Added: 10 months ago
From: amberisnotaman
Views: 74,550
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (176)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i came to listen to this song.. not to just listen to amber's voice.

    i came hereto listen f(x)! :))

  • Gosh... Amber's voice.

    I'm just praying for the day Amber comes out with her own solo album, singing and rapping. Like a BOSS.

    <3

  • That is an "unadvised" video. =p

  • really?!

    amber is just amazing as well as the members, if she hasn't improved then why would she debut now?! just appreciate the song and amber's rapping and singing skills! so stop saying bad things about her! ¬_¬

  • Amber's a really good singer. Eat food all of you, haters.

  • This needs to be in a KDrama. NOW.

  • tons of kpop groups are assigned roles but that doesnt mean they're only good at rapping singing dancing some less talented members need to shine too

  • Amber 1:15 - 1:27 <3

  • Comment removed

  • F(x) ,I so into u.^^

    Fighting,F(x).

  • Ah ambers a great singer xD and every time I hear krystal sing she sounds like Jessica lmao and whoever sang after Krystal kinda sounded like yuri lol (at some parts)

  • I absolutely love this song and I LOVE Amber! Thanks for uploading! :D

  • 1:15- 1:26 ♥!!

  • LUNA IS MY BIAS SO WHAT?! she is the main vocalist after all T_T

  • VIDEEEOOOO would be awesome <3 :DDDD

  • I deffinetly wnt a music video :P

  • Best part at 1:14 :D amber sings

  • i like amber's singing voice, she's definitely better than victoria or sulli, but i still think luna and krystal are better vocally :P

  • i dedicated this song to my crush:)..he just smiled and hugged me:)..he also loves f(x) like me:))))..she likes sulli while i like amber:)i soo love f(x)..thnx 4 making this song

  • is it just me or I think Amber have a better vocal than Krystal, she is just behind Luna. Maybe her lack of the language; thats y, her company doesn't allow her sing much.

  • @cathy91G I kinda agree but I've never heard Amber sing live or high notes like Krystal. So I really only have studio versions of a few songs (like this song) to judge >.<

  • @jacobwiththeface heres a vid of amber singing krystal's high part in pinocchio :) she can sing high notes too :D /watch?v=gzo4JpGv0jo

  • @cathy91G that's not it. amber can speak and sing in korean very well. and if she didnt, that wouldnt be the reason why she doesnt sing. that reason would be the most ridiculous. she doesnt sing much because she's the rapper, not vocalist. vocalist like luna and krystal sing a lot because that's their positions. if amber where vocalist then she would had more lines to sing. for example taemin from SHINee, he doesnt sing much 'cuz he's da main dancer, he dances more..

  • @cathy91G not true...SM knows what they're doing when they pick main vocalists. if amber was better than krystal she'd be main vocalist not krystal.

  • i thought jessica who sing first but its krystal cuz there voice are like the same here......

    love the song... amber is also good in vocal singing aside from rapping... wow

    f(x) fighting!!!!

  • i love this song! is my favorite song of this album

  • Whoaa...! Amber's singing voice is so vocally and pretty :'D

    Its like she's the whole package!

  • LOL love the username.

  • Amber starts  from 1:11

  • Is this song just amber singing? When does she sing?

  • this song is nice

  • i want to hear more of Umber's singing!!!! she did really excellent here!!!!!

  • Kyaaah! Hearing Amber sing makes me so very very veeeeery happy! I'm glad that she actully shows her singing talent and not just her rap

  • Thanks to SM they found amber......if not my life will not be like today...

  • love Amber's voice - it's not whiny. this is one of my fave songs in the album.

  • wow.. really like this!

  • Amber can rap, dance, and sing. WOW! ^_^

  • When i'm listening to Amber's part i always close my eyes and feel the song..Amber really have a amazing voice

  • I donno why but i am addicted to Amber's part!! Its so wonderful!! <3

  • Can someone tell me when exactlly Amber sings? I have no clue.

  • @finesse183 : Amber 1:14

  • @gianneism AHHHHHHHHHHHHHA!

    I THOUGHT THAT WAS AMBER WHEN I FIRST HEARD THIS SONG, BUT THEN WAS LIKE "NAHHH THEY DONT GIVE HER NO LINES!"

    BUT ITS REALLY AMBER!!!! *O*

    I LOVE that low/tomboy but feminity thing she has going on!

    SHE NEEDS MORE FREAKEN LINES!! T__T

    I know Luna and Krystal sing REALLY AMAZING, but I honestly dont even know what Vic, Amber, and Sul sound like cause they get no lines! D;

  • For the people that keep insisting that "Amber got better, she has improved".

    No. She hasn't gotten better.

    She was already, for those who don't know, when she auditioned for SM, she SANG, a R&B song by Wheesung, one of her favorite korean artists, so if they choose her to be a trainee then we must assume she was well...fucking good.

    If you don't believe me, go look up Amber singing heal the world, back in their debut days.

  • @iRockYouRock67 she doesn't get better, dude.. She's the best from the beginning

  • @annepank Uhh, that's exactly what I said in my post. She had to be freaking good to be chosen.

  • 1:14 Note : Amber starts singing repeat it always... Love you AMber!

  • I love this song

  • OMG. Love this song out of their whole album. its so sweet and nice. krystal sounds just like jessica its creepy. but i agree love ambers voice, never really heard her sing before but when i heard that part i knew it was her. and plz dont bash me for sayin this but i thought amber sounded kind of like minzy (2NE1) (im a minzy biased person) and i love them both. they both have a sweet husky soothing tone to their voices. but yea love f(x) and the new album not bad and this is my fave from it.

  • OMG lm in love with amber's voice!!!

    i've repeated her part like thirty times ;p

    im so into u AMBER <3

  • amber's voice is so strong and warm >.< please have some more duet in the future <3

  • seriously...why are there 2 dislikes?? this song is so nice... :(

  • You know what I think SM should do, cause this is just my opinion. Mkay they should let Vicky and Amber do a duet, make a MV. And perform it on stage like with what they do with 2ne1. Cause I almost never hear their voices.... And they have good voices!!! >.<

  • @MoonChildLunaViolet I was thinking the same thing since their debut upuntill now it show that both Vic-unnie and Amber can sing and not just Luna and Krystal has to get alot of part, but I agree with u they do need 2 have a duet and make an MV and perform it on stage.

  • @Icetrinh Finally someone agree with ME!! ^^ YeA! 

  • Who read that 'allkpop' review of this album. It was so unnecessary.

    The best album so far this year. =)

  • @DiabloSVV12 i know right, i wanted too bomb Allkpop >.> BIASED SHITS !

  • Automatically thought of KHUNTORIA!!! ^.^

  • i make cover for this song~

    please check it out guys~ because i like this song very much~

    especially whn amber sing some part in here

    im really happy!

    amber fghting!

  • Amber needs to sing more. I love her raps and everything... but her singing is underrated...

  • Amber <3

  • Krystal REALLY sounds like Jessica

  • Author:*This song is so simple that a child could learn to play it on a piano in about one minute*

    huhu you must read Fx pinocchio review at allkpop. com

    TT_TT

  • @snsdimsone4ever i've read it -.- i felt offended o__e it was a really negative review... which i completely disagree with. i LOVE this album >.>

  • @cathycookiechan wht review?

  • @snsdimsone4ever i mean this albume is not that bad Danger is very good too.. the review was harsh seriously 2.5/5 i remembered JYJ's Their Mussic Our Room got bad review too but not as bad as f(x) though. these people need to try to do this see how tough it is and start writing review about other people's song

  • live plzzz~~

  • Who was Singing First, was it Krystal? if it was.. it sounded alot like jessica to me :o

  • LOLS!! amber bias Generation!! eheh.. AMBER BIAS here too!! :)

  • where can i find it with eng sub to it?? " ) Thanxs

  • Love this song <3 <3 <3. Loving their album and being able to hear all their voices, a nice surprise hearing Amber sing more. Luna's voice still amazes me, so clear, rich and strong, but softer not so overpowering. They are blending more in the album, f(x) rocks!!!!

  • This song and 'Beautiful Goodbye' are the best songs on the album in my opinion. They've improved so much!

  • Comment removed

  • @DiabloSVV12

    I think so too!!

  • I love amber's voice!!

    I don't know that she has a soft voice.

  • that one person that disliked this vid does nt have anyone into

  • Can anyone tell me where Victoria sings?

    I can't distinguish any of their voices except Amber. (x

  • @verenachuu

    Victoria: 0:37 -0:43 1:39 - 1:45

    hope this helps ^^

  • @Fab1529 D: that's so little for victoria

    why why why D:

  • Amber can rap, dance, and SING SO FRIGGIN' WELL! I totally loved her from the start and after hearing this, I am mesmerized. Kyahaha~ :)) She should be given more lines to sing and not just rap^^

  • amber is singing a lot on this album! go amber! :D

  • Victoria's voice is so sweet.

  • she is given such a short part and it doesnt make sense if she doesnt sing it well. it is obvious that she cant be the 2nd best ainger in f(x) but only at the same level as sulli and victoria.

  • LOL I love your username..

    And this song is fabulous

  • Amber's got a surprisingly beautiful voice (: She's a bit vocally better than Sulli and Victoria in my opinion. I actually prefer her singing than her rapping.

  • @K4RAM1LIA I totally agree with all of that. But I'm afraid that some people will get mad and disagree, haha. I'm glad someone shares the same opinion as me. :]

  • @K4RAM1LIA hey can u tell me when amber is singing? i can't recognize her voice when she's singing! thanks

  • @sujushineeroc Amber sings @ 1:15-1:26 (:

  • @K4RAM1LIA WOW! her voice is so pretty. tan kiue

  • daannnnggg amber needs more lines!! she sings n rap!

  • DAng....Amber can singgggggggg, awesome job unnie...Krystal Unnie and Luna Unnie voices blend so good together...Victoria Unnie and Sulli Unnie voices are just toooo sweet^^ I love their voices...

  • victoria!! #cute

  • why the f* don´t let Amber sing ??...This totally proves she does know how to sing!!.Damn Sment!

  • @perulovesfx i hope that you dont stay angry at SM entertainment. its not actually their fault. it's basically the person who the song belongs to, they separate the parts to all the members... and i'm not very sure but it could be because amber's korean is lacking after her stay at the states, maybe they're more worried about her learning korean properly. maybe in the next album she'll get more parts or she might even get a solo (that's highly unlikely)..... hehe. btw, no hard feelings anyone!

  • @sumaya234 I´m not angry at them anymore, but I´m still dissapointed. I think she should´ve had at least a 5 second-line in Danger like she has in "Mr.Boggie"=(..

  • @perulovesfx i totally agree.... probably in time they will realize that Amber is actually a gem in the group... and maybe she will get more lines.... but at the end of the day there is always a member who does not get many lines and unfortunately it had to be her.... but we can still hope hehe

  • @sumaya234 yeah..=)... Hopefully.. =)

  • Sulli has a sweet voice too! <3 Amber's is powerful. XD

  • i really like this song!

  • Victoria's voice so sweet.

  • this has a very 2 Become 1 feel to it haha.

  • @EpyAnna IKR?! This song could be a nice 'PROPOSAL' song! lol.... (maybe to the WGM couple?! *uknowho*)

  • Beautiful ballad song! Love it so much....

    Luna's voice is nice...! Hope they make a nice MV with this song! I really, really, really like this song very much! (4 thumbs up!)

  • amber is actually an amazing singer, SM just can't seem to get that thruu their heads. and she's SUPER PRETTY . i've seen a picture of her with long hair ONCE. & it was WOW :O

  • One more sleepy song... Will sleep immidiately if I hear this song again^^

  • Amber will bloom into singing more just like Taemin did, watch in a year or maybe months she'll probably start intensive vocal training like Taemin. I SO got tired of hearing Krystal and Luna take what? Like 90% of the songs. Big ups to Amber cause I love her unique voice and Krystal #CUTE <333

  • @WonderfulSoshiGrlxox you kno krystal is snsd's jessicas younger sister

  • @DonnaBee4life not being rude but what does that have to do with anything?

  • @DonnaBee4life not being rude but what does that have to do with anything?

  • @DonnaBee4life not being rude but what does that have to do with anything? (being jessica's sister?)

  • @MsFuzzygirl i was just saying it wasn't like "oh she's famous because of her" kind of thing

  • @DonnaBee4life i understand ^^ it was really that Krystal was discovered before her sister, its just that her parents wouldnt let her go since she was (i think) 11. so they let her sister go instead :)

  • @MsFuzzygirl She was actually 5 years old when she was discovered. Which we all know is too young so that is why her parents refused and allowed Jessica to go.

  • Isn't Luna the lead singer in f(x) ? But Krystal sings the most in every freakin' song. When they perform this live I hope they give some parts to the other members like Amber! lol I'm calling Pinocchio Krystals song cause it seems like she has the most lines in it.

  • @Pulerull Luna is the main vocal, Krystal is the lead vocal.

  • @MizuRyu333 seriously? so the lead vocal is the one who sings the most?? or... I don't get these things.. lol

  • @Pulerull It's not only Krystal who sings the most. Luna also sings almost half the song too. Luna's the main vocalist while Krystal is the lead vocalist. Basically, Krystal follows Luna and does the back-up vocals for her. The others, Sulli and Victoria are supporting vocalists, and supports Krystal. Amber's the main rapper so it wouldn't be a surprised that she's only got a few lines, but I wished she got a little more, her voice isn't just for rapping.

  • @winnietehpoohie Aaah thank you! haha. :D now I know. I agree. I really like Amber's voice.

  • whooo gooo amber. love her lines~ :)

  • 2PM Taecyeon wrote this song?

  • @Tomboychristy wait how do you know?

  • @Tomboychristy WHAT??!!! No...!!! 2pm Taecyeon DID NOT write this song!

    I said I found this song from his tweet message!

  • I want all f(x) members to make a solo after they had promoted this album!! Please oh please!!! So that everybody's individual talent will be WELL known!

  • Sulli voice ?

  • AMBERRRRRR <3

  • i can identify amber's voice easily. she has a unique voice. ^^

  • Ironically I knew about this song from 2pm Taecyeon's RT!

    But this song is very nice ballad! Wish they make a good MV for this song!

    f(x) pretty girls....fighting!

  • SOLO BALLED SONG FOR AMBER HURRY HURRY PLEASE SM

  • Amber needs to sing more!

  • Amber~amber~ after one year later~U GROW UP ~SOUND SEXY NOW~ AND STILL SO HOT~

  • They really, really should give Amber more singing parts, her voice has such a gorgeous tone. She and Luna really make this song. It's probably my favorite right now.

  • kyaaaaaaaaaaaa... i love amber's voice along with luna's.. gorgeous.

  • Amber and luna have the better voices ^^

  • VIC'S VOICE IS SO SWEET!! :) watching all those wgm episode has made me a master in identifying her voice LOL

    hey, can you please GET RID OF THE DOWNLOAD LINK? let's help f(x) by having people who want the songs to actually get the album. thank you so much! :)

  • @justincaseyouredown Same here :)

  • Woah! Amber sounds great! I wish they would give her more singing parts.

  • Sigh. I'm in love. With the song. With f(x).

  • this song is soo beautiful :D

  • awww, this song's so cute..

  • When Krystal sings, I can really hear her sister's voice <3 =) Jung sisters fighting ! F(x), I'm so happy to have you back ^^ <3 love you so much.

  • OMFG, Amber please sing more lines. Your vice is so damn beautiful when you sing <3

  • Love the "tell me what's up?" It has a young innocent feeling...fits f(x) style!

  • Amber. Always be ur alien. Lol

  • AMBER!!!!

  • I love Vic's voice, very sweet. 

  • Good one!! I like it!!!

  • great song...^^, F(x)- jang!

  • 0:57 is Victoria <333

    i love her !!!

    i love fx <3

  • is 0:57 Victoria?

  • You know Amber reminds me of Ella from a taiwanese group called S.H.E. her voice that is and how they're both kinda tomboys. XD Amber should sing more than rapping. I think she's a pretty good singer, more than rapping.

  • krytsal sounds so much like jessica now

  • OMG AMBER IS SINGING!!! I FINALLY GET TO HEAR HER VOICE. THEY'D BETTER MAKE THIS THE FOLLOW UP TRACK.

  • Seriously SM should make it to all title track!! :P it sounds greedy but cant help it. the song is have good beat and catchy lyrics. hope they won their first Music bank, Inkigayo, Mnet, Music core

  • i love this song!

    Fx 5ting!

  • Amber could seriously be the 2nd best singer in f(x)! Her voice is really good!! Hope she sings more!!

  • so cute.

  • love this song.

  • Should do more songs like this.

  • Is that Amber singing at 1:17 - 1:25???...It sounds like her.

  • @CurlyKoki it is! And yes, I believe that we all know she has good voice, just that she brights more when she raps xD. I;m so INTO THIS SONG. It is utterly cute.

  • @CurlyKoki yes derr, thats her.

  • @CurlyKoki It is

  • @CurlyKoki Yes! It is amber :)

  • @CurlyKoki yup! Amber's voice. so beautiful. i just realized her voice and Luna's