Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (867)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I give it a C - I loved the music but I tuned out in the more slow scenes

    Extra points for the Samcede's kiss!

  • i think that lea michele looks constipated when she sings but i do love her voice. [:

  • I loved the smooth criminal scene w/ Sebastian and Santana! I love Sebastian!(Grant Gustin) -3

  • I did really like this episode, for once there was only a few scenes I disliked. Finally Blaine got to sing and have good scenes with lines! Loved anything to do with Blaine in this, the awkward moments and the funny. I seriously died when he was on the floor screaming! I still hate Samcedes though.

  • Can someone pls tell me what songs were being sung cos i missed the episode:(

  • you forgot to mention sebastian and santana singing smooth criminal

  • *raises hand* Maybe u shud sit down....

  • buck come on! Sam+Mercedes=Samcedes!!!! every gleek knows that :)

  • 1." I taped the recorder to my underboob" 2.

  • Now you understand the life of a Gleek, your downtown abbey is my glee, i spend every second thinking about my OTP :P

  • keep doing ur aaweesome reviews!

  • i hid it in my underboob lol!!!!!!!

  • Sebastian outbitched santana....WHAT HAS THIS WORLD COME TO! D:

  • I'm 100% Irish :)

  • Just came across your videos today. Seriously I have spent the past 2 hours watching them. HAHA!

  • Do Downton Abbey Re-caps!

    

  • Comment removed

  • uuuuh, I wouldn't mind some Sebastian jizz on my face. well, preferably not in my eye, but still.

  • Yeah Artie was weird in this ep.

    And I was legitimately shocked when Quinn got accepted into Yale... but I guess it IS just a TV show :P Wonder what the chances of a girl like Quinn actually getting into Yale early would be....

  • Artie was so ANNOYING in this episode. Everything he says sounds completely forced and fake! He has the worst personality.

  • You can call them Mam.

  • it's Samcedes by the way buck

  • quinn got into yale because of her essay, i'm sure. colleges looove character like that...

  • I miss Jessie :((

  • Worst episode EVER!!!!

  • I started DYING when you said michelles make up looked asian!! HAA!

  • i give it a B, good but could have been better.

  • My favourite part... Darren Criss's yellow trousers.... ;)

  • Grade: C-

  • i love you hand thingy lol!! where did u get it

  • I'm a gleek, but I disagree with you buck. Don't take this the wrong way, but I feel like ur only focused on the homosexual relationships (which is fine) and downplaying all the other roles. Again, nothing aganist gay people. Now, I do agree with some of your other episode reviews, but I started to notice this issue. Glee isn't suppose to target only "Blurt" and Britana fans..writers sometimes just wanna try something new. i give this episode an 8.5/10

  • A! "I taped it to my underboob!" 

  • The badass scene of the Michael episode

    At the garage when Blaine says : It's time to see who's bad. and Santana : CLICK and everybody shows up.

  • I think you should have a Downtown Abbey episode/recap!!! <3 Bates and Anna!!!

  • I loved this episode, I thought it was a B or A- :)

  • Eye injuries suck! Last fall, both of my eyes got messed up from my contacts, and I had to wear and eye patch on my left eye for a few days. Worst pain I've ever been in!!

  • seriously though where is Samuel??? he was my favorite!!!

  • I thought Human Nature was the best song of the episode. It was beautifully done and I was surprised at the chemistry between Sam and Mercedes!

  • i appreciate michael but I HATE HIS MUSIC HE CANT WRITE/RHYME/NOR CREATE NEW WORDS IN THE CHORUS we get it you never can say goodbye no no no get some new lyrics!!!

  • @16triley16 Er that song wasn't written by him, that was written by Motown when the Jackson 5 did canned music that the label fed them, do your research. Some of his own songs, however, are very good lyrically.

  • I give the episode 4 out of 10...

  • 1. "This is not violence, it's clever. I taped it to my underboob." gotta love the underboob haha

    2. Fav song is a toss up between Smooth Criminal and Human Nature (least fav was Ben like wth was happening there? idk).

    3. don't care

    4. B I guess. I mean, as a tribute it was decent, as most tributes are, the cast is good at what they do so, in my opinion, it's not like the episode can be terrible. But if Rachel and Finn do end up getting married I am going to flip tables, punch babies, etc.

  • You should talk more about Downton Abbey! :)

  • YOU DIDNT EVEN SAY SMOOTH CRIMINAL!

  • B-B+ My favorite number was Human Nature. Second favorite Smooth Criminal.

  • Why is it that every time we have an excellent episode this season they follow it up with crap like this?

  • firstly, you didn't talk about smooth criminal! it was epic! secondly, i thought this episode was an amazing tribute to the God of Pop.

  • @pantherpatty i'm just correcting you not being a jerk but its The King of Pop

  • @DaughterOfAthena101

    I know. But he has always been more than a king to me. I always call called him the God of Pop,

  • @pantherpatty now I feel high because I've never thought about it that way

  • "STFU Blaine"

  • is it just me or has glee not been on for weeks and weeks in the uk.:/?

  • @PrettyPic880 yeah, sky 1 has decided to wait till march so the last 12 episodes can air in 12 weeks without pause.

  • @totlbabi101 I see thanks:)

  • I thought it was pretty good. Not one of the best ever but it was pretty cool and worth watching again. I really liked Human Nature when Sam and Mercedes sang together.

  • im in LOVE with this episode :D

  • it was an AMAZAZING episode!!!! im happy they used songs that arent the obvious MJ songs it was great

  • i HATED it. i LOVE MJ....LOVE MJ. love glee...not as much as MJ, but i love glee. this was a DISASTER! only a few can pay tribute, they couldn't...*sigh*

  • xP Downton Abbey is amazing! But the episode was good but Rachel did have a great line in where she was all like that she didn't quite get MJ. xP Hehe.

  • I thought it was a great episode!

  • i thought it was a really good episode!

  • that is not Asian...!!!

  • DOWNTON ABBEY OMG -3

  • Watched this and then put on bring it on! Thank you Buck <3

  • I kinda liked the performances and well I'm a sucker for Santana so yeah I enjoyed her the whole episode ;) Smooth Criminal tho... that was like the best! I need Naya Rivera's album like yesterday, I give her all the awards!! (I miss Brittany A LOT!)

  • I give this episode a C. Love the music, but I wasn't super into it. The best part I thought was Smooth Criminal, and that was 99% because of the "Two Cellos" guys.

  • Handicapable?

  • ughh why you recap Gossip girl 

  • this episode was so... wtf

  • tribute episodes suck... give me gLeeky plot & rememberable music... love the side boob... hot

  • I don't know if I liked this episode. I think I wanted it to be good so badly that when it came on I was just disappointed. They should have done more mainstream Micheal and then I probably would have liked it more because I didn't know any of the songs and then it was just disappointing. (I also hated the britney episode because of that, but the Lady Gaga one was good)

  • The proposal and MJ were the best episode is a LOONG time!!

    AND GET DAMIEN TO SING, I adore him!! -3

    No Samuel -.-

  • I hated this episode. Only parts I liked were the scene with Kurt and his dad and Quinn's number. I'm done with watching the show weekly (this episode broke my resolve), but I will watch the episode with Rachel's gay dads!

  • I think this tribute episode was better than the Britney/Madonna/Gaga episodes. I think the songs actually fit into the plot better.

  • I was just waiting for your nipple to pop out this entire video.

  • did NOT expect a downton abbey spoiler while watching a glee cap. darn you buck!!

  • You didn't even talk about how epic Smooth Criminal was!!??

  • @musicalgeek24 Watched Glee for the first time, I didn't think of the show. But...sweet JESUS ON A MOTORCYCLE! Smooth Criminal...on the violin or...what was it. Ahhh, just sweet.

  • I personally love tribute episodes when they have at least a little plot, which this one did. I enjoyed New Directions taking the high road and LOVE that Sebastian has NO CHANCE with Blaine now. Hahahaha! I thought the song choices were very nice as they highlighted the different eras and phases of Jackson and fit the story. All around, definitely an A.

  • OMG....you need to do a Downton Abbey recap! That would make my day!!!!

  • the Scream video with Artie and Mike Chang (with eyeliner) was amazing!! I loved it, it was my favorite part. Sam and Mercedes Human Nature duet was also great (Mercedes gets a kiss finally!!) and also Black or White was really good. I really enjoy MJ songs and overall I thought it was a good episode.

  • Smooth criminal... yeah I think I've said enough!

  • Cum jokes in the eye are ALWAYS funny.

  • You didn't EVEN mention Smooth Criminal? That was the best duet/song in the history of Glee! My grade : B+

  • @IloveGleeandTVD I would say C or C-. The original song is MUCH better.

  • Did anyone else notice that after Santana threatened to throw coffee in Rachel's face she stood up to talk to Sebastian and the cup was empty and perfectly clean?

  • dont bother doing glee caps if your not going to do it properly ffs this was a fucking stupid

  • @saltandpepperarlie Don't be such a dick. If you don't like it don't watch it lol. It's that easy.

  • well i liked it .... its just that simple <3 

  • I really enjoyed this episode. Personally, I didn't like some of the songs. I see why they chose them but they certainly weren't my favorites. Where was Billie Jean? What about Leave me Alone?

    My favorite parts really were the battle songs. Bad, Smoothe Criminal and the phenomenal remake of the Scream video...was that shot for shot? Anyhow, I really enjoyed those three the most and the others were more or a less meh for me.

  • I'm still waiting for the guy with the dreads from the GLEE PROJECT to appear XD

  • cont...

    so freaking excited, I can't even handle it! Oh, and another random thought- where has our leprechaun been all season? Give him a plot line!

  • I give it a B-. I agreed with Rachel- I'm not a big Michael Jackson fan, so the music didn't interest me in this episode. The plot made some progress which I liked, but most of the Warblers related stuff (like the song at the end when New Directions got sassy through song) annoyed me. I'm glad about Quinn, Rachel, and Kurt's good news and am excited to see what happens with Finchel next week. Although I am DEFINITELY more excited for the Valentine's Day episode because... BRITTANA KISS!!!!! I'm

  • mediocre episode about a "C" not very seamless transitions the episode just seemed a little like stuffed with songs and no real plot. The answer to the mariage proposal and Kurt and Santana brought the fire in terms of the singing. When are the bringing in Samuel Larsen and when will Rory do something again he's so background its ridiculous

  • "i look like a whore, side boob" my favorite line in the whole video. haha.

  • I really liked this episode, I thought it was really good!

  • LOL , its called "winged eyeliner" ;)

  • I just watched all three seasons in the last week and I am up to date! Its a official im a new gleek :)

  • Thumbs are on the inside, your glee hand is on the wrong hand.Downtown Abbey S2 aired in the UK already, a real fan would of found a way to watch it months ago. Glee went downhill after s3e3; and am i the only one wondering were the glee project kids are(Samual and Alex)?

  • DO A PRETTY LITTLE LIARS RECAP

  • SMOOTH CRIMINAL ALL THE WAY.

    some songs were great, others... Not so much.

    But I love when Finn brings Blaine the movies with heroes who have eye patches.

    That part was cute.

    AND ALSO, WHY IS KURT WEARING A PONCHO?

  • I wasn't too keen on this episode. But I loved Artie and Mike Chang doing scream!!!

  • YO BUCK. you should watch NIKITA! FRIDAYS CW 8! like for him to see

  • When does SAM come in?

  • @gigi3b5 Valentine's day ep, on feb 14

  • "i was like STFU you Blaine, seriously?"

  • PLEASE DO PLL RECAPS!

  • I did not like the MJ Tribute. Britney was wayy better.

  • i loved this episode

  • the eyeliner was kinda 60's babs

  • but i thnk what you said about artie and handicap able kids was REALLY funny

  • Ily nd btw I am handicap able... i have cerebal palsy

  • Smooth Criminal! (amazing with Naya and Grant and the cello dudes!) Ben! (singing to Blaine about a dead rat...they really zig when I think they're gonna zag.) Black or White! (the Warblers joining in and the weird face transition!)

  • What are you talkin bout?

    I loved this weeks glee!!!

  • I loved this episode !! Glee keeps getting better !! Love your glee caps !! Up the Irish =)

  • Aunty Snykes just arrived on the Bitchtown Express.

  • All I can think about is the barely political "glee parody"

    I feel like glee copied them lol

  • the foam finger is on the wrong hand!

  • The dueling cellos and voices in Smooth Criminal were phenomenal!!! Wow! Nicely done!

  • Oh my lord Downton Abbey is SO GOOD. I finished all the seasons online and I now feel a huge void in my life.

  • yay im not the only one how laughed when blaine got slusheied i love blaine but he took it a bit far!!

  • sebadtian is hot

  • Also the Supernatural fan in me came out when Sebastian said he put rock salt in the slushie. I literally told my mom, "Rock salt is emergency purposes only. Like a demon attack."

  • @RogueAngel08 You are so cool. :D I can see Dean making a sarcastic Glee comment about Sam breaking into song right now!

  • I loved Scream and Smooth Criminal. I loved Artie dancing and that they made Mike Janet, he looked awesome in eyeliner.

    I loved Mikes "An Eye for an Eye". It was perfectly placed, and his was so serious. Also Mike being so upset makes the Bike Chanderson fan in me squee.

    I think it would have flowed better if they hadn't had to edit it down so much. It was originally planned to be longer, like "Born This Way". I know they cut a few key scenes.

    I could have done with Rachel/Finn duet honestly.

  • Downton Abbey is the best. I started to watch it and i finished it in like # days. I LOVE IT!!! Thanks Buck for introducing me to the show. Smooth Criminal was amazing btw.

  • "i wonder what matthew and mary are doing.." haha i love it now add sybil and branson, thomas and o brian grrr and bates and anna oh and of course carson the butler and that's what i think about and also what would the dowager countess (maggie smith) say? and i cant wait for them to get into the 20s

  • WHAT ABOUT SANTANA`S SMOOTH CRIMINAL????

  • @KrisChalakov omg yesss i could noth stop listening to it

  • I disagree. I thought the proposal was way too forced (although I did love Rachel and Santana singing "we found love", They are the best duet team IMO on glee). I really liked this MJ episode and I thought all the songs were done really great and MJ would have approved. I don't know why everyone is dissing this season. The story may be different but I think it's moving along fine and I think a lot of the songs are being done better than they were done in the first season.

  • I love that you say handicapable

  • @AMB33ZY he's married

  • For me it was so-so. MJ is MY FAVORITE! I felt like they ruined a couple of my favorite songs... Overall the whole Finchel part is sickening cuz either theyre together or they're not... Too rollercoast-y?

    But smooth criminal was my favorite of this episode.

    I don't think it's gonna work out with Finchel, who would want to be second to someone's dream? Like the shadow who stands behind her in the spot light.....

  • I loved it but I felt like this was more of a filler episode, kind of like "Night of Neglect" last year but I did love "Smooth Criminal" and "Black or White"

  • Comment removed

  • I really am done with Glee and all things Ryan Murphy once this season is over. Its like you watch a while fucking season for 2 good episodes. It makes me feel like I am in an abusive relationship.

  • @MsSpacelam HA LOL who'd I u think you are? NO ONE calls Sam and Mercedes troutytots, it always has been and always will be Samcedes, get with the fandom, second of all, Buck! You would know what all the ship names are if you followed some glee blogs, u would also be up to date with ALL of the spoilers ;)

  • @theqwertykeyvoard100 I think I'm MsSpacelamb! And* I* call Sam/Mercedes TroutyTots, it's much more creative than Samcedes. That's just a lazy effort. Most couples have multiple portmanteaus, people use the ones they like best.

    I'm up to date with the fandom, I just don't take the crazy/obsessed spoiler maniacs very seriously. You seem to be one of those.

  • @peron75 I sense a Middle Finger sticking out inside that big hand.

  • gosh that awkward hair on mercedes lip when they kissed bothered me so freaking much.

  • is buck single???

    

  • @AMB33ZY noooope. he's married.

  • C'mon, everyone knows the Sam and Mercedes portmanteau is TroutyTots :0)

    You didn't mention "Smooth Criminal" at ALL? Loved it!

    Plus "Wanna be Startin' Something", "Bad"," Scream", all excellent.

    You missed out on the best Santana line of the night: "today is your lucky day, because Auntie Snixx just arrived on the Bitchtown Express."

    Going with an A- on this one.

  • DOWNTON ABBEY RECAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i absolutely agree. im not a huge michael fan and i feel like a lot of people are because they have to be. i like the plot and storyline of this episode and the music was cute. onto the next episode...

  • Sassy Artie reminded me of Kevin's NLT days

  • I call them by sam's stripper name "white chocolate" and blaine totally is rich.

  • OMG I know what you mean abou Downton Abby Buck. 4 days ago I downloaded both seasons and finished them yesterday. Downton Abby is my new obsession. Love it. Absolutely LOVE Bates.

  • A. They can have our Journey and our Dreamgirls, but pilfering my Michael? Mm-mm, that’s another level of not okay

    B. Scream and Blaine protecting Kurt from slushie

    C. BackStreet Boys

    D. B+ i was mad when they cut the whole dalton and iwyb scene, w/o it the begining felt to rushed. out of all songs why they pick ben to sing and they could of at least change ben to blaine and why did finchel have to be there, i was hoping for just klaine, and why no klaine kiss, finchel got to have a kiss.

  • HA BUCK Lana Del Rey was amazing on David Letterman... TAKE THAT you catty QUEEN!

  • Eww do you like Mary from downtown abbey she's a bitch.

  • C+

  • I want to know where Sugar was this episode...

  • Quin said earlier in the season that she applied to Yale....

  • Smooth Criminal was the best cause it had the 2cello guys that are on YouTube...and everywhere else. lol

  • did anyone else notice Sebastian checking out Santana during smooth criminal? YOUR SUPPOSE TO BE GAY FOOL!

  • @JerzeeLay427 lol yeah i saw that

  • Critics loved it, fans think it was so-so.

    What i've learned now from Glee is that the first time i watch it, im really critical and then the more i watch it, the more i like it and enjoy it. So to the people that didnt like it, just watch it 2 more times. im sure you'll get into it

    PS: that Ricky Martin ep is gonna SUCK! that is all

  • my god u r sooo funny showed ma friend 1 of ur old videos she pissed herself laughing!!!! :D

  • blaine jumped in front of kurt to take the slushie for him <3.. i had to watch it again to notice it but it was sweet <3

  • I like Sam-cedes!!!!! :D SAM-CEDES FOREVER <3

  • your glee glove thing is on the wrong hand

  • Samedes! ;) 

  • I think it's less about artie getting sassy and more about the actor who plays artie not wanting to have to dance in a wheelchair next to everyone else who is really dancing all the time :) And also, whoever produces glee obviously has never had to apply for college, because they know nothing about it (Quinn is not getting into Yale, come on) And also, Finn and Rachel are really dumb. But despite all that, it was an ok episode.

  • you will stand up .... to CANCER. lol