"going postal" is a great book -- funny, wise, and sharp. the movie is cheap, cheesy, and crass. it was a damn good story, and the dickhead of a director just HAD to dumb it down and have his useless, pathetic "vision" inserted like a bad suppository.
This film was shite. Moist is a charming conman, but in the film he isn't charming, or a seemingly good conman, he's just a sarcastic asshole. This movie pissed me off.
I didn't quite like this as much as the other Disc World stories. The entire plot is focused on one person and it is unbearalby personal to that individua but worst of all it supports a character. This is so unlike Terry Pratchet to write like this not to mention it detracts from the Disc World aesthetic. I do, however, understand that to have written this for screen in the same style as the Hogfather or the Colour of Magic wouldn't have been nearly as successful.
We always watch Hogfather as a Christmas tradition. 4 days from Christmas eve I find out about this movie. *face palm* >.< ...Does Amazon do extra speedy deliveries?
The book was really good, I honestly don't think there is a book I don't actually like. I mean, I have my favorites, but he writes such cleaver, witty, imaginative stories!! Honestly, I was relieved after reading the first book lol I finally found something I *really* enjoyed reading.
Going Postal is one of my favorite books from the Discworld series, and this movie is one of my favorite too (I know, the movie its not exactly like the book, but this happens :P, but for me its still a great movie and I had lots of fun watching, and Charles Dance is awesome) :D
I begin to write symphonic music. I knew about him from screen version of his first Discworld`s novel "The colour of magic". Since then I had read half of his books. I didn`t remain indifferent and wrote the number of symphonic suite "Images" - Absurd Discworld.
I suggest your attention the video with my music on my channel ra2006ra "Pratchett" or h_t_t_p_:_/_/_w_w_w_._youtube.com/watch?v=6NbM0faHptk (delete all "_").
Because of some cause servise of youtube don't let the possibility to send video-responses more than one time. I can`t hear your applause, that's why don't estimate my video if my music is liked you. If my music is liked you, help me to spread it to your friends.
I hope you'll like my music, that's why this music was written for you!
Who wants Terry Pratchett's Troll Bridge made into a movie i know i do so please visit kickstarter and make Terry Pratchett's troll bridge a reality for all the people at snowgum films
Otto Chriek. he even has a thick steroetypical accent, like in really old movies. Pick up The Truth by pratchett to see whole chapters about him and his (suicidial) love of photography.
and once more it is shown that you can't / shouldn't put a great book into pictures...
what i don't get, is why they keep changing characters when doing this. Moist von Lipwig never believed for 1 second that he really had the chance to just leave. he checked properly , and didn't almost fall (2:00).
I absolutely love Pratchett's work but was skeptical about whether or not a novel about a post office could be entertaining but once again Terry's genius shines through. I think that going postal is perhaps one of his strongest novels to date and that is saying a lot. As good as the film was, it didn't do the book enough justice in my opinion. Not because the film was poor which it wasn't, but more because the book is so well written and I think anyone would have a hard time adapting it to film.
@InfiniteBlueUK Very true, I think that's the root of the problems that some people have with these films. There's someone who's borrowing the books off me. He hasn't read Going Postal yet, so perhaps I'll lend him the film first to see how that works out, out of curiosity.
It's always necessary to dumb down a story for TV, but much of the message of Going Postal is lost in this version. Instead of focusing on how big business and big finance are dominated by conmen who conspire together to limit innovation, this version focuses on the evil done by a two-bit criminal forging bonds. Instead of spurring us to become informed about the larger world, it dispenses a lame moral lesson on the importance of following the rules.
Moist doesn't seem suave enough, period. Neither does Gilt. I mean seriously, the whole point about Moist is that he's a witty fast-talker, and with Gilt he's supposed to be larger than life.
Instead we've got a bundle of nerves for Moist, and a skin-crawling wierdo for Gilt.
Why can't they get an actual Discworld fan in for these things?
I'd say he doesn't really gain his sauvity? sauveness? Until Making Money, he appeared to be very close to a bundle of nerves from what i remember of reading 'Postal.
I love the terry prachett's books and the movie was just genius.
SentenzaGomez 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You love Claire Foy?
Sir you are not the only one haha
Pjeteh 2 weeks ago
"going postal" is a great book -- funny, wise, and sharp. the movie is cheap, cheesy, and crass. it was a damn good story, and the dickhead of a director just HAD to dumb it down and have his useless, pathetic "vision" inserted like a bad suppository.
kalevraa 3 weeks ago
This film was shite. Moist is a charming conman, but in the film he isn't charming, or a seemingly good conman, he's just a sarcastic asshole. This movie pissed me off.
Cespinarve 3 weeks ago
I didn't quite like this as much as the other Disc World stories. The entire plot is focused on one person and it is unbearalby personal to that individua but worst of all it supports a character. This is so unlike Terry Pratchet to write like this not to mention it detracts from the Disc World aesthetic. I do, however, understand that to have written this for screen in the same style as the Hogfather or the Colour of Magic wouldn't have been nearly as successful.
Moogitard 2 months ago
We always watch Hogfather as a Christmas tradition. 4 days from Christmas eve I find out about this movie. *face palm* >.< ...Does Amazon do extra speedy deliveries?
The book was really good, I honestly don't think there is a book I don't actually like. I mean, I have my favorites, but he writes such cleaver, witty, imaginative stories!! Honestly, I was relieved after reading the first book lol I finally found something I *really* enjoyed reading.
AliCat42 2 months ago
i really want to see ray winstone as sir samuel vimes
96marzie 2 months ago
i am 15 and i have been reading terry pratchett for five years. I NEVER GET TIRED OF IT!
96marzie 2 months ago
hmz hab was geiles entdeckt haha
YokoRimazk643 2 months ago
I love this movie. The chemistry between Moist and Adorabelle is amazing. I hope they do Making Money next.
grimeldasnodpocket 3 months ago
Going Postal is one of my favorite books from the Discworld series, and this movie is one of my favorite too (I know, the movie its not exactly like the book, but this happens :P, but for me its still a great movie and I had lots of fun watching, and Charles Dance is awesome) :D
SammEater 4 months ago
Im from Hungary, Budapest, where the film was captioned. I never thought that my homecity will be "Ankh-Morpork" in the movie. :)
lordmakarix 5 months ago 4
@lordmakarix
This is awesome. :P
SammEater 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello, fans of Terry Pratchett!
I begin to write symphonic music. I knew about him from screen version of his first Discworld`s novel "The colour of magic". Since then I had read half of his books. I didn`t remain indifferent and wrote the number of symphonic suite "Images" - Absurd Discworld.
I suggest your attention the video with my music on my channel ra2006ra "Pratchett" or h_t_t_p_:_/_/_w_w_w_._youtube.com/watch?v=6NbM0faHptk (delete all "_").
ra2006ra 5 months ago in playlist Terry Pratchett is LOVE
Because of some cause servise of youtube don't let the possibility to send video-responses more than one time. I can`t hear your applause, that's why don't estimate my video if my music is liked you. If my music is liked you, help me to spread it to your friends.
I hope you'll like my music, that's why this music was written for you!
ra2006ra 5 months ago in playlist Terry Pratchett is LOVE
/watch?v=rXUMOmyvgxQ
Breeza2011 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
h_t_t_p_:_/_/_w_w_w_._youtube.com/watch?v=6NbM0faHptk
ra2006ra 5 months ago
youtube.com/watch?v=6NbM0faHptk
ra2006ra 5 months ago
It looks fantastic! If the world were exposed to Terry Pratchett's wit, the world couldn't help but love it.
turtleguardian211 7 months ago
Who wants Terry Pratchett's Troll Bridge made into a movie i know i do so please visit kickstarter and make Terry Pratchett's troll bridge a reality for all the people at snowgum films
ramtopsman 10 months ago
youve been a naughty boy
bubbah671 11 months ago 3
hmm this looks better than some other TV adaptations of Pratchett's work. i must check this out
dtek40k 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@dtek40k
The full film is on my channel
ramtopsman 1 year ago
oh. my. god. Its. But. Him as... him! MUST SEE!
Dokph 1 year ago
JEAH I got this movie to christmas!
zorrderschnitter94 1 year ago
@PracticeRecover
Otto Chriek. he even has a thick steroetypical accent, like in really old movies. Pick up The Truth by pratchett to see whole chapters about him and his (suicidial) love of photography.
Henevas 1 year ago
and once more it is shown that you can't / shouldn't put a great book into pictures...
what i don't get, is why they keep changing characters when doing this. Moist von Lipwig never believed for 1 second that he really had the chance to just leave. he checked properly , and didn't almost fall (2:00).
Spartakist85 1 year ago
I absolutely love Pratchett's work but was skeptical about whether or not a novel about a post office could be entertaining but once again Terry's genius shines through. I think that going postal is perhaps one of his strongest novels to date and that is saying a lot. As good as the film was, it didn't do the book enough justice in my opinion. Not because the film was poor which it wasn't, but more because the book is so well written and I think anyone would have a hard time adapting it to film.
InfiniteBlueUK 1 year ago 24
@InfiniteBlueUK Very true, I think that's the root of the problems that some people have with these films. There's someone who's borrowing the books off me. He hasn't read Going Postal yet, so perhaps I'll lend him the film first to see how that works out, out of curiosity.
Reorte 1 year ago
so fucking awesome! One of my fav's comes to life ^^
Kakarroto82 1 year ago
damn please release this here in Canada...PLEASE!
grahamkeithtodd 1 year ago
@grahamkeithtodd i think you can but the dvds online or even watch the films online
simp1234579 1 year ago
another cool hungarian movie!
wildufo 1 year ago
@wildufo Attól még nem lesz magyar film, hogy Itthon forgatták és magyarok is részt vettek a készítésében. Az Index mindig túloz egy kicsit...
CaptainRumi 1 year ago
@CaptainRumi de.
wildufo 1 year ago
Considering who he's played in the past, it seems pretty fitting that Richard Coyle should star in a Discworld movie.
typacsk 1 year ago
"You have been a very naughty boy, and you know what happens...to naughty boys?!!!"
Claire Foy is awesome =D
lordabomity 1 year ago
"If you don`t know where you`ve been then,you cant know where you`re going" Pity our govenments dont follow that rule!
swollower 1 year ago 2
CHARLES DANCE AS THE PATRICIAN. Effing AWESOME.
KryssLaBryn 1 year ago 17
@KryssLaBryn Good in the role, but they could have easily dyed his hair and beard black!!!!!!
FulchesterUnited 1 year ago
If more people read Pratchett's work then the movie works well, whether it is true to the book or not.
beeceekay 1 year ago
I always love it when Pterry expresses his opinions on his own work and what people make of it. Almost as much fun as the books themselves! :)
SatyreIkon 1 year ago
Shouldn't mr Pump be bigger?
Blargaha 1 year ago
after the post office burns down, the movie goes downhill with it. really sad becouse it had a very good start...
jackobyuk 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i just love this movie! very interesting!
Jula7Jilia 1 year ago 3
It's always necessary to dumb down a story for TV, but much of the message of Going Postal is lost in this version. Instead of focusing on how big business and big finance are dominated by conmen who conspire together to limit innovation, this version focuses on the evil done by a two-bit criminal forging bonds. Instead of spurring us to become informed about the larger world, it dispenses a lame moral lesson on the importance of following the rules.
hasatum 1 year ago 2
@TheRadicalClan
Moist doesn't seem suave enough, period. Neither does Gilt. I mean seriously, the whole point about Moist is that he's a witty fast-talker, and with Gilt he's supposed to be larger than life.
Instead we've got a bundle of nerves for Moist, and a skin-crawling wierdo for Gilt.
Why can't they get an actual Discworld fan in for these things?
Lodatzor 1 year ago
@Lodatzor
I'd say he doesn't really gain his sauvity? sauveness? Until Making Money, he appeared to be very close to a bundle of nerves from what i remember of reading 'Postal.
Wharficron 1 year ago
@Wharficron
Only on the inside. He'd never have been a successful conman in the first place if he was a bundle of nerves on the outside. ;)
Plus, many of his lines in Going Postal are smooth as hell. ;)
Lodatzor 1 year ago
@Lodatzor Terry Pratchett himself loves it. You can tell in his interviews about it. I think he's just about the biggest fan they could get for this.
dsdepadova 1 year ago
@dsdepadova
Yes. getting royalty money will have that effect. ;)
Lodatzor 1 year ago
They missed out Bloody Stupid's post sorting machine. :(
Vehementi 1 year ago
<3 his beard
efg13 1 year ago
4:39 Otto!
Kumiyanagi 1 year ago
I love Drumknott's expression at around 3:40 :D
DarkElfMairead 1 year ago