@imgonnaeatyou222 You should listen to Peter Schreier's version than. It's also somewhere here on YouTube. She has a very nice voice, but her "sch" and "ö" are a little too "light". Actually, that's no good pronunciation. It only can seem good to the non-German users.
Mein Senf: Egal ob es um eine Vergewaltigung oder doch nur um eine Rose geht, diese Interpretation drückt weder die Emotionalität des einen noch des anderen aus.
Schusterlehrling: @ Du hast Deine Lehrzeit wohl noch nicht aus? Der Pianist hat sich nach der Sängerin zu richten. Deine Ahnung und Musikalität lass bitte außen vor, und
Schuster bleib bei Deinem Leisten. (zu hart? dann perdono!)
This is false, the only word with a 'z' in this poem is 'zu' at the beginning 'Lief er schnell, es nah zu seh'n, and it's pronounced as the correct 'ts/tz'.
@mengyl She seems to be icelandic. But her pronunciation is quite ok for german ears. But I wonder what she's doing now, no new recordings since April 2008?
My language has ö and ü too, but her ö sounds like ü to me. Of course that doesn't mean it is true for German. Maybe in German ö and ü are closer than in my language.
Oh my gosh.... That was so unbelievably amazing! You really interpreted it well, and your pronunciation was done beautifully! I was looking for a decent video of this song to help me get a good idea with pronunciation, and you definitely had that covered. Not only was the pronunciation good, but I actually enjoyed listening to you as well. This is the first time I've found a COMPLETELY enjoyable performance on youtube. Nice Job! I plan to listen a few more times :-)
VERY wonderful. i loved this. the best i've seen on youtube. you are really INTERPRETING the music and the text and getting a nice line and placement in the process.
I really like your voice - vibrato doesn't sound out of control like some sopranos when singing this song. Wonderful expression - you look really involved :) If you put on a concert I would come and watch - I love how you tell the story with your face and show your personality while you're singing. Best recording of this song I've heard so far!
Is it just me, or does she really resemble Marcia Brady? Gorgeous singing voice!
Natalie7ization 3 days ago
Good work!
Adele8705 1 month ago
I sang this in chorus and she is good but were awesome
Athenaacm 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like listening to Heidenröslein 我好喜歡聽野玫瑰(Heidenröslein)
jay840322564 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like listening to Heidenröslein 我好喜歡聽野玫瑰(Heidenröslein)
jay840322564 1 month ago
Comment removed
jay840322564 1 month ago
I have to sing this in chorus!!! This has helped me with the pronunciation:P
imgonnaeatyou222 2 months ago
@imgonnaeatyou222 You should listen to Peter Schreier's version than. It's also somewhere here on YouTube. She has a very nice voice, but her "sch" and "ö" are a little too "light". Actually, that's no good pronunciation. It only can seem good to the non-German users.
DameMitHermelin 2 weeks ago
i have to sing this for my vocal production class for school! you sing it great!
JennyAnn9884 2 months ago
wowowowowow.
purpledinosaurs1213 5 months ago
Wonderful rendition, thank you very much for your singing, great talent!!!
Jaimejimmyjim 5 months ago
Škoda,že nerozumím německy,je to moc krásná písnička ....česky jsme ji slyšela ve filmu:Hodina tance a lásky.....pěkné díky ♥♥♥
100Wena 5 months ago
Do you have the notes of the piano?
xxLeaMalinxx 7 months ago
This is in Williamson at Westminster Choir College! YAY WCC
burgosc09 8 months ago
schusterlehrling @ Spätaufsteher oder macht das lesen soviel Mühe?
Hören Sie sich leber Jay Khan an - paßt besser zu Ihrem Niveau !
26rubirosa 9 months ago
greetings from an impressed german
Toby48624 9 months ago
Mein Senf: Egal ob es um eine Vergewaltigung oder doch nur um eine Rose geht, diese Interpretation drückt weder die Emotionalität des einen noch des anderen aus.
Setzen - 6!
77subculture 10 months ago
Schusterlehrling: @ Du hast Deine Lehrzeit wohl noch nicht aus? Der Pianist hat sich nach der Sängerin zu richten. Deine Ahnung und Musikalität lass bitte außen vor, und
Schuster bleib bei Deinem Leisten. (zu hart? dann perdono!)
26rubirosa 11 months ago
@26rubirosa
Also nach Noten sollen sie sich nicht richten, und gut singen auch nicht?
Das nennst Du dann Kunst..
Tja, Musik ist ein Handwerk, von dem Du nichts verstehst.
Das sehe ich sogar als Lehrling.
schusterlehrling 9 months ago
Ugh the only thing I don't like is the tempo because it goes faster then slower then back to faster :b
I'm actually using this as a practice because I chose this as my solo.
It's my same key and everything.
AsiaBabyy24 11 months ago
You sound amazing, and I love your facial expressions :)
sealionluver 1 year ago
its really good! im from germany and your pronunciation is almost always right, great job!
Werwoelfi 1 year ago
that was georgeous!!!! im singing this as a solo for my music festival this year, but in a much lower key.
MissGracetopher 1 year ago
I loved this. She's gorgeous too.
mannerpanner 1 year ago
You need to take lessons for how many years to be able to sing like this ?
1Neurasthenique 1 year ago
what key is this? =)
anabarza07 1 year ago
we are singing this in choir. u are amazing
BobBuilder102 1 year ago
such clear vioce!
Toby48624 1 year ago
That was an excellent performance.
schusterlehrling 1 year ago
ehh the pronunciation is a little butchered with morgen, sehen, roselein. but not bad
fccorbett 1 year ago
♪ 童は見たり 野中のバラ
Heidenröslein とはゲーテの詩なのですね。
Goethe ギオエテとは俺のことかと ゲーテ言い
classycafe29 1 year ago
You are from Iceland, right? GREAT German. And beautiful voice.
Greets from Germany.
o0BeriiShirayuki0o 1 year ago
beautiful song, beautiful voice
abelmybluecoast 1 year ago
Molto bene!!!
Roberto.
robertocasitenore 1 year ago 2
great mezzosopran !!!!!!!!
the best röselein i ever heard !!!!!!!!!!
nikall11 1 year ago 14
I sang this for district competition in Highschool (95) she does a beautiful job!
Sheasmam 1 year ago
best performance i ever heard of this piece!!
guitar17johnny 2 years ago 3
gorgeous voice
musicismylifegrazia 2 years ago 3
also 'z' sounds like English 'z'.
lansinglambert 2 years ago 3
This is false, the only word with a 'z' in this poem is 'zu' at the beginning 'Lief er schnell, es nah zu seh'n, and it's pronounced as the correct 'ts/tz'.
Gadgetist 2 years ago
@lansinglambert The pronounciation is perfect. In Germany, we have many accents. Her accent is very good and acceptable.
GermanoDeppe 1 year ago
good voice. Is she german? i think her pronunciation is not like native german.
mengyl 2 years ago
@mengyl She seems to be icelandic. But her pronunciation is quite ok for german ears. But I wonder what she's doing now, no new recordings since April 2008?
ajoachim01 2 years ago
@ajoachim01
Thanks. I think her ö sounds like ü. such as röslein, morgenschön. Do you think so?
lansinglambert 2 years ago
@lansinglambert No, her ö is perfect.
ajoachim01 2 years ago
@ajoachim01
My language has ö and ü too, but her ö sounds like ü to me. Of course that doesn't mean it is true for German. Maybe in German ö and ü are closer than in my language.
lansinglambert 2 years ago
@mengyl
Her prononciation is quite good.
Can't tell if she is a native speaker.
Just have to say say she is a very good singer.
Da Capo.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
I love your voice.
gauss2005 2 years ago
Bravo. Who are you!!!!!!!!!!
Ektct37 2 years ago
This is beautiful :)
nicoletxl 2 years ago
Absolutely gorgeous voice
& a face to match ;)
Fr05tByt3 2 years ago 3
Great!
christinanoordberger 2 years ago
The melody is from Schubert.
The lyrics are a very, very, very famous poem by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe.
This one is very good, but look out for the Helen Schneider Version from 1978.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
sehr schön gesungen!!!
Gadgetist 2 years ago
sehr schön
kaliinou 2 years ago
GREAT!
Lenchen72 2 years ago
QUE LINDA VOZ, FELICITACIONES!!!
camilodelgadodiaz 2 years ago
Sehr schön gesungen. Beautifully sung!
MMfanAZ 2 years ago
schön erarbeitet und klasse interpretiert - das stimmt alles.
Kompliment!
mlkoln 2 years ago 2
You made me smile! :-)
Twice! Your voice is so beautiful and...
By the way...
Your articulation of the words is amazingly correct, too. I can tell as a german native speaker.
Motorola68000 2 years ago
unbelievable voice... just amazing...can't find words for this...awesome!
Schaendchen08 2 years ago
Very nice. What a pleasure
musicbox99 2 years ago
My classmate didn´t believe that this poem is about a rape :(
It was the topic in our german lessons -
it´s a brilliant work. ♥ goethe
and by the way ....
AMAZING VOICE!!!
JADElovesAUSTRALIA 2 years ago
Your voice is wonderful, very relaxing for some reason. Man, does that sound creepy. sorry. :)
voiceofopinion 2 years ago
you have the loveliest voice ever! and your a great performer too. :)
maijapop 2 years ago
Beauitful voice*****
Och! So, so lovely.
Thanks
thomasojii31 2 years ago
very well supported xD Well done!
purrplefreak 2 years ago
Oh wow, great pronunciation and your voice is absolutely lovely.
cwo12 3 years ago 2
Well sung, and I like the expression as well.
Chocolateluvr1987 3 years ago 2
beautiful voice♪
xxxjasmine0319 3 years ago
Beuno !!
KasTryMixtape2008 3 years ago
Aiiiiiiiii q linda você cantandooo!!!
Parabéns!!!!
\o/
Heyn20 3 years ago
wow your pronunciation is so much better than everyone else's. your really good. i have to sing this for my exams tomorrow. ur an inspiration.
flogorian 3 years ago 21
same i have to do it for an exam :S i just forget it all :s
zinxy45 3 years ago 2
haha, i have to do this for an exam too XP. I hope you passed ^^.
flyingneoncows 2 years ago
@flogorian Eine laute Stimme macht noch keinen brillanten Vortrag., die musikalität bleibt auf der Strecke.
Sotto voce hätte mir besser gefallen! Die Tempobezeichnung die Schubert vorgegeben hat, wo blieb die ?
26rubirosa 1 year ago
Das musst Du wohl eher den Pianisten fragen als die Sängerin.
Aber wenn Dir die Musikalität fehlt, dann wirst Du leider einen so brillianten Vortrag nicht genießen können, was wirklich sehr schade ist.
schusterlehrling 11 months ago
She has my name o3o
lol
BEAUTIMUS VOICE!
YellowBanana00 3 years ago
I have a major, major crush on you!!
stungun1001 3 years ago
This songs translation:
A boy so a rose on a hedge(heiden)
He told the rose that he would pick her and she would die
the rose said that if he did she would prick him with a thorn
the boy picks the rose.
i luv this song!!
rose=Rooslein
luvclique2192 3 years ago
Mjög smart!
Gaman að hlusta og horfa á þig syngja.
Verður áhugavert að fylgjast með þér!
Karlott
Alfifa 3 years ago 3
Brava! Beautiful voice, and so expressive, so enjoyable to watch.
musicdivinemusic 3 years ago
Williamson Hall?????
Very nice. Greetings to Disela and Teddy; and Sandra Shuett.
aicochea 3 years ago
Hey, I know that room...
Aniretak205 3 years ago
Oh my gosh.... That was so unbelievably amazing! You really interpreted it well, and your pronunciation was done beautifully! I was looking for a decent video of this song to help me get a good idea with pronunciation, and you definitely had that covered. Not only was the pronunciation good, but I actually enjoyed listening to you as well. This is the first time I've found a COMPLETELY enjoyable performance on youtube. Nice Job! I plan to listen a few more times :-)
intligentdumblnd 3 years ago
Wonderful and great!
viscountli 3 years ago
VERY wonderful. i loved this. the best i've seen on youtube. you are really INTERPRETING the music and the text and getting a nice line and placement in the process.
mowho33 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
stungun1001 3 years ago
Very good =) Just make sure u say 'zehn' instead of 'zeen' but ur voice is amazing nontheless.
LadyPwnerer 3 years ago
I really like your voice - vibrato doesn't sound out of control like some sopranos when singing this song. Wonderful expression - you look really involved :) If you put on a concert I would come and watch - I love how you tell the story with your face and show your personality while you're singing. Best recording of this song I've heard so far!
clmarais 3 years ago
Great job! I really enjoyed it. Schubert would be proud. :D
SecuraOberonis 3 years ago
I really liked your interpretation. One of the better ones I've heard. And you have a beautiful voice : )
eimstudent 3 years ago