i think you can sing very well, but for a song like this i think you need to slow down a little... i feel like you rushed it a bit. So next time just take your time. But overall nicely done!
she is amazing. she truly pays tribute to kate bush with this cover, which is what i'm sure she is trying to do (considering she loves her). charlotte's voice is flawless. :)
Its tooooo fast.... don't rush, but then again, why bother trying to improve on the original? Leave Kate alone... her version is forever memorialized in music hall of fame...
How can any of you say Charlotte is not putting HUGE emotion in this performance? This is as true a rendering of Kate Bush's classic as there ever was - especially considering Kate herself never performed it live.
If she'd said this is a song by Maxwell she would be singing it too fast but she starts off by saying 'this songs by Kate Bush' and gets it right on the button.
the tempo is too fast if you are unfamiliar with the original and have only heard the (no where near as good but still nice) Maxwell version. If you know the KB version this is perfect tempo as you have noted..
Lovely! I don't know where this "too fast" stuff is coming from--I've heard the Kate Bush song about a zillion times since the late '80s, and you're on the mark. I think Maxwell has addled many.
You have a talented voice, but this song is not meant to be so fast, your voice is not meant to be so sharp, and your singing should not be so emotionally empty.
Take it slow, feel the song, and you'd do so much better.
u guys are out of your mind--kate doesn't even play this the rare times she tours--this is a gem heard live! charlotte does a beautiful rendition! what are you going to say? heifitz didn't play that as well as beethoven would l have?
very beautyful. this is a wonderful mix of soul and her own interpretation.i can feel her emotion and i´m deeply stirred when i hear all the versions.i love this song...
great version of this song; especially considering it's live & acoustic; not everyone can do Kate Bush justice, but I'd go to hear this one again & again. Fantastic job!
although i liked kate's version,...but charlotte's version is fresh,represents our generation. but indeed i share the opinion with transmittance practice makes perfect...
She's no Kate, but this is better sounding than her original stuff. Work on your live mic technique a bit though hun, you need to back away when your volume goes up, otherwise it sounds piercing and shrill. Not bad for a beginner though, keep working on refining your music, and try and find a sound of your own.
Well that explains the problem I mentioned, and why she needs to work on her mic technique. You see, opera singers don't use mics, and don't train to sing on mic. So if it's true what you say, that she is a "trained opera singer", then it proves my point.
She needs to work on her mic technique, thats constructive criticism. Watch ANY K.D. Lang video for great examples of perfect mic technique, watch her placement, her hands, and distance when her volume goes up,flawless.
This performance was recorded under unprofessional conditions, or else with inferior equipment, which is the reason the audience as well as the singer is generating distortion. That's not the singer's fault.
The composer of this song, Kate Bush, also invented the headset radio mic, where backing away when volume rises isn't even physically possible. If your electronics can't handle crescendos, then get better electronics. Because that's where the fault lies, not with the singer.
Nice. Had no idea this was on YouTube. I was at this show, and had the chance to meet Charlotte after the show. She's as nice as she is talented (which is quite a bit).
Niiiiice. That was an amazing cover. I think some parts in the beginning sounded a little rushed, but I really enjoyed it a lot. You have a really expressive voice. I've always admired people who can both sing and play an instrument at the same time.
Is this the Eric Clapton and Jimmy Page Charlotte Martin? Sure looks the same but maybe too young.
TWR1961 5 months ago
i think you can sing very well, but for a song like this i think you need to slow down a little... i feel like you rushed it a bit. So next time just take your time. But overall nicely done!
kayahra 9 months ago
Too fast. Vocals are a bit weedy as well.
curiousted 9 months ago
if you would have slowed it down i think the song would be 10 times better. but u did very good you have a nice vioce <3
flyboyallday1200 9 months ago
she is amazing. she truly pays tribute to kate bush with this cover, which is what i'm sure she is trying to do (considering she loves her). charlotte's voice is flawless. :)
GetSkintight 1 year ago
...nice :)...
Doppeldropper 1 year ago
thank you darling
poada2008 1 year ago
Its tooooo fast.... don't rush, but then again, why bother trying to improve on the original? Leave Kate alone... her version is forever memorialized in music hall of fame...
gold95 1 year ago
this isn't better than the maxwell version but it's still go his voice is cleaner than hers on this song
WyattDstevens12 1 year ago
very nice
wvawwtopline 1 year ago
beautiful....
Truthbearer1 1 year ago
she is good :) she sound better than maxwell ^___^ and it's not too fast, it's a nice tempo....
i like this one :):)
asoraXsuicide 1 year ago
u japped hard as hell
prettyboiakadanny 2 years ago
lovely, you've done Kate justice :)
beautiful voice.
oddn 2 years ago
How can any of you say Charlotte is not putting HUGE emotion in this performance? This is as true a rendering of Kate Bush's classic as there ever was - especially considering Kate herself never performed it live.
manco82 2 years ago 2
@manco82 agreed.
SuperRajay 2 years ago
it would have been better if she put more of her self into the performance, it sounds just like Kate Bush's version
bearmountain114 2 years ago
If she'd said this is a song by Maxwell she would be singing it too fast but she starts off by saying 'this songs by Kate Bush' and gets it right on the button.
popyy11 2 years ago 4
Why is it too fast? The tempo seems fine to me.
Umagula 2 years ago
the tempo is too fast if you are unfamiliar with the original and have only heard the (no where near as good but still nice) Maxwell version. If you know the KB version this is perfect tempo as you have noted..
Gotbc 2 years ago 3
ITS GOOD...BUT IT IS FAST
russilini 2 years ago
Lovely! I don't know where this "too fast" stuff is coming from--I've heard the Kate Bush song about a zillion times since the late '80s, and you're on the mark. I think Maxwell has addled many.
Thank you!
keithdeweese 2 years ago 5
pretty good!!
sleezymany 2 years ago
too fast
MEE051677 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
too fast, melody is off and not in a good way. lacks soul. i can hear that you can sing really well, but this wasn't a good cover... sorry :o(
slimgiddy 2 years ago
You have a talented voice, but this song is not meant to be so fast, your voice is not meant to be so sharp, and your singing should not be so emotionally empty.
Take it slow, feel the song, and you'd do so much better.
BlackStallion777 2 years ago
nice one girl
poada2008 2 years ago
Not a bad voice but I didnt get any emotion. Singing is all about acting with your voice.
tabithacate 2 years ago 2
if you wann feel emotion you should watch cover by Kasia Stankiewicz she is so talented
karypel19 2 years ago
pritty girl.. pritty good
drumheadelijah 2 years ago
not good, all over the place.
pilomaya2012 2 years ago
lol are u serious, at least maxwell sings in tune, she is way too sharp in the beginning!
lowend99 2 years ago
I think she just changed the note =P
asdfhuliashduflasihf 2 years ago
Your voice is absolutely amazing, your version of that song is spot on!
catspinkpencil 2 years ago 2
that was rly rly pretty, dun listen tew them, sayin it was awful, it was Great!
<3
:D
xVampyrehunterDx 2 years ago
bravissima.................... complimenti!
artistafolle90 3 years ago
u guys are out of your mind--kate doesn't even play this the rare times she tours--this is a gem heard live! charlotte does a beautiful rendition! what are you going to say? heifitz didn't play that as well as beethoven would l have?
cuddlebuttons 3 years ago
awful ! No lightness ! let kate sings
AmakirEtLuce 3 years ago
sexy!!!
keto6789 3 years ago
oh man....
she juz make the song so awfool
mrarifufu 3 years ago
very beautyful. this is a wonderful mix of soul and her own interpretation.i can feel her emotion and i´m deeply stirred when i hear all the versions.i love this song...
MssJenni88 3 years ago 4
You made it go away. x
poada2008 3 years ago 2
awsome ,, sobbing ,,,,,
tara1941 3 years ago
beautiful
DanParry445 3 years ago
Congratulation this is good.
Kate has the hit but this girl sings well. Wish you well and thank you
phus2001 3 years ago 3
You rocked this song!!!! Very nice!!!!
Oceanbeech 3 years ago
I think she's FANTASTIC! I mean I'm a huge fan of both Kate Bush and Maxwells versions but she made this her own and came out good.
She's got a very strong voice as well!
jennyloughman 3 years ago
ok not as good as the original or max but not all bad
blacksigy 3 years ago
Nothing on the original or Maxwell's cover.
RangeofMotion 3 years ago
great version of this song; especially considering it's live & acoustic; not everyone can do Kate Bush justice, but I'd go to hear this one again & again. Fantastic job!
rumbleseat69 3 years ago
ignore the idiot who says this sucks.
that was awsome, maybe some people cant here beyond the poor recording quality, but then this wasnt recorded in a six million pound studio.
follylandtales 3 years ago
Great Job!!!
erinmerle 3 years ago
slow down...
lynnandjensbabe 3 years ago
too fast. lacks feeling. sucks.
skePtikmartian 3 years ago
Best cover I'd ever heard of this song... obviously she is no Kate Bush, but it's a fabulous interpretation.
ourbovinepublicxx 3 years ago
i love wayy too much this version!!!!
although i liked kate's version,...but charlotte's version is fresh,represents our generation. but indeed i share the opinion with transmittance practice makes perfect...
MusikFashioNLuV 3 years ago
Charlotte Martin is absolutely amazing!
littlemisslovex 3 years ago
BELT IT BABY!!! I love when singers just let go and just belt those notes out.
mulioctaveman 3 years ago 2
a beautiful song that always makes me cry, Kates verstiom is perfect, you did a great Job
Check the Vid out to this song
tentheagle 3 years ago
nice version!
GrissomLovesSara 3 years ago
i really like this, she should slow it down a bit. obviously not as good as Kate's version, but nothing ever is ;)
ceeerrl 3 years ago 10
She's no Kate, but this is better sounding than her original stuff. Work on your live mic technique a bit though hun, you need to back away when your volume goes up, otherwise it sounds piercing and shrill. Not bad for a beginner though, keep working on refining your music, and try and find a sound of your own.
transmittance 4 years ago 4
?? beginner...check out her CD :)
I think the sound distortion might be from the camera recording it?
highwaykind 3 years ago
Charlotte Martin is a trained opera singer, I doubt she needs your condescending "advice".
Katywackerz 3 years ago
Well that explains the problem I mentioned, and why she needs to work on her mic technique. You see, opera singers don't use mics, and don't train to sing on mic. So if it's true what you say, that she is a "trained opera singer", then it proves my point.
She needs to work on her mic technique, thats constructive criticism. Watch ANY K.D. Lang video for great examples of perfect mic technique, watch her placement, her hands, and distance when her volume goes up,flawless.
Practice makes perfect
transmittance 3 years ago
This performance was recorded under unprofessional conditions, or else with inferior equipment, which is the reason the audience as well as the singer is generating distortion. That's not the singer's fault.
The composer of this song, Kate Bush, also invented the headset radio mic, where backing away when volume rises isn't even physically possible. If your electronics can't handle crescendos, then get better electronics. Because that's where the fault lies, not with the singer.
ketmaniac 3 years ago
Well maybe it's just me, but I just don't see how she can use her hands to handle the mike, play the piano and sing all at the same time.
asdfhuliashduflasihf 3 years ago
well done ,youve got talent.
davestany 4 years ago 3
Oh my god, I love it.
laikalynx 4 years ago
If only Charlotte had kept the pauses, it'd be perfect.
manco82 4 years ago 2
indeed!
CCarmen 3 years ago
I think it WAS truly great. It made me cry, such a beautiful song sung by a beautiful voice.
adstargel 4 years ago
Slow down, don't rush it. Let the emotion take over and you will be truly great.
JohnPertwee 4 years ago
beautiful!!!!!! And she didnt cry!! I know its hard not to.
oOXenaOo 4 years ago 2
good cover not as good as origlan because thats well amazing but relly relly good
Forgonner 4 years ago
Superb performance - Bravo :)
AtomAntTC 4 years ago
wuah... uhm...
EvelynAndrews 4 years ago
nice...you kind of sound like mandy moore
jopaul 4 years ago
Very great voice, so is the cover
bumbeez 4 years ago
You nailed it!
rnboone01 4 years ago
i would like to know where did you get the sheet music for the song ( the one you just played)
omegaoti 4 years ago
Thank you for posting this!=)
CCarmen 4 years ago
I cant believe how good your voice is
Kate Bush is one of my favourite singers Ever
you really have done this song justice
fluften 4 years ago
Nice. Had no idea this was on YouTube. I was at this show, and had the chance to meet Charlotte after the show. She's as nice as she is talented (which is quite a bit).
DekeRadio 4 years ago
this is an extraordinary cover of the great kate bush! i love charlotte
freehip 4 years ago
You know that's maxwell's song right?
nellycme 4 years ago
No it isn't, it's Kate Bush's song.
silgen 4 years ago 5
Whoops i just looked it up on google. I didn't realize Kate Bush had written the song. my bad!
nellycme 4 years ago
Oops, I replied below without reading this one, my bad as well :D
silgen 4 years ago
I love this song and also this version is pretty awesome... wow, wish I had such a voice ;)
Coco1893 4 years ago
Niiiiice. That was an amazing cover. I think some parts in the beginning sounded a little rushed, but I really enjoyed it a lot. You have a really expressive voice. I've always admired people who can both sing and play an instrument at the same time.
ThEsUpReMeDiVo 4 years ago
LOVE this. Thank you for sharing.
Love.
doyoudaredare 4 years ago
she is so amazing...another spectacular cover.
buriedlovely 4 years ago
beautiful. when was this?
WashedOYS 4 years ago