Added: 4 years ago
From: fw22901
Views: 1,103,841
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (940)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why would anyone vote a thumbs down for something as perfectly beautiful as this?!

  • This just blew me away Welch has a truley wonderful voice and the harmonies were so well blended. I dont know why each one of these perfomers arent signed to lost highway records and living life at the top of the ladder. Still cant put them above the Band the songs the same but the music is apples and oranges. loved it.

  • Damn. That was so...very...very...good.

  • Perfect.

  • What more can you say? At least as good as the original,maybe even better!

  • I need more Will Watson.

  • 3rd Verse, He could be Rick Danko's son! Love this

  • @scarlton23 boy are you right. It sounds just like him.

  • Love the way she looks at Dave at around 1:34. Seriously, I love to sing but I will never have what this woman has, do what this woman does. She's got the mountains in her voice. White mountain woman blues with soul to spare. Truly my soul's sister.

  • Key of F

  • @konrrade Nope, B Flat.

  • Take a load off, Annie...

  • @konrrade take a load off Fannie :)

  • Old Crow rocks

  • I got to see these guys together in Chico a few years ago and I still think it might be the best concert ever.

    Loved the whole thing...this song was soooo great that night.

  • gillian welch you give me such a boner

  • An amazing blend of musical and vocal harmonies.

  • Shucky darn I love OCMS!

  • the 27 ppl comment was perfect

  • kenny garth and the rest of them wish they were this good ,this has soul something missing in music today just my feeling not meant to offend

  • This version is lacking something. I think a big part of the original was the drum beat that drove the song. Deep and powerful beat.

  • Good shit! I gotta catch the Medicine show.

  • They should have called themselves W.S. Walcott Medicine Show

  • If you don't like it... don't watch it... I think it's one of the best versions of this song since The Band... and it's on my favorites list!

  • I saw Old Crow, Gillian and David perform this at Hardly, Strictly Bluegrass Festival in 2009 and it did indeed give me chills...(it's as good as any of the dozen or so times I saw the Band perform it over the years). It's so great to have this video to relive their performance.

  • its just amazing having that many brilliant people on a stage at one time

  • I don't know how many times I came home drunk, down in the dumps, and put this one on. This is the best video on youtube.

  • Dat's goood!

  • 3 am chills, so beautiful, now i can sleep in peace.

  • 33 people have absolutely no taste in music and should be band from listening to it for t the rest of their lives.

  • man, this so goddamn good :)

  • I have listened to this numerous times and I have listened to the original numerous times I have compared the versions time after time and I am a huge fan of the band. but this version just has more depth and I must say it's better then the original, well done people

  • Sounds Old Timey music of 80 years ago. Gillian has real soul.

  • YES!! it finally has over a million views. its what this music deserves

  • wow that was good

  • NuBlue grass...great to listen to!

  • I never noticed until now how Willie Watson looks like a young Doc Watson.

  • The fiddle solo increases entropy. In a good way.

  • amazing...

  • this truly is about as close to 'perfect' as humans can get

  • I'll never get tired of this version. Just wow.

  • Good old Canadian tune...nice job.

  • this sounds so good!(:

  • <3

    

  • awesome - i wonder why they reversed verse orders 3/4

  • Truly amazing on every level.

  • It does not get any better than a great cover of the best song around. This song is a perfect mix of blues, country, folk, bluegrass, and pop. It is the perfect example of a mixing pot of the American experience.

  • @sartainja pop?? im not sure i hear any wiz khalifa in there..

  • if you think that there is no soul in this music.....then you probably havent been in any neck of woods. I myself am from the foothills of california. "GOLD COUNTRY!" And we love your music.. If you dont like this sound i dont know why you are here?!?

  • Gifted , - but no soul, R.I.P:

  • @Runnershighfive if you think this has no soul, then you clearly hvent listened to modern radio. just go home.

  • @Runnershighfive i agree fully man. as long as you meant to type R.I.P: levon helm and rick danko.

  • @MrSleazymoney rick manuel. not helm. derp.

  • you have to be a true ass hole to dislike this video.

  • They used to be good. And then they got better.

  • To Old Crow Medicine Show: Thank you.

  • What's up with the Old Crow guys? Who is in rehab??

  • I must say, you guys really do this classic justice. Excellent!

    Ron

    ( ;-} >

  • Takes me to a happy place

  • My lord... those harmonies are so perfect they give me chills.

  • @rehtlh They made me cry. It's amazing how happy they are just because of the music and how happy they make me.

  • @Wajlonis The same happiness makes me think of The Last Waltz

  • shoot a load on annie

  • WOW.... these two bands fit like a glove.. definately rates right up with The Band.

    Maybe Levon should get together with this and do some recording or at least

    a midnight ramble.

  • AWESOME cover!

  • Comment removed

  • This takes a load off Terry. It just feels good right down to the floor!

  • The Crow and Gillian are perfect compliments for one another. Love it when great performers don't create music only for radio.

  • A gem !

  • People who insist that everyone likes the same music they do are despicable. At least those who don't like this tried something outside of what they were used to.

  • Holy shit. I can't turn this up loud enough. awesome.

  • Holy shit. I can't turn this up loud enough. awesome.

  • Old Crow Medicine Show is always great, and gillian is herself which is awesome. Cover I think was than the band if I may say:)

  • @Thraxmen dont forget dave rawlings!!

  • wow that moved me what a great version

  • They are singing with their souls, beautiful

  • one of the best songs ever!

  • yep i think this is the best cover! rock on marktrenkele just sweet music ! man are they are into it the musicians - you could see that it was special

  • 27 people couldn't handle the amazingness and passed out on their computer, accidentally hitting the dislike button

  • @jumeau1 Haha I think your right!

  • they can all play and they can all sing- evidence of the possibilities. wow. peace and love

  • 27 people have bad ears....or a lack of good musical talent

  • great cover of a great song by great musicians, nuff said

  • i would love to take gillian to bed,she probally knock a guy right out of his socks in bed!!!!!!

  • the most beautiful song about shootin dope after carmalitta

  • @gregabate This song isn't about shootin dope.... ya dope!

  • @dancingspike if you want ill break down the lyrics but im sure you can research it yourself

  • I love this!!!!

  • Awesome!

  • good good good. all good.

  • try digging up aretha franklin's cover...a lot more life!

  • @canormusic More life? MORE LIFE? You can't anymore life in a song than this. Mellow doesn't means lifeless, they're pouring their hearts and souls in to this.

  • Outstanding vocals and musicianship -- all of them were born singing, probably raising the rafters when they were barely able to walk, would be my guess.

  • oh wow...this is amazing!!

  • my grundle hairs only extend when something amazing happens...after having heard this i could have braided them

  • Ketch Secor could make any instrument sound BA.

  • Must have listened to this version at least once a day since I saw them last September!

  • Gillian is so great!

  • Why have I not heard of this lady before--Great talent and real feeling for the songs

  • It is some measure of social justice, I suppose, that millionaires will never be able to buy the happiness this group of musicians exudes during a brilliant performance.

  • @hugosalI I THINK THAT YOUR COMMENT IS THE MOST SUCCINCT ,I'VE EVER HEARD ON THE SUBJECT,,NICE ONE

  • @hugosalarm  THAT IS THE PERFECT COMMENT.......THANKS FOR SHARING

  • @hugosalarm Well put !

  • @hugosalarm -->> Fuckin' A, bro.

  • @hugosalarm

    Which is why I sold my guitars at age forty to prepare for my retirement.

  • @kouzgondeh keep one.... :)

  • Does anyone know where I can get an mp3 version of this? It's not on any album as far as I can see?

  • @flikmuth88 If you find out, please share it with the rest of us... Id kill to listen to this away from youtube... ;)

  • @chefboy077 google youtube to mp3 converters. That's what I did. Listen to this song quite often on my ipod...love it.

  • What a great cover-Gillian is great on this. Great post. There is no way anyone can dislike this version if they like the original. No auto tune or manufactured sounds just strings from wooden instruments and some great voices. Would love to see Alison Krauss do this song-anything she sings is like a thing of beauty. I have to listen to Gillian a little more a I really like her sound.

  • Not to take away from the performance because it was a great cover - but did Ketch and Willie Watson mix up the order of their verses?

  • This is the BEST cover I have ever heard of this song. Don't know if I prefer this or the original by The Band.... so much the same and so different. Class! Thanks for posting!

  • this is a hot stone jam. awesome.

  • how can you not like this? Perhaps you didn't like the original either...

  • excellent rendition of an excellent song

  • And the guitar player even makes rick danko faces as he sings the chester verse! love it!

  • its not a guirar, google it

  • what kind of guitar is David playing?????

  • @jlbsr1959 it's a 1935 Epiphone Olympic...if you 'wiki' him it talks about his rig. he sure does work it.

  • beatifull

    

  • didn't write it

  • Comment removed

  • wow.

  • love this song pure music sung from the heart

  • Gillians smile at 1:23 melted my heart.. she is the authentic musician

  • no one can do it like the dead

  • @bpolitepass2urright lol, true. This is wonderful but the dead made everything they ever did, their own.

  • @earthlyradiodotcom nicely said : ] take care

  • @earthlyradiodotcom Even if it belonged to The Band ?

  • Such happy good spirits. Love it.

  • Absolutely Amazing! As a huge fan of both Gillian & David as well as OCMS it only makes sense that they'd make incredible music together.

  • Gilliam Welch is one sexy lady and what a voice!

  • gillian welch makes a stinky face when she sings

  • Beautiful music, lovely happy people, doing what they love, the warmth and honesty of this music just oozes like sweet sweet honey off of warm toast between the fingers of a laughing child...

  • god damn i love OCMS

  • I turn the corner and yet another wonderful surprise. That was so worthy. Sometimes being human has it's perks.

  • Yeah, Joy, I love her.

  • Its always cool (to me) when I see musicians who look like they are having a good time :)

  • It doesn't get any better than that!!!!!!!!!

  • I really, really like this. Her smile makes it all the more precious. The joy of performance is amazing and I have felt it. Spiritual joy and much more.

  • I really, really like this. Her smile makes it all the more precious.

  • The fiddle solo is how you should love and make love ...

  • @jasonspearssc ketch is the f'n man! his singing outshined the others as well. i catch ocms every time they come to town...awesome!

  • @bkershaccount shit really? I love watson's voice. It's so unique, but with roots to it.

  • @tycer18 i love willie too, but this wasn't his best performance in my opinion. ketch owned that shit. but ya, i love willie too!

  • @bkershaccount yeah, the whole frickin' song kicks ass

  • More ! Oh my god, I want more, pleaaaaaaase !!!

    That's simply brilliant !

  • I wish this was available on itunes or something!!! so amazing!!!

  • fresh as the morning dew

  • I'm a peacefull man. But I really want to kill anyone who dislikes this video. This was one of the best covers I've ever heard even though it wasn't too 'original' as far as unique covers go. But it was SO GREAT. Seriously. If you downvoted this you're no better than a panda who won't screw to save it's species.

  • @marktrenkle why put the pandas under the buss mate? they're so cute :D

  • @marktrenkle I couldn't have said it any better! This is a fantastic cover

  • @marktrenkle your so right mark they must be a panda how can anyone dislike such a beautiful piece of musicianship is beyond me all i can think is overdosed on brittney spears or some shite 

  • @marktrenkle check out Stoney larues Cover its so awesome!!!

  • @marktrenkle I'm a peaceful man, but I want to kill people who want to kill people for stupid reasons like not liking a song. .......unless the singer's from American Idol

  • @marktrenkle Nice. :)

  • @marktrenkle great use of mixed metaphor. Im sure Kung FU panda would step up if need be, though he did seem a bit gay.

  • @marktrenkle dumb comment on way too many levels to mention.

  • @marktrenkle How did you find 43 people as stupid as your comment makes you sound?

    If you like the version, how about; That's nice eh. Or is this your best shot at expressing yourself?

  • @Sointula2 I dunno what their excuse was, but I was pretty sloshed. Plus, it's a joke not meant to be taken seriously.

  • @marktrenkle lol, remind me to never criticize anything you like. but yeah, the video is pretty awesome.

  • @marktrenkle: Some people just don't get the foundation of democracy. Here you go: I disagree with you but I'll fight for your right to say so (Voltaire)

  • @marktrenkle this truely is the greatest rendition!!

  • @marktrenkle - that sir, is a fundamentally correct statement.

  • Just beautiful...

  • wow what an awesome tune my hairs have just joined your hairs L:)

  • hair just stood on end... ohhhhhh baby this is awesome

  • Anyone else think Ketch seems completely hammered?

  • Comment removed

  • Anyone know how to get a copy of this show on CD or DVD its awesome!!!!!