Added: 4 years ago
From: r7752
Views: 180,966
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (315)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ummm maybe this comparison would make sense... if they pitted a bmw x5 against the LR3.... otherwise... ridiculous marketing ploy...

  • Your video is a favorite on Gabon

  • Rover VS BMW on snow !? , Doesnt make sense.

  • Wouldn't it make sense to race another 4 wheel drive. What a croc of crap

  • Equal driving ability? My ass! One of the drivers is an empty kitchen!

  • @petersenct would like to see you do that

    

  • If you live on the poles and you want a supercar! Just go for the Land Rover! :D

  • Well it just shoves a fact: The M6 is useless in the north of the northern hemisphere during 4-5 months per year. The LR3 is very useful. Plain and simple.

  • The m6 has 507 bhp and has more torque and more bhp per tone but it can't put all its power down on these surfaces so no matter what driver the LR3 would win but on Tarmac bmw's Mbutton will make gear changes quicker and faster throttle response. The bmw has DSC (DYNAMIC STABILITY CONTROL EXC AND OTHER CLEVER SYSTEMS THE M6 IS A ROAD GOING RACER

  • The m6 has 507 bhp and has more torque and more bhp per tone but it can't put all its power down on these surfaces so no matter what driver the LR3 would win but on Tarmac bmw's Mbutton will make gear changes quicker and faster throttle response. The bmw has DSC (DYNAMIC STABILITY CONTROL EXC

  • there is no way to compare these two cars by this stupid race cuz each one of them was designed to do it's purpose

  • gay shit fuckin bullshit piece of race. BMW rules nigguhhhsss

  • should of used a car with the same price tag of the bmw m6, but it should be AWD/4WD

  • @scorpio3lion thumbed the fuck down cause i hate people asking for thumbs ups

  • Ahah, enjoy wintertime, M6 faggots!

  • They should have takes BMW X5 instead, with AWD.

  • To the stupid people here.... they are comparing a SEDAN to a land rover which i'm sure is 4wd or 4x4 drive

  • I think LR is looser but this video proved yes they are looser..they choose RWD sports car leaving all the 4WD in the planet cos simply they can't compete with other offroad 4WD...

  • Holy fucking shit! I've always wanted to know whether a 4WD SUV with off-road pedigree can beat a rear wheel drive GT car on a snowy ice track. Thank you to the geniuses who devised this test, now I need not wonder anymore.

    Were you guys also behind The Onion's report on research to determine the effects of repeated stabbings on monkeys?

  • Land Rover OWNS

    it may not win on a race track. but it won't spinn like hell and drive off the road either.

    This shows how crap a BMW is and how good the LR3 is. It will win in every terrain against whatever BMW. The LR3 is one of the best Luxury 4x4's in the world. no argueing

  • LR doesn't once slag BMW off in this video. In fact, the ad doesn't even once show the whole BMW logo.

    More to the point, I agree that both these cars are suited to their own environments; the BMW on-road and the LR off. And certainly, the test would've been more fair if the BMW were four-wheel-drive. The point LR is making is that the Disco is suited to environments that people in Europe are inclined to encounter everyday and let's face it, a racetrack isn't one of those everyday environments.

  • Conclusion:

    Land rover Discovery is for womans

    BMW M6 is for man's!

  • Crap who compares sport race car with 4x4 all wheel drive machine on the ice even then I think if u put here a 4wheel drive BMW it will smash crap out of land rover .....

  • MILF !

  • if the m6 didnt romp on the throttle and spin tires. he would be fine, if he slowly applied gas monimizing wheel spin he would be fine...but definitly not as good as the lr3

  • Pointless video. Just stupid.

    "Next on our fabulous show: Bugatti Veyron Super Sport versus a submarine -- who is the better diver?" :P

  • most retarded race EVER

  • They should let Top Gear do all their ads.

  • BMW need to stop making their cars so ugly

  • what a idiot comparition, try compare same cars, on clean roads in summer see what happens and who win`s, what a shitty clip fuck LR, long rule BMW

  • how do you say it's an unfair race? i mean, sure, the landrover has four wheel drive, but then, it also has a woman driver :P who STILL managed to win, proving, that, even with fair competition, the discovery three is better.

  • land rovers are more status and power rank

  • HAHAHAHAAH wow 

  • the land rover looks so nice but... this test not have sense, but no metter i even love land rover lr3!!

  • stupid test

  • I used to own a discovery and the only thing i can say is that I am amazed that they got the fucking thing started!

  • damnnn the lr3 looked so sexy on the turn

  • Fuck the lr3. I want the M6

  • lol this isnt sayin much or the rover....if a rwd street car can keep pace with something built they say for snow...ya, thats sad.

  • Now put them both on the Tarmac so we see if Discovery can rule that too...

  • HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • Driver's of equal ability?  She's a woman... she should be in the kitchen cooking him dinner!!

  • Fuck the discovery 3 i want the M6!!

  • Okay so wheres the counter response race? The Discovery 3 vs the M6 on a normal tarmacked track?

  • retarded.

  • I passed a few beached BMWs last winter, rear wheel drive is shite in the snow.

  • you know what's really gay there trying to show how awesome the lr3 but the use the sound of the m6 when showing it.

  • Hahaha this is Land Rovers commercial.They knew if they would do a 1/4 race the M6 would pwn the Land Rover.They only could beat the beemer in winter.While they didn't want to compare X5 against Land Rover....muhahaha....

  • i still think bmw m6 is much more fun to drive than that fat lr3 lol

  • Land Rover 4WD

  • how idiot's can they be?!...they challenge a sport street car whith a land rover on snow????.......

    why don't they challenge the bmw x5 or the x6 with that shiti land rover....?

  • @valibmwe92 you're idiot. they advertise awd superiority, not LR over BMW superiority. it doesnt matter what carwas there, bmw, merc, volvo, vw, as long as they had 2wd

    and, btw, LR can beat every single 4wd at offroad. proven thousand times

  • @Areoplane7 OK lets see it go against a Subaru STI, of a Mitsubishi EVO in the same test as here and see which one wins.

  • @adamslurch71 i'd love to see subaru sti fording rivers and mitsubishi doing some rock crawling.

    this is not a test. this is an ad. it says: LR is the only thing you'll ever need.

    there is no other car in the world so universal. as in it does everything good.

    LR was under bmw command until recently. this is their FUCK YOU MOTHER thing. get it now?

  • its not supposed to be an actual race... its supposed to make u want to buy a land rover if u ever drive in the snow... its just a cleaver advertisement....

    but id get the 4.8is x5 if i needed 4x4!

  • ridiculous, not the car of the same class with the race they let x5 or x6

  • i'd love to take my audi out there.

  • @nickyb628 i would like to take any awd out there lol

  • @tashtan1 hahaha touche!

  • AT LEAST GET A ALL WHEEL DRIVE BMW NO?

  • What there trying to say is the Discovery has the power and means to control it. It's about performance, power and control. You can use the BMW some of the year in some conditions, but use the Land Rover all of the year in all of the conditions.

  • OMFG even a 10 year old would know the land rover will win hands down!

  • Stupid... was there ever any question whether or not AWD is better in the snow? Put them both on pavement and watch that Land Rover get owned....

  • that's so unfair 2wd VS. 4wd!!!!! put that land rover against a 2010 subaru impreza WRX STI and se who wins this time haha. 199lives block43

  • @impreza2010drifty Ya, in extreme winter conditions. In the summer, I'd rather bomb around twisty roads in a BMW M6.

  • Now go and make this test on german autobahn...

  • Now go and make this test on german autobahn...

  • how is bmw m6 luxurious? and im not even talking about disovery 3

  • stupidiest add i've ever seen, only the stupid people whould turn to buy discovery after seeing this add,

  • Stupid TEST!!!!!!!!

  • A stupid test by stupid people ...I'm sure if they put a every X from BMW in this race the LR3 will be defeat.

  • A stupid test by stupid people ...I'm sure if they put a every X from BMW in this race the LR3 will be defeat.

  • suv's r for off road and sports cars r for on road

  • they would put the woman in the discovery wouldn't they, how stereotypical lool

  • i'm a huge disco fan, but this comparison is truly rediculous. this isnt apples and oranges, this is apples and........grand piano's!!?!!?

  • Whats the point of this apples to oranges comparason? Might as well have made the other car a Ferrari with slick racing tires for what it's worth.

  • how can they be equal, ones a woman

  • Honestly now what's tha point of this shit........shocker tha m6 doesn't have traction on a damn sea of snow

  • @e40cally Exactly! I don't get the point of this video either! A 4x4 vehicle is better than a high-powered sports car on a snow track. Gasp! Shock!

    Now lets put them on a normal race track and then let be shocked about how the M6 beats the LR3! Utterly pointless comparison.

  • unfair competition..

  • MrBeastandtheharlot ur kinda wrong...u see the t/c for either car is different and has different uses....the m6 uses its traction control to keep its tired on the road...were as the LR3 uses it for the of road environment....now i personally have an lr3 and there the most bad ass car out there....but ive driven an M5 which is basically the same as the M6 just different body and it truly is the ultament driving experience......but nothing compared to the lr3

  • even if they would put an xDrive BMW i still think the Land Rover would win

  • Last sentence is just for me! Ahh Damn, why they cost so much!

    Maybe there is anyone, who can sell me reliable Land Rover Discovery 3 for 1.000$? :D

  • Omfg the vid is trying to show that having truckloads of power in a car is fuck all useless if it cant put it 2 the ground.

    basicly: The disco 3(with less power) won because it can harness all of its horsepowers because it has a sophisticated t/c system and AWD system.Wereas the m6 has more power but is RWD and not as good t/c system

  • This is a stupid test! RWD vs AWD really!? Audi R8 vs LR3 is far.

  • ok all land rover fans --since they compare suv with sport coupe --stupid idea , anyway land rover made by FORD --you still think they are Number 1 ,, copere it to audi allroad :)

  • there not made buy ford ok land rover made the willys jeep for the us army then went back to brittan and made land rover i said nothing about ford in there ok its ford licoln and mercury

  • ford owns land rover but land rover still builds their own product, ford also owns volvo and jaguar too, anyone not believing me, go do your research before you argue with me here.

  • @rcrocker02 ford do not own land rover, mabey you should do your research before critizing others! Tata now own land rover and jaguar, also @hockeyrock Land rover didnt make the willys jeep that was made by willys and ford! Some people need to do there research, honestly!!

  • tata? lol alrighty then...in any case, yall have fun arguing, i got better things to do...peace

  • the willys jeep was stolen from a british company called austin

  • @rcrocker02 not any more

  • They would have done a comparison with the BMW's off roader (cough) I mean SAV for convenience, but that would have been just as shite as the M6!! LOL

    BMW / Merc / VW / Porsche - Owned by Land Rover

  • ya, land rover can do better than that.

    at least take a x5 or x6, it will be more convincing.

  • @lordsnooty01

    yes,u right. Microsoft also owned by Land Rover

  • stupid comparison , they should have compared it to the bentley continental gt , putting a two wheel drive vs a 4 wheel drive in icey conditions is unfair everytime , but the bentley gt is the fastest car on ice , now that would be a challenge.

  • strange comparing hehe but great

  • separating the M6 from the video, you have to admit terrain response is superb, I have driven on sand and mud with it and its incredible, it looks great also on snow. what happened to the bmw traction control? not suitable for snow

  • try it with the new Land Rover Discovery 4 which is even better. Currently the best 4x4 on the road

  • It's not faer !! Unleast they could chouse the 320xd but M6 no chance this was unfear !!!

  • Romona Carlson...hmmm wonder if her dad is Erik Carlson Saabs Swedish rally driver from back in the day. lol

  • this is a useless video... of course rear wheel drives are not as good as four wheel drives on slippery surface -__-x and dont give me a thumb down unless if u really didnt know that which proves that ur a dumbass, so the more thumb downs i get, it means the more stupid people there r on youtube

  • @davidzzz94 Douche Bag.. obviously we know the m6 is a TAD faster than the LR3! But im glad you found out..

  • um... im sorry? rude person? i didnt even mention nothing about M6 and LR3, plus i got 3 thumb ups and u have a thumb down

  • Stupid video..

  • THIS WAS SO POINTLESS~!!!

  • Oh no, now Hans is going to add an optional rocket thrusters/ rocket stabilizers package on the M6... or a 4 wheel drive system.

  • While the BMW is definently better on the track, the LR3 it an amazing feat of engineering on its own. Your trying to relate them to different standards. The 6-series is BMW's grand tourer which was built for the track, poised and filled with power. The LR3 was built to handle any surface, and be the best off-roader, not compete in track days against each other. Trying to race them together fairly is impossible.

  • those are different cars built for different purposes, this test doesnt show us anything. they might as well have tested a fork versus a spoon in a soup eating competition,

  • the moral of the story is.. 2 wheel drive sucks.. You have 4 wheels, why not use them?

  • ya but the hard part is equalizing the power and torque, also if u want to minimize the understeer on a race track, u have to distribute power to the out side wheels more like what nissan is doin with the new R35, plus, u cant drift as fun with a four wheel drive car. period. i think those three facts r enough to make u shut the fuck up by now aint it?

  • It all depends on where you live and what you are in to genius. How many M6's won the paris dakar? oh, there weren't any. I'm even bothered I wasted my time responding to this. I'm ashamed at sinking to this level

  • @iheart4wheeldrive yea thats a thought but in the case of m6, you dont buy it when you live in sweden but in southern countries and high speed usage

  • what.....

  • Throw there a BMW X5 M it can to 0-60 mp/h in 4.7 sec it will smoke Land rovers ass !

  • yep, and no matter what it won't even come close to the rovers offroad abilities... Sorry...

  • I would severely suggest that that much power would compromise the BMW's already sub-par 4x4. Too much torque on a track creates lots of wheel spin, imagine that on mud. Even with traction control and anti-slip mechanism, all that power disappears so that it can handle the terrain. I don't know why German manufacturers keep forcing mass power into their engines instead of engineering what they already have. LR has the best off-road capabilities due to extensive research and implementation.

  • not if ur on mud it wont they are crap of road

  • this test is very unfair obviously, lol, a RWD BMW vs. a 4WD Land Rover. Seriously you take this to a track or something and you'll see whose better.

  • pathetic comparison...

  • and i forgot BMW sold your sorry assets to ford and then they sold you

  • the m6 still looked sexy they should have did an Audi s5 or something or at least a (classic) beetle give rear wheel drive a brake and oh hell no i would rather stay home if the rode conditions get like this how bout Land Rover the only vehicle that stays in the shop and i know this for a fact my mom has one not one week without a problem

  • i am pursuant  with bang1221

  • tbh that is a stupid test, thats a jeep and that a car,

    but i woould by a m6 because i love them

  • both good cars as i own both cas, i own a land rover disco 3 and x5, both good cars, im a bmw fan but prefore land rover on jeeps

  • what a stupid test... go fuck some snow guys..

  • I love land rovers and I dont care much for beamers but that made me giggle. what a crap add. Staged, practised and scripted. LR were probably owned by BMW at the time too judging by the BHP commentary of the BMW and photography and the disco winning? Bowler Land Rover may even thrash the M6 on tarmac? fun video tho.

  • wow Land Rover is pathetic ...BMW forever

  • The fact that on the turns the M6 can keep you with the LR3 show that even on its "own" ground the LR3 is shit.. hahahahah btw i have a disco 3 that is sad

  • this is the stupidest test iv ever seen, might of well of tested a unimog against an f1 car

  • wtf....thats like taking them to a track n seeing the bmw wip the discoveries ass...this is a shit comparison

  • even a subaru impreza can outrun a bmw m6 in these conditions

  • Мудизм.

  • это пиздец я отвечаю )))

  • This is the most bullshit comparison. It is so obvious an M6 cant be on heavy snow like that. If you took an all wheel drive BMW it would whoop the land rovers butt. My dad has an X3 and it is amazing in the snow!

  • x3s are fuckin shite, look at the top gear review

  • You are obviously an ignorant viewer.

  • What a bullshit comparison. How many out of 365 days does it snow, in fact how many times does it snow that bad? And if it did you still couldnt go nowhere because of the drivers who dont have all wheel drive vehicle. Hummmm.. WHY DIDNT THEY COMPARE APPLES TO APPLES LIKE THE X3 OR BETTER YET THE X5??? THAT WAS PURE BS. A publicity stunt!!

  • WOW!!! 4x4 beat RWD on snow!!!! That's amazing !!!

  • how about the discovery versus an audi RS6 Quattro?

  • Fair, enough, but I don't actually have anything against this video. People are always bagging out 4x4sor SUV's for having bad performance. They are peformance cars, they perform off road and that is worthy of as much respect as on road performance.

  • Lets see what happens on normal roads. M6 vs the land rover. and btw, whoeva made this video is wierd. who compares a m6 with a 4x4 ON SNOW TERRAIN? M6's wernt engineered for of road tracks you pratz

  • wtf wow that is birght test a fukin 2wd car against a 4x4 SUv that is made for shit lyk this

  • LR3 is an amazing suv... but this video is just a advertisement for LR and its terrain response system.. nothing more.

  • I would just like to know which idiot got idea to test all wheel drive SUV vs rear wheel drive sports car

  • this video is cut (edited) it is longer and its compared just for fun not for real.

    btw isnt that view marvelous...

  • you dont race a luxury sport car vs. a suv

  • wha t the fuck where they thinking when they made this vid??

  • I don't know, but i think L3 should be compared with a x3 or a X5 not a M6....

  • 4x4 vs rwd

  • Comment removed

  • A company that pays for this type of advertising is desperate to make the winner look bad. It's the same as asking Michael Phelps to run the 100m against Usain Bolt...idiots!

  • who is so stupid to give money for such an AD? compare on ice the G with the 3 diff locked if you ton't know wha to do with the money...just my opinion.

  • fucking ad for the LR3

  • this is the most stupid comparing i ever seen in motors world

  • I used to work for Land Rover. Best car company on the planet.

  • Very nice. LR is the best 4X4

  • what a stupid AD

  • this is heaven for me

  • never seen such a silly advert...

    why didn't you compare X5 or X6 versus LR3???

  • Cos an X5 is no good offroad ;-)

  • he says they are both for professionals... the BMW for buisness men..the LR for offroaders. but the end of the ad the effectivel states that the LR is good for both so why have the BMW :)

  • 335iX would be enough to beat that poor land rover

  • My dad had this LR3. I loved it. It was metallic silver with beige interior. Got rid of it for a Jaguar though

  • tis was an adevertise...not a test...what about x-Drive vs Terain R.

  • This was a fucking ad!!!

  • Dumb test, fun tho!

  • yeah, pretty much, the BMW would have done a lot better with snow tires.

  • OMFG ,listen to the guy he says " both vehicles are equiped with standard snow tires"

  • those hardly look like snow tread to me, they look like z-rated sport tires, there was hardly any tread in them at all. Just because that dude said something IN AN AD, doesn't make it true.

  • he said standard winter tyres not snow

  • leading female swedish a-class rally driver...

    ice specialist...

    there no thought in this

  • what was the point?? i didn't get it. just try the same race on a normal road and you will see what is what

  • What a pointless comparison!! Put the Disco up against the X5 or any high end 4X4. How about the Cadillac Escalade for a laugh.

  • Absolutelly stupid comparation! Of course a 4x4 is better on ice

  • ice driving expert bullshit

    anyone who has driven on snow and ice knows that you DO NOT PUT THE GAS TO THE FLOOR when starting, you take off slowly

  • Pleaseeeee...Who byes a car to drive it over the snow?? Fuckin idiots!! Total diferent cars, and both good cars!!

  • its the only vehicle youll ever need! JAJA eat that

  • Suprisingly enough- the 4wd car works better in the snow and ice.

    Stil- I far rather have a Disco than a BMW- in any weather.