He......SLAUGHTERED this song. "Think Of Me" is NOT meant to be made into a pop song, And it's also a piece meant for a woman to sing. He just completely DESTROYED one of the most beautiful pieces from the show by turning it into a pop song.
I don't think he did THAT badly, I mean he's a good singer and he did his best. However, I do agree with you that it shouldn't have been made into a pop song. It's not a good song for American Idol. I'm not sure why I don't like this version, it just makes me shudder when I hear it. Maybe it's because I'm such and original Phantom fan.
There are lots of Webber songs that David could have sung. I was actually hoping for "Close Every Door" or "Any Dream Will Do" from "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat." Instead, he took a whale of a chance here. Consider the lyrics: Why can't it be rearranged into a pop ballad? A young man has just been dumped by his girlfriend. "When you find that once again you long to take your heart back and be free." ALW was right: "We should all be saying 'Bravo!'" Gutsy and it worked -- for me.
So this is my favorite song from POTO and i CANNOT listen to this version of it! David is ok but for me this is just one of those songs you do not mess with and you most certainly don't turn it into a pop number. But that's just my opinion.
I find it interesting on these david links that the Archuleta fans seem to have achieved greater lengths academically. On Cook's site, the fan's can't even speak proper English. GO ARCHULETA FANS!
That speaks volumes as to this boy's real appeal and value. It takes life experience( and a college education doesn't hurt) to recognize that which is so far superior to the norm, as to be compelling. That is to say, his presence and performance are even getting us more mature folks to sit up and take notice. I take much solace in the fact that many, for whom this boy is a favorite, don't use or even know about youtube. His fans run the spectrum.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
he is killing the song cant you see on yahoo blog its really true i dont like the way he sing it and i dont like him toooooo his nose is big when he sing.......lol
You need to go back to school RICAONFIRE and learn your grammar and spelling. Then go and get some music education and then you will have the intelligence to comment.
Only the Davids showed the ability to think beyond the terror Webber's songbook clearly induced. Archuleta showed off his musical sense, finding an unexpected groove in one of Webber's semi-classical arias, "Think of Me." Gliding into that downy-soft upper register, he made the song a secret mash-up with Babyface's "The Loneliness." Archie may be the show's youngest prime competitor, but that's not stopping him from being the most sophisticated.
Even though the show is called "The Phantom of the Opera" it's still musical theater. The song is not in an operatic style, so I do not believe his interpretation was that far off considering the genre it comes from. It's not like he was trying to sing "Nessun Dorma" in a pop style. That would be a true tragedy. i.e Aretha Franklin. haha! :)
Well, I'm currently getting my Masters in Opera Performance. I can say with confidence, that while to you it may sound like an opera song...it isn't. I'm so glad you are able to enjoy it and you are entitled to your opinion about the arrangement.
It is NOT OPERA. It's Broadway...it's from a Broadway show. I am also getting a degree in opera, and I can guarantee you that Broadway and opera are completely different styles of music.
However, with that being said, I agree that he slaughtered a beautiful song by turning it into pop...his voice is good, but this song is soo ruined when sung this way. :-/
Keep the eyes open, and stop with those ugly gaspy breaths between notes. It ruins every song he sings. Just hold the freakin' mike back. And change your posture so you don't deliver every song the exact same way.
hahah yeah, being a theatre lover i have definitely heard a guy sing this song. his arrangement though is soo played out, with those high school runs and all that (i think randy called them "stevie" runs. he calls them this because stevie has already done them, as well as countless others). i really wasn't impressed.
no, I agree, I don't get it. My mom LOVES him. I don't see it. And I really don't like what he did to this song! I love the Phantom of the Opera, and he made it into a poppy song!
He is way too over rated, i think he is terrible, he needs to pick it up with some fast songs and hopefully he wont mumble the lyrics like in this performance, Carly and David C are the two most talented, i just like carly more because i think david c is too full of himself
Is it just me, or does Ryan love flustering David? Well, it's just that the whole "You said you were thirsty and needed to pee" bit in the Top 16, the "Choose the group you think is safe" last week and now this? Those little girls were cute, don't get me wrong, but yeah...just a little something.
he has the best voice overall, but too bad, he seems to lack the personality to be the american idol. i hope he improves his stage presence before david cook overtakes him completely. if this andrew weber episode is the only basis for the final two, then its david cook and syesha mercado on the finals.
yeah i agree with paula and randy, the song is known for it's theatrical classic beat what david did is made it into a more modern pop ballad song, the song was made for a diva and obviously he's not a diva so he put his own youth and heart to it and he's learning to take a risk for someone as young as him... it's sad that of all the judges simon didn't manage to get, o well our votes are for you david all the way! Godbless and goodluck!
I thought it was VERY creative and original... It showed a new side in his ability to arrange a piece a whole new way that hasn't completely come forth till now... I thought he did a great job!
Me neither! I saw the Emmy Rossum version when they released the song spoilers and the whole time I was thinking, "How's little Archuleta gonna work with this?!" But wow...pretty good.
Man, he's so awesome! I absolutely LOVE this performance. Phantom's my all time favourite and he made it work. Beautiful! YOu did a wonderful job, DAvid. Way to go!
ooohhh now poor Simon ... you just didn t get it this time (I m disappointed in you) ! YOU GO DAVID ARCHULETA ... keep on shining ! we love you so much !
I really liked the melody to this song and I thought it suited David's voice really well. I was surprised when Simon said it was weak because it definetly wasn't.
he changed the song wayyyyy to much...its not supposed to be like that at all..
samg12316 8 months ago
did I see Andrew Lloyd Webber in the audience?
angelsunny8 9 months ago
i thought he wouldn't make it work, but how wrong was i?
jagirl966 2 years ago
He......SLAUGHTERED this song. "Think Of Me" is NOT meant to be made into a pop song, And it's also a piece meant for a woman to sing. He just completely DESTROYED one of the most beautiful pieces from the show by turning it into a pop song.
xNightmarexVampsx 2 years ago
@xNightmarexVampsx
I don't think he did THAT badly, I mean he's a good singer and he did his best. However, I do agree with you that it shouldn't have been made into a pop song. It's not a good song for American Idol. I'm not sure why I don't like this version, it just makes me shudder when I hear it. Maybe it's because I'm such and original Phantom fan.
seventhlostgal 2 years ago
There are lots of Webber songs that David could have sung. I was actually hoping for "Close Every Door" or "Any Dream Will Do" from "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat." Instead, he took a whale of a chance here. Consider the lyrics: Why can't it be rearranged into a pop ballad? A young man has just been dumped by his girlfriend. "When you find that once again you long to take your heart back and be free." ALW was right: "We should all be saying 'Bravo!'" Gutsy and it worked -- for me.
wkyken 2 years ago
simone... i have 3 words to say to you
GO TO HELL!!!! =p
10respect 2 years ago
HATE it
takingbacktuesdday 2 years ago
So this is my favorite song from POTO and i CANNOT listen to this version of it! David is ok but for me this is just one of those songs you do not mess with and you most certainly don't turn it into a pop number. But that's just my opinion.
darkblueproductions 2 years ago 2
uh don't throw carrots at me but i so agree with simon :D i usually do
XIDudetteXI 2 years ago
He did great with this song!!! love it.
LOLproductions9 2 years ago
umm what does the language actually come into this when all it matters is how talented the performers are and how people actually LIKE THEM?
arculeta's great but i think it's kinda true that cook's more cut out for the idol image
but hey, the ones who actually had a chance to compete as the final 10 are amazing enough already!
( :
xo
ashleypancakesxx 2 years ago
Awesome
rockinindigo 3 years ago
too cute.He is my little inspirational guy.I love him with every bit iside me.He is my lover
PinkCrushGuitar 3 years ago
Oh David Archuleta, what a cute little poppy boy.
He really has a cute voice, but I love the musical version of this song to much to really enjoy this poppy version. But nice job anyways David.
gillmacd 3 years ago
A real musical soul, bravo - ALW
bumiputri 3 years ago
I find it interesting on these david links that the Archuleta fans seem to have achieved greater lengths academically. On Cook's site, the fan's can't even speak proper English. GO ARCHULETA FANS!
OJfrolic 3 years ago 2
That speaks volumes as to this boy's real appeal and value. It takes life experience( and a college education doesn't hurt) to recognize that which is so far superior to the norm, as to be compelling. That is to say, his presence and performance are even getting us more mature folks to sit up and take notice. I take much solace in the fact that many, for whom this boy is a favorite, don't use or even know about youtube. His fans run the spectrum.
051038 3 years ago 2
Wonderful David! Love your singing!! Simon was 100% wrong! This one is the most memorable song to me! Great job you done!!
Just love it 200%!
duckling1015 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
he is killing the song cant you see on yahoo blog its really true i dont like the way he sing it and i dont like him toooooo his nose is big when he sing.......lol
ricaonfire 3 years ago
You need to go back to school RICAONFIRE and learn your grammar and spelling. Then go and get some music education and then you will have the intelligence to comment.
OJfrolic 3 years ago 3
Show Tracker
Apr 23, 2008
Only the Davids showed the ability to think beyond the terror Webber's songbook clearly induced. Archuleta showed off his musical sense, finding an unexpected groove in one of Webber's semi-classical arias, "Think of Me." Gliding into that downy-soft upper register, he made the song a secret mash-up with Babyface's "The Loneliness." Archie may be the show's youngest prime competitor, but that's not stopping him from being the most sophisticated.
IglooCanada 3 years ago
I think it was wonderfully executed.
The only things I would like to change?
His stumble over the lyrics and his awkward stage movements.
He just needs to work on getting more comfortable, I think. He underestimates himself too much, haha.
SeeingSnitches 3 years ago 2
it was ok...he's done way better
this is a phantom song and phantom is amazing so it's hard to have the courage to change it up like that
and those breaths are really annoying
urmom27 3 years ago
He forget some lyrics!
janagunod 3 years ago
i loved david! Now I hate him! he turned an amazing opera son to a stupid popish preformance
NO WAY!
JoJy54 3 years ago
Even though the show is called "The Phantom of the Opera" it's still musical theater. The song is not in an operatic style, so I do not believe his interpretation was that far off considering the genre it comes from. It's not like he was trying to sing "Nessun Dorma" in a pop style. That would be a true tragedy. i.e Aretha Franklin. haha! :)
EjmGa 3 years ago
It is an opera song, I have heard it like 10 million times. Its not like I'm randomly criticizing David.. i just hated the arrangement.
JoJy54 3 years ago
Well, I'm currently getting my Masters in Opera Performance. I can say with confidence, that while to you it may sound like an opera song...it isn't. I'm so glad you are able to enjoy it and you are entitled to your opinion about the arrangement.
EjmGa 3 years ago 2
It is NOT OPERA. It's Broadway...it's from a Broadway show. I am also getting a degree in opera, and I can guarantee you that Broadway and opera are completely different styles of music.
However, with that being said, I agree that he slaughtered a beautiful song by turning it into pop...his voice is good, but this song is soo ruined when sung this way. :-/
SJmusicjunkie 2 years ago
THANK YOU!! I m so SICK of people saying Phantom ...Is an Opera!
elliosmi 2 years ago
He has GOT to lose the tired jackets! David PLEASE!!
melfre2004 3 years ago
wow my two fav singers paul and david!!!
LuvGun77 3 years ago
Keep the eyes open, and stop with those ugly gaspy breaths between notes. It ruins every song he sings. Just hold the freakin' mike back. And change your posture so you don't deliver every song the exact same way.
gwright199 3 years ago
Is he a Vegetarian??
Is he a Vegetarian??
olovedavidarchuleta 3 years ago
was that paul stanley?
paengspace 3 years ago
David is awesome! Great version!!!
ritoritocreoqueno 3 years ago 2
nothing special
SuptheDup 3 years ago
i can't beleive it, he BSd his way through it and IT ROCKED!!!!! wow. i'm glad he didn't let it show this time!!!
jaella08 3 years ago
i think a good word to use to describe him is generic. he is good, but in my opinion he isn't very original
redatpct 3 years ago
he is so original, have you ever heard a guy sing that song? doubt it.
and he has such an amazing voice! i never heard anyone with a voice like his.. and i have heard a lot of people, incase youre wondering.
Suzy9000 3 years ago
hahah yeah, being a theatre lover i have definitely heard a guy sing this song. his arrangement though is soo played out, with those high school runs and all that (i think randy called them "stevie" runs. he calls them this because stevie has already done them, as well as countless others). i really wasn't impressed.
redatpct 3 years ago
IM SO JEALOUS OF THESE GIRLS!
Jules06482 3 years ago
Is it just me or is he way too over-rated?
gekkexx 3 years ago
It's just you,lol...
051038 3 years ago
no, I agree, I don't get it. My mom LOVES him. I don't see it. And I really don't like what he did to this song! I love the Phantom of the Opera, and he made it into a poppy song!
kelldizzle89 3 years ago
He is way too over rated, i think he is terrible, he needs to pick it up with some fast songs and hopefully he wont mumble the lyrics like in this performance, Carly and David C are the two most talented, i just like carly more because i think david c is too full of himself
scott9465 3 years ago
Is it just me, or does Ryan love flustering David? Well, it's just that the whole "You said you were thirsty and needed to pee" bit in the Top 16, the "Choose the group you think is safe" last week and now this? Those little girls were cute, don't get me wrong, but yeah...just a little something.
beastboy2007 3 years ago
David Archeleta is simply wonderful.he was awesome last night and every night
Joyce3290 3 years ago
he has the best voice overall, but too bad, he seems to lack the personality to be the american idol. i hope he improves his stage presence before david cook overtakes him completely. if this andrew weber episode is the only basis for the final two, then its david cook and syesha mercado on the finals.
islawmagalaw 3 years ago
Utterly boring... He completely failed to communicate the feeling of the song... very limited capacity as a singer... needs to grow up a lot.
mihira66 3 years ago
get a life!
iamtalds 3 years ago
yeah i agree with paula and randy, the song is known for it's theatrical classic beat what david did is made it into a more modern pop ballad song, the song was made for a diva and obviously he's not a diva so he put his own youth and heart to it and he's learning to take a risk for someone as young as him... it's sad that of all the judges simon didn't manage to get, o well our votes are for you david all the way! Godbless and goodluck!
elliu 3 years ago 2
I thought it was VERY creative and original... It showed a new side in his ability to arrange a piece a whole new way that hasn't completely come forth till now... I thought he did a great job!
Keep working hard David! You got this!
amskiurts 3 years ago 5
ahahaha... it's easy to forget to get bored if davod's performing...
greatbreeder 3 years ago
i never thought "think of me" can be sung this way... go david!!!!
chiruruzu 3 years ago 2
Me neither! I saw the Emmy Rossum version when they released the song spoilers and the whole time I was thinking, "How's little Archuleta gonna work with this?!" But wow...pretty good.
beastboy2007 3 years ago
bravo bravo bravo bravo bravo
Alvino76 3 years ago 2
Man, he's so awesome! I absolutely LOVE this performance. Phantom's my all time favourite and he made it work. Beautiful! YOu did a wonderful job, DAvid. Way to go!
ldskidsrock 3 years ago
GO DAVID!
CarolinaGirl316 3 years ago
ooohhh now poor Simon ... you just didn t get it this time (I m disappointed in you) ! YOU GO DAVID ARCHULETA ... keep on shining ! we love you so much !
miuzefreak 3 years ago
very nice rendition!
hey, what was it about when simon put his fingers on his chest and like made a circle on the table?
did he disapproved what randy said?
iamtalds 3 years ago
What a great song choice...GO DAVID ARCHULETA!!!..... what an amazing performance
redhair115 3 years ago
H...O...T... HOTHOTHOT
BRAVO
CelestGal 3 years ago
i agree,this will be a hit
pnas93 3 years ago
Please VOTE for David Archuleta!!!!!!
I love him so much
Pattee08 3 years ago
guys vote for david a
we cant vote here from singapore
Alvino76 3 years ago
yes...everyone, vote please
Iatingirl2005 3 years ago
I really liked the melody to this song and I thought it suited David's voice really well. I was surprised when Simon said it was weak because it definetly wasn't.
Streetweare 3 years ago
I think he did decently. Not my favorite, but I still love you David <3
AnalissaProductions 3 years ago 3
aww. i love him
he is the next american idol
AlwayzbLindy 3 years ago
kewl. thanks for postin this. keep your eyes open david! those girls were so lucky to hug him!
blahblahblah92695 3 years ago 3