This is one of Szeryng's best performances, I believe.
He combines exquisite taste in sound and intepretation with fine, intellectual muscianship and an almost aristocratic way of playing the violin! What a stunning performance! :)
@lezare2012 That is not true that he sounded like others. He made you follow the music and feel the music in your mind; whether others gave you the feeling and made you think of: wow what a great violonist. He makes you say: wow what great music. He is a true musician.
I've always loved his Brahms.... in that great series The Art of the Violin ,Perlman made a comment something like "if you hear a violinist and he sounds a little like everybody it must be Szerng" i found that comment very unfair
You're right to be upset by what Perlman commented. I wonder many times what Perlman himself sounds like???
This is it....It comes very easily to many of these contemporary musicians to step on the dead bodies (but forever living spirits) of the past! One of them is Szering for sure!!!
What I love about Szeryng is that he doesn't seem to be forcing his own personality onto the music. When I hear him play, I just think, "Yeah, that's Brahms, that's Bach--that's how it's supposed to sound."
Great Posting. Don't ever erase it. We need to remember the Great Viloinsts of th 20th Century. In my opinion, Szeryng was underrated; there were so many great violinists during his life; Heifetz, Franciscotti, Milstein, Grumiaux, Menuhin, Oistrakh, & Stern to name a few. I believe Henryk's interpretations were the most genuine to the music and composer. RIP....Szeryng.......
I agree...but Szeryng was a huge name during his lifetime, he wasn't so underrated, not as much as someone like Kogan, for example. However, he deserved much more credit than he received.
I think Szeryng with his sensitve performing is closer to the original hungarian styl and feeling than Kogan. He is an amazing performer, I alltimes prefer listen her play to.
spiritual. not sure which performance I prefer - that of Kogan's or this one. Both are tremendous, very different from one another and equally effective.
I agree with you I think. I too prefer Kogan's version and the searing intensity he brings to the table. Szeryng is special though with his sensitivity and modulations of tempo. Two giants of the violin. Szeryng had enormous respect for Kogan by the way.
(not referring to No.17) i think Menuhin's playing on Hungarian dances are better (just my taste though), I think his "rudeness" (can't think of a suitable word lol) in playing suits the set of dance
Szeryng played the violin at the hotel garden when the hotel caught fire and the guest in panic were evacuated to the garden. The news article I read in the late 80's said his violin play made the guest calm.
Kogan and Szeryng play the piece in quite different styles. I think that Kogan's interpretation is more dramatic (as opposed to whimsical), while Szeryng takes more freedom. Can't beat the end of the Kogan performance, though.
i actually think that szeryng's performance is incredibly dramatic. in my opinion, i think that kogan is much more precise in how he plays as far this piece goes. i also like szeryngs ending a lot more because it seems to be more powerful, and less flashy. i am obviously very biased towards szeryng. i love his playing so much
Man, you gotta love the sound of a guarnerius violin, it's so dark and beautiful, and Szeryng really knows how to bring out its best sounds. At 0:48 it sounds like its crying. Good stuff
Does anyone know why Szeryng keeps playing at the frog at the beginning of the second movement? Does it gives you more power and strength and clarity in sound?
If only Szeryng could play Bach with 1/100th of the soul he plays this peice with... Very nicely played. However, I do agree that Kogan's version is better.
Kreisler has to be given a little credit here; it is he who wrote the transcription to violin. He must also be heard in this piece. Thank you for sharing a wonderful video.
One of my favorite players, in my top 5. His recording of the Beethoven Violin is the only one I ever listen to. Always tried to get my vibrato to sound like his. never worked. LOL
At 0:26 he's like "God, I need a drink!" ;-)
amarie123 2 months ago
the best I ve ever heard!!!!!!..
zadory74 2 months ago
This is Fritz Kreisler's arrangement of the piece, which gives it a major ending.
angreagach 3 months ago
THE BEST.
ugisanu 4 months ago
Its best very best hhahaha'
/watch?v=34dkfyUTOnI
/watch?v=34dkfyUTOnI
/watch?v=34dkfyUTOnI
/watch?v=34dkfyUTOnI
thevitormed 5 months ago
oricine interpreteaza cu sufletul ........is the best !!! oricum ar iesi.....
dlaacord 7 months ago
Brilliant! TY SamLee for posting.
paulostroff99 7 months ago
Kogan the best...
MrVko94 1 year ago
I'm proud of being Pole.
Terfan 1 year ago
@Terfan
Nebenbei, er war ein Jude.
theviolinist12345 1 year ago
@theviolinist12345 Ha ha if it takes being Jewish to play like that I'll convert immediately!
atchicago1 7 months ago
Thank you for posting this! Brilliant!
muurtalo 1 year ago
Heavenly beautiful... just listen.
akikosukigara21 1 year ago
szeryng is playing the kreisler arrangment of the piece in f minor. joachim also arranged it in f sharp minor.
cigtt 1 year ago
haha! 3:20 i'll show you, whatch out now! XD
AmelieWuensche 1 year ago 2
This is one of Szeryng's best performances, I believe.
He combines exquisite taste in sound and intepretation with fine, intellectual muscianship and an almost aristocratic way of playing the violin! What a stunning performance! :)
Bachismydiety 1 year ago 7
Great performance.As for Perlman's comment on Szeryng,I don't think he meant it badly,but as a compliment of sorts,and I think he was right!
HeifetzRanew 1 year ago
@HeifetzRanew If anyone sounds generic, it's Perlman. Szeryng is in another class.
MadAuralSkills 10 months ago
My favourite hungarian dance and the best performance, especially the beginning, it's very hungarianisch. . Partying by crying. :)
I am hungarian and I can tell you Kogan has no idea about hungarian soul, Szeryng feels it. This is the perfect one.
Sirvavigad 1 year ago 3
49testsamiam49, Perlman said that Szigeti sounded like everybody...I'm pretty sure about that...but nonetheless, it is not very kind to either.
lezare2012 1 year ago
@lezare2012 That is not true that he sounded like others. He made you follow the music and feel the music in your mind; whether others gave you the feeling and made you think of: wow what a great violonist. He makes you say: wow what great music. He is a true musician.
duopassion 1 year ago 2
This Hungarian dance is actually in F Minor, not F# Minor like the description, just a minor thing. Fantastic performance.
Personwithface13 1 year ago
Comment removed
TariqSecret 2 years ago
What a beautiful performance!
cwldoc 2 years ago 2
I've always loved his Brahms.... in that great series The Art of the Violin ,Perlman made a comment something like "if you hear a violinist and he sounds a little like everybody it must be Szerng" i found that comment very unfair
49testsamiam49 2 years ago 5
You're right to be upset by what Perlman commented. I wonder many times what Perlman himself sounds like???
This is it....It comes very easily to many of these contemporary musicians to step on the dead bodies (but forever living spirits) of the past! One of them is Szering for sure!!!
alex77727 2 years ago 2
his tempo is perfect. His shading and phrasing is stunning. Szeryng = a truly great artist.
calloffthedogs 2 years ago 4
L'embassateur!!!
Bautisnemo 2 years ago
a g r e a t artsist will for ever be e great artist bravoo....
boaziko007 2 years ago
love the face expression at 3.21!!a great artist!
ilkolli 2 years ago
what year was the video made?
belaerdei 2 years ago
around 1962-1964, I guess
4LX1M1K 2 years ago
What I love about Szeryng is that he doesn't seem to be forcing his own personality onto the music. When I hear him play, I just think, "Yeah, that's Brahms, that's Bach--that's how it's supposed to sound."
charlesviolin 2 years ago 30
He is quite a well player I just don't like the tone all that much
opoqu 2 years ago
Well those mics were crap back then, so you have to kind of imagine it in a lot of ways.
oatboy 2 years ago
Great Posting. Don't ever erase it. We need to remember the Great Viloinsts of th 20th Century. In my opinion, Szeryng was underrated; there were so many great violinists during his life; Heifetz, Franciscotti, Milstein, Grumiaux, Menuhin, Oistrakh, & Stern to name a few. I believe Henryk's interpretations were the most genuine to the music and composer. RIP....Szeryng.......
GeniusHaydn 2 years ago 3
I think this is the best version of No, 17 out there. Szeryng plays it just right...
GeniusHaydn 2 years ago 4
I agree...but Szeryng was a huge name during his lifetime, he wasn't so underrated, not as much as someone like Kogan, for example. However, he deserved much more credit than he received.
eudoxas 2 years ago 2
great sound, great vibrato, great tone...what else?!?!?!
tonyuccio 3 years ago 3
absolutely amazing. I wish I could play like him
auds
dancsut 3 years ago
Thank you, SamLee...
gdbernoli 3 years ago
So dramatical ...
dzeljpiano 3 years ago
What a delicate,uncommon soul ...
danadatz 3 years ago
He was great but in this piece he realy touch
my heart
Leibik 3 years ago 3
I think Szeryng with his sensitve performing is closer to the original hungarian styl and feeling than Kogan. He is an amazing performer, I alltimes prefer listen her play to.
Sorry for my poor english...
Lythia89 3 years ago 6
This really is wonderfull, I have always loved 'The Szeryng Sound' as my teacher used to call it!
Great job by the pianist as well, not easy playing with Henryk Szeryng!! Thanks for this video!
Violin147 3 years ago 3
Fantastic. He has to be my favourite violinist ever!
Yankees1007 3 years ago 4
magnificent.
catlvr4567 3 years ago
Mutch better than Cogan,He plays a real hungarian style-:)What a surprise!!!!!
mikilikike 3 years ago 3
Wonderful interpretation! He is a great violinist with good technique and knows each music well.
takamori400 3 years ago 2
sencillamente excelente violinista con una interpretacion muy buena de la dances hungarian 17
metvany 3 years ago
sad but warm
SS29365 3 years ago 4
amazing... my favourite violinist of all time
cgd147 3 years ago 19
@cgd147 I agree! I feel that he's underrated.
MomSaysImCool 1 week ago
spiritual. not sure which performance I prefer - that of Kogan's or this one. Both are tremendous, very different from one another and equally effective.
NestorAudinotviolins 3 years ago 7
I prefer Kogan's, but it's a matter of taste, personally I love Kogan's "integrity", but we're speaking about two giants
kavakosfan 3 years ago
I agree with you I think. I too prefer Kogan's version and the searing intensity he brings to the table. Szeryng is special though with his sensitivity and modulations of tempo. Two giants of the violin. Szeryng had enormous respect for Kogan by the way.
NestorAudinotviolins 3 years ago 3
(not referring to No.17) i think Menuhin's playing on Hungarian dances are better (just my taste though), I think his "rudeness" (can't think of a suitable word lol) in playing suits the set of dance
nokia1242000 3 years ago
So heartbreakingly beautiful.
I'm proud to be Magyar when I hear this!
lexigore 3 years ago
Which Adams family epi does this duo appear in? I must have missed it.
wiccalite 3 years ago
This is taken from a French television broadcast on November 27. 1963. The pianist is Tasso Janopoulo.
TomBarrister 3 years ago 2
Very nice!!! And Kogan too!
CuciucGriga 3 years ago 2
this performance is amazing but i cant imagine anybody dancing to this music
bballstar0309 3 years ago
Szeryng all ways perfect(Bach),but in this
dance he is greatest artist
Leibvio 3 years ago 3
Freaking brilliant, artistry pushed to the limits.
MomSaysImCool 4 years ago
at the piano, Tasso Janopoulo, masterful.
gt001g 4 years ago 2
Brahms and Szeryng;what an amaizing magician "duo"!!
gagga96 4 years ago 5
this is so good, i have this song , but cant play it =[ i wanna play like him
csillampeto 4 years ago 2
Bardzo dobry! Dziekuje, SamLee :)
¡Muy bueno! Gracias, SamLee :)
osverol 4 years ago
Szeryng played the violin at the hotel garden when the hotel caught fire and the guest in panic were evacuated to the garden. The news article I read in the late 80's said his violin play made the guest calm.
mozartjpn137 4 years ago 6
Szeryng the greatest
rapacc 4 years ago
beautiful
schilippe 4 years ago
Man, Szeryng has my favorite vibrato ever
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
how about Ferras's vibrato in Berceuse?
govibe 4 years ago
ya know, this isnt the joachim version. does anybody know where to buy the sheet music to this?
whitemexnumba1 4 years ago
it's the kreisler edition. I think it can only be found in the Fritz Kreisler collection, volume 2, but i'm not sure.
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
I love these people's facial expresions^^
jkwon666 4 years ago
Outstanding
sherom 4 years ago 2
Kogan and Szeryng play the piece in quite different styles. I think that Kogan's interpretation is more dramatic (as opposed to whimsical), while Szeryng takes more freedom. Can't beat the end of the Kogan performance, though.
imperialadmiral121 4 years ago
SO beautiful!
lexigore 4 years ago
i actually think that szeryng's performance is incredibly dramatic. in my opinion, i think that kogan is much more precise in how he plays as far this piece goes. i also like szeryngs ending a lot more because it seems to be more powerful, and less flashy. i am obviously very biased towards szeryng. i love his playing so much
whitemexnumba1 4 years ago
Some truly heartbreakingly beautiful playing.
GreatPianists 4 years ago
Man, you gotta love the sound of a guarnerius violin, it's so dark and beautiful, and Szeryng really knows how to bring out its best sounds. At 0:48 it sounds like its crying. Good stuff
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
Kogan's version is better on youtube
nathanbob12 4 years ago
I've already seen Kogan's rendition, I don't think it's better at all.
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
I've been looking for this piece on CD, but in vain. Now thanks for your great sharing. I love Szeryng so much.
brandonhu 4 years ago
Bravo Szeryng! So much joy!
sunjans 4 years ago
damn! i love hungarian dances! do you have anyother hungarian dances ??
hongphuc163 4 years ago
szeryng oistrick mendez brain may all be b/w video but the quality is unsurpassseddd
maynardmorris 4 years ago
It is actually in F minor. Brilliant playing by Szeryng.
vlnking 4 years ago
Kogan is my favorite, but Szeryng plays this piece with much more passion. His vibrato is phenomenal.
DED319 5 years ago
Thank you Mr.SamLee!!
fiddleorg 5 years ago
I can think of only one word to describe him.
Genius
marymorstan 5 years ago
Does anyone know why Szeryng keeps playing at the frog at the beginning of the second movement? Does it gives you more power and strength and clarity in sound?
ARCTrooperAlpha 5 years ago
playing at the frog allows you to have a stronger, deeper sound. the logic is that it is closer to your hand, where you are putting pressure
thermodynamics2 4 years ago
this is pure genius!!!
andreigocan 5 years ago
If only Szeryng could play Bach with 1/100th of the soul he plays this peice with... Very nicely played. However, I do agree that Kogan's version is better.
aimson 5 years ago
I prefer Kogan's version on youtube better
OistrakhMilstein 5 years ago
Kreisler has to be given a little credit here; it is he who wrote the transcription to violin. He must also be heard in this piece. Thank you for sharing a wonderful video.
robotnik77 5 years ago
Actually, I'm pretty sure Joseph Joachim transribed all of the Hungarian Dances for violn
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
Joachim did transcribe Brahms' Hungarian Dances. This
particular transcription is Kreisler's.
robotnik77 4 years ago
Oh ok, i didn't know that. Thanks for telling me. Is there any significant difference between the 2 transcriptions?
AbsoluteZ3R0 4 years ago
such lovely playing. i wish i had even more of his recordings. ; 0
trevorpinnocky 5 years ago
One of my favorite players, in my top 5. His recording of the Beethoven Violin is the only one I ever listen to. Always tried to get my vibrato to sound like his. never worked. LOL
trevorpinnocky 5 years ago