You play wonderfully I think. Nevermind the ugly effects, that's sort of a "mothers' thing" I guess.. :-) I like your hands though. They look beutiful and ethereal.
I'll just start learning this piece. Good luck to me.:-)
i agree with you, if you are saying his performance was good, but i'd like to comment, that the trillers were way! too unprecisely played. i am playing this myself right now and it is not that hard to play clearly and more distinguished.
Me encanta este vals, me transmite mucha ternura y es magnifico, por cierto sale en la pelicula "Noches de Sol", con unas maravillosas vistas de San Petersburgo.
Thank you for recording, but could any one re-record? Its really beautiful but the poor sound recording drives me crazy. "Fryderyk Szopen" played it wonderfully but it was added almost three years ago and who knows how long before that it was preformed? I can't find a good recording anywhere :(
Does any of you know if there are sheets of this waltz online?? Or does anyone have them on the computer or could scan them for me?? I'd appreciate :)
You played this piece so exquisitely; a waltz that is rather sombre, but nevertheless you reminded us of it being a waltz. However, you should have diminished the pace towards the end because, even though you were playing a waltz, it is recognizable that its end should be rather peaceful and almost unnoticed--a sad memory that vanishes and goes away as if wafted by the air. I wished the acousitcs would have been better so that it sounded more fantastic.
Could you please tell me how difficult this walz is to play? I can play Chopin Walz Op69 n. 2. Is this much more difficult? I love it and I would like to learn it too.
Goos show. Is it the acoustics or the excessive pedalling which is causing the souds from previous bars merge each other? If its the pedalling, I would suggest, pushing the pedal for every bar and also this piece can played a little stacatto.
Heavy abuse? Why would people flame this guy? Fabulous job. Great clarity and I appreciate the dynamics and slight tempo 'phases' here and there, it gives more meaning to the piece IMO.
Erm... Your tempo is not right. It's like slow at the first bar then suddenly very fast And you played the third bar wrongly. The dynaics are not very obviously.
I don't like the pedaling. It sort of makes a dissonant sound. It may be the echo in the room also. It just sounds different than I am used to playing it.
Hola! soy de Argentina, y no conocía este vals en la menor... Me encantó tu interpretación, lo limpio de la técnica y sobretodo el sonido sumamente dulce.
I love it. Slow, with emotion. I also use the pedal in this piece. I think it brings more emotion and softness. (you can watch my video). Bref, Awesome interpretation.
Well, this might come from the room and the bad quality of the camera (sorry for that), but why shouldn't i be supposed to use pedal, if I interprete it this way,
im learning this right now. nice use of the pedals
mikeymee33 1 year ago
One of the better videos I have seen on here, nice presentation
luckyniji 1 year ago
You play wonderfully I think. Nevermind the ugly effects, that's sort of a "mothers' thing" I guess.. :-) I like your hands though. They look beutiful and ethereal.
I'll just start learning this piece. Good luck to me.:-)
katalinkelemen 1 year ago
Nice video!! watch me playing Walz in A major/minor!, search "PianoWhiteAndBlack" the best version every1 ever heard~
PianoWhiteAndBlack 1 year ago
Sounds rather mystical in a way...why not relax and enjoy the talent put before you.
missionfarstar 1 year ago
i agree with you, if you are saying his performance was good, but i'd like to comment, that the trillers were way! too unprecisely played. i am playing this myself right now and it is not that hard to play clearly and more distinguished.
ichigiku 1 year ago
had to play it on solo recital i like the way you played it.
Sh0eMakers 1 year ago
It's amazing..:)
MissLolanthe 2 years ago
I HATE THE ACOUSTICS IN THAT ROOM!!!
anizato 2 years ago
I played this piece, accept I playerd it alot slower; is it wrong to play the piece more slowly, or is it safely open to interpretation?
PianoplayerX007 2 years ago
All music can be interpreted however you want....but Chopin intended it to be played at 113= quarter note as a minimum
MomoIsMyHero 1 year ago
Comment removed
Magda1763 2 years ago
Brilliant performance and nice video!
svetlankasilver 2 years ago
Good playing and nice video!
svetlankasilver 2 years ago
take your foot off the pedal once in a while
fonedork 2 years ago
its the acoustics of the room more than lack of dampening i think. he has mentioned the noise etc
sp9rks 2 years ago
I think it's just the awful acoustics of the room, not his foot on the pedal.
wildflower12 2 years ago
how old is this dude? cause i can play this and im eleven
74project 2 years ago
It's a Post piece but hard to play well. Yes it's easy to play but you need rubato,feeling etc. he does a good job.
tjamassey 2 years ago
I played this for an exam i like this song
MyEinstein1 2 years ago
how long did it take you to learn this?
luvya901 2 years ago
it's easy; i learned it in 2 days
mchorchos 2 years ago
beautiful, play for me :)
zaroc18 2 years ago
I like it! You play so naturally and so sincerely
yueyuanli 2 years ago
wonderful, do you by any chance have the sheets for this peice? :D
lars517 2 years ago
wie ich dieses Stück liebe ^^ Tol!!!!!
mo0o0o0ose 2 years ago
I would like you to play this waltz again under your contempory capabilities!
Pianda 2 years ago
is this op.34 no. 2?
MichaelElvisJustin 2 years ago
op.posth no 19
mchorchos 2 years ago
I have to learn Chopin Waltz in E minor over the summer.
gorillabread 2 years ago
thats beautiful,chopin rocks :) 5/5
bchick1987 2 years ago
nice playing"!!!!!! Beautiful interpretation and what a beautiful and romantic piece
gerald824 2 years ago
i love this song....great job
tomat0es 2 years ago
what the hell happened at 1:37
DogSoop 2 years ago
anything thing in the minor! Good selection.
CordovaLovesGod 2 years ago
Me encanta este vals, me transmite mucha ternura y es magnifico, por cierto sale en la pelicula "Noches de Sol", con unas maravillosas vistas de San Petersburgo.
maganxa 2 years ago
OMG i wanna cry ;_;
rockmusscarcella 2 years ago
successo brilliante. great work my man!
SicSkatez 2 years ago
I love this, you play it very beautifully! I am hoping to play this song for my exam, thank you for the inspiration!
animefangirls13 2 years ago 2
gut gemacht
xyzx124 3 years ago
wow,gut gemacht,ich mag es
xyzx124 3 years ago
You played it very well, but the background-effects... (You know it better... ;-) )
GreyPhoebe 3 years ago
This is pretty.
concerto35 3 years ago
im working on this piece i just need to play it faster
justarandomkid231 3 years ago
acustica della sala troppo fracassona
miliona1re 3 years ago
Whatever he says^^
Dehus 3 years ago 5
@Dehus lol
mees04101993 1 year ago
@Dehus he's saying your room acoustics are shit
itsonlykano87 1 year ago
I love the acoustics in the that room. It's too bad that great acoustics don't discriminate against background noise!
MousikeTechne 3 years ago 2
OOH. im playing this song. it's pretty,
pazuzapxpedxu 3 years ago
im working on this piece too
alexd36place 3 years ago
nice :) I'm working on this song now ^^ started on it since wednesday can only play page one so far ^^
avatar6091 3 years ago 2
Stupenda. Peccato il suono.
Ch1opin 3 years ago 2
how can you listen to a waltz in THAT bad quality.
if i hear chopin,i wanna listen to it.but if i listen to this video,my stomach turns and my ears fall of.
felifeldfrosch 3 years ago
Then maybe don't listen to it?
Sometimes life can be soooooooo easy Oo
Dehus 3 years ago 22
Well, I think you did a beautiful job! Magnifique!
Ellhime 3 years ago
whoa.
BallroomLuvrxoxo 3 years ago
I love playing this waltzer, it's fantastic.......
I love Chopin!
Marylittlemusic 3 years ago
Does your mother mix your videos? You're strange.
karlinx 3 years ago
[Quote] I did this before i went to Australia for 6 months as an exchange student as some kind of gift for my relatives. [/quote]
I played this, left the tape in Germany and my mother mixed it.
Dehus 3 years ago
You're totally not strange dude, this piece is great.
gonya33 3 years ago
You play well too! But in my opinion too fast and not soft.
And in my opinion the part form 1:34 to 1:40 has to be more clear. Don't you think?
How old are you?
sissichopin91 3 years ago
i play this better! chopin wrote the most beautiful pieces for piano!
sissichopin91 3 years ago
Good on you. Proof?
Dehus 3 years ago
Thank you for recording, but could any one re-record? Its really beautiful but the poor sound recording drives me crazy. "Fryderyk Szopen" played it wonderfully but it was added almost three years ago and who knows how long before that it was preformed? I can't find a good recording anywhere :(
mewmewkittygirly 3 years ago
Does any of you know if there are sheets of this waltz online?? Or does anyone have them on the computer or could scan them for me?? I'd appreciate :)
tanssijatar85 3 years ago
its well played but a few mistakes too much for a waltz thats so easy.. thats like the first waltz that everybody learns..
ilwmb 3 years ago
I know, but this recording is 'bout 5years old now^^
Dehus 3 years ago
You played this piece so exquisitely; a waltz that is rather sombre, but nevertheless you reminded us of it being a waltz. However, you should have diminished the pace towards the end because, even though you were playing a waltz, it is recognizable that its end should be rather peaceful and almost unnoticed--a sad memory that vanishes and goes away as if wafted by the air. I wished the acousitcs would have been better so that it sounded more fantastic.
contrerados 3 years ago
not that the comment is bad, but while reading it, it reminded me of blanche from
"a streetcar named desire" just the way it was worded
worstfear 3 years ago
ohhh so sweet...., bravissimo!
sujimsusana 3 years ago
I'm learning to play this song right now, but I never imagined it would go this fast!
VampSlayer17 3 years ago
Nice, im using this to tutor myself.
cause im learning it too ;]
XxForeverLov3xX 3 years ago 2
lovely music. but shame on you for blaming your mom! she probably got you involved in music in the first place!
a mother
pieisbonet 3 years ago 3
he is Fryderyk Szopen
beautiful song Polish Song
tupowinnizblokowac2 3 years ago
Why does it sound like there is a whale blowing its blow-hole in the background?
OorvakanSar 3 years ago
hahah. maybe whoever is near the camera had a stuffy nose?
lschaff15 3 years ago
I need some help, I have to play this song in the paino concert!
shineforce 3 years ago
Which waltz is this?
mewmewkittygirly 3 years ago
It is the waltz in a minor, number 19,Post.
gguo96 3 years ago
Not referring to the technical quality of the recording, it is musically one of the best having been posted on youtube. Excellent Job, bravissimo.
Also a very nice piano:)
OneToGreen 3 years ago 2
what opus & no is this? or Brown Index if it is posthumous??
FlashMaster20000 3 years ago
Realmente precioso
salimalalima 3 years ago
I listen Guns N' Roses and Megadeth but this is the real music ;) I love it :)
vrevolverr 3 years ago 2
It is beautiful! I would like to learn it too.
Where were you playing it on this video?
janusska26 3 years ago 2
so what if its played in a bathroom?! anyway, the best on youtube for this song.
tingting8888 3 years ago
Amazing like just magnificent.
johannasebastiana 3 years ago
i learned it on 4th of piano.
puchusara 3 years ago
What a beautiful interpretation !! Chopin was a genius !
laupiaka 3 years ago 8
haha reverb grand piano
amcal6 3 years ago
could be recorded in a bathroom;p. beautiful anyway... kisses for u... xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
judyrosati 3 years ago
Oh my god, it was recorded in bathroom ?
mixeon 3 years ago 3
does anyone know what grade this would be?
sweetacapella 4 years ago
like a II, it's really easy
dirtydeeds1192 4 years ago
Terrible Acoustics in that room
babyrakes 4 years ago
This piece is in A minor. It is not difficult in anyways, still it's so beautiful!
jeffzp 4 years ago
¡Qué bello!
macloviodetodas 4 years ago
You are very gifted :)
Horseinthefog 4 years ago
i play my left hand like elephant walking on street . = ="
shiisalad 4 years ago 2
Could you please tell me how difficult this walz is to play? I can play Chopin Walz Op69 n. 2. Is this much more difficult? I love it and I would like to learn it too.
AnaMarriia 4 years ago
I've played this piece before, and I think it's relatively easy. However, I don't know the other Waltz you mentioned.
crystalsxyz 4 years ago
it is not that difficult,i am in my second year of piano and i'm learning to play it with my teacher
Mirunaz 4 years ago
you play very beautifully.
i am currntly learning this piece.
it was nice to hear it played by another.
bellaXmonster 4 years ago
SPAM nah jus lisenin to some chopin cos i have to analyse him for my music elective
nice playin
darkreaper91 4 years ago
Noone else has so many beautiful pieces..
kwastormayt 4 years ago
How did you enjoy your time in Australia ? I am from Cairns in North Queensland. Nice playing.
brian777999 4 years ago
Very good, maybe a little less pedal...Thats a nice ebony grand
acorn49 4 years ago
Hi,
Goos show. Is it the acoustics or the excessive pedalling which is causing the souds from previous bars merge each other? If its the pedalling, I would suggest, pushing the pedal for every bar and also this piece can played a little stacatto.
ForMusicVijeya 4 years ago
love this song :)
thatmademegowow 4 years ago
This one is...magnificent -,-
Ahh,can't resist it...
OddPotato 4 years ago
Heavy abuse? Why would people flame this guy? Fabulous job. Great clarity and I appreciate the dynamics and slight tempo 'phases' here and there, it gives more meaning to the piece IMO.
Pegasus444 4 years ago
I just got a chopin waltz book, and I flipped around, this was at the end, and I basically sight read it perfectly. A MINOR :)
trigalg693 4 years ago
That is so pretty! And I get to play it...and i'm much younger than him! (no offense) and remember PRACTICE MAKES PERFECT yeah right
ps: good job :)
wehavegold 4 years ago
Wonderful rendition!
Those trills are haunting and yet sweetly poignant at the same time...
Another reason why I love Chopin!
MusicalConnoisseur 4 years ago
Erm... Your tempo is not right. It's like slow at the first bar then suddenly very fast And you played the third bar wrongly. The dynaics are not very obviously.
MickTay 4 years ago
Thats lovely. A nice rendition.
GreatFezzo 4 years ago
nice well done ^:)^
GoDsIgby 4 years ago
Lovely! I'm trying to play this song without the sheets...
ekleinhaneveld 4 years ago
suppperrrr supperrr suppperrrr......
rapilda07 4 years ago
chopin è semplicemente un pianista degno di lode..
ValinaFromMilan 4 years ago
I hate Kawai pianos.
gorgeousecret 4 years ago
are the trills supposed to be done on the beat or just before it?
B0MBTRACK1 4 years ago
There are not trills, but they are counted before the beat, Just though, like a really fast rolled cord
classical000 4 years ago
that sucks, i always did them right on the beat. Now i have to practice them correctly. Thanks for the info.
B0MBTRACK1 4 years ago
I don't like the pedaling. It sort of makes a dissonant sound. It may be the echo in the room also. It just sounds different than I am used to playing it.
chopinfreak50 4 years ago
Hola! soy de Argentina, y no conocía este vals en la menor... Me encantó tu interpretación, lo limpio de la técnica y sobretodo el sonido sumamente dulce.
Te felicito!!!
MariaMofle 4 years ago
Whatever he said :P
Dehus 4 years ago
what is the opus number?
SimonSpieltKlavier 4 years ago
It's posthumous.
WotGoPlunk 4 years ago
number 19
haplous 4 years ago
thank you... i got it ;)
SimonSpieltKlavier 4 years ago
I love your piano playing!
TessaSunniva 4 years ago
this is truly beautiful - well done! :)
ingenue15 4 years ago
sublime:)
kissesunited7 4 years ago
you played very will
EmmaYip0126 4 years ago
you play so well
CHANHUI1983 4 years ago
WOW. Simple songs can be cool!!
hypnostratos 4 years ago
this song is soo simple i played in a concert when i was in yr 4
ninjagirl112 4 years ago
Great, you're so good...
Dehus 4 years ago
but i cant ply it anymore because i cant remember it
ninjagirl112 4 years ago
that was beautiful~
janna25 4 years ago
no no it's Waltz n°17 in a minor, op. posthume.
pacoo75 4 years ago
wat opus number and which movement is this?
tehmariachi 4 years ago
Im not quite sure, but i think Waltz No.19 in A minor, Op.posth.
Dehus 4 years ago
what op. number and movement?
tehmariachi 4 years ago
CHE SPETTACOLO!!!
lunetta20 4 years ago
I love it. Slow, with emotion. I also use the pedal in this piece. I think it brings more emotion and softness. (you can watch my video). Bref, Awesome interpretation.
mlema094 4 years ago
I always use pedal on this song--it sounds a lot better. Ah, yes... my first chopin piece. Brings back memories.
I would kill for that piano, though--I'm stuck with a little upright in my living room.
Great job--I'll forgive the little e-natural slip on measure 48 ;). We've all done that one time or another.
Alexifish 5 years ago
are you supposed to use pedal in this piece even though it doesn't say to?
Joemama468 5 years ago
Well, this might come from the room and the bad quality of the camera (sorry for that), but why shouldn't i be supposed to use pedal, if I interprete it this way,
Dehus 5 years ago
Oh! I love have you've done this! you are fabulous its so excellent and moving, I just love it.
secretrain 5 years ago
you are GREAT!!
aznbabe794613 5 years ago
exellent
tyau14 5 years ago
soo great and wonderful !!
lepianiste921 5 years ago
Excellent!
I would love to play on that piano.
The room that its in too...
great job
calbee219 5 years ago
Well, the room isn't anything amazing, but it definitly is a beautiful piano. Good job, too, with the playing. I like that song a lot.
Spartan3500 5 years ago
Its the room that gives the semi-bright echo.
So its really nice to something like this for a change, because most of the personal piano vids on youtube are done in a small room or living room.
calbee219 5 years ago
Yeah, I know. While the room is bright, I still would have taken out the fire extinguisher and the portable chairs.
Spartan3500 5 years ago