I know this video is a few years old, but very inspiring! Awesome job!!! I'm a huge Rush fan and while I am a guitarist, I can't help but play air drums when I hear this song! It's on my bucket list to learn how to play a few Rush songs on the drums (not that I would be anywhere near as good as you or Neal, but just for kicks). You have a pretty efficient kit layout. That's one thing I've noticed about Neal over the years is that his execution is continually evolving to look so effortless!
Dude, awesome kit! Great playing! One tiny bit of constructive criticism from one drummer to another. At about 2:47, you might wanna go back and listen to what he does there. If I remember correctly, he does what I call tap 5's, or tap 5 stroke rolls, between the small toms and the hi-hat. The tap would be on the right hand on one tom then a 5 stroke roll then a tap on the left hand on another tom, then the rest of the fill. So RllrrLrrllR then the rest of the fill. Great job man! I loved it!!
@drewper73 It's funny should mention this because I have never, until last Friday actually tried to figure out what he was actually doing there. I was preparing to redo this with my new kit, camera, view, sound etc. but I knew that that one little part was not quite right. I welcome your constructive criticism, especially when you don't tell me "dude, you really fucked that one up" and actually give me insight into what is going on. thanks!
Great drumming man. I play along with this on my bass and seeing and hearing you really helps me get a better feel of the interaction with the rhythm section.
I think its cool that you get a different message out of the lyrics, the interpretation is relative to the listener.
People are allowed to have their own personal take on the song but dont go around saying thats what the song is about when it isnt ...just say this is what the song makes me feel thats the beauty of music when you can relate to it in a way that almost doesnt have much to do with the song thats proof that the lyricist is genius in My opinion like to me this song is about Loving then loosing love but it will always be there and reflect in your next loves eyes. youll never forget love.
Great to see someone tackling Presto, Counterparts and RTB. My heaviest Rush-listening/playing years were 'round then, so it's a treat. Keep up the good work.
If that's what you read in, then that's YOUR deep metaphor, because this song was inspired by Neil and his daughter rowing out to watch the sky in the middle of a lake.
@Pauliewanna - that is it. (correct) I have that interview on cassette tape. .Good job on drums Paulie. What brand/style and size is your China type (above your ride) ?
@skatenorthport89 Actually he was in the middle of a lake with his daughter Selena watching a meteor shower, an ostensibly ephemeral occurence like..nevermind!
...interpretations! ...and, even if you improve your own video productions with better equipment, then you will have done more than most! ...any original material on the horizon?
...not to sound ridiculous, but exactly which Music recording software/hardware would allow you to upload to youtube? I'm tired of my sony net sharing cam with a condensor mic and no audio input jacks! ...you really are one of the better drummers, like ready to go pro! I know the famous types forget their humble beginnings, but Rock On! You will find the occasional fan who ate cornflakes his dog pissed in! ...the reason we have security! Your renditions and interpreations are very good, too!
Thanks for posting these videos, man, you're pretty awesome, i pretty much watch one of yours whenever i want to see what is going on after listening to one of the songs. Rock on!
Well, sorry i didn't mean that! It just wasn' t good time to reply anything to anyone in that feeling. It was not a good thing to say shit things to someone who's a pretty good drummer :)
Why do people have such a hard time speaking English on youtube? Your comments are uncalled for. FYI no Rush song is "easy" to play. Some songs, like this one, are easier to approximate, but it still takes some serious dedication and skill to play each fill exactly as it appear on the album. When you do this you realize exactly how much thought Neil puts into each drum part in a song.
Keep up the excellent work Paulie, you're an inspiration to many of us.
Very good job polie, excelent drumming, very good timing and a very nice drum kit, I strongly believe that if you just added some emotion and if you pounded harder you could achieve the closest thing on earth to Neil's performances, because that's the only way to play Rush baby ! With emotion, strength and deep feeling, congratulations and keep up the Rush spirit !
The last two "Rush" shows i went to Neil looked totally void of any emotion...He looked like a robot,never smiled once..it was kind of a turn off to me,but still an awesome show!
i'm not a drummer (played guitar in a Rush cover band) but Peart has always had some wicked ride cymbal work and you nail it. the little 'triplets' on the ride during the chorus (sun dogs fire on the horizon...) is cool. i never really noticed it before til i saw you do it. seems like that would be hard but it sounds cool.
Paulie you TOTALLY kick ass brother! I haven't watched a single one of your videos that wasn't right on the money! How about another great tune from the Presto album, how about some Anagram (For Mongo)?
If you people rip on him you need to go back and start taking lessons all over again becuase you just have no idea hoe good this man is so if you say bad things go back to a teacher becuase he is tops on my list!
MrDumbass: Please stop Your typing and go away ! You're a complete MORON. For what You said, it's plain to see You're not a drummer or have even drummed before.
Hey Sammie/Handi, I appreciate you guys sticking up for me, but don't worry about it. I've already explained to Mr. Depp that I'm not trying to do an 'imitation' of Neil Peart, just playing the songs. Comments such as his don't bother ME, so don't let them bother you. Just sit back, click and enjoy.
Are you kidding? He's playing these songs perfectly. Of course he's not going to have Neil's feel and especially not his BODY LANGUAGE (you've got to be kidding on that one). He's NOT NEIL.
I was under the impression that I would find no other outlet from which to get my Rush fix after seeing them in concert. I am only 17 of coarse but that doesn't mean that Rush can't be my favorite band. The point is that you are an excellent Neil Peart cover drummer and I hope you keep it up for years to come. I feel that Rush should never stop having its music played and you do it the justice it deserves.
Yes, you are correct, but with my current sound recording setup, sloshy hi-hats really drown everything out. I did have them half-open, but I think the gate on the compressor silenced that a bit. Thanks for your input.
Very good, even though Neil plays ten times harder than that! Come on man this is rock music, give it some pizzazz!
SciMasterGeneral 5 months ago in playlist Good stuff
@pickmylocks Vital Signs is posted... I think in this old view AND in the new over head HD view... search for "vital signs drumming rush"
Pauliewanna 6 months ago
Top notch.
Alumirun 6 months ago
Sir, that was most outstanding. I really like that track. well done!
rothman24 10 months ago
I know this video is a few years old, but very inspiring! Awesome job!!! I'm a huge Rush fan and while I am a guitarist, I can't help but play air drums when I hear this song! It's on my bucket list to learn how to play a few Rush songs on the drums (not that I would be anywhere near as good as you or Neal, but just for kicks). You have a pretty efficient kit layout. That's one thing I've noticed about Neal over the years is that his execution is continually evolving to look so effortless!
tgorycki 10 months ago
Very educational.Thank you.
Capcoor 1 year ago
Dude, awesome kit! Great playing! One tiny bit of constructive criticism from one drummer to another. At about 2:47, you might wanna go back and listen to what he does there. If I remember correctly, he does what I call tap 5's, or tap 5 stroke rolls, between the small toms and the hi-hat. The tap would be on the right hand on one tom then a 5 stroke roll then a tap on the left hand on another tom, then the rest of the fill. So RllrrLrrllR then the rest of the fill. Great job man! I loved it!!
drewper73 1 year ago
@drewper73 It's funny should mention this because I have never, until last Friday actually tried to figure out what he was actually doing there. I was preparing to redo this with my new kit, camera, view, sound etc. but I knew that that one little part was not quite right. I welcome your constructive criticism, especially when you don't tell me "dude, you really fucked that one up" and actually give me insight into what is going on. thanks!
Pauliewanna 1 year ago
you are just like Neal pert
98pinball 1 year ago
Comment removed
98pinball 1 year ago
Great drumming man. I play along with this on my bass and seeing and hearing you really helps me get a better feel of the interaction with the rhythm section.
I think its cool that you get a different message out of the lyrics, the interpretation is relative to the listener.
RallyCat909 1 year ago
Bravo - well done!
mtlhed1000 1 year ago
Comment removed
urallmuckers 1 year ago
Hey man what symbols do you use?
Elliotcapper 1 year ago
soooo nice, brother...thanks.
shavepate 1 year ago
Love the playing! btw if you live in alabama we need to start a band! heh:)
therealvaliantthor 1 year ago
People are allowed to have their own personal take on the song but dont go around saying thats what the song is about when it isnt ...just say this is what the song makes me feel thats the beauty of music when you can relate to it in a way that almost doesnt have much to do with the song thats proof that the lyricist is genius in My opinion like to me this song is about Loving then loosing love but it will always be there and reflect in your next loves eyes. youll never forget love.
HeartOfMetalx11 1 year ago
ohh i love this song, one of my favorite, thanks. great job dude!
saludos desde Mexico
roldanharo 1 year ago
This song is an excellent example of how timekeeping can accent such an energetic groove.
ObltKG4 1 year ago
you play very good
from panama, panama
rolando0572 1 year ago
That's awesome!! Rush FTW!!!
eggnoglugia 1 year ago
que grandeeeeeeeeeeee gordoo maestroooooooooooo
WOODDYelcomisario 1 year ago
Great to see someone tackling Presto, Counterparts and RTB. My heaviest Rush-listening/playing years were 'round then, so it's a treat. Keep up the good work.
bigasssuperstar 1 year ago
Man, those small ride toms make "the" sound don't they...I have to admit, I would hate to move your kit. LOL
5150printer 1 year ago
nice ;-)
fogliolinasullacqua 1 year ago
Good work, Presto is SUCH a great album.
natural2112science 1 year ago 2
Once again, excellent performance!
A169KL 1 year ago
A deep metaphor about sex! My favorite Rush song ever! Listen to guitar bridge: a baby crying.
skatenorthport89 2 years ago
If that's what you read in, then that's YOUR deep metaphor, because this song was inspired by Neil and his daughter rowing out to watch the sky in the middle of a lake.
Pauliewanna 2 years ago 5
@Pauliewanna - that is it. (correct) I have that interview on cassette tape. .Good job on drums Paulie. What brand/style and size is your China type (above your ride) ?
GentlemenPreferHanes 1 year ago
@skatenorthport89 Actually he was in the middle of a lake with his daughter Selena watching a meteor shower, an ostensibly ephemeral occurence like..nevermind!
BTW great drumming, your awesome
skatenorthport89 1 year ago 4
You know... I usually HATE watching covers on Youtube... but, I REALLY enjoyed this. Great job!
gemari77 2 years ago
3:52 onward is quite a awesome beat,Good job.
NismoDJ20 2 years ago
Very smooth and natural as always. You are awesome.
Pokkelipuu 2 years ago
PERFECTION as always Paulie!!!!
menom7 2 years ago
how much did your china cost?
howycwap 2 years ago
PRESTO is a Rush's album not enough famous. :( Great song from great album
DavidBaatzsch 2 years ago 9
Couldn't agree more.
jisa39 2 years ago
The sickest of the sick...
(i.e. slang for very very very awesome in North American English)
dbb6 2 years ago
you make it look easy, dude .... well done
kenfoye 2 years ago
pretty good
rushlover56 2 years ago
This is how Rush would sound with Omar Hakim....Good stuff.
U3X6785 2 years ago
Must be all that Indian food I eat.
Pauliewanna 2 years ago
What part of Canada are you from?
codematrix 2 years ago
The cool part.
Pauliewanna 2 years ago
Nice lol, Canada rocks, And how long have you been playing the drums?
TJrushfan 2 years ago
Since 1988, but I took 6 years away when i went to University and lived in an apartment when I basically didn't play at all. So, I'd say 15 years.
Pauliewanna 2 years ago
Oh, Nice you're a very talented drummer, Seeing you play Rush songs so well is making me want to drum lol.
TJrushfan 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
now "THATS NICE !"
tyedyeguy35 2 years ago
This is really well done...don't underestimate the difficulty of that opening!
rossboss1 2 years ago
...interpretations! ...and, even if you improve your own video productions with better equipment, then you will have done more than most! ...any original material on the horizon?
JohnSmithXIV 2 years ago
...not to sound ridiculous, but exactly which Music recording software/hardware would allow you to upload to youtube? I'm tired of my sony net sharing cam with a condensor mic and no audio input jacks! ...you really are one of the better drummers, like ready to go pro! I know the famous types forget their humble beginnings, but Rock On! You will find the occasional fan who ate cornflakes his dog pissed in! ...the reason we have security! Your renditions and interpreations are very good, too!
JohnSmithXIV 2 years ago
you definetly got the feel for this :) keep on going
lordofemeralds 2 years ago
great!!!
GabrielBittio 2 years ago
Presto is a vastly underrated album, y'know? Anyway, this is an old video, but still, great one, Paulie.
rabidbiscuit 2 years ago 8
Thanks for posting these videos, man, you're pretty awesome, i pretty much watch one of yours whenever i want to see what is going on after listening to one of the songs. Rock on!
darkanz 2 years ago
GREAT JOB, I love Rush and you did well. I have seen most of your other ones as well, keep it up!
Blaineisawarlock 2 years ago
Well, sorry i didn't mean that! It just wasn' t good time to reply anything to anyone in that feeling. It was not a good thing to say shit things to someone who's a pretty good drummer :)
So, all apologies. and you did it well.
Jusba90 2 years ago
Why do people have such a hard time speaking English on youtube? Your comments are uncalled for. FYI no Rush song is "easy" to play. Some songs, like this one, are easier to approximate, but it still takes some serious dedication and skill to play each fill exactly as it appear on the album. When you do this you realize exactly how much thought Neil puts into each drum part in a song.
Keep up the excellent work Paulie, you're an inspiration to many of us.
57precision 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wWHO fuckin cares about your fucking shit drumming!!! There is too much that Rush cover shit !!!!!!!!! There is only one RUSH and one ME !!!
PS. Try to play somethin' little harder!
Jusba90 2 years ago
a) how did you happen to get to my video?
b) why did you watch it?
c) who pissed in your cornflakes?
d) where are your videos of you playing something harder?
Pauliewanna 2 years ago
THAT'S NICE!!!!!
cjt1881 2 years ago
Very good job polie, excelent drumming, very good timing and a very nice drum kit, I strongly believe that if you just added some emotion and if you pounded harder you could achieve the closest thing on earth to Neil's performances, because that's the only way to play Rush baby ! With emotion, strength and deep feeling, congratulations and keep up the Rush spirit !
trevizons 2 years ago
The last two "Rush" shows i went to Neil looked totally void of any emotion...He looked like a robot,never smiled once..it was kind of a turn off to me,but still an awesome show!
05R6R 2 years ago
dude you rock xD
btw my fav rush song =)
PedRoMaGGoT 3 years ago
always loved that mini-cymbal at the start.....
tiradeoftruth 3 years ago 2
nice job man!
MeyioLI 3 years ago
Is there the original studio version anywhere on here?
supercool126 3 years ago
Keep on Rock-n Dude ! Dont forget the family tough ! Love the tune for sure !
Gus
gus4CHRIST 3 years ago
Spot on! You wouldn't happen to be looking for a gig in the Houston area, eh?
arson2112 3 years ago
i'm not a drummer (played guitar in a Rush cover band) but Peart has always had some wicked ride cymbal work and you nail it. the little 'triplets' on the ride during the chorus (sun dogs fire on the horizon...) is cool. i never really noticed it before til i saw you do it. seems like that would be hard but it sounds cool.
earthshine2k 3 years ago
I know his drumming well. I'm on in 45 seconds. Quite DEAD ON.
jimmynorton10 3 years ago
Paulie you TOTALLY kick ass brother! I haven't watched a single one of your videos that wasn't right on the money! How about another great tune from the Presto album, how about some Anagram (For Mongo)?
jugzilla267 3 years ago
Wow! I'd love to jam with you (guitar player). Thanks for posting; I love this song as well as your skill and passion!
donostia13 3 years ago
You're great man. Greetings from Sweden.
setagayafajitas 3 years ago
dude your AMAZING!!!! RUSH!!!!
airsofter2222 3 years ago
If you people rip on him you need to go back and start taking lessons all over again becuase you just have no idea hoe good this man is so if you say bad things go back to a teacher becuase he is tops on my list!
langer1972 3 years ago
FANTASTIC!
caribbeansun 3 years ago
Dude you are an amazing drummer
KDM512 3 years ago
I never understood why Rush haven't played this tune live.....Presto is my favorite album.
Mowac 3 years ago
Dude, awesome job. IMO the most underrated song in their later catalog. There, I said it!
Good to see this posted, I was impressed :)
AeroZach1029 3 years ago
Pretty much nailed it bro! Great job!
vinnykster 3 years ago
Good job, in the last month this song has been in mind every day... a like a lot because the meaning of lyrics...talking about the power in nature.
and also the drum of the song is fantastic... great job
gguinez 3 years ago
MrDumbass: Please stop Your typing and go away ! You're a complete MORON. For what You said, it's plain to see You're not a drummer or have even drummed before.
See Ya- but hopefully not!
SammieDeLuce 3 years ago
Hey Sammie/Handi, I appreciate you guys sticking up for me, but don't worry about it. I've already explained to Mr. Depp that I'm not trying to do an 'imitation' of Neil Peart, just playing the songs. Comments such as his don't bother ME, so don't let them bother you. Just sit back, click and enjoy.
Pauliewanna 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You need to watch Neil Peart more. Totally DON'T have his body language or feel.. but very good effort.
MrDeppness 3 years ago
Are you kidding? He's playing these songs perfectly. Of course he's not going to have Neil's feel and especially not his BODY LANGUAGE (you've got to be kidding on that one). He's NOT NEIL.
handidrummed 3 years ago 3
I was under the impression that I would find no other outlet from which to get my Rush fix after seeing them in concert. I am only 17 of coarse but that doesn't mean that Rush can't be my favorite band. The point is that you are an excellent Neil Peart cover drummer and I hope you keep it up for years to come. I feel that Rush should never stop having its music played and you do it the justice it deserves.
Thanks for that.
ReonOe 4 years ago
Wow, even for Neil, thats a busy song... kudos as always
Rendclaw 4 years ago
Cool! But it would be better with the open hihats!
Best Regards!
TheHitman1990 4 years ago
Yes, you are correct, but with my current sound recording setup, sloshy hi-hats really drown everything out. I did have them half-open, but I think the gate on the compressor silenced that a bit. Thanks for your input.
Pauliewanna 4 years ago
Oh... Well, I hope you keep uploading videos!
Thanks for answering!
Best Regards!
TheHitman1990 4 years ago