Added: 5 years ago
From: SemNick90
Views: 257,543
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (213)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Just got 6 missed calls from and some pretty angry voicemails... From God. He says stop ignoring him and give him his song back.

  • one of the best nights in rock history..

  • played at my mates funeral the other day.. he was in a very dark place before he died but we all know that somewhere up there he's lighting up the sky, shining on like a crazy diamond, playing the music he loved for us all.. taken from us so young but he made such an impact on the world.. this song is perfect for him. i'll miss you so much x

  • Sorry but Tory improvisation is the best, HERE IT SCARES

  • I never seen to find a live version of this song similar to the original.

  • YOGUR DE LOS GRIEGOS

  • This voice is so dry.

  • is it Rachel Fury? she´s so beautifl but sadly this time she didn´t keep the required level of mastery

  • Comment removed

  • Pure horror! That first woman can't sing... What the hell were they thinking when they hired her?

  • In fact, the original version is not possible to repeat. The entire album is great, but this song will forever remain as one of the best things Floyd ever did. Plato used to say that in order to reach the real world, only reason would get us there. No other way. But he conceded two options also. One was love. The other was music. He must have heard this one to have hs mind changed.

  • I can´t listen to this song without miss Clare Torry..she was the best!

  • I have never been able to listen to this song without almost being moved to tears. It's unbelievable.

  • THAT'S AMAZING!! Today, after about 22 YEARS since Delicate Sound video release, I watched this second, alternative, version......full of clips and behind-the-scenes from that day.....THANKS SO MUCH FOR PUTTING IT HERE!!!! Maybe one day we would see all the best of those 2 nights?

  • Wow. I was not there. But I saw this tour a year before, in Auckland, NZ. I'll never forget. The music of the gods.

    

  • Clare Torry version is the best

  • @Thekaisersoze71 that's the point though, no one can ever be the original.... and the women who try and have better tone quality but are so boring. . .

  • /watch?v=tETCC5wCqkY please rate and sub! i sub back!!

  • There are two versions on U tube that knock the spots of this version by a singer called Bianca Antoinette who currently sings for Aussie Pink Ffloyd. In fact I would go so far as to say in comparison this is terrible.

  • @2:21 rachel fury: "shit iv'e used too much emotion and made myself cry.. quick!! some one take over!!" Claudia Fontaine: "k"....... ahhhh ooooohhh whoooaooo raaarghhh!! and so forth...... haha look a flying pig.. literally...... 3:13 shake it... sh sh shake it.. hehe haha.. ohhh how i love pink floyd.. great gig in the sky is THE BEST piece of music EVER! and don't even DARE argue.. I'm right.. think i've drank too much lucozade. damn you stupid drink! ARGGGHHH need more.

  • ME I like her voice, inspite others sing it very very good too; sorry the voices;

  • ME I like her voice, inspite others sing it very very good too;

  • @koto bollocks!

  • Im only upset that I cant turn my computer up any louder

    ...

  • vocals suck ass!

  • 3:16 Oh David

  • Now that was a cracking gig;)

  • J'adore cette version de The Great Gig in the Sky.

  • This will be never again.This Feeling of music, the show... spectacular. Pink Floyd is the best of the best.

  • Comment removed

  • Is that Clare torry?

  • @smashface31 No.

  • Geniuses! :-)

  • I've never wanted so bad in my life. I wish I was there, sadly I was born in 1996. My generation doesn't appreciate real stuff and I'm not just talking about music. They don't see power in art or love. I am so grateful that I found Pink Floyd because their music has got soul and that is what's missing in todays music.

  • @0lica

    I hope its a comforting thought for you that there actually are a lot of people of our generation (im from 1992, and i really love Pink Floyd). You just have to find those people. Becouse even those people are almost forced to listen to todays music ( and there is still hope, not all music you hear on the radio these days is bad.) I Guess what I am trying to say is. You are absolutely not the only one appreciating this kind of music!

  • Best instrumental and lyrics ever!!

  • Deux nuits de folie, un groupe d'enfer , un public exceptionnel. Je fus l'un des trois chauffeur du groupe avec Christophe Y. et Pascal D. ( Service Prestige) durant une semaine et ces concerts à Versailles furent l'apothéose. Merci à Nick, Richard ( + 15/09/2008) et David et toute l'équipe de Lesly Productions ainsi que Dédé Mallet et sa sécurity team.

  • Their best song ever

  • Vocals were a little weaker than the studio version, but still exceptional. This had to be a kick-ass concert...

  • I've been there, the two shows, and for the second one the band ask to their three drivers to got up to the white tente in the middle of the public, to watch the Gig... it's one of the most important moment of my life, after 250 différent concert, in 3 years, this One was incredible... and thank's again to Dave, Nick and Richard.

  • wonderful is great, come to my old memories

  • i was there to, and was and still is the best concert i've ever been with rachels voice it is off on this i actually have the concerts on a dvd and doesn't sound as bad as on here it's a shame as saw them many times on this tour and she did pull it off !still have my sweatshirt from there which i'm very proud of my ticket and huge flag me and mate done which the band took pics of at end fond memories of a lovely summers night !

  • Trucks that looks more beautyful,than actually being one of the band members,/kinnda

  • I was that too. Fabulous concert, the best i have ever been to.

  • Es una de las canciones mas maravillosas que haya escuchado en mi vida. Ni siquiera puedo expresar lo que me hace sentir... Es increible, Pink Floyd es lo mejor!

  • BAD VOICE !!!!!!

  • @hand2gland NOOOOOOOO!!!!! :P

  • @hand2gland

    i agree

  • @petaludia lol its like a cat screaming and its a shame because shes pulls it off in other versions.

  • @hand2gland - Rachel Fury - yup...an off night, but search "The Great Gig In The Sky - Pink Floyd - Live" & you will see her singing this in The Delicate Sound Of Thunder video - may be the best version ever! Although can anyone ever surpass Claire Torrey's original version?

  • I was at this very gig 22nd June 1988 - My first meeting with Pink :)

  • @jansenmann Mine too... :) Forced me to see them in Werchter, Cologne, Wembley, Bercy, etc....still, none of them topped THIS one for atmosphere and spectacle.

    I doubt that anything else ever will....

  • Un très souvenir...J'y étais et jamais je n'oublierai ce concert fantastique. Les Floyds ont joué 2 soirs de suite. Les 21 et 22 juin 1988 devant ce magnique château de Versailles avec en prime un feu d'artifice gigantesque pour le final!

  • an occean of people

  • fabuleux....fabulous !..grand souvenir !

  • What about the one at Nice that one was so good too

  • Rachel Fury murders this song. Sounds like a cat fight.

  • Yup - not her best here - her version on the Delicate Sound Of Thunder DVD is much better - superb in fact - this must be a terribly hard song to sing - very few decent versions out there - no one tops Clare Torry's original.

  • @MrSavedawhales oh yea,check out Bianca Antoinette version

  • ..So where did this footage come from? I know they filmed the 2 concerts they played there,but as far as im aware hardly any of the footage has surfaced..There,s small bits in the 'Delicate sound of thunder' video,theres a few clips in the 'Wired' documentary from 88' maybe some news footage from France at the time,& an audience shot voio from the gig on the 21st,but apart from that....? So anyone know where the hell this surfaced from?

  • It was... at The Chateau de Versailles - Versailles - France. And I was part of the audiance ;-))

    Remember : Chateau de Versailles : Versailles - France ! Friendly and RIP Richard.

  • God speed, Richard.

  • i really didnt like the first singer

  • Pretty but excrutiating. Pretty Excrutiating.

  • I didn't care much for the first vocalist, but the rest was beautiful.  The first singer kind of sounded like my mom yelling at me back in the day, haha

  • i was a point in the crowd.

  • 3rd vocalist is the best in all Pink performance of this song.

  • Yes.  This is the best version so far. Thanks for uploading!

  • WOW!

  • MrOhjames. You will understand as you grow older. If you have the time. I recommend taking a vacation from work, then go to high country with the complete collection of Pink Floyd. Enjoy your Vacation and remember. You don't have to leave home to go on Vacation!

  • this version is simply the best im speachless...the way that asian lady sings at the end all i wonna do is lock her in my basement and let her sing for me all day...

  • surely one of the best song in whole history ^^

  • lol wow

  • this piece is so awesome. always have chills, so full of pain and relief! rachel fury is sooo hottttt. yes?

  • Please god release Live in Versaille on DVD/Blu-ray or whatever!! Was a great tour and the Delicate sound of Thunder video is AWFUL!! Its edited by a child on steriods. Check out the Omni gig on DVD, much better, but not entire gig.

  • Cuantos años llevo escuchando a estos grandes de la música Pink Floyd, mas lo escucho mas me gusta. Descanse en paz Richard Wright

  • que imprecionante¡ viva pink floyd

  • I was @ Versailles in 1988 unbelievable concert would like to have the Floyd tapes of it as it was recorded enrirely by the Floyds camera team.....

  • Linda demais nunca ouvi igual maravilhosa !!!

  • Best part skip to 2:30 onwards.. AWESOME!!

  • and the girls voice your refering to was Rachael Fury but i honestly don't ever remember it sounding that bad and i saw them a few times .

  • Fantastico e suggestivo

  • I was at this concert and remains to this day the best i've ever been to just for atmosphere and and you only have to watch clip to see how beautiful it looks i pray it is released one day as the editing on delicate video was a joke .

  • best part skip to 1:38 and 2:16

  • Grandi!! onore a Tony

  • this voice is genious! this is about dying.

  • Mais c'était à Versailles !

  • 1:39 is just painfull. I love floyd with every part of me and this just hurts to listen too. Clair tory would laugh at this.

  • great video clip but who the hell did they get to do clair torry's part she sounds awful.

  • jesus listen to 1:38!

  • What about at 2:23 she sounds like she's dying?

  • J'y étais le mardi 21 juin 1988, il y avait un autre concert le lendemain.Un grand moment inoubliable!Le lit géant qui s'écrase au pied de la scène.....etc...Déja 21 ans....Nostalgie quand tu nous......................

  • I WAS THERE>>>>>

  • @RobinSmith001 yes you are the guy at 0.24

  • @overban888 haha no he just looks like me I was near the sound desk at 1:31 and again at 3;34. hahaha

  • @RobinSmith001 wow ... how old are u friend :D

  • @papapupunana well I was 18 at the time of the concert. Am curious as to why you want to know? Are you the guy from Belgium who sat next to me and had some acid??? hahahaha.

    I was sat next to a guy from Belgium who was on acid.

  • @RobinSmith001 no am not that guy just asked .. deam i will never have chance to be on this kind of consert :(

  • @papapupunana there is hope google 'the Wall Live" Roger Waters is touring the globe with the Wall live over the next year. You may be able to catch him. I will keep my fingers crossed for you.

  • @RobinSmith001 I was there too!!!

  • @fearfacteur1967 Respect, what a gig, there is a full 30 min show on here about it. Check it out Think the sow is called Wired was on CH4.

  • @RobinSmith001

    FU .. you lucky bastard !! :)

  • @dodetina I know it. FU2 haha.

  • but im not frightened of dying any time will do i dont mind why should i be frightened of dying there's no reason for it you gotta go sometime

  • I want this song to be played on my funeral.

  • Same here

  • and here

  • @Anonferiest not fair all your loved ones will bawl their eyes out ;-) this song makes my cry even when i'm happy.

  • @Anonferiest damn I was just thinking that when I listened to the live version a 1 minute ago!

  • @Anonferiest Me tooo! Even as a kid-it is so beautiful huh?

  • @Anonferiest Me too my friend, it is the best possible track to depart to the void with dignity

  • One of the best!!!!!

  • Did She messed up at 2:52 any ways I love Pink Floyd !!!!

  • Rachel, you are my siren and I am Odiseo sailing to the depths of the abysmal cosmos, maddened of love by your voice...

    Jorge-Argentina

  • Was at this best gig of my life have some great pics but nothin on vid

  • Power!!!thank you very much! all the best!

  • thing is if u listing to any version off this song the 1st lady is in it that was ment to be part of the song and without it i do think the song would have been better as more amazing guattir but who are we to judge the great writer of this song

  • Il y a eu 2 jours en suivant de concert, et je suis allé aux 2, car je bossais sur Versailles à l' époque. C'était génial, et c'est vraiment impressionnant de revoir ces images.

    Merci à celui qui a intégré cette vidéo dans youtube.

  • i found the dvd of this concert (this exact one from versailles not the delicate sound of thunder) and i am going to download it right now

  • there was a concert that I lost, Jerry Hall was there, maybe Ronnie Wood....fuck even C. Lauper ...do u know of this concert & where i can get a hold of it??

  • by the way this is your quick choice ok buy it after watching it if you can its so much better especially when watching at a home theather

  • glorious

  • hear this whisper and you die

  • Bye, Rick. You music will stay forever. You made me a better person with it. Thank you.

    Adeus, meu mestre!

  • muy impresionante!!!!!!!!!!

  • muy impresionante!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Bye Rick, (I don't talk about it, I'm too depressed)

  • Rest in peace Richard. Thank you for the music!

  • Loved you Richard.....it all changes now..BL Trez

  • RIP Rick I'm sure you having fun up there with you'r friend Syd

  • Richard's song.

  • My god Richard I liesten to this amazing song and I can't stop to cry.

    Thank you for all Richard.

    Now 2 stars are again togheter,you and Syd.

    R.I.P. Richard.

  • See you at the Great Gig Richard...

  • Thank u Richard.

  • it's a very sad day today

  • A beautiful piece of music composed by a very talented musician. RIP Richard.

  • this is absolutely beautiful

  • this sounds like the other one in black and white but the singing is a little different. is it the same? cause they sound way better in the other one! but margaret taylor stole it!

  • omg is she singing or sreaming?

  • I think that the "screaming" is just part of the singing in the music... Kind of the way she "feels" the music...

    I "don´t dislike" her singing at all...

    (and yes, I know, poor English detected...)

  • no man she has really no control,don't misunderstand mistakes with style choices

  • I think the girl one on The dark side of the moon is much much better this girl aint good at all. This sounds like axl rose :S

  • Awesome

  • qualkuno ha sto dvd ?

    o meglio il koncerto di versailles intero?

    rispondete........

  • I was there.

  • lucky bastard

  • I was visiting the palace of versailles that day, when I heard about the concert. Bought tickets and watched the first concert taged in front of the palace. The lasers reflecting off of the hallway of mirrors was pretty amazing and the sound was great.

  • You bought tickets in the same day? bullshit

  • I think I scalped them. Friend was visiting; summer study in Paris. A couple of Brits I think were scalping. Lucky.

  • hehehe ok sorry them, I was just fucking around

  • tears from this song everytime

  • Singer with Australian Ponk Floyd MUCH MUCH better - she rates with original.

  • Only tears on my face 4 this beautiful song.

    Thank you so much

  • In questo pezzo infatt non conta una voce divina. Deve essere cosi la voce. E' Questo The Great Gig in THe Sky. Inutili le polemiche sulla bellezza di questa voce

  • giusto!

    cmq la voce è divina lo stesso :-)

  • what the hell do they wait to release this concert on a DVD ? it should have been this one for DELICATE SOUND OF THUNDER but finally they preffered New york. bad choice.

  • Rachel Fury sings incredible, from outer space, even when she sings "bad".

  • I really, really hate this woman's voice. Seriously, she hasn't got the voice for this song. Not at all.

  • Zardiel, her vocal chords were in rough shape for this performance. I feel sorry for her when I hear this recording. But compare the version that JimmyToast uploaded. That's how she sounds when she's healthy.

  • her voice is really horrible, i think i will have nightmares before hear this...

  • sounds like a fucken screaming pig in 2:10-2:25

  • or like a dying pig

  • in the 2:18 that is what you call a pig impersonation

  • Love it!! :D

  • this is one mind blowing song no one could sing this like sam brown and rachel fury but i went to see aussie pink floyd and she did very well

  • bajo anestesia es musica no esta mierda.IGNORANTES

  • jajajajajajaja tu eres el ignorante

  • i'm sorry, PF fans are entitled to liking this song but i find her voice very annoying when she's screaming. the music is AWESOME though. Yes, PF rules!

  • the hairs on the hairs on the hairs on the back of my neck.....

  • this song would be difficult for any singer,female or male to pull off since clair tory did it in one take after listening to the track twice...so anyone elose trying it is mearly trying to duplicate a one off performance,so the feel will never be right. on a side note...clair thought she blew it and appologised to the crew there after she came out of the studio when she saw them stunned in silence

  • ich war damals als beleuchter dabei. wir durften das schloss in pink beleuchten. so bekam ich zwei unvergessliche auftritte geschenkt. die jungs waren echt gut drauf. später bekam ich karten von david in mailand und viel später für münchen. versailles ist der richtige platz für pink floyd, ein gutes erlebnis und eine gute erinnerung. danke.

  • i know i'll catch hell for this...but i'd like to see mariah carey or chritine agularia do a version of this song