Added: 5 years ago
From: skywalker74
Views: 277,302
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (276)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Happy Noel

  • Her make up looks so fresh here in the opening song, Israel. Watch the entire gig and see how it wears off more & more :).

    @ OfraHaza, i think she is one of the best live singers ever.. You have to consider how intense they toured at that time, and after the years, touring did let her voice suffer, but in 81 she sounded just brilliant!

  • Does anyone knows where to get the original release of this?

  • @EruptionLaVey

    This "Rockpalast" concert has never had an official release, but there are various bootleg DVD's of the gig. I'm very fortunate enough to own a bootleg DVD of this full concert called "Voodoo Dolly: Live in 1981". It includes this full show as well as the broadcasted songs from the 9 March 1981 "Rock Goes To College" gig and a few bad quality clips performed in early 1979 on French TV.

    I've uploaded clips from the bootleg DVD on my other channel, 'Mr13595Stephen'.

  • I love Siouxsie, but I don't think she can sing live, and that is not a good thing. I've seen her live and it is no different.

  • Powerwoman!!!

  • fantastici!!

  • A classic from her......

    

  • Here's a great example of how, for all the blather about punk going against the old school rock, in the end it was still just another variation on it - and I mean that in a good way. McGeoch was a rock guy - playing Zeppelin tunes since he was 10 - and he brought that skill and his immense creativity to a band that had great potential, but needed that "something" more - something that a punk guitarist would not have had the skill or diversity.

  • SHePP sann DarR ,

  • The guitarist was cut short

  • john mc geoch sos lo maximo , aguante siouxsie !!!!!!!

  • This Video will draw me to it time and time again XX

  • incredible

  • she's got that look I always look for in a girl

  • She looks like a female Pharoh...ahead of their time

  • i want sooooooooooooooooo much this showww :X

  • 5 years before I was born....

  • A goth band should write a song about the dispossessed Palestinians called "Palestine" that goes "little orphans in the sand, with no place to call their home, start their singing..."

  • @wolzek the cure did killing a arab

  • @mathamore americano?

  • @wolzek Then they'd be slammed for praising subhumans and cannibals (yes, I read someone calling "those ay-rabs" this) only good to be turned into collateral damage and be summoned to write about Israel. On and on and on and on…

  • If i could have two Girls, these would be Siouxie and Debbie Harry

  • raw talent , and oh so awesome because of it . where is she now?

  • @ahian5620z She lives in Paris, last I heard. I think Mantaray was the last time she toured.

  • and ps. nobody now or ever can command an audience quite like siouxsie sioux. love her or hate her,you were (and still are!) interested in what she had to say.

  • not did the banshees bode the most prolific guitarist but they had the best drummer that ever existed,imo,in budgie.

  • What a masterpiece!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Is great song. and why Israel?

    this kind of guitars in 1981 is amazing!

  • Saw them 3 times around this time, twice at Hammersmith Palais, right at the front, skinhead riot at the 1st one. This is when they were at the top of their game. Your right, McGeoch was a genius.

  • If it was £1000 to get into this gig I would get a bank loan.

  • she is so cool. so, so, so cool.

  • Saw them in Cardiff on this tour what a great singer!!

  • Their music, their image is timeless.

  • 1980 all over again....power,and passion from the queen of punk and goth.....siouxise ...you gave so much....thank you

  • Awesome!!

  • John McGeoch, Greenock Strone Guitar Genius, ya bass.

  • John McGeoch, like myself, from Greenock Strone stock. Artistically, worlds apart.

  •  What is the meaning of this song?!?

  • Great band, takes me back to my teenage years. Doesn't Alan speak in German, then says the band's name in a northern accent?

  • You know who ripped these guys off blind? U2, that's who. Plenty of examples, but just play 'Pride' after this one...

  • @Slammerworm1

    The Banshees, yes....

    and Joy Division/New Order, another victims of U2

  • @Slammerworm1 not surprising at all! Edge got his inspiration from McGeoch and can hear that in most of their songs.

  • @yahoosirius Ah, evidently not just from McGeoch but also from John MacKay, Banshees guitarist over 1977-79. Check out 'The Scream', which one imagines was a popular spin around at Edge's place. Play 'Jigsaw Feeling' and then U2's 'I Will Follow' and thar she blows...

  • siouxsie un icono, lo mejor del underground ochentero

  • Siouxsie sounds a bit.....Cockney????

  • @bludgeonbunny That would be because she is London born nd bread.

  • Santa Claus fave band and tune!

  • I think Siouxie sounds great live. Saw her in the first LaLaPolooza tour. I agree about Bernard of New Order. Still love 'em both. Been a fan since alternative was truly alternative.

  • great song and fotage by a great band, boy did Sioxsie look hot back in '81! Thanks for this skywalker

  • 1st time I have heard this, thought she and the Banchees are pretty good, will listen to more

  • I like siouxsie and the banshees but she sounds dreadfull live(her singing not the band) lol, about as bad as new order live but i still like both of them...its all about the music!

  • This is sooo cool! I never heard of this band until 1988..I was into other band before this

  • i love you banshees

  • SIOUXSIE<33333333

  • I love it!

  • Apology taken. Sorry for my rude response, It wasnt my bay back then.

  • definitely arabs hate this song!!! who cares?... we love this!!!

  • Arabs? Never heard of 'em.

  • And I wasnt talking about the star on her shirt. You should have listened properly.

    Siouxsie often wore a swastika necklace, which people found shocking.

  • I just TOLD its not a nazi symbol.

  • Today's exactly a year that I'm living in Israel... :)

    I love Siouxsie since I was 15 (now I'm 20)

  • great performance !

  • thanks for sharing.

  • I Love

  • So haunting and fckn brill.. Love u Siouxsie..

  • Reminds me of Kay in Brighton. Young love

  • Uh oh! Everyone scatter, Thought Police have arrived!

  • Siouxsie was around long before Sinead .

  • Very true my friend

  • her voice is almost the same as Sineád O'connor I like that

  • i was playing this record all the time, it,s still magic.

    Ashley Holland

  • what a great guitar solo.

  • one of the best songs of the 80's and fuck with everyone who politicizes or disagree

    its a great song period

  • kossom is rael!!

  • kossom israel!!!

  • Yeah, because all women should be available for your personal masturbation needs. Right?

    How sad.

  • Yes, it was played in Germany, so bloody what ? Are we going to blame Germany forever ? Then why not blame Churchill, who founded concentration camps during the South African war ? We're in the XXIh century, can't we stop pointing fingers ?

    Don't get me wrong : I'm from France, and I'm really proud to count Brits and German folks as my very dear friends and to speak both languages (okay, my German needs improvment ;). We'reall Europeans nowadays, and we're mate/Freunden !

  • Siouxsie wrote this song after getting into trouble wearing a swastika herself (she did it for fashion, a bit naive on her part) and subsequently National Front-type followers starting showing up to her performances.  She nipped the swastika backlash and NF attendance with this song.

  • The swastika has never truly been a nazi symbol. Its a symbol of indian culture and even more then that.

    Siouxsie didnt wear it as a nazi symbol.

    She was propably perfectly aware of the symbol.

    Either way, she really is a charming and a very talented woman.

  • She admitted that she wore it for shock value, and that she did it out of youthful stupidity.

  • @pateris Totally agree dude, it's over lets move on. peace

  • @pateris cromwell killed half the population of irleand in the mid 1600s and then the potato famine in the 1840s the brits never apologize the japanese never apologized for the rape of nanking, the turks dont even admit they commited genocide against armeninans, my family in holland fought in the reristance my aunt was tortured by the gestapo for hiding jews.. its my opinion however that its long past time to stop bashing the german people they suffered too why are all germans to blame

  • @MrBillcale Indeed. No one can take the high ground… So it should be time to forget about it and concentrate on music ç

  • @pateris s'cool

  • do we blame russians for communism should other gruop be held collectively resposible for marxsims crimes?? no germany has been made to feel guilt, why not pick on some group that never took respsiblity for its crimes

  • Alan Bangs (the host) was a real douche. Never liked him. I remember when he (tried) to interview Johnny Rotten. Johnny made him look even more stupid.

  • What a woman!! I love her to pieces.

  • Siouxsie and the Banshees ROCKS!

  • She wrote this after getting beat up for wearing a swastika to i guess prove she's not rascist/fascist. She only like how it looked to be anti-bourguoisie... she rocks.

  • Meiner Meinung nach wäre ein ähnlicher Auftritt heutzutage schwerlich möglich: Man singt über Israel, sofort wären irgendwelche Muslim-Bruderschaften auf den Plan gerufen.

    Selbstmordattentäter würden den Saal bevölkern...

    Meine Fresse, wie ich solche religiösen Spinner hasse...

  • I wish that every person in the world would read the study by Daniel Bar-Tal and Nets-Zehngut (Tel Aviv University) entitled:

    "The Israeli-Jewish Collective Memory of the Israeli-Arab/Palestinian Conflict"

    If they did and truly understood all of it's implications then war would end in an instant.

  • I have not read this Study but if what you say is True then why not promote it?

  • he just did you fucking braindead retard. jesus. some people.

  • No need to be rude to ppl meatymouldia! One comment on U tube isnt exactly promoting it .

    But If I see the book I will give it a look.

  • sorry - im only on youtube for the comments bunfight. i dont want to mess with normal people only americans :)

  • @meatymouldia

    The police of the world, what have they done wrong apart from insist onfreedom of speech (for themselves and no one else) LOL

  • she is so fuckin awesome.

  • @revosuicide86 ill go with that

  • 2.47-3.04 - great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • John McGeoch! So Cool.

  • WAS

  • how true

  • Comment removed

  • John McGeoch is (sadly was) a genius. One of my favourtite guitarists.

  • I agree 100%. The quintessential post-punk guitarist.

  • @wdamian

    Hi do you know other post punk guitarrist with a distintive sound,  apart of the mediocre of robert smith?

  • @Tengocuentadeyoutub Andy Gill of Gang of Four springs to mind. His guitar playing on their first couple of releases sounds like a Pollock painting to me.

  • @wdamian

    gang of four... umm I've heard some songs , but don't they play with distortion?

    I like more a clean DISTINTIVE alternative guitar sound.

    Like john mcgeoch , smith, etc.

  • @graemereaper May Israel grow and prosper but not on the cost of taking land from their neighbours.

  • so Siouxie like. Opening w/ this song in Germany...

  • Funny isn't it ?

  • I love this song 'israel' and siouxie sue for it expresses my support for the state of Israel and the Jewish peaple.

  • siouxsie sue is just brilliant!! musician

    she really is a genius of rhe performing arts

  • is the best , good live in Israel.

  • I was only 6 but , i am such a siouxsie fan, the most amazing woman..

  • i wasn't even born in 1981 i born on 1991 xD

    altough i LUV the song

  • me too ;D

  • If I were male I'd ask her to marry me.

  • that shouldnt stop you :)

  • GEIL, GEIL!!!!

  • love her

  • Siouxsie awesome voice & awesome image

  • i have a video i downloaded from around 2k where she is wearing knee length leather boots, same song. cannot find it anywhere. she is so awesome ..

    hard to believe that the cure, sex pistols, and souxsie all have histories that tie together ..

  • Well, it always goes like that, there are tribes of artists, tribes of musicians all connected ;)

  • john mcgeogh looks so fucking cool, no wonder johnny marr was a big fan

  • when you compare her vocals back then and what she sounds like now....it's a seriously amazing difference.....the way she sings now is so bad, i can't even listen to anything she does now.....that solo record was AWFUL! it seems like people just don't notice or choose not to.....i miss the way she used to sound...now she just sux bad!

  • Sadly, you're right. She didn't take care of her voice.

  • FANTASTIC!!!!!!!

  • Believe me, I live next to Germany (Holland) and I can still see some conservative sentiment by the Germans when it comes to national pride, nationalism, their history, etc. I don't give the youngsters any blame of what happened during the war. But it's a common fact that no one talks about it with their parents/grand-parents, because of shame from their elders. I don't think they are to blame, but it still is a sensitive thing... that's all.

  • I have this concert on the Siouxsie & the Banshees "Voodoo Dolly Live in 1981" DVD which contains this whole concert as well as the Warwick University "Rock Goes to College" performance and French TV specials.

  • my to

  • goddamn her voice is awesome! and shes so young here....shes like some kid here

  • Bit awkward to play a song about Israel in a Germany concert. Lot of people must felt a bit unconformable.

  • not really, after all, the third reich ended 36 years before the concert and no-one really felt any sort of connection to that time by the 80s

    I honestly wonder when people will stop obsessing about the Third Reich, yes it was a terrible act, but German's shouldn't feel guilty or uncomfortable about it now. After all the Americans and British killed off nearly all of the Native Americans - stop trying to make modern-day Germany feel bad for a history it has nothing to do with.

  • i dont understand how its possible to knit such a dense music carpet with only three instruments!!!singing and shouting 4 2 hours must be very exhausting!!

  • The Police do it quite eloquently too.

  • thank u so much skywalker!!!That is the german concert S and the B gave for the german TV program Rockpalast for the WDR TV Station in Cologne back in 81!!Brings back great memories!!!best music ever!!!enjoy instead of talking about religion...

  • I dont think Siouxsie is Jewish though at all, i thought she had more gipsy blood but who really cares. I guess she donned herself in 'Jewish' symbolism against the antics of shortsighted bigots to make a point.

    She's an artist who observes the world and writes about it. I dont think her sentiments would be the same of Israel today though!!

    Still, she's eternally gorgeous and was my fave teen pin up!

  • SIOUXSIE on the song ISRAEL: "No it's not about religion as such, its more general. A disillusioned person, or whole race whove ceased to understand or believe in what they held to be the truth. It tries to put across, you shouldnt cover what you feel inside by teaching or attitudes imposed on you. It emphasises the strength of the individual." Source: Sounds 28/02/81.

  • Thank you for posting this. Siouxsie never fails to impress me.

  • I heard in an interview on VH1 that she used to dawn a swastika arm band on stage for shock value.

    My theory is this song is at least in some part atonement for that. I also see a lot of videos where she wears a star of david t-shirt. Who knows.

  • Swastika was just a punk provocation/

  • Siouxsie's background is actually Jewish. The swastika thing was when she was younger and was just a gimmick -- a bad one at that. Maybe she did feel guilty.

  • siouxie started wearing a big swastika on her arm, so i guess she felt guilty

  • ahahah i'm a huge fan but my side is hurtin im laughing so hard

  • Always glad to bring a smile into your day as I certainly did with Souxie and the rest of the band for that matter...It was a happy house that night I can tell you

  • Amazing composition

  • In regards to what Demachman said responding to the ignorant person; its called Zionism for the calling of the jewish nation to, get this, zion= israel/palestine. Because I don't know if you've heard of this but there was a thing called the holocaust and there were plenty of displaced jews after the war and they looked to refuge in zion.

  • I'm agree with you, they'll never understand this, but this song don't mention the "Zionist" side of Israel. Remember: Not all jews are Zionists (just look for David Cole's videos and revisionism articles and you will see)

  • Siouxsie is an artist - Zionism is a scam... It's not THAT hard to distinguish, now, is it?

  • Siouxsie is indeed an artist and zionism is not a scam. Your birth is, maybe, but not Zionism. Zionism is as old as the day Judea got called Palestine by some Roman Emperor so the Jews would forget their Heritage. You understand? Or do you copy the biassed media and don't investigate or thinkm before you talk sh-t?

  • No need to get aggressive. Not everybody knows every term in english. I just misinterpreted.

  • it was in Germany, Rockpalast was somethhing like Top of the Pops in UK once a week on TV and steered away from the charts with a more alternative twist

  • I think the lyrics to Arabian Knights are misguided and generally a bit crap, but that aside, Zionists aren't the only people who might take issue with some aspects of Arab culture.

  • Is Siouxsie Jewish?

  • I don't think so, I believe on her first album she had a song called: "The Lords Prayer" which is Christian.

  • Who cares?

    Throw all religions away, they don't have positive aspects, they are the reasons of all wars.

    Believe in mankind, not in "gods" from myths thousand years ago.

  • That's just about the most historically ignorant comment I've ever seen.

    The history of the 20th century abounds with examples that disprove your assumption.

  • Maybe this problems are results of that religious nonsens? Ever thought about that? And they carry it to this century...

    9/11, ever heard of?

  • Well, sure Islam has a long history of extreme violence, beginning with Mohammed.

    But that's not really addressing the assumptions involved in the comment I responded to.

  • Before the Nazis stole the symbol and corrupted it, it was used(and still is) at many Hindu, Buddhist and Jain ceremonies.

    Yeah i grew up in Thatcher's Britain and used to 'worship' Siouxsie as my goddess!

    People were using all manner of symbolism to rebel against the order but the very ideals of punk were bought and sold back to the masses without the meaning!

  • I saw them at Bracknell Sports Centre in 1981 and all i can remember it was invaded by a load skins.

    They were all 'Seig Heiling' so i joined in!!!

    Well as a 15yr old kid it all seems a bit of fun but i could never work out why SATB attracted so many skins to their gigs. A bit sad really as they aint Nazis for sure.

  • Several months ago I've read in some UK music mag interv.with her (her new solo record was coming out) and the reporter asked her about swastika. She was so pissed about the question, she walked out, and they had to promise they won;t ask it again. So I guess to this day she feels ashamed and perhaps guilty of her young days' stupidity.

  • Before that, I;ve seen a documentary in which she gave an interview wearing swastika. She wasn't nazi, she tried to be antisocial, anarchistic and came kinda like a stupid & spoiled nazi brat instead.

    On the other hand I've heard late 70s & 80s were quite a hard time for many young people in GB, Thatcherism, antisocial & anticultural politics, so...;)

    Anyway, I like S&tB songs very much and this one's my fav.