Beethoven Minuet in G

[vannah1201]

lol i played this at my second year recital ^_^

[Lactoris1]

I like it slower for expressivemess apart from questions of ease or difficulty, and ritards at cadences. Work on loud-soft dynamics subordinating accompaniment and adjusting beat and connecting notes.

[Hippodude5]

It's very blur. ( shake my head)

[LuisdelaCuesta]

You Tube no debería permitir este tipo de interpretaciones tan defectuosas, tan malas, tan mediocres.

In México we say WAKALA

[kentmorita]

is it true that "Beethoven composed [this] only so that he could detest it"? I read it in the introcduction to A Clockwork Orange.

[mortson978]

excellent job, but the piano hasn't seen a tuning wrench in a while it seems

[kentmorita]

Sometimes I actually like the out-of-tune-ness of some instruments lol

[mortson978]

it depends on what you're playing. It's okay for ragtime, but i still prefer perfect harmony. Try tuning a piano once. Once you develop your ear, intonacity offends your senses.

[mortson978]

well, there is no replacing the sound of real strings if you ask me.

[vannah1201]

@kentmorita .lol i cant comment anything mean on this about tuning the poor piano, cause mine is just as bad,haha

[Johnno3D]

ladny sweter

[sfour]

I like it

[paopaomana]

This song should be played very gracefully. Avoid hurrying when playing. And watch your notes, there are a lot of "out-of-tunes". Good job though!

[Brutuseh]

Tempo isn't consistent.

[damnxthatsxhotxxx]

This is a really great attempt, I think it's very musically artistic. Pay no attention to the ignorant people that are trying to bring you down, keep up the good work.

[Mathwiz921]

God whatever ive been dealing with this for like 5-6 months! so just whatever!

[fclavijo]

good effort! keep it up man

[jkilbey1]

You're funny Chris.

[jkilbey1]

it's nice that you're excited to record yourself playing, but another five to ten years of more intense studying may show you why a post like this is a waste. good luck.

[GormanToons]

What a loser you are saying a discouraging thing like this to a musician. It sounds great, you're a nobody trying to put other people down. I'm Chris Gorman and the greatest composer ever and I think this guy will be a great musician if he keeps it up. Shame on you for behaving like this towards another human being, especially in my industry, entertainment. Chris Gorman

[Zddy9]

Not the best...

Way to slow man!!!

[vonbrimstone]

a minuet is a dance. check it on wikipedia or somewhere :) so there's lot's pieces that are named just minuet

[Montefusco1]

Actually, Minuet is just the name of the song. Beethoven AND J.S. Bach made songs that they just so happend to name Minuet.

[renman000]

no, minuet Is a type of dance, they name types of peices by how they are arranged this particular one is a minuet in Gmajor by beethoven, it doubles as a name but is just how it is classified

[noramyt]

it was bach!!!!!!!!! not beethoven!!!!!!!!!!

[renman000]

dude are u retarded, that peice he just played was beethoven not bach

[Rebekahgirl2]

I like the song. Too bad the piano is out of tune.

[musical21girl]

i think it sounds out of tune cuz ur watching it on the computer

[Mathwiz921]

just to say, minuet was done by bach

[dilgosh]

Bach has done minuet in G major...this piece was done by Beethoven...just wanted to say:)

[Mathwiz921]

ya, but bach invented the piece ;)

[renman000]

thats correct, bach did make his own minuet but this is beethovens'

[Mathwiz921]

in my opinion, bach is like 100000 times better and bethoven copied because bach made the first minuet didn't he

[renman000]

ok, beethoven was a deaf composer who made great music, does that not speak for itself?

[Mathwiz921]

maybe...

[amarnamriju]

i don't think bach compares to beethoven. i'm no classical musician by the way but from whatever i've heard of them beethoven's music just makes more 'sense'...lol watever u think that to mean

[Mathwiz921]

i just think its pretty...lol

i'm still learning

[gattz11]

Let me correct you. A minuet is a dance, like a slow waltz. It's called Minuet in G because it is in the key of G Major. There can be a vast array of Minuets in G major/minor... Bach's is great, so is Beethoven's :)

[Mathwiz921]

alright whatever!!!!! I thought I would get rid of this vid a month ago and now u just had to reply to me!

[damnxthatsxhotxxx]

No one knows for sure the Bach actually composed his Minuet; rather it was found in Anna Magedalene's notebook. So you are a little historically off there, mathwiz.

Bach is great, and so is Beethovan.

[chobrocoli]

no he didn't, lots of minuets were composed before him, actually I dare say most were, since they were really only popular during the baroque period, even though classical symphonies tend to have minuets as a third movement.

[redjumpsuitappatatus]

I was totally going to post that exact thing!! lol

[Mathwiz921]

oh thats cool!!!:)

[mopresto15o]

alot of composers made minuets, its like the bourees its a type of dance a minuet is a type of song.

[Mathwiz921]

minuet is a piece and bach should get the credit

[renman000]

anybody can make a minuet, i am making one in the collage class i am taking, it is only how u use your dynamics and how u arrange the song, i am also composing a sonatina which is a small sonata

[mrsmops2]

You play this piece very nicely...not too rushed (after all a minuet is dance!)...a very musical rendition too. Good job!

[emphaticapathy]

It sounds much more impressive played a bit faster, especially the second half.

[Hairboy01]

I liked your jaunty playing - I am learning this piece and it has really helped me to see you playing it - thank you.

[kakyoukuzuki]

the upright iano is too small for you!

[Gretta57]

Hi, I just began this piece yesterday, so it was good to hear how you played it, and very well, too. Thank you so much for your contribution to my lessons.

[pianofiend1]

this piano is teribbly out of tune. nice playing though.

[pianolovers]

Harika, ellerinize sağlık.

[engin911]

Enişte süpersin :)

[RomanideCarpathia]

Nice balance, work to relax your fingers. I would recommend reading The Inner Game of Music. It would do wonders for your playing confidence and mental techniques.

[devenautar]

your fat ahahhahah, nice piano playing though

[h812]

???

[prestopianist]

Super!!! Good work, thanks...

[bluetazeyes]

awesome!! I just started learning this

piece this week.

Thanks from a musical fossil for the inspiration.