Amy Lee VS Carly Smithson : Bring Me To Life

[Athena8823]

Amy lee... WTF is that kind of question? She is the ORIGINAL!

[THANASIS996]

amy Leee of course <3

[RomanovKatina]

Uhm las 2 cantan muy bien pero esa cancion es de evanescence y este video de carly... el sonido es pesimo, ami me gustan.las 1 voces :))))))

[MsZoey1009]

Amy by far!!! carly just doesn't suit it and has no emotion in her voice which is the quality that amy has to make it sound beautiful and meaningful...EVANECENCE FOR EVER! <3

[crazykittykilerX3]

Amy Lee of course :)

[DaniAmoBichos]

AMY LEEEEEE VERY BETTER, BECAUSE IS THE ORIGINAL

[Emotionsthatrun]

Amy lee of course

[deborahwinelover]

AMY LEE HANDS DOWN . CARLY CANNOT COME CLOSE TO AMYS VOCALS AND PREFORMACE.

[Jothike]

AMY !

Carly has a good voice,

but she is just a rip off

[XxArschkeksxX]

AMYYYYY!!!!!!!

[paris5433]

Amy Lee All The Way !! XD

Carly Can Suck It.

[TheMonrose18]

HOW.THE.FUCK.THAT LITTLE PATHETHIC UGLY GIRL COULD SUNG BRING ME TO LIFE?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?! THAT'S FUCKING PROFANATION!!!!!

[amyleesi]

Amy Lee !!



[TylerStina989]

Amy lee. carly isn't that great or she would have won american idol.. lmfao

[LihSayuri]

Amy Lee , e obvio.

[fuzzyboots38]

The song is not only meant for Amys voice, but Carly is too poppy for this kind of music. Amy throws her soul into her performances and really shows emotion with the lyrics, while Carly simply flips her head back and forth and throws her hand towards the crowd like I've seen so many popstars do before. Amy has feelings behind this music, and Carly rips it off because she has the same vocal range and Amys original songwriter. NOT COOL. Be original Carly. Copycats suck ass.

Amy Lee, hands down.

[myheartbleeds74]

Amy.Hands down.

[blastedretard]

I knw these two would eventually collide with each other

[TheCataIyst]

Amy Lee, duh.

[Boneaparte386]

uh easy...amy fo sho! :)

[dimevishuu]

amy lee is the best !!!!

[Leleleths2]

Amy Lee

[Judie066]

ncerely, Carly is good, true, but ... XD, what did a replica of Amy Lee?. Amy is unique, no one can compare with her and not for nothing, but gives a thousand kicks in many respects to Carly ...

YOU ONLY AMY LEE!!!!!!!!!!!!

[REIREI29]

Both these women are great singers.

But, Amy's a better singer, and her stage presence is awesome.

Carly is more like "Lemmie flip my hair and look purrrrrty."

Amy is more "I'mma rock the fuck out, rip and run, work the stage, get sweaty-cause-who-the-hell-give­s-a-fuck-about-always-lookin'-­pretty-headbang-like a MOTHER FUCKING ROCKSTAR IS SUPPOSED TOO."

[REIREI29]

0:46......WHAT is on Carlys fingers?

[REIREI29]

At 0:26 THAT's how you sing the song.

[ozbilege123]

@HayZing She knows about autotune but refuses to use one and this is what every singer out there should. I doubt that Amy uses autotune in the studio too... OK, maybe a little... but autotune is deceiving the fans..

[DigiTilDeth]

I like Carly but I put my money on Amy. And its not just loyalty. This video proves that shes both a better singer and better performer.

[MetAutrique]

I know tha Amy is originally who sings the song but she is so lazy when she sings live so i prefer Carly

[1skittlebear7]

Amy is the better voice, srry



[younishaider100]

Amy is the best

[lance22x]

amy lee xD

[waterlilly166]

Amy wins of course! And what concert is the Evanescence clip from?

[MsLebbel]

@PunkRokFaerie At least get your facts straight. Ben Moody was not the primary writer of the songs from the Fallen CD, they were written by both him and Amy. This song was written by both of them, (and David Hodges)

Also, she only fired one of her bandmates, (John leCompt,) the others, (including Ben Moody,) left out of choice. Ben Moody is also allowed to use the songs actually.

So most of your arguments are invalid.

[stefnuletsu]

Amy oviously!!=P~~~

[pajamagirl123]

Vocally, Carly is a little bit superior to Amy. I watched her on American Idol and the chicks got some pipes. But Amy IS Evanescence, so she wins by default :)

[LoveAmyLeeEv]

Amy will win everytime but I think Carly has some good voice, too.

[MsSecretdoors]

yang paling mirip ma aslinya ya amy lah

[jissypissymissy]

Definetly Amy Lee.....:-)

[RadioDomination]

If I was starting a band and had t choose one over the other, I would go with Carly... Amy has an amazing voice but then again they both do, Carly however doesn't have an ego so big it needs it's own bus while touring....

And as for We Are The Fallen performing Evanescence songs, get over it they wrote the songs and played the music Amy didn't... All of us at kxrx. net play We Are The Fallen all the time on air... \,,/(>.<\,,/ Horns Up Bitches, Rock On!

[alwynes]

I don't understand why people make such a big deal when Carly sang EV songs..

[robotdog1991]

Amy Lee is the source of inspiration as to how I came to love goth rock music.. Her voice is unique and sepcial and shld not be compared to another singer who did a cover of ev. I agree Carly sang well, but it is not enuff for me to say oh she sang so good I would stop watching amy lee, cuz amy lee proves that she can sing rock without forcing so hard on her voice, without trying to be so angry, her voice is kinda like soft but at the same time so edgy and rockish.

[Argentina891]

Amy Lee rocks, but this Carly Smithson was an absolute beauty on American Idol. They're both good, Carly just fell in the wrong place. Look up Carly Smithson American Idol, she could've done so much better.

[nazarethvargasberni]

amy!

[felixtrenta]

amy lee has a perfect voice !! and She is very beautiful !!

[emodalittleboy]

amy lee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!yeah..is the better

[mick471]

the new EV,,cant hold a candle to WATF,,the whole band sucks,,i still love amy,,but the band sucks

[DeadHeartBeat2011]

Amy lee is truly the great one. Bow down to Evanescence! Carly is an okay singer. but watching her singing an Evanescence song is like watching a sailor fly an airplane. Carly just needs to find her own song writing style. I'm not being mean. I'm just stating carly should only perform her own songs. Evanescence is back! I missed them very much. I'm tired of hip hop. Rock needs to be number one!

[grcinque]

amy lee

[lilmissnoone]

It doesn't have to be the end of the world because Carly did a cover... People do it all the time, Both talented singers, Yes Amy Wrote it and is the original singer but could you not also see it as a compliment that Carly learned it and sang it..

[sefa370]

amy leeeeeee

[darkangelkelsi20]

this honestly makes me mad.... how can it even be a challenge? it's amy's song. i'm with amy all the way and always will be. she is my inspiration and honestly i don't know where i would be without her music!! we are the fallen, no but you will be :)

[TheSlorg]

I think Amy performs better on these songs, but I also feel Carly and We Are The Fallen have produced better quality songs than the new-look Evanescence. Her performance of With or Without You is amazing, and Tear the World Down is an album without a single "skip it" song.

[chrispearsz1]

The first Amy's version in the video is from which live performance?

[Mind17]

It's obvious that Amy Lee wins!

This is HER song and not Carly's..

.. is like to ask: "better a paint of Picasso or an imitation?"

this is made for Amy.. but we all have to admit that Carly made it very well and she's a good singer too.. but Amy .. <3

[GhostCrazy27]

amy lee will always be the best..even though carly does sound ridiculously like her in we are the fallen <3 amy wins :3

[PunkRokFaerie]

Oh, and amy lee sounds like shit when she sings live... i loved evanescence when their first album came out and i thought amy lee was amazing. when i went to see them in concert i was so disappointed because amy lee's voice is nothing to write home about... shes really not that special

[PunkRokFaerie]

STUPID F***ING IDIOTS... BEN MOODY WAS THE PRIMARY WRITER OF THE SONGS ON THE FIRST EVANSCENCE ALBUM!!! THEY BELONG TO HIM... IF THERE'S ANYONE WHO DOESN'T HAVE A RIGHT TO THE SONGS ITS AMY LEE!!! IT DOESNT MATTER IF SHES THE FRONTWOMAN OF EVANESCENCE... THOSE SONGS ARE MOSTLY NOT EVEN HER WORK, SO WHY THE HELL SHOULD SHE BE ALLOWED TO USE THE SONGS BUT NOT BEN MOODY-THE ACTUAL WRITER!!! MY GOD PEOPLE AMYS NOT THAT GREAT... SHES A SELF-CENTERED B*TCH WHO HAS FIRED HER BANDMATES AT LEAST TWICE

[tmg996]

@PunkRokFaerie actually amy wrote this song for her husband, ben helped, but they definitely aent his, so calm down

[SinisterNight96]

@PunkRokFaerie However she founded the band and Ben only co founded. You need to do some research because both of them AND David Hodges wrote this song together. Not to mention bring me to life is about her husband. on the fallen album There are 12 songs. AMY WROTE ALL OF THEM BEN HELPED WITH 11. Do some research before you come up with your own made up shit!

[GreciaShyGirl]

Of course Amy Lee is better..She has an awesome voice !!!

the other girl (carly) is not a really good singer..she has a squeaky voice!

[Blackrose6767]

Amy Lee.. this was no contest, you won before I even hit play!

[ginee23]

When Amy Lee sings its like what happens on Harry potter.. "MAGIC".. Maybe Carly just want to prove she can also do it.

[sexyvampire1864]

Carly JUST NOOOOOO!

[sexyvampire1864]

WTFFF! why is this Carly singing an evanescence song. sing yo own songs which i happen to like. idk, the carly one's quality is really bad

[rrobinn1]

amylee for ever >>> amy winnnnnnnnnn

[bulma502]

Amy lee have the nice outfits

i like Amy lee outfits and her video

[bulma502]

Amy lee is the best : )

[bulma502]

Amy lee is the best

Carly smithson suckkks!

Amy lee is the best singer the best song i like is BRING ME TO LIFE that is the best song and the other one's too :)

i hate carly smithson because she have sqqeeeky voice

* * -

[synystergirl11298]

No DOUBT STRAIGHT UP Amy Lee Is The WINNER coz she is more talented tht Carly presides Carly has less talent then my pinky finger no one can beat amy lee she is just amazing i wish i could also coz she role model and always will be

[AwaiHashiba]

question who the hell is this wanna be amy lee chick? she should shut her mouth right up cuz excuse me her voice sound more karaoke then actually singing!

and who the hell would compare original with nothing? sorry futch face by apparently named Carly (YGO 5D's WTF? O.o), u'll never ever be good enough even to sing the most lamest song in the world, try russian...they don't need to a voice to sing, they just muble the words, u can do the same...Amy Lee the victory goes to u...!

[andwedance10]

Carly is great and did a good job, but it's Amy hands down. And does anyone else notice that Amy is thrashing around ROCKING out? It's hard to sing perfectly when you're also entertaining and enjoying being on stage. Carly just stands there.

[kbaker2011]

Carly sung this better.. sorry carly is a better live singer than Amy.. IMO.

[froggyoggy]

@kbaker2011 that's because Carly wasn't dancing around and rocking out. It's much harder to sing the way amy moves around the stage while Carly just stands there

[rnhrdt1]

amy lee definitley!!! :)



[blore]

Some comparison.

Cellphone quality VS studio quality.

Either way, I like more how Amy sings, but Carly still sings it very well.

[athousandstrats]

All these Evanescense fantards are all "AMY AMY AMY AMY" when in fact Carly sings much better in these clips. MUCH better. Amy is kinda hard to listen to here...

[BizzeyBunny]

@athousandstrats Well to be honest, if you look at how much Amy moves in her performances, you'll see why sometimes her voice breaks and she gets short of breath. She shows much more emotion and passion when she sings where as Carly is just there.. singing, no passion for it.

Amy still beats Carly by a long shot imo.

[got2beme100]

@BizzeyBunny Yeah, i totally agree.

[mtpretty]

IT'S AMY LEE'S SONG SO U CAN'T  COMPARE IT

[angel1988turkey]

incomparable!!!! amyyyyyy of courseee ;)

[wongson0811]

AMY FOR SURE !!

FOREVER AND ALWAYS !!

[AnaPaula9814]

porraaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa ate bring me to life essa merda pegou do evanescence

q merda de banda fala serio isso mostra q essa banda e faxada

[xLaulipopx]

No need to ask HAHAHAHAHAHAHAAH

EVANESCENCE'S THE BEST <3

[Mattroful]

Original will always trump the karaoke version.

[Blossamfall]

Evanescnece 4ever, Amy is my idol <3 <3

[LittleHispanicMan]

Amy actually knows how to FUCKING rocks out hard!! not like this hair flicking shit that carly does!!

[Cormierguy121]

You know...from what I heard here, I think Carly hit the notes better, Amy lacked control.

[snow27white]

Amy. Duh! its her song. and she sings it with a mysteriousness that carly does not.

[umaestrela1]

naunm gostei porque qualquer um sabe q a amy lee ganha sem nem diputar

[KISSALIVEROCK]

@umaestrela1 é isso aí! Amy diva forever

[27roxxx]

"WE ARE THE FALLEN" SHOULD BE NAMED AS "WE ARE THE FAIL" IT SOUNDS MUCHHH BETTER...LOL

[flerfymcflerf098]

its funny how she tries to be gothic-ish now but in this video she trys to dress the way other people do

[mIGRAINeGRRL]

Amy!

[Thexpumazoxrock]

AMY FOREVER AND EVER¡¡¡¡¡ CARLY IS SHIT¡¡¡

[Thexpumazoxrock]

AMY FOREVER AND EVER ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

[aceofnekos]

Just by looking at the title you can tell who wins automatically Amy Lee :3

[iloveevanescence1795]

Well since it's Amy's song, Amy's lyrics, Amy's melody, designed for Amy's voice, and Amy's a way better singer, guess who wins?

SPOILER ALERT.

Amy.

[EvanescenceFreak01]

carly sucks !

[1995jocelynespino]

amy lee wins this one

[GothicAngel00100]

Carly doing like a striper!!!

AMY LEEEEEE

[MegaTyler2121]

Amy won hands down Carly and we are the fallon are just a copy of evanescence they will never be as good as the original band

[LamiaBella14]

@MegaTyler2121 They kind of are the original band. They have three of four original members, Evanescence has one. I'll always prefer Amy's vocals on the Fallen album, but as far as I'm concerned, Evanescence died the day Ben Moody left.

[TheKotecaava]

@LamiaBella14 Amy Lee, Tim McCord and Terry Balsamo... They Didn't left. so Evanescence is a live...and getting stronger and they become more famous than ever before....no matter was ban moody left EV or not. he's a betrayer for me...He's new band WATF Sucks!!! They will never compared with Evanescence, Coz' EV The Best Band Ever and Owner 2 Grammys for one year...

[Alysin123]

Carly needs to gain weight she is a Talentless stick compared to amy THUMBS UP FOR WOMEN WITH REAL BODIEAS!!!

[8692brent]

Well amy its going off cuz shes rockin around! Of course lol. She sings like with a long note/opera voice you cant do that perfectly while running around the stage duh! But ya amy def is way better

[ladygothMetlee]

wtf!! Nada como Amy Lee THE ONLY ONE ok forever!

[SpiritofInsanity]

...What on earth is Carly doing with her head.

Amy is better.

[afroditasexmetal]

amy lee's voice is more sweet... carly just want to look good...

[Ucheny]

Oh how is that pathetic - compare professional photage with quality sound to crappy-photage with shitty bit-rate

Amy is hysterical infantile girl, and sings *now* songs that she didn't write.

She is nothing more than a precious tool. Just like the Taria Turunenn from Nightwish but they are nothing without ingenious musicians

[saturaist]

la cantante de we are fallen es puro plastico!!! q viene a cantar o a hacer desfiles de moda!!?¡ dedicate a otra cosa nena!

no hay como la naturalidad de amy lee.

[saturaist]

no comparen a amy... es mucho mejor amy lee que esa mujer!!! por dios!

[loveisgreat41]

Without a doubt AMY LEE....tht woman whatever her name is,does tht have quarter amy lee has...she needs to stop coping amy and get herself a life!!!...........Amy we all love you =)

[MrMikroula]

AMY IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN CARLY

CARLY JUST TRYING TO BE SIMILAR TO AMY BUT SHE CAN'T!!!!!!

AMY IS UNIQUE!!!!

[RockerGirlGoRawr]

Amy Lee of Courseee . That carly?who the hell she think she is..?Blaaa she Suckkkks! Never compare such a nice voice like amy's with a horrible sqqeeeky voice like Carly Eghhh.

AMY LEE♥ FOREVER Shes is awesome she is my idol

EVANESCENCE THE BEST♥

Fuck Yeah. x)

[JordanMcCoyFan94]

Amy, although I think Carly is still a great singer. I think that her band We Are The Fallen is VERY similar to Evanescence though, but they are both really talented

[twigirl31197]

Once again, can't we just accept the fact that Amy Lee is a godess and can't be defeated?

[kaify12]

although she was sick in rock am ring 2007

she is so fuckin better

[nixichixi85]

not that i dont apreciate this video clearly showing how beautiful and talented amy is...but why are we EV fans pushing to prove amy is better than carly. evry one knows that. why arnt we fighting to prove that amy has more talent in her little finger than all these people who are waaaay more famous than her. like katy perry and all those bubble gum pop stars. amy gets no fame for being a goddess. and they get it all for being whores.

[xLipsOfDeceit7x]

Obviously Amy

[RandomPosts4Ever]

amy lee(my reasons): 1.what is carly wearing to sing this dark, beautiful song? 2. amy's stlye is amazing. 3.amy is moving around singing this(its hard) while carlys STANDING THERE.4.amy lee IS MY IDOL4.Carly took 2 band members of evanescence. and her voice in this video is just..doesnt fit this song.5.carly copies amy (in my eyes.)6.again..what the hell..is she wearing to sing this song?! totally ruins the point of the lyrics. 7:AMY LEE FOREVER SHE IS AMAZING.

im done..maybe.

[rocknroller1986]

I've been an Evanescence Fan since the beginning, and Amy will always be the best at what she does! Carly Smithson is a american Idol reject and desperate wannebe Amy Lee. She's pathethic!

[reila93]

amyyyyyyyyyy <3 ovviamente!

[Sasnaru367]

Why do people never take into consideration that Amy lee is running around stage and how that really fatigues her voice? Cmon people if you've ever seen her do bring me to life acoustic you know she sounds 1,000,000 times better than Carly.

[WickedZZzY]

Amy is a far better singer

But carly sounded better in this video

[jonnythong22]

God amy is struggling with her own song, she sounds horrible doing this song live. Carly can sing the phone book without much effort at all. Sheesh, Carly wins this battle with Amy's song, hands down. Die hard/heartbroken fans will say otherwise.

[KDaNinja]

The only reason Carly cant win is because Amy did the original "Bring Me To Life."

[cblachsa]

AMY.

[archsirius]

Carly nailed the bridge in her own way, was a really good adaptation

[MrHahn94]

I think the only advantge carly got over amy is that she has her old band.....I think old evanescence is way better than Amy's new band

[darklight076]

Amy's voice almost broke when she climbs into the treble, Carly

much more vocal power I think. In addition, the video with Carly

is very poor, it can play in favor of Amy Lee ...

[aquament]

I think we are the fallen and Carly are good but they will never be better than evanescence and Amy lee's amazing vocals

[thebwahbuddies]

Amy Lee is way better at singing the song BECAUSE she is the original! But if Amy were to sing a different song, like "Bury Me Alive", where Carly is the original I think Carly would sound much better!! It just depends on the song!!

[FREAKYHIPPIENINJA]

amy lee by a long shot



[lilpop559]

First I love amylee and Evenescence always did yes they sound the same not gonna lie BUT...... its amys old band ofcourse its gonna look and sound the same do I think carly is trying to look like her yes in a way do I think amys old band is hating on her yes I do we are the fallen sounds good and is a good band do I think they should stopped singing evenescence songs in concerts yes because thosed are amys song they should sing their own songs in concerts

[starrfall3n]

Carly has a nice voice but she sounds and looks like a pop singer instead of a rock one(definetely doesnt look like one), Amy on the other hand has not only a great voice but is and looks like the rock/goth band style she likes and represents... No offense to WRTF or Carly because some of their songs are enjoyable but they still seem to me like a cheap copy of Evanescence.

[Haliaaloha]

all you haters need to get a damn grip. amy is amy carly is carly grow the fuck up if you dont like somebody whoever it is dont listen dumbass!

[chipmunkgurl122]

amy

[22Sweetybarbie]

amy lee I like you

[atomicbobcat92]

Amy has an all around better voice than the that stupid non winner, how could anyone think shes good? She didn't even win American Idol. Amy's better

[KakashiHatake2121]

Carly is singing like a freaking pop star and look at her fucking hair. She needs to go do some other shit.

[KakashiHatake2121]

Not to mention, Carly looks like a freaking pop model some shit IDK WTF. Amy... her face was made to be goth rock, was made to be a goddess, was made to be dark and badass. >[ Amy pwns.

[KakashiHatake2121]

I don't understand why those money lusting jack asses leave the band to form a rip off copy of what they just left. And then they go on and pick on an American Idol chick to imitate Amy? That is SOOOOO low. Amy is the original, her own style, her own lyrics, her own compositions. You can NEVER compare Carly to Amy. AMY LEE IS THE GODDESS OF IMAGINARY LIGHT!

[kacdela]

Amy is the best...

[anntsuy7]

AMY !! 234678983467892837489938728498­371924877289384738473248 veses !

[SucideLoveStyle]

Amy!!! (: sin duda

[JenMars15]

Carly is singing it like a pop song, when it's supposed to be ROCK!!!!!

[sweetsugarhoney2]

@JenMars15 my thoughts exactly. It's like Kelly Clarkson singing. Carly seems to have a good voice for a pop singer, but this is a rock band, you can't sing Bring Me To Life like you sing a song by Britney Spears.

[maionesitafull]

AME LEE :)

[siculari]

Vocally Carly is clearly the better of the two. Sorry guys.

[mckcmckcmck]

AMY LEE ALL THE WAY

[poloistu01]

Amy 100%!

[LeeZenith]

i dont like the accent of the shit Carly! I like the goddess voice of Amy ♥

[LeeZenith]

Please AMY LEE!!!! carly is a shit! and a flop! ¬¬

[Siddius83]

I like Carly's stuff...and her accent ;) but Amy can't be beaten at her own songs. No contest!

[JOJO20127]

i like them both....but amy lee cant be replaced

[IsabellaTnR1]

Wat is carly wearing?! Its a rock song not a whole bunch of pop s***

[DarkAteeq]

Carly Smithson MUCH BETTER

[IsabellaTnR1]

@DarkAteeq sorry but very few people agree...

[MsJune6969]

No one can replace Amys great voice!!!

[joze1245]

Amy Lee of course, the other one is just a poser

[daperrote6168]

I choose Amy Lee!

[NatashaLee1992]

GO AWAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY!

AMY FOREVER <3

[manospitsis]

AMY LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE........­..!!!!!!!!!