Added: 4 years ago
From: bladnik
Views: 899,041
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (604)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Translation from German:

    (Woman) Oh, he is yet heading down again...

    (Narrator) Sunday afternoon in Magdeburg.

    (Man) He is side-slipping.

    (Woman) Oh, Crap. Lets go there.

    (Narrator) It was a normal start with a winch. But at a height of 80 meters the steel cable breaks. The pilot gets out of the crash with some cuts.

  • Hey this is just like that wing walker video; same situation. In that vid, the biplane lost power at around 100ft and he tried to turn tight and go back but got a spin instead.

  • Am I right? looking on the windsock on the left he was landing with the wind not upwind so he simply stalled his glider and the wind push him into the turn direction?

  • @matt4436 When I learned to fly gliders, the cable snapped at low altitude when one of my fellows started. He managed to do a 180 degree turn with the wings almost vertical and made it, despite he was a beginner...

  • Setting up a winch launch in which if the cable breaks early in the launch

    you cannot land in the launch direction due to obstructions....is basically

    asking for trouble. You cannot make a 180 turn from 80 meters just because

    'you want to"...magical thinking is trumped by physical laws every time.

  • And that is why you cordinate your turns at low altitude.

  • When the cable snapped he should have carried straight on for an into wind landing instead of turning back. But maybe there were obstructions straight ahead so he had no choice but to turn back?

  • ha ha, see I misread the title. I thought this said How TO land a glider. OOPS

  • I tell my students all the time "NEVER" Turn back to the airport without sufficient altitude during an emergency after takeoff. You have to man up and commit to landing straight ahead no matter what. Golf Course, parking lot, Road, farmland whatever is there you must resist the urge to turn back. At low altitude it "ALWAYS" ends in a crash. Its called The Impossible turn in class. I had a great friend that attempted the impossible turn, and it cost him is life

  • @HallaBalla1959

    You are right, its a fine distinction. I don't want people to be put off trying a glider winch launch because they think its intrinsically dangerous. Before anyone is sent solo on the winch they must show that they can safely react to low, medium and high breaks, and to release the cable before a wing touches the ground.

    Enjoy your flying.

  • I dont see the issue thats a greaser landing for sure 10/10

  • Scheiße!

  • The only word I understood was Scheiße (Shiza)

  • ok the cablebroke, 80 meter to low for parachute, he didnt make it to the runnway, just land frontwind where it looks flat.

  • Comment removed

  • it is called a stall due to high bank angle.

    this formula makes it easyer to understand because stall speed increases with increasing load factor:

    Vs(turn) = Vs1g x root(1/cos(bank angle))

  • not trying to fly into the wind huh? I WILL CALL IN A SUPER TYPHOON AND TELL YA TO LAND THAT RIGHT AWAY MATE!

  • A successful landing, he's a winner and survived without taking out the airshow audience..

  • I'm going to go out on a limb here and say loss of lift.

  • @dieselmac Uh -uh. Firstly -- too slow, THEN loss of lift --- especially under the inboard wing. In this case the right wing. Right wing goes down, and the result is a spin. unrecoverable at that low height.

  • Probably instructor's fault? Before signing someone off to solo, make sure they know that the stalling speed increases with the bank of a turn. If this guy was higher, he would have gone into a full spin. Hardly survivable.

  • wiso is der bei 80 m nicht geradeaus gelandet??

  • @haha2927 normales verfahren im 1/3

  • Die versuchte Umkehrkurve war ein Fehler. Glücklicherweise ging der Absturz für den Piloten glimpflich aus.

  • sheisse.. xD

    

  • This clip has been used to show hundreds of student pilots the importance of pre-spin recognition, recovery, proper flight and circuit management.

  • @fadinas111 You've got to be kidding! From that height there is no time for spin recovery! The best you could do is to fall on wing to absorb energy! Rule is simple, fly fast!

  • If it was a cable break at low altitude, the pilot would normally not attempt to return to the airfield for exactly this reason - low, slow, and downwind - with the spin as the finale. However here we don't know if landing ahead would have been possible - obstructions, whatever. he may have had no alternative to turning back, with the result you see.

    Hope he/she was OK!

  • lucky.

  • The costruction of the cockpit of one of those means the pilot probably escaped unscathed

  • its called too low

  • That's pretty much a demonstration of how not to land Anything.

    It's not just Gliders that will enter an accelerated stall.

  • must normaly fly choppers and got confused .

  • Spin entry from slow, ruddered turns.

  • This is what's called an accelerated stall, and I've never seen such a good demonstration before. Basically, when you bank into a turn, the wings are no longer oriented horizontally, so their lift is no longer entirely directed upwards.  This guy got low and slow and banked sharply, upon which he stalled and fell out of the sky.

  • Why did he have the spoilers out?

  • FWA.

  • Classic example of a spin on finals - Low + slow + too much rudder = Spin in! The pilot should have known better. Luckily looks like he should have survived the crash!

  • Woah! Is he ok?

  • @concorde232 According to the reporter he was lucky and got away with scratches.

  • Wow some fake sounds.

  • Fail

  • Many comments misses basic facts: The winch cable braks at 80m, and the unlucky pilot is forced to attempt a 180 deg turn and tailwind landing from very low altitude.

  • @HallaBalla1959 yes it's a what we call a special flight situation. If the winch cable breaks between 50 and 100m then the pilot has to perform a 180 degree turn open the airbrakes and land with tailwind!

  • @HallaBalla1959 Performing a 180 deg turn from 80 m altitude is never a good idea in a glider... Unexperianced pilots will hold back on the stick to save altitude = high risk of stalling the plane, just as in this video. To bad if the terrain ahead gave no other option than to try to make that unlucky 180 turn. I hope the pilot wasn´t hurt.

  • @MrUllersater they say he only had cuts

  • @HallaBalla1959 If i had a cable break (again) at 80m, i'd try and land in front of me, 180 is too risky that low

  • @STRURM249 Exactly, I was taught under 200ft AGL land straight ahead, over 200ft "consider" a 180 turn. If there's a strong headwind you should still land straight ahead.

  • @HallaBalla1959

    Your basic facts are wrong.

    Its normal for glider pilots to experience cable breaks at 80 meters up. It happened to glider pilots dozens of times either during practice or for real. First thing is to get the nose down to a flying attitude, then wait until the speed builds up before maneuvering. If high enough go around an abbreviated circuit otherwise land ahead.  If neither are possible you should not have launched.

    We all make mistakes, but this was a mistake.

  • @groberts101 I don't see much disagreement here. The pilot obviously decided that a straight ahead landing was not the best option. Maybe he was wrong. We don't know the exact circumstances.

    Never learned cable lauch myself, only towing behind a Cub in a Bergfalke, many years ago. :-)

  • @HallaBalla1959 I have had similar things happen with RC gliders and can attest that these situations are nearly unrecoverable.

  • He had a rope break in about 80m height. That's what the reporter says.

  • Looks like it hit a power line???

  • Comment removed

  • Reminds me of that one CF-18 crash in Cold Lake last year.

  • OMG SHIEßE!!!!! Did he DIED!?!?

  • @eeektavius no

  • What is this all about?

    I expected to see a vid about somebody who puts gold leaf onto inanimate obects.

    Not somebody in a cheap plane that doesn't even have an engine.

    Dyslexia lures KO.

  • @johnpetermalcolm first of all, it's called a glider for a reason..

    gliding is one of the most enjoyed leisure activities in the world

    secondly, the thing you're expecting to see is a gilder, not a glider.

  • @ALexpWTFISTHAT

    I honestly thought that my last line would have made people realise that I was making a joke :(

  • wow he did land!

  • Scheiße hahaha

  • allein schon das RTL diese Töne bei der Zeitlupe hinzufügt

    ech überflüssig von RTL !!!!!!!!!!!

  • @benedicthac is halt hartz 4 tv

  • The man, who's talking in th evideo says that the steel cable of the winch broke off and because of this the glider was falling down and the pilot didn't make any mistakes and yes there was a stall because the glider hadn't the correct speed

  • Does anybody know what happened to the pilot?

  • @Ratshee The commentary says he got away with some minor injuries.

  • @Airblader

    I don't speak a word of german unfortunately, thank you.

  • Diese verdammte 4. Kurve- ist doch klassisch

  • shizer!

  • Doesn't look like a stall, looks like he hit wiring

  • That was half cartwheel, and half pancake.

  • I think also

  • landing is always made into the wind what was this guy thinking doing otherwise?

  • @whiteTiger941 - not if terrain does not allow it... better land upwards with tailwind instead of downwards into the wind (steep slope, apparently not the case here)

  • 80 meter and cable rupture = land straight ahead. What was he thinking turning around??? Too lazy pushing his plane back or so? 100% pilot error.

  • Tip stall!

  • right wing stalled and dropped, otherwise known as a spin entry.

  • Lesson

    Effectively coming in dead stick in a hard bank downwind.. Not very smart!

  • looks like he was turning into a downwind instead of a headwind. why would you land going with the wind?

  • uh niner niner six four fiver. we got a engine stall, left wing shaky. out of control glider, permission to set this bitch down hard on the ground.

  • The pilot was fighting a crosswind but slightly turning nose to the right but the glider was diving, and finished in a tip stall.

    The error was a crosswind maneuver when diving.

  • The report of the German Federal Bureau of Aircraft Accident Investigation states that "...In a reverse curve, the glider touched the ground with the wing as a result of Bank angle..." (Original: "...Bei einer Umkehrkurve berührte das Segelflugzeug mit dem Tragflügel den Boden infolge Querneigung (Ringelpiez).")

  • Scheißer.

  • Approach turn stall...

  • guys, he was landing wid strong wind from behind!!! shouldn't you land into the wind?

  • scheiza!!!!

  • Landings of the pros

  • its called a stall.

  • @wristp1n nope. if you nothing about it you should better stop talking

  • @1812over2 thats a fucking stall retard! and thats not a fucking guess! even the title of the fucking video indicates a stall! look at the fucking windsock! watch the fucking plane stall with your own two fucking eyes! if your blind im sorry, but that is the only fucking excuse not to fucking recognise that AS A FUCKING STALL!

  • @wristp1n You call me a retard? The fucking winch broke

    I know what I'm saying I'm flying gliders myself

  • @1812over2 nice try poser they dont use winches to land, and besides THATS A FUCKING STALL!!! the only gliders you fly are the foam ones you can buy at the local store!!! quit talking now your making yourself look like an ass!

  • @1812over2 read the other posts!! notice a trend in comments? notice the word "stall" mentioned a couple times maybe? are we all wrong? what ever Tchaikovsky!

  • @wristp1n lol you could see the wing scrape the ground that brought the glider down not a stall.

  • @JetFlyyer oh great here we go again! you can obviously see that glider stalling before the wing tip strikes the ground. watch the vid again

  • @wristp1n you know one or 28 people could consider the reason next time for videos like this with poor deph perception :P

  • @JetFlyyer stop wasting my time. you dont know what your talking about! sure the wingtip hit the ground. but it hit the ground while the glider was in a stall. do some fucking research. what ever happened to making well informed decisions. if cant recognise a stall when you see one you have a lot to learn.

  • @JetFlyyer at .05 seconds he is not in contact with the ground in any way, and he's is in a tip stall. do you land with the wind? didnt think so! notice the wind sock.

  • @wristp1n well yea he was trying to land with the wind. Where gliders are not responsive

  • @JetFlyyer you just described a stall basicly. anyway when the amount of wind over the wing adversly affects the lift coeficient then your talking about a stall. steep banked turn, low airspeed, and linding with a tail wind are a really bad combo.

    

  • @wristp1n Ahh I see now but of course all aircarft stall differently not just SLOWLY lowering their nose and wing. If he was flying an aircraft with a higher wing loading he would enter a spin if im correct.

  • @JetFlyyer if that glider would have been another hundred feet off the ground you would have witnessed a spin. any plane can spin in. planes with high wing loading need to have more air moving over the foil to mainain lift i.e. airspeed.

  • @wristp1n excatly

  • @wristp1n He was still on the starting rope. So no stall...

  • @wolfpilotde sorry didnt realize they could make tow cables go in 90 degree turns in germany. because here its a little different.

  • @wristp1n more specifically, a tip stall.

  • @wristp1n or a stall developed into a spin?

  • @wristp1n Actually, that was a spin. Only the right wing stalled. The left one kept flying.

  • @wristp1n No, its called stupid pilote!

  • @wristp1n Epic glider crash

  • Comment removed

  • its called a MAJOR BLIP OF MIND !

  • At first it looked like he struck a wire with the left wing, but it looks more like he struck the right wingtip on the ground trying to make the turn to final. As someone pointed out, he's landing in a tailwind.

  • @rlrsk8r1 he didn't struck anything... he just stalled with the inner wing...

  • I'm surprise it didn't get thrown to peaces

  • Crowd demands fireballs 100ft high!

  • Haha, diese reingeschnittenen "Crash-Geräusche"... Lächerlich.

  • This guy is incredibly lucky, that could have gone a lot worse!

  • of course, loses height as soon as it gets a tail wind. have often wondered if and how they may check winch cables for stress and strain, or is it that they (should) have an expiry based on the number of winches? does anyone know? all cables will eventually break.

  • YOU FAIL!!! When you go low and slow, a man in the sky by the name of Murphy strikes down on you with the gift "tipstall"

  • i always land that way :D

  • In Soviet Russia, glider lands you...

  • my kite broke!

  • I dont understand german but i think what they said was "oh shit that guy might be dead, do you think we should tell his family?"

  • He just didn't had time to eject... lol. Hope he's ok.

  • 0:08 Scheiße!

  • The low speed of the wind is a big mistake.

  • What an idiot. Look at the wind sock,...He's landing with the wind and lost lift....  Should be landing from the opposite direction.

  • @urgdaddy we all knew that...

  • @urgdaddy - maybe there was no other option since the cable broke during the launch at 80 meters above ground. There seams to be a slope at the end of the field (Another plane damaged after the cable broke at 30 meters...)

  • @simu0 even at 80m you should still be able to land straight ahead as you have barely started the launch, you might end up right near the winch though and need a tow back

  • @funfly3 - sure, if the runway is long enough, the terrain is all plane up to the winch, there are no others obstacles, wind is favorable (should normally be, but ...). Have you read my second sentence? seams like landing straight (from 30m) can be a problem there. But I were not there, I have no idea... Where I normally fly, 80m is the height at which you can/must decide to land straight or turn around (depending mostly on wind). BTW ending up near our winch would likely be a destroyed plane

  • @simu0 I did but I dont think from the video you get any clues the cable broke at 80m so all this might just be speculation

  • @funfly3 - might... but it‘s not speculation; at least it is exactly what the commentator/reporter is telling! My translation: “Sunday afternoon in Magdeburg. It was a routine start with cable winch, but at an height of 80 meters the steel cable broke. For the pilot this crash ends with a few cuts.”

  • Speed and High keep your teeth...

  • Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

  • The following entry in the database of BFU (Bundesstelle für Flugunfalluntersuchung) matches the details. Not sure if it is the correct one.

    State file number: BFU 3X063-00;

    Local Date: 07.05.2000 15:42;

    Location: Magdeburg;

    Wind speed: 6,173 m/s;

    Damage aircraft: Destroyed;

    Injuries: minor: 1;

    Aircraft type: SZD 41 JANTAR;

    Narrative: Beim Windenstart kam es zu einem Seilriss. Bei einer Umkehrkurve berührte das Segelflugzeug mit dem Tragflügel den Boden infolge

    Querneigung (Ringelpiez).

  • @simu0 I told it was a DG500 but I could be wrong

  • @funfly3 It is SZD-41A Jantar Standard. Two pieces canopy, plain trapezoid wing planform, midwing configuration, and yes can bite unawary drivers... Flown such and other Jantar's. Probably more than 500 h so far. It is very popular here in Poland. How can you mistake it with doublesiter, I wonder???

    Cheers

  • Wow...maybe the pilot should've gunned the engine?

  • wie war das nochmal mit "keine engen kurven in bodennähe" fliegen? vollhonk.

  • ouch ...

  • Your stupid heads. This was a breakage!

  • I know that guy, he always lands like that.

  • wenn man auf den windsack schaut sieht man das er die lezte kurve mit rückenwind macht das war also ein eindeutiger pilotenfehler

  • Gotta love those added-in sound effects for dramatic impact! (not)

  • Comment removed

  • why he turnd around?

  • According to the commentators the pilot survived with minor superficial wounds.

  • use crazy glue+ duckt tape=proven technology.

  • tailwind landing...looked like he had enough speed but, alas, no. Silly. Very silly. Cant see much of the airfield but look long enough for a cross wind landing at the least.

  • @aaronos1980 as he turned downwind on the erroneous final approach he probably had let the airspeed already decay in anticipation of landing. As soon as he turned downwind, you basically subtract out that windspeed and he was left with no enough. Right wing stalled first and she spiralled right. He is lucky he was reasonably low.

  • tip stall!

    

  • low, slow and turning. Not a good combination!

  • Low, slow and turning. Not a good combination!

  • i'm sure that'll buff out

  • ten out of ten for a spot landing

  • @sunrunner6993 correct but it will give the pilot the perception of moving faster than they are

  • Too low too slow with a tail wind, right wing stalled out

  • @lhitchins Incorrect! both wings would have been stalled. keep reading your books dummy

  • @lhitchins Tail wind is irrelevant to a stall. Tail wind will affect ground speed not air speed.

  • scheisse!

  • stalled the wing

  • The pilot was flying too slowly and stalled. He/she thought that he/she was flying too fast because of the ground rush affect when flying low. With a strong tail-wind, this gives the allusion that you are flying too fast and in fact you are flying too slow through the air and stall. I refer to this video when instructing glider pilots.

  • Landing into the wind is desirable because it results in a lower groundspeed, that's all. It has nothing to do with stalling or not stalling, i.e. the aircraft's energy level. This glider stalled because the pilot exceeded the maximum angle of attack as he ran out of energy (airspeed and height above terrain) before completing his turn, wind direction is irrelevant for that occurence.

  • @jedrinck Landing downwind is not always an option, from a small gliding site or on a field landing even a moderate tailwind would mean fluing through the hedge. A headwind gives you the most options for landing particularly on a cable break.

  • He Hit the rudder a little toooo much *rire

  • Its not the bank..you can bank as much as you want if you don't slip or over...his problem the Wind sock (wind direction) and he stallled his right wing

  • That impact could have been deadly. If you look at the wind ballon, he was going with the wind.

  • Ran out of altitude, airspeed and ideas all at the same time...

  • HAHAH! The wing doesn't even break off xD

  • the glider WAS landing into the wind, what are all you saying about the pilot NOT doing this?

  • @cptstubing Look at the wind sock blowing in the same direction as hes flying.....

  • @harryGShunt Oh yeah yeah yeah you're right... i read it wrong.

  • what was he thinking