Hilary Duff-Last Christmas

[squirrleydew]

I really reeaallyy I mean Reeaallyy haaate to say she can't sing better than Ashley at this because Hilary has good music and can sing The problem is, well, try and think of the music tracks alone being flip flopped They both sang the same song but, it seems as if Ashley and Hilary swapped music tracks(stole each others music style) It seems backwards. I feel she not as prettier after lizzy Ashley(HOT good music) simply sung with more power has a Hilary musical feel and at time does sing Better

[gatororade]

Yes, she can sing this song better. Beside, she is HOT!!

[xXAshleyxX2]

Ashley tisdale is WAAAAAAY better

I can feel the Love in Her voice

Hilary just singing without any Emotion...

[BlondeStar1000]

Ashely Tisdale; wayyyyyyyyyy better on this song!

[luluzheng1]

i love taylors's version!!

[hype4sistas]

@luluzheng1 she doesn't count.

[HenryClearwater]

i love that "Chiki kah* whisper part

[eiramana32]

she sings good, but I prefer the 80s, really :)

[BlondiesxD]

Hilary Duff better than Ashley Tisdale! Hilary sing in original version!

[vh0590]

Ashley Tisdale's version is WAY better...

[filipmuratagik]

Nobody can sing it better than George Michael !

[Dodo14O6]

no, ashley is the best.

[TheKinected]

GLEE

[gisellesph210]

taylor swift sings best

[richieinca]

@gisellesph210 - No, George Micheal sings it best, after all, it IS his song.

[sargun101]

hilary is better than ashley tisdale

no favoritism....like both equally

[Cukiedome]

Hillary sounds kind of funny when she goes high.

[patryk2193]

Ashley better.

[gengy100]

LOVE HILARY DUFF

[Niahlong]

ashley  !!!

[TheKcsmommy]

hONESTLY TO TELL YOU THE TRUTH SRRY HILLARY BUT ASHLEY SINGS IT BETTER

[TheGjkcity]

hilary is the best

[91nitran]

i like hillary duff more than miley or ashley, because she doesn't have scandla. On the other hand, miley is just 17 but many scandals, many boy friends, sex scandal, i hate her so much

[n1wrestlingfan]

hilary sings better than ashley tisdale

[zanotmom]

hilary is better but in the begining ashley and hilary sound sorta the same:/

[CanalBraveNewGirl]

Hilary's voice is better. Ashley sings with a shrieking voice u.u

Merry Christmas =)

[MileyRayFansz]

as much as i looooooooove hilary, like aloott! but i'll always say that ashley did it better. she completely pwns > i do like hil's version. but idk, i guess i like the more "dancy" sound ashley has to hers! xDD

[FRANKMANNACO700]

WISH I HAD HER TOES IN MY MOUTH

[Tswizzleful]

oh my goodness look at her roots!!! :S

[Hellokittycool1]

i have been jealous of her hair lol

[potter01smiley4eva]

hilary duff sings it better

[ashlee4048]

COOOOOOOOOOOOL SONG

[BeauLagrou]

This better :)

[msvikki100]

I like bothe but hilary is better

[Raikoma]

i like the echo special ashley does

and the whispered merry christmas hilary uses

[funnygirl825]

she is better = ) she has an awsome voice

[78dma]

I like all

[12344happydays]

This is the order I think sings it best Taylor Swift,Cascada(do not know how to spell it),Ashley Tisdale and then Hilary Duff

[hilaby]

Me encanta esta versión ... incluso ayer mismo la escuche en un centro comercial =P

[jenkha]

I like this version better :]

[applejak96]

Hilarys way better than Ashley!!! I love Hilary with ally heart

[tinayang95]

i think both are nice! ^^

[gengy100]

belissima voce hilary sei bellissimaaaa

[HamsterClawz]

idk  i love both XD

[xxlauracurtisxx]

i like ashleys hilarys and cascada coz lyk its only a christmas song.. eash!

[dn2021]

Ashley Tisdale is much better

[chels879]

hilary is much better

[CarrieUFan10]

Both!

[nadiaizdashii]

Hillary can sing; just not in this song. But i do like the song =] but ashley is Way better for this song.

[sweetpriam]

cascada is wayyyyyyyyyyy better and ashely tisdale

[avrilfn]

I am not 9 I'm 12

GOD!

iLHER she rox my world i know but her voice without being fixed is still beautiful in this world

[iDUSTlN]

hilary better

[JaYKaNdii]

help send me to the hospital she sings terrible :P

[avadakedavra62442]

This song is so godawful, I'm at a loss for words right now.

Hilary Duff cannot sing.

[KeswickCamp08]

then you shouldnt watch it

[laurenprouductionz]

ashley is better

[Domino57Blues]

hilary is totally better

[xSpecialgirlx]

Nice song xx

[1Mudkip88]

Hilary is a better singer but Ashely is a better actress in my opinion Asheley's version is catchier but Hilary sings better.

[joeajonaslover4ever]

Hillary is sooooooo much better at singing than Ashley!!!!

[avrilfn]

IlY hilary u r my idol forever

and hilary is the best singer in THE WHOLE WIDE WORLD

BECUZ SHE BETTAH THAN ANY1 ELSE!!!!!!!!!

XOXOXO

Haley

[thechestnutpony]

it would have to depend on what you mean by better. if you mean style, it's Ashley Tisdale. But mizz Tisdale can't sing at all and the record company just mixed her voice, so on singing talent, you'd have to go with

Hilary Duff.

[vikicafilka]

Merry Christmas..

[DemilovatoRocks4]

Ashley Tisdales is better!=)

[doofwahd]

i prefer cascada's version =) this is still good though

[vaishalig1995]

I love Hilary Duff but I like Ashley Tisdale's version much much better!!!

xoxo

vaishalig1995

[Uanaa0]

i prefere ashley's last christmas song.

[jamesbainejr]

Great voice Hilary,I love it. Merry christmas to all and have a very happy New Year 2009.

[15Rosa]

Whaha, it sure does sound so.

[OsirisNeil]

wonderful!!!!!! so much

[XTarzxndHattiX]

Heii..x

Well For A Start I Love Hilary Duff ♥♥♥x

And i really don't no who or how people Could say Miss Tisdale

is better

Love you Hilary

♥♥♥

Idal

Any way Happy Christmas Everyone

and Happy New Year....x

[Miamore016]

Cascada is the best

[Mellyz7]

Wham wrote this like Lol

I (L) all the virsions :D

Wham has to be the best they wrote it Lol xx

[youtinkyourcool]

Dont really like the drums at the start x

[XxtoniilovexX]

this is better than Ashleys

[bLoDyPreasuRe]

5* uR VideoS :D <3

[Liloxox]

Ahsley Sounds all whiney in her version. this is so much better!

[browneyedgirlxox]

this is by far the best version of Last Christmas there is. and im no hilary duff fan either.

[falsedoll]

that's the besz version!!!!!!

HILARY DUFF <3

[jb9217a]

Yeah Hilary sings this song much better than Ashley

[jazzyjoyner]

Okay, Yah. Lol. Wham is better! x

[meesha22]

hell yea way better than ashley

[prettyxKittyx]

I personally like Cascada's version best!♥ But I like Hilary lots!

[jazzyjoyner]

SSOOOO MUCH BETTER THAN ASHLEY!!

[unisinkleburge]

u know whos better??? WHAM! thats who sang it first!

[besties4life186]

BETTER THAN ASHLEY TISDALE!

[jabjabby]

no ashley is better in this song

[BillabongNL]

I love both.. I like the way Ashley sings it better but I like Hilary's overall song better.. like the beat is more laid-back.

But I also love Taylor's version, I just love this song in general haha

Can't wait for Christmas :D

[preppyblonde2929]

hilary is way better like x10

[mkaolsenlover]

i thiink they have there one Style xD xx

[whizzpic]

i think ashley is better! CHRISTMAS IS COMING AND IT'S SNOWING!!!

[hilarypunk]

hilary is the best

[khalifeh101]

this song rocks ur better than ashley tisdale thats coming from the heart!!! xoxoxoxox

[Rebby100]

hmm its not bad, i think thats a bit better

[tzitzidefirma]

i can't wait for christmas:X

[RachelPaws]

this is cool

[LyxTele]

Hilary's version is more better.

[ashleysbigfans]

I like Ashley's a little better, but Hilary's is pretty good..

Hilary seems more staccato and traditional (to me anyway), while Ashley is like mainstream pop.

[bengalicupcake]

I love the song. I love all the versions. But my fave is the one by cascada.

[sexyspud00]

i think hikary and ashley tisdale are the same i thing they are both good

[supercoolhannah08]

i love this song i love everybodys version they are all soo cool

[Crazyteen04]

Geez people! If you guys don't like this version then just go listen somebody Else's O_o;

Thanks for uploading this video btw. =]

[JazzMan426]

i kinda like ashley tisdale more and i do like ashleys version better but its not cuz i like her more i just think hilary didnt do a very good job

[skinnyaznkid]

The Ashley Tisdale version is wayyy better!

[CaliGirlz3862]

she sucks ass man no offence though i think ashley tisdale and taylor swift's verision is way better

[hilarypunk]

HILARY IS BETTER

[desertseatingoceans]

I heard Hilary's version first and was in love with the song. However Ashley Tisdale's version is a lot better in my opinion only because in parts of the song Hilary's voice just doesn't sound right in various areas of the song. She over pronounces some of the words like the word heart, she emphasis the T. Not only that but Hilary's version is upbeat while Ashley's gives a different vibe and doesnt have any unnecessary acoustics which is distracting and takes away from the song.

[MileyRayFansz]

I LOVE HILARY! But idk why, out of Taylor,

Hil, & Ashley... Ashley is my favorite! [ :

HAPPY 21ST BIRTHDAY TO MISS HILARY ERHARD DUFF!!!!!!!!!!

[LaLunaDarkSpirit]

Ashley Tisdales version is better

[Striptizeta5]

I love this song. my favorite christmas song.

[poseidonrocks123]

i love this version and casada's version :)

(whatever you spell it, lol)

:]

[babygurll7]

she sux compared to ashley and the cheetah girls in this song.

[EmmaRoberts17]

i don't think so.

[babygurll7]

well honestly, i don't care what you think

[Clemsona]

I love this song.

this is one of favorite songs by Hilary.

[Nazzygirl008]

I love this song

[bubblyfrostingrocks]

ok i guess shes not that bad i like ashly better though and truely i think she is not as good as when she was younger srry

[berryberrygirl123]

i really like both of them, but im going to have to say Ashley, no Hillary, well, i dont know...THE BOTH ROCK!

[Domino57Blues]

hilary is better

[iMaplestoryx33]

Ashley say is sadder and HIlary like just uh A lil techno and a lil sad ish

[BackToLila]

hilary hat eien tolle stimme,aber das lied ist zu abgehackt..echt schade ich glaube sie hätte es echt geil gesungen,wenn es nicht so angehackt und so doofe musik dazu wäre..^^

[pianoplayer17]

Ashely is wayyy better!!!!

[xoxYazzii3xox]

Deffoo Hilary... Ashley is good at he said she said x

[LUVashley22]

I like Ashleys better.

[Hockey1787Hockey1787]

I love taylor and hillary but just for this song hilary sings it best but just one question why are we all lisening to christmas music when its not christmas lol rofl:)

[ROXie1793]

ROFLOL

I AGREE

I just asked myself that question. XD

[coolsasypunk]

hilary sings it way better than ashley,taylor and carrie,although i think that hilary ans cascada both can really sing this song.

[bex787]

WAY better than ashley

[maako6]

Excelent song, excelent artist... Everybody is excelent

[NatuZzZzZ]

BEAUTIFUL SONG!!! <3

I lOve Hilary Duff!

Bellissima e bravissima!

[timtaylorfaith]

taylors is sooo much better

[JonasLuvXoX5]

I like

Ashleys

Hilarys

Cascada

Then.. Taylor :D

[iDUSTlN]

shes my fav so far

[whywontyouwork777]

I love every version of this song but I think that WHAM does it better then Hilary then Ashley

[xamiiies]

Both. BUT mostly Carrie Underwood :]

5 stars (:!

[iHEARTemo14]

well taylor swifts is the best and ashleys is better

[degrassi44]

WAY better than ashely tisdale

[born2shine448]

ahley does it 100 times better

[halohottie904]

I like this version...also Carrie Underwoods and Ashley Tisdales!

I ♥ this christmas song!

[EQuaka]

I love this song with Hilary Duff.

[TheTragic13]

yes.

[sophie1070]

i love hilary's voice, but ashley's song is more... i dunno, like the rythm. and i love cascada's because it's like dance in christmas, u know?? but still 5 stars and added to favorites.

[JLee1989]

Dont forget about Cascada... I think she sings better than any of them

1. Cascada

2. Ashley Disdale

3. Hilary Duff

4. Carrie Underwood - she can sing, but not exactly the way it was pose to sang...

[iDUSTlN]

i love hilarys the best

[cooliono9]

this is sung by soo many ppl plz reply wich 1 is the best

1}WHAM

2}Hillary Duff

3}George Micheal

4}Taylor Swift

5}The HSM crew

6}Ashley Disdale

7}Carrie Underwood

chek 'em all and reply plz ok

[kam21179]

ive always liked the original and thats wham. u also listed george micheal at number 3, thats the same as wham cause he was their lead singer, they broked apart and george went solo

[MimiiKoala2008xoxo]

Ashley Tisdale^^

[babygurll7]

the cheetah girls sang this song too.

[bravepinay]

love this song

[hellawellproductions]

ashley is so much better and i toatlly agree with hsbforever

[ClawtailNRazor]

Hilary Did ALOT Better then Ashley Tisdale.

[SmaragdRubinSaphir]

Hilary is so much prettier and I love her films, but i think Ashley is a better singer.

[neomillionaire936221]

ashley is better compared to hilary. cascada is better thatn both.

[bluueyboo]

did she make up this song

[JLee1989]

no its by WHAM

british singer

[CaraandSydney]

ASHLEY'S IS WAY BETTER

[NamiAndRoxie4ever]

Nami: My opinion....I think Taylor Swift and Cascada do the best....but Hilary does good too....

[gwenissweet]

i love taylor swift version better than all srry;)

[cutie01277]

i think i like hilary's better. idk why i just think it's more my style.

[hsbforever]

Ashl;ey sung it so much better when I heard ashley I thought it waws the original...was it?Got hilary pronounces her words too strongly in this. She doesn't really give it much of a tune...thank got the music is there!!

[dorith3]

ashley is much better sorry

[GlamGirl125]

ashley did such a better version

[TrishThuyTrangclub]

just as good as WHAM!(origanal)

[sparklingflower]

hey hilary! i luv your hair. you are so good at smiling when taking pictures that i feel so jealous! you are also so beautiful!!!

[mangagal111]

i really loved hilary's "last christmas", but ashley's is a bit better. :)

[NadiaAISS]

to me hilary's voice is nice but i prefer ashley's version

[musicandlyrics22]

hilary's version is better i have to admit...

[itsmegirl92]

i love so much her but i think asley's version of this song is better but i love hilary too and her beatifull voice :)

[JoBroLuvr4LiFe2016]

yeahh she sing wayy better!

[Drakestarz]

you all do noe that ashley tisdale stole this song from her and on the news i saw her shaving her head and i swear shes bald and for the last time this song is stolen from ashley tisdale

[kappy911]

i hate this version i like asley tisdales better she sings way better than hilary duff!

[iDUSTlN]

hilary sings it way better i think,

so yh u go girl ♥

[icegurl563]

I like this version compared to Ashley Tisdale's.

I do like Cascada's version better.

If you have a different opinion,

Don't go bitching please.

[FreakyAmerican0]

*whisper* (Wham is WAY better) hehehe i just had to say that :D i love the hottness's version too