say a song is sung in G then goes to C then say D and someone does it from G but goes to a different chord rather than C that would make the song sound crap and not how it should be done
@marycockburn1 You are of course entitled to your own opinion on the subject, but I along with many other musicians like to play and sing songs as I interpret them and deliberately not copy others. If we all sang songs exactly the same way, there would be no point in listening to other versions as everything would sound the same. All music is subjective. Even classical music is interpreted differently by different conductors. As I said in the accompanying information (cont)
@marycockburn1 I am not a competent enough guitarist to play the sort of accompaniment Paul Simon and the session musicians play to Garfunkel's singing. I do not read music, but I enjoy very much playing and singing which I do by ear. If you want to hear Simon and Garfunkel singing the song, choose one of their videos. If you want to hear how other musicians interpret the song, check them out. Each to his/her own.
ok i can respect that and making a song your own doing it your way is fine but the chords in my opinion still need to be used in the way it is really . what i meen is for example say you want to say it in your own style different to art then thats fine but if the chords were not played to sound much like simon and artfunkels it would sound bad . its hard to explain what i meen. ill try it another way ok
It's a pleasure to meet you, Tony. I'm honored that you've posted your video as a response to my own. Thank you very much. I really enjoy your guitar picking. It has great character and your overall presentation is very endearing.
I love this. I am so happy that I can hear the passion in your voice and playing. Great job!
yeahimmel 5 days ago
I think is fantastic you enjoyed playing this beautiful song and that is what matter. I wish I could do that. Keep going.
Charming7366 3 weeks ago
Just wonderful. Thats what this forum is all about - men being themselves - kids
ndinigwe 8 months ago
say a song is sung in G then goes to C then say D and someone does it from G but goes to a different chord rather than C that would make the song sound crap and not how it should be done
marycockburn1 10 months ago
@marycockburn1 You are of course entitled to your own opinion on the subject, but I along with many other musicians like to play and sing songs as I interpret them and deliberately not copy others. If we all sang songs exactly the same way, there would be no point in listening to other versions as everything would sound the same. All music is subjective. Even classical music is interpreted differently by different conductors. As I said in the accompanying information (cont)
threelegsoman 10 months ago 3
@marycockburn1 I am not a competent enough guitarist to play the sort of accompaniment Paul Simon and the session musicians play to Garfunkel's singing. I do not read music, but I enjoy very much playing and singing which I do by ear. If you want to hear Simon and Garfunkel singing the song, choose one of their videos. If you want to hear how other musicians interpret the song, check them out. Each to his/her own.
threelegsoman 10 months ago
i take it this is your own way of playing this yes? and you are not playing the correct chords by paul simon on perpuse yes?????
marycockburn1 10 months ago
@marycockburn1 You are correct in your assumption. I am playing it my own way with chords I have worked out for myself.
threelegsoman 10 months ago
ok i can respect that and making a song your own doing it your way is fine but the chords in my opinion still need to be used in the way it is really . what i meen is for example say you want to say it in your own style different to art then thats fine but if the chords were not played to sound much like simon and artfunkels it would sound bad . its hard to explain what i meen. ill try it another way ok
marycockburn1 10 months ago
thanks so much
george20081234567 1 year ago
Loving it man!
AlsoKnownAsYou 1 year ago
@AlsoKnownAsYou Thank you
threelegsoman 1 year ago
nice job
MrFantasticSarcastic 1 year ago
Fantastic singing and guitar playing!
TonyMcWatt 1 year ago
It's a pleasure to meet you, Tony. I'm honored that you've posted your video as a response to my own. Thank you very much. I really enjoy your guitar picking. It has great character and your overall presentation is very endearing.
cglazaro100 1 year ago
nice playin i like it
SwingSweeet 1 year ago
@SwingSweeet Thanks. I appreciate that.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
This is brilliant, well done (:
me0and0my0rejects 1 year ago
I always liked that song, Tony. Pretty finger picking. ...Bill
cariboubill 1 year ago
very touching version, Tony.
SuperZielke 1 year ago
@SuperZielke Thanks Art
threelegsoman 1 year ago