Added: 2 years ago
From: jarksjold
Views: 45,770
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (59)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • Can't get this song out of my head just love it even that is a dark depressing song

  • Solo una cancion puede expresar mi interior. y creo que es esta..oh dios..

  • unforgettable

  • When I listen to this song I imagine just packing up my tiny backpack and going away from everything. And I'm not sure if would ever want to come back. This is amazing.

  • cold- wind- rain- cigarettes and this song

  • This song is pure SEX

  • I don't believe in any God or heaven or hell but im sure Ian is right now in paradise ( if there is one...)

  • sad but beautiful... beautiful but sad...

  • La mejor canción. La más desoladora, vacía...

    Gracias Ian, por todo lo que hicisite. Gracias Joy Division...

    Siempre dentro de mí.

  • Such restraint...they could have taken this somewhere "big" but didn't. The mood is enough to carry it.

  • funeral music... lovely

  • I can't stop listening to this song...

  • songs dont neccesarily need to have a narrative,or be about anything in particular.

  • @dreadedwheat26 No, but it helps if the song has meaning, and is more than just a song. Bands like Joy Division do not just write a song to sell...they write a song to vent, or express opinion.

  • Great Joy Division ....!!!

  • i've listend to this song numerous times , and each time em only closer to death

  • esta e´uma das melhores músicas do JD!!!!

    E na minha opnião a mais melancolica!

  • This song bring tears to my eyes...beautiful!!!

  • wow, zian 1977c!!

  • you can tell ian curtis was inspired by jim morrison it sounds like

  • @zian1977c Hey hey hey - your soul can't be that bad if you are listening to this :) all the best.

  • Back in the day, JD was not the critcs´ first choice. Listening to their music nowadays makes clear, that they were quite unique, despite of all the darkness. The eternal is giving me the impression of time standing still, a disturbing experience. Masterpiece.

  • great song !!!!

  • your music will always be eternal

  • i want to kill myself after reading these lyrics...i guess he was in that mood as well when he wrote it...thank you

  • @Guitargirlmx Don't kill yourself.

  • @Guitargirlmx IT'S ABOUT A NEIGHBOUR OF MR CURTIS'S WHO HAD(S) DOWN SYNDROME. IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH KILLING HIMSELF -WELL. NOT DIRECTLY. IT SHOWS WHAT LOVELY AND HUMANE EMPATHY HE HAD.

  • @TheOldEchoes i've never thought of a suicidal depression as lovely before, he was obviously too affected and very very sensitive

  • @TheOldEchoes

    you also should mention the root cause of him writing this song. he returned to his house YEARS AND years later to find the boy sitting by the gate of the garden, hence the title "the eternal" the boy was still there after all those years :(

  • @guitar19904 ... just... completely sad, knowing this made my eyes wet.

  • @TheOldEchoes Jeeze can you use more captials?

  • @Subadai111 Haha I know right? I DON'T GET WHY PEOPLE WRITE WITH CAPS LOCK.

  • @TheOldEchoes yes,it is about a boy,who had Down's Syndrome that lived in his neigborhood,and he would see him all the time,but he never seemed to age.

  • @JoyDivisiongirl

    well, he saw the person years and years later sitting in the garden, still the same

    hence the title "the ETERNAL"

  • I can practically hear the sound of wrists splitting open.

  • @PorroFirst Fuckwit.

  • The saddest song in the world?

  • A sad and touching little masterpiece.And dear Ian is a beautiful immortal soul.Thanks to jarksjold for sharing:-)

  • fantastica !

  • This literally speaks to my soul. There is no other song that I would want to listen while painlessly and slowly dying in my bed, alone and filled with hapiness.

  • It's like Hell's Theme... when somebody is about to go to hell itself, the abyss receives with this song.

  • on ne pourra plus jamais tourner la page, Ian ...

    peut-être qu'avec toi, on a su ce que c'était que de passer de l'autre côté. pour un peu, on aurait pu y rester ... mais la vie est mal foutue. tu ne crois pas ?

    RIP, Ian.

    thanks a lot for this song.

  • this song is fuckin nice live.

  • Una cancion hermosa pero depresiva y oscura en extremo, quien si no joy division para transportarnos mediante esta cancion a los sufrimientos de Ian Curtis

  • @joydivisionbauhaus No es depresiva y no es sobre los sufrimientos de Curtis - perdone mi espanol malo, soy irlandes.

  • @joydivisionbauhaus disculpa bro. pero no concuerdo mucho.

    si tienes razon, pero es lo superficial que se vio o se sigue creyendo,

    curtis con problemas, no, el solo tenia dudas,

    sufrimiento, que es sufrimiento al lado del bacio que el dejo,

    creo que solo es una descripcion...

    viva por siempre la vieja escuela  que viva la reyna...

  • hay thanks for post this amazing song!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more