Added: 3 years ago
From: planetrock1
Views: 658,597
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,629)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Uploader is trolling. Good pun from Homme (pronounced 'om') though.

  • Was this used out of context?

  • after troy left APC he became such a douche and if he had such a problem with maynard why was it never said to maynard himself....

  • LOL do people really take this seriously?! XD

  • uploader doesn't understand humour...or is trolling

  • @pugghead

    uploader is just a regular douche looking for views.

  • This is a real YouTube video...?

    Are you fucking kidding me?

  • Why post a clip with a misleading title about a nonexistent beef?

    Trollbait, of course.

  • those guys are fuckin high

  • Kyuss.... Tool is great but if u do not know of any of the other amazing groups that haven't gotten or taken mainstream success then you are naive. Especially if you think bands like Seether, nickel back, creed etc are worth a shit cuz they are not!!!

  • HAHAHAHA fag.

  • Who is Josh Homme?

  • @homeball Queens of the Stone Age/ Them Crooked Vultures - Frontman

  • @XXsteviegfunkXX and Kyuss and Eagles of Death Metal and Desert Sessions...etc

  • Josh made a punny... ie whine vs wine. This title is very misleading and is fuel for the stupid fire.

  • @1overthehillsfaraway you are so right. But you can never go wrong with WAFFLES!

  • LOL its well known when maynard talked about his winery project at live shows some time ago, he implicitly and very clearly stated how angry and distasteful it would be if any "Tool" fan came into his winery talking about Tool with MJK. Homme is just poking fun at Maynard, they are likely friends a bit I would imagine.

  • @bdbb6- I like pancakes?

  • @coffeebeanman no no, its I LIKE PANCAKES! with butter and syrup. 

  • Hes not attacking him. This is Josh Homme being Josh homme...

  • It's funny cause Troy's mannerisms are extremely similar to Maynard's. *eyebrow raise*

  • I don't think you know what the word attack means

  • fuck every1 here ur allpieceofshitfaggots!!!!

  • uploader is a stupid tit. Thanks.

  • XD thats a corney joke

    where is this guy from? nebraska?

  • smh

  • whats funny isnt the false title, its the fact that people actually think this is an insult and are bashing josh.

  • i sense alot of butthurt in the comment section

  • what a vicious attack! I can't believe someone could talk about Maynard in such a way.

  • WHINERY!

    

  • Josh Homme will never know what it means to create art.

  • @coffeebeanman lol, i take it youve never heard of kyuss :D take it easy this guy was a pioneer of stoner/sludge/desert metal, and if you make stoner/sludge/desert metal, youre alright in my book :D

  • @coffeebeanman - and what gives you any right to say? Are you shitting me? Songs For the Deaf is a masterpiece.

  • @bdbb6 Fuck yes it is. 

  • who's this asshole

  • How does this get perceived as a "diss"? There was nothing resembling a personal attack an anything Homme said.

  • HE CALLED MAYNARD A GREAT LISTENER come on, change your fucking stupid youtube video title you fucking gimick

  • pfffft. weak.

  • @EraserinRainbows

    The misinterpretation of sarcasm is simple: to comprehend sarcasm takes intellectual talent beyond that of 7th grade brain function. This isn't a common trait among human beings in this day and age; especially those who argue on Youtube frequently.

  • fuck the title of this video.

  • what i find funnier is how actual maynard haters are commenting on this video thinking theyre getting somewhere with this like "oh this is so clever i totally agree" but like, no.

  • jeez louise, some ppl have no sense of humour - apparently Josh does!!

  • Comment removed

  • Who is this Maynard guy?

  • @mahavishnuxc You have got to be taking the piss...

  • @YouMustBeKidding1 what a coincidence that your username is "YouMustBeKidding" and your replying to my sarcastic comment. I was replying to someone who didnt know Josh Homme. I know who Maynard Keenan is, and especially Josh Homme.

  • This no attack on Maynard

  • Who the hell is Josh Homme?

  • @equitium The guitarist for Queens of the Stone Age, Kyuss, and Them Crooked Vultures

  • Who is Josh Homme?

  • this is not an attack this is josh homme playing his sense of humor when reporters are trying to be serious.

  • come on everyone, it was a play on words "winery" as in people come there to "wine," "he is a great listener." It is a little funny.

  • @hanous1 Possibly something to do with his vine yards either? "He is the current owner of Merkin Vineyards and the associated winery" Its actually written into a lot of his contracts that he does not perform or record during when his winemaking endeavours cannot allow it, seems he puts the wine first :|

  • maynard and josh have worked together in the studio on multiple occasions, you can go goggle pics of them hanging out n shit. this whole thing is pretty innocuous

  • I'm a die hard Queens of the Stone Age fan but I think that Maynard and his bands have more notoriety than Josh's work.

  • maynard can do whatever the hell he wants. he has lots a money and a goal.

  • Tell Tool to get Steve Perry.

  • Tool needs to kick maynard out

  • I didn't find any attack in this video at all. Its true, Maynard has a vineyard & wants to make & sell wine. Nothing wrong with that.

  • someone needs to tell this Maynard dude that his singing voice sucks balls

  • @snaredrum110 if you genuinely believe that you must have no understanding in music...

  • @snaredrum110 Wow, you're either deaf or just a very, very stupid human being.

  • @berryhill88 tell Maynard that I'm just one of thousands, millions of musicians that isn't impressed with his singing. Tell him to sing the Star Spangled Banner at the World Series to impress some real singers..OK?

  • @snaredrum110 I can tell you have a very weird approach to music.. Give me some names of professional artist or proper musicians that are saying that Maynard James Keenan does not have talent, and "sucks balls". OK?

    And why sing the Star spangled banner? It's a matter of integrity, an artist shouldn't need to bastardize that song (like all those pop-artists do) at some AMURICN braindead sports-event to earn the respect from the likes of you.

  • @berryhill88 Cut the shit. 1. nobody ever has or will ask a choked duck to embarrass his country and ruin our song. 2. He can't sing it even if he wanted too. Fail

  • @snaredrum110 @snaredrum110 I love it when people have no comebacks, and just chokes on meaningless and repetitive arguments. Ah well, whatever makes you feel better, little buddy. /endofdiscussion

  • @berryhill88  I love it when Tool can never get good too.

  • @snaredrum110 Why are you trolling so hard? You won't get a decent reaction here,,, Do a barrel roll onto a gay pride video and have fun :D

  • @densetsuhadouken116 No thank you. I don't want to go the fag parade with you. I'm not a faggot.

  • @snaredrum110 Awww but it'll be fun :D

    Join us, faggot, you know you want too ;D

  • Wasn't really an attack.. more of an off handed joke and a pun.

  • Josh comes across as having a big ego. But I love a lot of his music. What happened to QOTSA??? Oh, well...

  • i didn't see any ninjas

  • Why doesn't anyone research anything? And by anyone I mean the people who posted thinking that this wasn't just a witty joke and also the ones who are disgracing one of two MAJOR, MAAJOR contemporary rock artists who have influenced and been influenced by some of the greatest musicians known by the twenty first century.. To those people, in the words of Josh Homme, "go eat a bag of dicks." And from me a BIG fuck you too.

  • maynard is one of the most philosophical rock stars of this generation.

  • Tool=More Popular

    QOTSA=Better and Tool fanboys if your trying to use sales to see which band is better than Katy Perry and Justin Bieber are better than both bands so yeah pwned!

  • @mentalfeed70 i would say that tool is better...not because of sales or anything like that, i just think it's more quality music than QOTSA...not that i dont love them too, cause i do

  • @roflocopter101 no way Tool is just an other alternative metal band QOTSA have way more variety song skills and are bad asssess that can make sexy ass heavy songs that no one can replicate because they have an original sound if you want good alternative metal check out Jane's Addiction they also kick Tools ass or System of A Down or Soundgarden,Alice in Chains,Rage Against the Machine,Red Hot Chili Peppers yeah so many better bands in that alternative metal scene.

  • @mentalfeed70 are you deaf!!!how can you put tool in that genre!!!

  • @840head what would you prefer Nu Metal? Progressive Metal? Hard Rock?

  • @mentalfeed70 soundgarden and alice in chains are grunge dipshit, and i listen to all those bands, a lot...but they still don't compare to tool. tool has a more unique sound than any of the bands you named

  • @roflocopter101 your fucking dumb aren't you? grunge is just a mixture of Alternative,Punk,and Metal do you even listen to them? because they blow tool away thats for sure!

  • @mentalfeed70 yes i do and no they definitely don't. and rolling stone sucks ass at making lists, who gives a fuck what all those websites say anyway? lateralus IS a masterpiece album...you just don't have the musical taste to know that obviously

  • @roflocopter101 how? sure the list isn't perfect but stop being a fanboy sure to a Tool fan that loves fucking tool it's a masterpiece but to me it's just good maybe great I guess we all have different opinions on different music.

  • @mentalfeed70 yeah...its just lateralus has so much meaning in the lyrics along with great, unique, and complex music, along with all of tool's stuff

  • @roflocopter101 yeah I just felt like all the tool fans were trolling on this video for some reason I felt like I had to do it to I guess the other qotsa fans are to stoned to care about something like this sorry if I acted like an asshole.

  • @mentalfeed70 no you didnt we all have our opinions. the title of the vid is bullshit no doubt...

  • @mentalfeed70 That's your own opinion. No band is greater than the other. They are both badass bands so I don't know why people need to argue on who's better. Josh Homme and MJK are both respected musicians that have changed music for the good.

  • @Stinkfist43 Rollling Stones Top 100 Albums of the decade QOTSA had a album on it not a single Tool album were is your precious masterpiece Lateralus? oh yeah it wasn't on there. go to Decibels top 100 heavy metal albums of the decade QOTSA had a album on there no Tool. go to allmusic.com and compare the reviews of all there albums as you can see QOTSA get better reviews. you guys think tool is the best band in the world the rest of the world doesn't.

  • @mentalfeed70 Did you just read what I said? I never said Tool was better than QOTSA. I am a huge Tool fan but I never said they are the best ever. All I said was that they are both respected bands. I don't care what band got the better review because I could care less about the media

  • @Stinkfist43 Well oh well you Tool take such offence really go to a beatles video talk shit about them nobody would care Led Zeppelin Hardly anyone would care but say something about Tool on a video about Tool and shit the world goes nuts!

  • @mentalfeed70 Did you eat paint chips as a child? I am not bagging on QotSA I like Josh Homme I have seen them multiple times so I don't get why you are getting so mad that I am saying that they are equally awesome haha. If you ask me you are the one going nuts because I never blew up about anything. I respect the fact that you like Queens they are fucking awesome. I am just saying that Tool is great as well and that no one really cares about which band is better.

  • @Stinkfist43 Well guess your right nobody cares but Tool fanboys they just like talk shit read the comments and you'll see!

  • @mentalfeed70 Geez I am done with you. You obviously don't get what I'm saying.

  • @Stinkfist43 okay don't talk crap but it's okay for other people to do it

  • It's a joke, not an attack.

  • If anything it was probably a inside joke between the three of them (Troy,Josh and Maynard)

  • how is that an attack? its a cheeky joke 

  • KYUSS, anyone?

  • I like Maynard because he's an artist and I like Josh Homme because he's a cynical hilarious bastard artist.

  • Jealousy is a stinky cologne

  • I don't really think Homme meant anything by it. It was just his way of being witty and sarcastic by making a joke about a whinery where folks get to come and whine. I'm sure Homme and Keenan have the utmost respect for one another.

  • Kyuss

  • Maynard is and always will be a legend, as for this guy, I had to do a Google search just to figure out who the fuck Josh Homme is. 

  • @videogeek27 i looked and nothing came up

  • @cheetoaddict Nothing but my D#$k

  • I love Tool and Maynard....but he is a huge Tool. He pretty much said "yeah we put out an album every 5 years fuck you until then" Doesn't mean he aint still great! These insults are.....insults I think anyway lol

  • I like Both bands (Tool & QOTSA) but I'll side with Josh Homme. Maynard seems to be the real stingy tool out of the both (not a pun).

  • Josh Homme is a fag and Queens of the Stone Age suck. One hit wonders.

  • misleading title

  • josh homme is a fucking faggot and so are qotsa!!! fuck you josh!! i hope you see this you poser bitch!!

  • MONKEYS. MONKEYS. MONKEYS.

    FINGER PICKING BEGINS.

    Angels. Who's Susanna? What is it about that, enough with that. Okay?

    My mom and dad are robots. My real mom and dad are robots right? Come to show Ella the truth about existence. And Ella's mom too.

    Time for another break?

  • Josh has the IMPORTANT this was the first thing I posted publicly.

    Not including Myspace.

    Unless he does.

    Unless that's along with Matt Baudin too.

    I'm jealous of him. He got to take chemistry in sixth grade and was talking about nuclear chemistry to me, from his school from where he came from before he moved to here, in Florida. But he knew and understood it - THAT WAY in the way of it being interesting and fun if you knew and understood it.

    That was another class I was going to master

  • He doesn't mean "whine" he means "wine" as in the alcoholic drink. Maynard owns a vineyard. Josh just made a joke out of it.

  • How is that an Attack? If anything its a compliment because he thinks Maynard should be making music.

  • lol what is context

  • Homme was being a smartass and making a joke. Subtle and it gave me a chuckle. There never was an attack.

  • Comment removed

  • '']['' {[]} {[]} ][_

  • This wasn't an attack at all. It was just joking about the word "winery." You suck for this.

  • maynard of fool.

  • lmao, he's sitting there laughing about his wine-producing career but just wait until rock music dies completely...then look who's still making bank. Maynard :)

  • "people like mike patton and josh homme are a major source of inspiration to me, the way they can wear many hats and do all these things. both of them were a huge nudge for me to get this thing going, for sure." ~ maynard james keenan (in reference to puscifer)

    source: unleashed: the story of tool (the only biography of the band to date)

    even if they were to hate each other i wouldn't care... i still love their music. i don't even care to meet them. i just hope they make music for ever!!!

  • Get a grip. Its a fucking joke

  • dont bite the hand that feeds you, josh! thank it! you should thank him for your lil "fling" in the limelight!

  • @SuperFatboi123 How do you figure?

  • I mean if anything this is just hilarious. I'm sure maynard got a kick out of it too. Come on that was hilarious!

  • Whiny? Homme refers to Winey, MJK is a wine producer. Attack? WTF

  • I am shocked and appauled, the sheer profanity and expletives used was incredible. Seriously, I can't believe that this video is even tagged as 'dissing' Maynard, that's more like a poke.

  • LOL its a play on words you morons

  • I love Troy's lil snigger at the end :D

  • Maynard is way more successful then Josh Homme so Troy is pretty much saying he'd be happier going on a trip to Nigeria then going to Italy - his loss anyway, fag!

  • @jb4life77 I don't know your reasoning for such strong hate towards someone just for making music/art. Did his music slap you in the face with it's dick one morning? Did it steal your girlfriend? Did it kill your parents? Why so much HATE. I understand being annoyed at people for being overly obsessed and think that one single band is the GREATEST BAND EVER (when there is no 'greatest band ever') because that makes just about as little sense as your blind hate does.

  • One no talent douche makes a dig at another not talent douche. And I should care about this, because...?

  • @jb4life77 Wow! Thanks!! If i cant be smart i might as well be an award winning retard then XD

    OK well, i dont think he's a faggot considering he has a wife and a child, and i don't know him personally so i don't know if he is deep or not, but i do enjoy the music he makes and i think he seems like a cool guy. But it's your opinion if you don't like him.

  • @jb4life77 It's where you make wine.

  • Comment removed

  • This is scene from a movie about Maynard's Winery in Arizona. It's a running joke through the movie where people rag on Maynard for being a wine geek.

  • whinery

  • Fuck this Fags their nobodys

  • @Slipknasty1 then what does that make you

  • QOTSA and A Perfect Circle(maynard leader) are my favorite bands so...fuck this! :D

  • I wanted to see Josh punching the shit out of someone.

  • It's a play on the word 'winery', not an insult to MJK

  • your link to the full interview is broken

  • Last time I checked, puns aren't considered insults...

  • how do people not get that this is a joke?

  • Well I'm a big fan of Tool; they're in my top 3 favourite bands. But this wasn't that bad of an insult, however I think this guy sounds kind of arrogant and no offence to fanboys/girls but QOTSA are pretty crap especially compared to Tool.

  • @andthemushrooms123 It wasn't even an insult.

  • @NightXemnas Who'd win in a fight though? If it happened. xD

  • @andthemushrooms123 Lol, prolly Josh. Idk how tough Maynard is, though. I think they're both beyond a fight, though.

  • @NightXemnas Maynard could use his wine bottles as weapons haha; i agree they're probably both beyond a fight. But there's a cool thought anyway XD

  • all tool songs sound pretty much the same

  • @SanctumStudios What? That is the most absurd comment i've read on Youtube. Listen to Undertow, then listen to 10,000 Days. Two completely different albums that sound way different. Please know what you're talking about first before you make a comment like that; because you just sound like an idiot.

  • @BASSxACE pfft

  • @SanctumStudios all your dicks are gay

  • @NightXemnas nice one keyboard hero.

  • @SanctumStudios omg fu noob

  • @NightXemnas yaa

  • Josh Homme is just jealous that Maynard is way more successful then he is and then he will ever be

  • Ladies ladies please. Let's all agree that QOTSA, Kyuss, APC, Tool, Puscifer etc etc are all awesome and get on with our lives.

  • I would have liked to see the linked video, but it's not found, just sayin'.

  • So where's the attack??

  • @Chillton :P only the trolls would pick up on that, who ever they are!

  • @chriswilliamstool I know. It's just funny :D

  • @7777timj agree

  • lets calm down people, it was just a joke haha.

  • Winery.. Whine.. ery

    Complain.. whine.

    It was a joke and a play on words. I don't think Homme has any strong opinions on Maynard of Tool.

  • I think Josh was just being funny. I don't think it was an attack on Maynard

  • Hater

  • pls flag for mass advertising or scam / fraud

    it will be removed

  • the fuck is this? i wanted an actual fight. now that would be worth watching. not this.. SHIT