The Hawking Paradox (Part 3)

[TechnoManiac2]

The scientists are struggling to figure out how the universe began. The key how particles can disappear could be in the question how can particles appear.

[DurexDurpaneu2]

--------(black hole)------- q•.•p ,\m/

[aaron9099]

4:48

That is in fact a moving tree.

[sgdevilzz]

to me,black holes are tears of the universe. Like fringe!

[photonman54]

a black hole could be in my head..... pshhh my teachers told me that along time ago

[Faraz70]

Dr. Sheldon Cooper resolved this paradox recently

[ZoloftSmoothie]

Thanks for uploading

[meteor4163]

This paradox is not "a black hole in your brain", but:

If information got destroyed somewhere in this universe (got theoretically impossible to retrieve) then the law of information (that no matter what you can deduce it by cause and reason) never ruled in this universe!

[LesPaul2006]

I don't really understand anything beyond the fact that "information can dissapear" completely. But somehow I've always believed that. I've always thought that eternity is a fiction, that nothing is eternal. Everything will be gone forever, sooner or later. I just believe that.

[fanmbv31]

black holes inside my brain? an great excuse to forget things!!!!

[kaas94]

who else noticed the weird green gas from that object at 0:42 ?

[konman001]

@kaas94 - LOLZ. . . I noticed it too That explains everything - Hawking must be an alien :-0

[WhereToGoist]

lol theres a black hole in my head!

[xXPointBreak]

what if every thing is backwards? the big bang is not the start but the end of the universe and we are just living in something that goes backwards

[MrHabs1993]

@xXPointBreak The direction would be relative and backwards would than be forward. But what if our entire known universe is just tiny dust particles floating around in somebody else's living and the entire time of the earths history is only a mere millisecond of there relative time and there entire universe is also a tiny particle floating around in somebody else's and so and so and so. What if your entire Universe is nothing more than an elaborate dillusion that you have created in side of

[MrHabs1993]

@MrHabs1993 mind



[lamochila66]

@xXPointBreak

that means me writing this comment was already predetermined

[Forman6]

I guess no one is as intelligent as hawking to understand his theories!

[dfonzerrelli17]

Have any of you thought about this deeply? Everything you hear from these physicians and deep thinkers might just be their point if view or idea. Then, that idea they came up with became popular for over time. Ordinary people are curious to know about these things.. but they don't sit back and come up with their own conclusions. So they listen to these "scientists". May be true.. may be not. I think out of any scientific knowledge we know today.. only 32% is actually correct! Just my opinoion.

[liorbs6]

@dfonzerrelli17

they dont just think "Hey, that might be the answer", they calculate in physics equtions, they they come up with a theory why the eqution is true, and finaly if they can they test it- thats why they built cern.

[dfonzerrelli17]

@liorbs6 It's all based off loose evidence and ideas and thoughts. Like i said maybe only 32% are correct with their theories and equations. But obviously there are mis-haps.. look at Hawking. He had to admit he was wrong. What if he's not the only one.. i garuntee some of the other GENIUS' were wrong too.. this world has answers that man let alone a philosophor just can NOT answer!

[liorbs6]

@dfonzerrelli17

he wasn't completly wrong, he just didn't understood it right.

the information maybe isn't lost but it goes throw an unusual state/progres (i dont know the right words).

i dont know if man wont be able to answer to those questions, look at what man kind achived in less then 100 years, and the whole world is just getting smarter and more educated plus each resercher has the works of the great people befor him.

i truely belive that we are capable of great things.

[dfonzerrelli17]

@liorbs6 You're English isnt so good.. where are you from? We as humans have achieved sooo much in the past 100-200 years. Yet we are still very naive and dumb. We keep testing the waters.. cars and automobiles which release smog in the air. Pollution. Nuclear bombs which cause toxic and cancerous poisons to fill the air. Mother nature will soon get it's say on man-kind. We as men are powerful.. but not stronger than mother earth. We mite never find out why or how a black hole exsists..

[dfonzerrelli17]

@liorbs6 Maybe we get to figure out the whole meaning of life, counciousness, black holes, the universe after we parish and turn to ash? You never know.. can a philosopher answer that question?!

[Instinctinside]

@dfonzerrelli17 No kid, it is not just their point of view or idea, new ideas in physics often explain the fundamental mechanisms of other sciences, while opening to new research areas in mathematics and philosophy. Simplified for you: Getting to the moon is not realized by having a point of view, but by science.

(Science: is an enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the world.) Cunt.

[dfonzerrelli17]

@Instinctinside Thanks for responding to my comment.. why are you wasting your time getting back at me if you feel my opinions & conclusions are so "obscene"? Getting to the moon is possible.. it has been done. Therefore we can expand on the knowledge of information we attained from visiting the moon. Black holes.. have never been visited. It's impossible! Like i said.. based off loose evidence and ideas. Theories, thoughts and conclusions.

[Instinctinside]

@dfonzerrelli17 And btw, the reason that ordinary people don't just "come up with conclusions" about freaking black holes, is simply because they don't have the capacity to do so. The day you read and understand Hawking's essay on black holes, maybe you should try to come up with conclusions of your own, otherwise abstain yourself of posting such obscenely stupid comments.

Ah and the 32 you mentioned, yeah, you might have confused it with your IQ.

[dfonzerrelli17]

@Instinctinside You understand where i'm coming from? Obviously not.. and i don't believe you can solve nor even understand these equations that these scientists are coming up with. Relax a little. Take a breather.. no need to get all worked up over this. Some answers can't be answered by the ones who have answers for most questions. You can't tell me the meaning of a black hole.. soooo why are you responding back to me?!

[dfonzerrelli17]

@dfonzerrelli17 I'm just messing with you man! Why even bother getting all deep into this shit.. you aren't a philosopher! Or are youuu?????!!!!

[Severe777]

A black hole existing in someone's head...? lol? what?

[11thDim]

Blackholes have a singularity and eventually shink into non existance.

Similar to how life on earth happens. It's created and it expires.

We humans have so much in common to blackholes.

Birth and death are apparent.

The massive density of a blackhole is probably equal to the density of non existant life. It appears the 11th dimension and blackholes are closely linked.

Picture The 11th dimension as a miniscule ultraviolet conveyor belt of life.

A billionth of a millimeter wide.

[JAYDUBYAH29]

oh i love these BBC documentaries - but why oh why are they so enamored of continually using language like "heresy" that makes science seem like a religious belief system and scientists seem like priests!? this makes the progress of science appear to be about overcoming faith and dogma, when that is true only in the loosest metaphorical sense, because really it is about evidence and well-reasoned theories...

[yezidi11]

8:13 so true

[Abmaj7add2]

does someone know what the name of the musical piece at 3:51 is?

[GShock112]

Does this mean a black hole can explode and thus completely disappear?

[monobrow638]

It's easy, all of the mass of the universe is slowly going into various black holes, into another dimension :D LOL it's not that easy :( I wish it was!!!

[Manny1222]

Stephen Hawkings holds the philosopher's stone. Ignoring the laws of Equivalent Exchange. xD

[charliechopstick]

I am no acedemic so dont riddicule me, I am just really interested in modern physics yet at school I hated it and never really grasped anything from the lessons, but the weakness of gravity in our universe, could that be explained by black holes sucking in and destroying gravity when black hole ceases to be, thus casing the weakness of gravity, obviously over deep time?

[arthurandroid]

@charliechopstick Not really. Gravity is weak compared to the other 3 fundamental forces. It's not seen to be weak because of short. or diminishing, supply.

[magicpen66]

@charliechopstick some scientists think that gravity is weak because it is actually leaking in from a parallel universe in which it originates, or so I've heard.

[amyleoness]

What, in your opinion would be the exact opposite of a black hole?

[Sovieto]

@amyleoness big bang

[HyperGolem]

An hole or something that creates matter and energy out of nothing instead of sucking it and destroying it?

[LovelyYTRocks]

There's a blackhole in my posterior.

[Braydawg69]

@LovelyYTRocks Ya once a dick gets within your event horizon, its going in there

[deeawn22]

not really related to the content but does anyone know what song plays at around the 6:28 mark

[egangoh]

Weird... light can't escape black hole. How came heat can be emited?

[johnbruder01]

light is both particle and energy, the particles are what make it impossible to escape. however heat is only found at what is called an eccretion disc, which is where so much matter or particles are colliding at the event horizon and are push away because there is not enough room to "suck" it all in. hope i helped

[Diosibundo]

@johnbruder01

Actually yes, it does help. Whenever I read about quantum mechanics or relativity it only makes senese WHILE Im reading it, the moment I put the book down I think "Huh?"

[InitialDAmine]

the heat is evacuated as radiation , the hawking radiation

[callofdutymw2geek]

To understand everything is like puting the ocean in a shot glass our minds could never understand everything but we try anyways.

[equallyeasilyfuqyou]

i don't find it so hard to believe that information can be lost. though mind blowing.

[rclxor]

If you don't find it hard to believe that you can violate the conservation of energy... Then something's wrong with you.

[sidewaysfcs0718]

theres a small difference

a black hole suck in matter and radiates the same amount of radiation out ...so mass and energy is conserved

but the properties of the matter that went inside, apparently had nothing to do with the properties of the matter comming out ....

wich means information (not matter) is missing ...and this would violate some basic newtonian principles

but it turns out that the matter going inside affects the matter comming outside, so information isnt lost after all.

[AnomalousAppendages]

But isn't this believed to be most likely wrong nowadays?

[AnomalousAppendages]

Oh. ok, my apolgiies. I didn't read your last line.

[DoubleDutchBust]

The Hawking Paradox (Part 3)

Knik Knak Pattie Wackedwardna

S-k i t e t r a g a m m a t o nHare 6:27

[DoubleDutchBust]

The Hawking Paradox (Part 3)Hawking

WhatisthegrandprizenABoxofTroj­anskg

The Hawking Paradox (Part 3)Hawking

[DoubleDutchBust]

EyE think you enjoy my sufferage Stephen

AnotherFridayNightSH-SKitCBast­ardHole

The Hawking Paradox (Part 3)Sciencenter

AnotherFridayNightSH-SKitCBast­ardHole

LEyE think you enjoy my sufferage KStephenaeSS

OidaReverseKK

NehpetskshHEY

OwChallengingOU 3:23

William edwardBC

[christiaan81]

mm the paradox of information.. what does it mean for the universal physical constant ?? :O

[badsign1980]

hawkind is not a genius, his theory has wrong, hes just another english snob who didnt admit he was wrong, the only reason he got known was his condition, there are more bright people from other backgrounds with theorys that changed everything and they never were heard...

[Chilledtea]

@badsign1980: "Hawkind" is a genius. His theory was right, the only thing was that he claimed that no matter what goes into a black hole,it emits the same radiation each time. This is what perplexed physicists for decades, because he claimed the information regarding a particles dynamics and life cycle just disappear. The reason he is a genius is because of his ability to calculate things in a way that is different from everyone else. Please don't bash someone unless you have the whole story.

[lordinfamous15234]

"theorys"??? yea im sure you have an extensive theoretical physics background. This is graduate level physics we're talking about...leave the extremely abstract physical sciences to others and go review your abc's.

[Chewy427]

if u wanna know the end of the story...

blackholes emit radiation

[1800ghostdance]

@Chewy427 doesn't account for the amount it eats.

[mnfchen]

@Chewy427 NOoooo don't "Snape kills Dumbledore" me!

[jatspageage]

@Chewy427 Maybe...

[xTheBestJokex]

@Chewy427 Wrong, the radiation from the Black Hole doesnt come from inside the Event Horizon, because nothing can escape from the gravitational force inside of it, the radiation emitted actually comes from space-time disturbances NEAR the Black Hole, but not inside of it.

[MrNaya8]

@xTheBestJokex i agree, the gasses around the black hole are moving so fast that they create radiation

[Chewy427]

lol @ 5:12

[pixnwaccount4]

no bigger subject

[PandabeerMEISTER]

Hawking we love you!

[Cloroformed]

Dude, that's really weird.

I wish I could be paid to harrass people.

[TAz69x]

@Cloroformed Become a priest.

[Darathexplicit]

@Cloroformed 

[OriginalAtomicSheep]

@Cloroformed you can... sales people do that very thing... thats why the guy did what he did... applied harassment in a different field.