years ago
This is so funny! Anny Ondra seemed so nice, and she was such a beauty too! Alfred Hitchcock is my absolute favourite director and BLACKMAIL is one of my personal favourites of his. He was a true genius with a great sense of humor!
watcherfilmsinc 4 years ago
If you listen carefully, you can hear the cameraman, Jack Cox, laughing his head off with Hitchcock's prank!
mendoncacorreia 4 years ago
Wonderful! Thanks for sharing this. Let's hope a restored Blackmail sees a release on region-1 DVD soon and includes this priceless artifact.
stuartgardner 4 years ago
Genius himself
konway87 4 years ago 2