Review: Urban Decay Big Fatty Mascara

[DestroyerKitteh]

MY COVERGIRL MASCARA WORKS TEN TIMES BETTER ;)

[tsukasatsukiko]

I personally dont have the shortest lashes on earth, but I don't have the worlds longest either. I notice it brings out the tips in my lashes and makes them look noticably longer and darker. I usually hate most mascaras cause they all seem to work the same and are about as obnoxious to apply as the last one you tried. I have a small tube of Big Fatty so I don't know if that has had an impact on my applications but I actually like this one! I usually only have to apply once per eye.

[annie2062003]

love your informative mascara reviews.

[96JessaSaur]

i feel the same way, and my wand bent! idk how it happened, i hope it doesnt break. I prefer a sephora mascara surprisingly! great review! :]

[kcolls88]

girl you are SO funny and awesome! Love the review :)

[SuziiQ418]

jahonkin' sized LOL! i subscribed to your channel pretty recently but just wanted to say i think your reviews are so thorough & AWESOME. thanks for 'em!

[iheartmac2010]

they don't test on animals.

[Meaganachska]

i love you your so funny:)

[cidness85]

OK I have this mascara...you are right, it does not lengthen at all...it's not for short lashes. However, this really did nothing for your lashes...crazy...they don't even look that much darker on you...well, hopefully you found a mascara that works for you!!

[05mjdubb]

This was OK. It's really not worth the price though. My drugstore Revlon performs better. This is just OK.

[ShannonVousAime]

hahahha big wands.

[coralreefXO]

You have the best reviews!

[Ella467]

I love this mascara. my eyelashes do not like to stay curled but with mascara they do nothing but stay curled ;)

[CheckeredRainbowTie]

ive got this :), love it alot. <3

[superroxmysox]

haha it was funny when you were giggling about the "big wands" :)

[GerardwHey]

I think the packaging is cute for all UD products, but every single one is terrible for getting all of the product out. Every. Single. One. XD

They're all wide designs and such with small openings. That's just doesn't work! Haha

[missoreoluvr]

One coat looks the best! It's subtle and it makes ur eye lashes look naturally darker

[lmfaooallie]

i was excited when i got this, but i ened up not liking it. the wand was def. to big. maybe because my eyes are sorta small? im not sure.

[CheckeredRainbowTie]

I have got this mascara, i love it. the best one ever!!

[Zwinkypr0ductions]

for me it just lik clumps them together i hav waterproof and for me it is the biggest piece of shit mascara out there for 20 bucks it just sticks them all togheter and even using the buisness card trick bye michelle phan still sticks them toghether this mascara is better of as a weapon 4 me

[toneartz]

I use this mascara, and I really love it!! I have very long lashes, so this is a very good mascara for me. Because I want more volume to my lashes and don't need that much lenghtening ;)

[ilovegrintt]

For me this mascara works really well! For me personally it does seperate, lengthen and creates bigger eyelashes. But i do have very thick lashes so i guess its different for everyone.

[MelinaElizabeth17]

What do you think about this mascara as far as volume? I have really long lashes so that's a must for me

[vbalock]

Oh, I do love this mascara!!

[pigheather]

i hate this mascara. LOL

[ryusenka]

Could you do a review of Urban Decay's Sky Scraper Mascara?

[pinkiecharm]

@ryusenka I have already reviewed it. It's included with my Urban Decay Smoke Out Kit review.

[MonikaCT]

If you have it can you do a reveiw on:

chanel inimitable mascara

??(:

[eyesliketheoceanxo]

your reviews are the best! always informitave, but fun too :D

[RosiesGurl91]

I -think- I have that same butterfly ring as you. But I couldn't get a good look at it.

[Carly41963]

Hi PinkyYou crack me up! I love your vids!You do very well at them=) Keep up the great work! I LOVE Urban Decay Big Fatty. I use the waterproof b/c it holds a better curl and last longer. I can get my lashes so long that a MAC MA asked me if they were long fales lashes. Ok try this Curl with Shisido curler, Prime with Shiseido primer, then us Big Fatthy Waterproof. OMG pinky if you do that your lashes will be so long. After I do that my lashes almost hit my eyebrows.Try that Pinky!U will love it

[MsKimi26]

you are such a nerd lol i love it i love the way you assume everyone know who that guys is you were talking about lol reminds me of my baby sister

[tlnjrp]

hahaha i laughed when u said big wands tooo :)

[n0necksbabii]

With one coat of Big Fatty Mascara, I got:

Tremendous length

great Separation

ZERO clumps

ZERO running

ZERO flaking

and perfect volume that stayed all day. But that just might be because of my lashes, they reach my brow(:

I love it. 10 out of 10 on my list.(:

[ModBeatnikGirl]

Does it make your eyelashes hard and sticky? Like most mascaras do. Also what font did you use?

Please answer :)

[VannaBananaLove]

Your make up looks so pretty in this video

[dreamer4vida]

i do get alot of length

[katvyy]

what are some other thick mascaras that you've tried? I like thick mascara :)

[pinkfreak98ily]

I just wanted to mention that i bought the water proof version about 2 months ago. I am NEVER getting it again! It is not waterproof at all and isnt worth the money. Just get the regular one. And it kinda thickens but not really. Dont waste your money on it. (:

[tinyham]

big WAND! hahahaha thanks for reviewing this!

[NEONPINKBFFL]

thats one crapass macara!

[CaraLienCerulean]

some people don't like big wands...

that's classic. thank you for making my day. ^_^

[beautybuff820]

that's what she said.

;-)

[gmed2]

Thanks Pinkie! I will look forward to ur review! Geminiagogo, that makes cents , but would love to know Pinkiecharms opinion on the products. :)

[morganandkatieshow]

you are hilarious:D

nice review irene!

[kharabgulab]

You always look pretty in your vids, but you look exceptionally GORGEOUS in this one! Ow ow!

[jmsneptuneonfire]

Your hair in this video is extra pretty looking...I also like this lighting. Thanks for this review!

[heytherekiddoily]

"big wands" hahaha i love it!!!!!

[xStarsnRockets]

im almost 100 percent positive that it comes in purple and blue aswell as black

[pinkiecharm]

@xStarsnRockets It's true that there are small versions of this in other colors but not in the full size.

[HannahHeartStruck]

@pinkiecharm im not sure if you mentioned or not. But does this mascara leave your eyelashes soft? Or make them hard, firm, or sticky? Thanks for the review :)

[pinkiecharm]

@HannahHeartStruck I didn't notice that it left my lashes hard, but they weren't sticky.

[HannahHeartStruck]

@pinkiecharm have you tried urban decays sky scraper mascara? They claim it leaves them "feather soft"

[pinkiecharm]

@HannahHeartStruck I have and I have reviewed it. It's included with my Urban Decay Smoke Out Kit review.

[HannahHeartStruck]

@pinkiecharm okay. Thank you i will check it out :)

[xStarsnRockets]

hey i was jw what you're lid color is in this video? i love the shimmery-ness of it! lol :)

[GeminiAGogo]

WHOA. WHOA.

Ratings enabled.

WHAT IS THIS BLASPHEMY

:O

[cindyheartsyou78]

i think i said "that's what she said" 20 times in this video >:]

[gmed2]

Hey Pinkiecharm, I am a total newbie at youtube. I cannot figure out how to request a video or message u, so hopefully u read all ur comments! Could u do a review on L.A. colors cosmetics? I bought a palette at a Family Dollar store, super cheap and i really love it! They are online. AND also, review on NYX stuffies! Thanks Pinkie!

[pinkiecharm]

@gmed2 You can request reviews by commenting on any video, sending me a message or commenting on my channel.

I do have an L.A. Colors review coming up so hopefully that'll answer some of your questions.

[GeminiAGogo]

Just to let you know, she doesn't do reviews on items under $5 unless it's a very very VERY special case because she feels as though if you want it that much, it's only a couple bucks to try it. :)

[mastoidrama]

I like this mascara because I have long eyelashes, and after I curl my eyelashes and then put other mascaras on. My eyelashes just fall. They go back to looking like I never curled them. But with this mascara my eyelashes don't do that.

So that is the reason I really like this mascara.

[brisweet55]

I love this mascara, it is my absolute favorite. Though, I do not need length, I just love how thick it makes my lashes. Though, I think you need multiple coats. :)

[aibab0]

your makeup looks gorgeous. I love the color on your lips! your mascara reviews are really helpful. I'm still searching for the perfect mascara that doesn't have a big scary wand xD

makinascene's suggestion of a rating system sounds like a great idea!!

[Laylal]

Like your hair in this.

[dirtfashion08]

5 stars for being as immature as me with 'big wands'

[makinascene]

love your vids, and i really like hearing your reviews

have you ever done, or considered using like a rating system to just sum up your thoughts?

[pinkiecharm]

@makinascene Others have suggested this but I don't like the idea of having to box myself into a ratings system.

[KnowMeAshley]

i like your hair here!

;)

[parodybarbiegirl]

The disign on the tube reminds me of Mika music videos which in turn reminds me of hs song big girls, you are beautiful....

[littletidbit30]

Urban Decay is so dirty, yet so fun!  Love this video! I have always wanted to know more about this mascara.

[AMYISRAD]

5 Stars for the big wands joke!

[suripopje]

Au contraire, I find that most people love big wands ;-P LOL!!!!

[Samspark72]

You wld think that at the price of this mascara it wld'nt clog up round the top of the tube. It's gd to know that it doesn't transfer but I think I must be lucky cuz I don't have that problem but I do have really dry eyes so that might be the reason why?

[Mehuber09]

Did you get a hair cut? I like it

[amyslak1985]

can you do a FAVORITES VID like your favorite mascara, lipstick, gloss, blush etc... although i love the reviews I would love to know your favorite Thanks for the consideration

[itsageoffrushthing]

The lighting looks really great in this video. And so does your skin.

I'm perhaps too old to chortle at the disliking of big wands quip, but I love being immature occasionally!

[hannersonthetube]

i love your reviews. very thorough and informative. i fully appreciate you! :)

[ladybugluvsmac]

mac zoom lash is really thick as well. i got a tube and i hated it at first but now its not so bad. but i have to say i perfer almay mascara. its more liquidy which i personaly like in a mascara. its lengthining too.

[falloutmnky]

takin big wands in a unique direction there eh? LOVE YOUR VIDS!

[bubblicious616]

hey irene sry if this isnt the right place, but what brush do u recommend for paint pots? i dont like fingers

[onthaway2stardom]

Mac 252 is really good.

[OrangeMusic34]

by chance, do you remember what lipstick you're wearing? it looks great on you :] love your videos

[YTfancol]

I just checked UD´s website ( price 20 dollars) and after watching your video , that is 20 dollars I am saving, big wand or not, hehehe.

Thanks for reviewing this mascara.

[CarnivoraDoll]

ARGH, that gunk residue when you put the wand back into the tube is the only thing I hate about this mascara.

[glamcandy2]

i love this stuff .. have long lashes its so nice and love it!!!!!

[Misschillchick12]

Gosh I'm so happy I dint buy it!

Thanks for making the video!

[stonesfanatik]

great review!

[MagicMirrorOnTheWall]

are u losing weight??

ur face looks slimmer in ur recent vids than in ur older vids =]

u look pretty XD

[chyld]

She really does look good. Keep up whatever ur doing pinkiecharm

[sarah8244]

i've noticed too! keep it up irene, you look fabulous ! :D

[stephaniixox]

oohh irene

big wands gets you everytime =]

[rockmyworldsteve]

Thanks for the quality review! You rock!!!!

[lnsceclipse1]

how much did the mascara cost

[kymym92]

$20

[narupurple66]

he is...uh....a..uh.....

[BrittanyBallisticccc]

Lmfao, "I know a lot of people dislike big wands..." -dies-

[ntash92]

hahah that was sooo cute! big wands....hahah

[coffee652]

bahahahahhaa "i know some people dislike big wands..."

you're hilarious!!

great review, btw :)

[hellokatiee1]

thats what she said;)!

[mizjazzegirl]

I didn't like this mascara because it did nothing for my lashes

[ehb101]

$20 bucks wow! You can get a really good drugstore mascara for only 7 bucks!

[Rainsangel]

Hey :]

i just wanted to ask for a review on all your slimshines. It's been a while and was wondering if you can do one that is more updated. thanks a bunch!

[makeupmyworldx]

i was thinking of getting this for my friend for christmas

[theycallmeeggs]

ahaha, irene so immature laughing at nobody liking big wands! ;]

i felt the sexual tension, lmao.

[BurnInMaLight]

hey whats a good drugstore mascara

besides lash blast

[ladykaede21]

I would recommmend Rimmel London Sexy Curves Mascara :) Great for volumizing lashes!

Thanks for the review Irene! I can't wait to try it out!

[KatieAndradee]

@ladykaede21 I totally agree with you. I love sexy curves. Its my go to mascara along with my life :)

[SweetHeartz119]

Loreal Telescopic

[BurnInMaLight]

thanks man

[mizjazzegirl]

@BurnInMaLight L'oreal extra volume collagen or rimmel sexy curves mascara or try the l'oreal telescopic explosion

[BurnInMaLight]

thanks man

helped a lot! i wiill try those out -=DD

[pinknglitter1]

i hated this mascara

[liza6458]

hiya your make up is lovely in this tutorial!

[TemariKind123]

'Big wands'. I actually said out loud, 'that's what she said.' xDDD Love your videos.<3

[Pinkgirl2951]

i have very long thin lashes and this works great!

[LoThePokerface]

hahahhaahhahahahahha

i died at "big wands"

great video!

[formysunny]

I love big wands.

[Jessiexo]

hahahahaha.

i loveeee your silliness -- you actually had me laughing out loud at "big wands".

LOVE your videos ahahahah

[Juxt13]

i love this mascara but i natually have long thick lashes i like it cuz on me it looks natural and i like that it doesnt give alot of lenth

[kimmiem231]

hahahah lol at "big wands"

[ilovehippos179]

Thanks for doing more Urban Decay reviews.

:)

[Cutii3Babii3]

Lol, the whole time i was watching this i was thinking, "That's what she said!" But the review was great. :]

[xPeaceSigns]

that's funny. i exactly what i thought.

[pinkandvampires]

Black, blue, black cherry, and purple methinks. It lengthened for me.

[bdar215]

cheers 4 the review I have to say I have really long lashes but looking for a mascara to curl its seems this would be it!

[leanncraigo]

I could use a big wand ;) hehe...had to say it!

[felicitaXamore22]

i couldnt watch this review without laughing every 10 seconds...my mind must be in the gutter. :)

your skin looks very glowy in this video...the lighting's different perhaps?

[Over40Princess]

I lost it at the, "big wand," comment too. Hysterical.

[xxpandafacexx]

I love the color of your eyes.

Wonderful review! :D

[vannahhalo]

you said big wand *snigger* ^_^

[szuchnic]

I know what you mean about the formula but this is my holy grail! After about a month of use my lashes actually grow in thicker and don't fall out as much...I find this is one of those products that is absolutely amazing for some people and nothing special to others.

[MakeUpMadeEasy]

personally i have no problem with big wands yeeha great vid

[cutiepiedev]

I have the big fatty mascara in black cherry (one of the colored ones) and I was so disappointed by it. It's really doesn't do anything. But I'm considering trying the regular formula and seeing how it works... great review!!!

[KillaPinkz]

never tried it but ima have to pick one of this up

[pinglala]

I really dislike this mascara, it just doesn't work for me, which is a pity cuz i love the packaging ha. great review as usual :)

[MusicLova84]

You look especially vibrant on this vid pinkie! Your hair looks full of volume and the lighting is fantastic! It laughed when you were talkin about whether the mascara added length to your lashes and you said "it's nothing to write home about" hilarious, gotta use that one, lol.

[halyvamp101]

i know most people dislike "big wands" i went into laugh attacks haha

[kimberlily4789]

can you do a review of the urban decay skyscraper multi benefit mascara that was in your favorites video?

[LisaFreemontStreet]

What girl DOESNT need a big wand? *chuckle*

[brenbren2]

LisaFreemontStreet:

I totally agree with you =D

[cutiepiedev]

lol loves it.

[goldiel0cks]

my lashes look like that without fancy mascara :D

[TheGirlNobodyKnew]

LOL, big wands are GOOD.

[aelievense]

Lighting and quality is particularly good in this video. Keep up the good work!

[Pixeldoodle]

I got this 2 months ago and Iv'e only used it a few times cuz the brush is so friggin big.

[EmilyBabeeyC09]

i loved it =]]

[PinkStar349]

Big Fatty sounds funny for a Mascara.

[itsmesues]

this is the only high end mascara i have ever repurchased! i don't feel like im wasting any money when i buy this one :)

[ButterflyDiorDiva]

I don't know about you, but I love big wands! lol

Thanks for the review.

[Montoyamommy]

lol you totally think like i do lol "fat wand" hehe I love this packaging tho

[Born2BeeDifferent]

ha ha love the name of it

[tanyarm]

This urban decay mascara used to be my favourite mascara.... Then I found Dior but now I LOVE smokey lash by Makeup Forever!

[tokyorosa]

Thanks for this review. I'm always drawn to UD because of their awesome packaging, too! But sadly, it doesn't look like there's a great difference in lengthening or thickening with this mascara.

[MsKellyko]

i love big wands, lol. badgal lash is great w/ a big wand. Is this thicker? thoughts?

[ValLovesDenis]

LOL..."some people dislike big wands..." That made me giggle too! Now...you must be missing your hubby for having such thoughts!! xxx love ya your are my fave youtuber

[Sarahisthebombest]

This is my favorite mascara ever ^_^

Great review

[thecrazzyshow]

great review