Would be better as a traditional mash-up. Can tell a lot of effort went into it, but they don't blend at all. Good try, good result for what you were going for, but completely unappealing.
its whack but at the same time its different really strange give hugo a break at least he tried to do something never been done..its only a video chill
This is truly terrible, doesn't do justice to either artist and both versions of Bowies song are brilliant, when played on their own! Good collection of Bowie footage.
whoever made this video clearly does not understand music. they are in DIFFERENT keys you moron. That is why it sounds like crap when you put them together.
thank God Nirvana covered this song. No disrespect but I really can't stand Bowie's voice. It is weird, creepy and he sounds like he has a gadget in his throat to make him speak because his throat was already terminated by cancer. NIRVANA rocks!
i like david bowie but not in duet with kurt cobain sounds diferent sounds bad i like solo david bowie and with mick jagger it sounds better this style is not good for david bowie sing
If they want to have them perform together then they should use the same computer apparatus like Natalie Cole did when she sang the duet with her father Nat in the great performance of Unforgettable!
95% of teens these days listen to the same crappy pop over and over again. If you're one of the 5% who still listens to real music, thumb this up, then copy & paste it to at least five videos. Don't let die the spirit of rock
@LUCAX333 Dude, just cause I'm a music fanatic I have to point out, that there is No Fb, and look it up if you don't belive me. It goes from Eb to E to F....
@Mocifer666 if you really knew anything about music beyond grade-school teachings, you would know that there is, indeed, an Fb. what there isn't is a KEY of Fb. maybe that's what you meant though, i can't be sure.
@haircut74 If YOU knew anything beyond grade school teachings, You would know that Fb does NOT Exist.... The Chromatic scale Ab, A, Bb, B, C, Db, D, Eb, E, F, Gb, G. There Is NO Fb, but there is an E#, A.K.A F, however, Fb is not interchangeable with E. Use other Resources if you think I'm wrong.....
@Mocifer666 i don't have to use other resources. this is basic material taught in first semester theory. if you really are a "music fanatic", you should take time to learn about the circle of fifths and various key signatures. the key of Cb is denoted by SEVEN flats, which means that a one-octave Cb major scale from tonic to tonic is Cb-Db-Eb-Fb-Gb-Ab-Bb-Cb.
@haircut74 Look.... You seem reasonable..... So listen, I did NOT mean to start an argument, though I was simply just pointing out what I was told..... This is what I know.... Maybe I don't know as much about MUSIC, but I do know how to play a hell of a guitar.... In which case, since I won't use all but the basics, I look no further into it. Sorry for the inconvenience. I don't argue, however, Unless I think that I am correct.
@Mocifer666 fair enough. but like i said, if you truly are a music enthusiast, some more in-depth theory is worth learning about. if you have the time to learn, it's pretty fascinating.
@Mocifer666 here's another context in which Fb appears: a Gb major chord consists of Gb-Bb-Db, and the major seventh of the chord would be F. the minor seventh, of course, would then be Fb. it could NOT be E, because E would be a raised sixth. as you said, Fb is certainly not interchangeable with E; they are two separate notes, and likewise F and E# are not the same note. the pairs may be virtually the same pitches, but the context in which they are used is different.
@haircut74 Sorry, but Fb does not exist...All I have to do to prove this to you is have you look at a piano, or a guitar. Half step up from E is F and Half step down from F is E...I am sorry, this is plain and simple music knowledge. Try not to over think it
@Kingofmusic14 the note below F on a piano COULD be E, and it usually is, but not always, just as the note above it can be F# OR Gb. but in any case, a piano isn't the best example, because it's tuned to work in any key, so most of the notes are not precise, because in reality they would be slightly different in different keys. look at my previous posts if you need further explanation. Fb does exist. that's advanced musical understanding, beyond "plain and simple music knowledge".
i like bowie a lot better than nirvana... but nirvana's version is much more like what the song is really meant to sound like... kurts voice fits it very well and i really dont like the phaser on bowie's.
This is possibly the worst idea ever, Bowie has some good stuff but lets face it, his version of this is terrible - original or not. ...also NOT EVEN THE SAME FUCKING KEY. WTF GARBAGE. ...ruins the otherwise amazing playlist this as on.
If David Bowie didn't write/make this song then Nirvana wouldn't have been able to cover it. They're both as good as each other, stop being pathetic and enjoy the song.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
any idiot can cut out bits of text from a magazine and write the lyrics to a song, Bowie does look queer as fuck and should know better for an old git
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
How could you even compare? I wouldnt listen to this song if it wasnt redone by nirvana and i probably wouldnt even know it if it wasnt, colbain has a way better voice, hes gota unique sound, and its grunge and i fuckin love it, bowie just sounds overly queer and retarded. Hands down Nirvana.
Well at least bowies not constantly mumbling the song when he sings it. Its pure preference who you like better but you dont need to say stupid things ok LOL
You need to make a Music video for the David Bowie song.
Itd. Be. Epic.
SaintJaded 1 week ago
Wonderful! Thank you!
lindeene 3 weeks ago
I didn't remember MTV used to be good
Dynam1xxx 1 month ago
More Cobain.
1992corleonesicilia 2 months ago
So Cool! That's what timing is all about!
AuntieN2 3 months ago 3
Some untalented ma...fuc...wanna push those artistic souls down...!Fuc.. them!!!
TheWhateverwhoever 3 months ago
kurt = legend
kurtcobain1grunge 3 months ago
@kurtcobain1grunge
david = living legend #fail
Rikipic 4 days ago
good video, but change the title.
LolaLavonda 3 months ago
fuck off nirvana you're ridiculously overrated.
20cFilmWannabe 3 months ago
@20cFilmWannabe hhahaha,, nirvana nirvana nirvana!!!!
maxshow27 3 months ago
@maxshow27 *middle finger*
20cFilmWannabe 3 months ago
lol. Those songs were in two entirely different keys.
justinmdominiak 3 months ago
love the song, but your editing sucks great big elephant balls.
Csensis 3 months ago 3
Nice idea if you like car crashes. Get a mixer that can bring them both together on beat and key.
GFisher111 4 months ago
Would be better as a traditional mash-up. Can tell a lot of effort went into it, but they don't blend at all. Good try, good result for what you were going for, but completely unappealing.
theshawnmccoy 4 months ago
Really? Fuck you
Blakeislegend 4 months ago
david bovie version is shit
Purkku69 5 months ago
@Purkku69 Your spelling is shit.
NoblyRotten 4 months ago
loving both)
Andiya2 5 months ago
:D Klaus Nomi @ the beginning fuck yeah!
universalsingularity 5 months ago 2
Kurt's version is better. Hands down.
Destructionboy23 5 months ago
shit
woodsy1808 5 months ago
man yo cool !
summonmancer 5 months ago 2
Acabas de destruir una hermosa canción
0oRaMoNo0 5 months ago
And so, I quote " he said I was his friend "
but nevertheless " I never lost control "
DenisJUMONT 5 months ago
I love the "besides the fact that they're in different notes" comments....they're different notes....what is there besides that? lol. This is shit!
gavroash 5 months ago
THIS IS SHIT!
migueltorres10h 6 months ago
apart from the fct they sing on a different key is not bad..
Rosie69ism 6 months ago
А кто-то скрывал, что Курт играл каверы???
78Sla 6 months ago
They're both in different tunings altogether, I think.
MissingINo 6 months ago
its whack but at the same time its different really strange give hugo a break at least he tried to do something never been done..its only a video chill
paulbrink6 7 months ago 2
Poor Kurt looks so miserable and out of it.
ronnogold 7 months ago
if Bowie would finish like Curt, then... You know what i mean?
katt100ka 7 months ago
terrible
dagobertje 7 months ago
This is truly terrible, doesn't do justice to either artist and both versions of Bowies song are brilliant, when played on their own! Good collection of Bowie footage.
rrreckless 7 months ago
what is this shit !!!!
mar37able 7 months ago
What fucking numpty came up with this SHITE ! Wasting ma fuckin` time asshole !!
auto4union 7 months ago
Screw every one, I like it! It's catchy and funny! =)
L0vebuzZ13 7 months ago
Nirvana X 1000 = David Bowie
TheOpuzenac 7 months ago
This is terrible. =/
xJTxRipperx 7 months ago
this is actually stupid but cooll
AnnieLeeKennan 7 months ago
this sux
QAHN1 7 months ago
whoever made this is retarded
GiveMeMyWhammy 8 months ago
fake and gay
darkdota 8 months ago
@darkdota
R u a Fucking Retarded?
ricardosasuke 8 months ago
Without Bowie this song wouldn't exist..you morons!! Thanks David for a great song.
lala5732 8 months ago 3
whoever made this video clearly does not understand music. they are in DIFFERENT keys you moron. That is why it sounds like crap when you put them together.
gheffty93 9 months ago
thank God Nirvana covered this song. No disrespect but I really can't stand Bowie's voice. It is weird, creepy and he sounds like he has a gadget in his throat to make him speak because his throat was already terminated by cancer. NIRVANA rocks!
t0ny0ngBayawak 9 months ago
this makes my head fuckin hurt
ThePunkjeff 9 months ago
gay
zshot2188 9 months ago
bel montaggio complimenti
xanadu1987 10 months ago 7
checkout my cover of Man Who sold the world!!!
watch?v=TZUVZLhhXrE
unitom13 11 months ago
fuck this!
Kallicles 11 months ago
Not that I am condoning the competition here, but please...Bowie wins.
GregPellerin 11 months ago 2
i like david bowie but not in duet with kurt cobain sounds diferent sounds bad i like solo david bowie and with mick jagger it sounds better this style is not good for david bowie sing
fiiiiiiillliiiipa 11 months ago
nice but i prefere only kurt sing is this the new kurt or the one that died in1994 lol
fiiiiiiillliiiipa 11 months ago
nice editing!
greadion4 11 months ago
328 people sold the world
forgiventimes 11 months ago
This is pathetic....
spectrumalaska 1 year ago
wouldn't it have been cool if Bowie and Cobain really DID perform together :D
FarmGiraffe 1 year ago 2
This both sucks and blows
markx64 1 year ago
If they want to have them perform together then they should use the same computer apparatus like Natalie Cole did when she sang the duet with her father Nat in the great performance of Unforgettable!
frank02111 1 year ago
Do you have a check shirt and an IPOd and no understanding of music or culture CUNT!.
joebstarsurfer 1 year ago
95% of teens these days listen to the same crappy pop over and over again. If you're one of the 5% who still listens to real music, thumb this up, then copy & paste it to at least five videos. Don't let die the spirit of rock
Sabic18 1 year ago
This is David Bowie on stage and Nirvana on stage. But not together.
NoelleNabob 1 year ago
video S U C K S and is so disrespectful to both! !!
batbreath77 1 year ago
this video sucks. why would you lie to me.
306ness 1 year ago
you have to raise the nirvana one a semi-tone for it to work. They played a half step down for unplugged.
BeTheDeathOfMe 1 year ago
This sucks monkeyballs.
wotererio 1 year ago
wat did i just watch?
bru3d3rl3 1 year ago
i like david bowie, but this song doesn't appeal to me except for when nirvana plays it.
harshman121092 1 year ago
awesome job Hugo1138 thanx for the vid :D
eobo1 1 year ago 7
FAIL The worst iv evr herd-
Calminmind 1 year ago
this does'nt work, the sounds dont match
goopee76 1 year ago
La cagaron...
profugosradio 1 year ago 2
ces con
guiguihandy 1 year ago
please do not prosecute me lol. I kinda like the Idea but the voices just don't match. The guitars do. :) verry creative anyway
Dezedaantje 1 year ago
I guss you know witch one sounds better david bowie sucks
Elliott871 1 year ago
an obvious idea that doesn't work
TheAmosAnon 1 year ago
Before MTV Showed Rap-Crap
Kazdal567 1 year ago
this is ridiculous.
haircut74 1 year ago
SCREW YOU THIS SUCKS> NIRVANA IS THE BEST
jujo63 1 year ago
you must use a pitch because the song was played in 2 tones diferents. Nirvana play in Fb but David Bowie in F
LUCAX333 1 year ago
@LUCAX333 Dude, just cause I'm a music fanatic I have to point out, that there is No Fb, and look it up if you don't belive me. It goes from Eb to E to F....
Mocifer666 1 year ago
@Mocifer666 yes, you're right, Fb is E, sorry i wrote my coment fast and i don't think in it. But Fb=E.
LUCAX333 1 year ago
@Mocifer666 if you really knew anything about music beyond grade-school teachings, you would know that there is, indeed, an Fb. what there isn't is a KEY of Fb. maybe that's what you meant though, i can't be sure.
haircut74 1 year ago
@haircut74 If YOU knew anything beyond grade school teachings, You would know that Fb does NOT Exist.... The Chromatic scale Ab, A, Bb, B, C, Db, D, Eb, E, F, Gb, G. There Is NO Fb, but there is an E#, A.K.A F, however, Fb is not interchangeable with E. Use other Resources if you think I'm wrong.....
Mocifer666 1 year ago
@Mocifer666 i don't have to use other resources. this is basic material taught in first semester theory. if you really are a "music fanatic", you should take time to learn about the circle of fifths and various key signatures. the key of Cb is denoted by SEVEN flats, which means that a one-octave Cb major scale from tonic to tonic is Cb-Db-Eb-Fb-Gb-Ab-Bb-Cb.
haircut74 1 year ago
@haircut74 Look.... You seem reasonable..... So listen, I did NOT mean to start an argument, though I was simply just pointing out what I was told..... This is what I know.... Maybe I don't know as much about MUSIC, but I do know how to play a hell of a guitar.... In which case, since I won't use all but the basics, I look no further into it. Sorry for the inconvenience. I don't argue, however, Unless I think that I am correct.
Mocifer666 1 year ago
@Mocifer666 fair enough. but like i said, if you truly are a music enthusiast, some more in-depth theory is worth learning about. if you have the time to learn, it's pretty fascinating.
haircut74 1 year ago
@Mocifer666 here's another context in which Fb appears: a Gb major chord consists of Gb-Bb-Db, and the major seventh of the chord would be F. the minor seventh, of course, would then be Fb. it could NOT be E, because E would be a raised sixth. as you said, Fb is certainly not interchangeable with E; they are two separate notes, and likewise F and E# are not the same note. the pairs may be virtually the same pitches, but the context in which they are used is different.
haircut74 1 year ago
@LUCAX333
Mocifer666 is right...Next time you feel like sounding smart, Learn your facts. Thanks
Kingofmusic14 1 year ago
@Kingofmusic14 Thank you Kingofmusic14....
Mocifer666 1 year ago
@Kingofmusic14 actually they were both wrong. maybe you should take your own advice.
haircut74 1 year ago
@haircut74 Sorry, but Fb does not exist...All I have to do to prove this to you is have you look at a piano, or a guitar. Half step up from E is F and Half step down from F is E...I am sorry, this is plain and simple music knowledge. Try not to over think it
Kingofmusic14 1 year ago
@Kingofmusic14 the note below F on a piano COULD be E, and it usually is, but not always, just as the note above it can be F# OR Gb. but in any case, a piano isn't the best example, because it's tuned to work in any key, so most of the notes are not precise, because in reality they would be slightly different in different keys. look at my previous posts if you need further explanation. Fb does exist. that's advanced musical understanding, beyond "plain and simple music knowledge".
haircut74 1 year ago
wtf? i was thinkin this was a real performance
lawrence096 1 year ago
i like bowie a lot better than nirvana... but nirvana's version is much more like what the song is really meant to sound like... kurts voice fits it very well and i really dont like the phaser on bowie's.
payinattention225 1 year ago
Objective: David Bowie is a much better musician/performer than Kurt/Nirvana.
Subjective: While I really enjoy Bowie, I prefer Nirvana.
gongargongar 1 year ago
deadly .....
WarriorWican 1 year ago
pay attention to the bass in Bowie's version. it's like, 9032975819204853085297 times better than nirvana's version hahaha
Mepelicer 1 year ago
@Mepelicer no one cares about bass
SoxRockers50h4 1 year ago
@SoxRockers50h4 thats what YOU think.
Mepelicer 1 year ago
I preffer Nirvana's version
skullhacks78 1 year ago
@skullhacks78 yeh but bowie created that piece of gold
lawrence096 1 year ago
HORRIBLE MIX!!!
r0bertpe 1 year ago
David Bowie's sounds more "spacey", which is how it was meant to sound. Nirvana did an awesome version, though! :D
NightmareSnake 1 year ago
Worst piece of shit ever.
staphinfection 1 year ago
This is bloody dreadful. Who do I complain too?
Jacko499 1 year ago
Thank you ..I have watched this many times
tannagilder 1 year ago 3
This is possibly the worst idea ever, Bowie has some good stuff but lets face it, his version of this is terrible - original or not. ...also NOT EVEN THE SAME FUCKING KEY. WTF GARBAGE. ...ruins the otherwise amazing playlist this as on.
dimmeow 1 year ago
@dimmeow Jesus christ on a bicycle! Bowie fails.
feedusafetus 1 year ago 3
@dimmeow its the studio version...the one he did on snl is basically the one that nirvana covers
brabon1 1 year ago
David Bowie looks like Cristiano Ronaldo (soccer footballer) AAAA LLL OOO TTT haha....
luiskurt206 1 year ago
@luiskurt206 I feel sorry for Cristiano Ronaldo
SoxRockers50h4 1 year ago
@SoxRockers50h4 For a bad world cup performance ? or for looking like David Bowie??
luiskurt206 1 year ago
@luiskurt206 for looking like David Bowie. No one watches soccer.
SoxRockers50h4 1 year ago
@SoxRockers50h4 Where do you live dude under a rock, or ur moms basement ?
luiskurt206 1 year ago
@luiskurt206 in your mom's basement
SoxRockers50h4 1 year ago
Fun mix Thanks
rcpmac 1 year ago 6
Kurt cobain is waaaaaaay better
FAKEHUNTER33 1 year ago
what a mix a fag and a hype!!! Sounds like they sure met their fate together. Except one is dead and the other one will live forever...
tmill909 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Thank you Kurt for blessing us with your music. Only here for a short time but touched so many people. Nirvana and Grunge forever
warlock8268 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is sooooo annoying
anteaterattack 1 year ago
i love KURT COBAIN,NIRVANA ROCKS!!!!!
He was the best guitarist and musician of all time.
his music was peice of art
RIP KDC
with love from INDIA
ron
rajrahul00759 1 year ago
Nirvana use diff tuning in Unplugged from the original song so the matching is kinda weird when listening.Nice work though,legendary song...
hasteros 1 year ago 2
This is a really interesting idea - I have been playing around with similar concepts. Nice work.
hotlinkcinema 1 year ago 3
i prefer nirvanas version .
DreaDethklok14 1 year ago
stupid. youre gay.
briargoatkilla 1 year ago
could be funny if it wasn´t out of time. annoying
jetstream468 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Uploader is a jerk
simasgar 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is so fuckin fake
minibreadsticks 1 year ago
@minibreadsticks
No Shit, Sherlock
eternalXxXmemorys 1 year ago
nirvana sounds match better,,,,can i get a HELL YEAH,,,,,,,HELL YEAH
Jose38Angel 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what are your trying to do?
festereteMiguel 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol this is garbage
1justinc 1 year ago
If David Bowie didn't write/make this song then Nirvana wouldn't have been able to cover it. They're both as good as each other, stop being pathetic and enjoy the song.
xLFBx 1 year ago 41
@xLFBx i thought lou lou did it originally??
no1boxingfan 1 year ago
@xLFBx i think lulu did it first?? i could be wrong either way i think nirvana version is best of the 3
no1boxingfan 1 year ago
@xLFBx David Bowie didnt write this song, it was Lulu, in the 60's... But i agree to them both being as good as each other
tomsk0 1 year ago
@tomsk0 Sorry but Bowie brought this song out in 1971, and Lulu covered it in 1974
Frank83600 1 year ago
@xLFBx ...david bowie is better...Kurt Cobain is still the fucking man, don't get me wrong.
pills2103 1 year ago
@xLFBx its bands like nirvana and others that keep old classics alive!!! :D n bands do the same for nirvana now!!!!
crazy4baseball47 1 year ago
@xLFBx you have to say if they did record a version together it would of be great
thebeerfest2008 1 year ago
I prefer David Bowie.
Killer0770 1 year ago
lol 0:48 looks like david spade in ten years. i hate david spade...
xHAMRxNxSIKLx 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david bowie s version sucks love the nirvana one and kurt cobain
9876metallica 1 year ago
Kurt CoBowie
moominpic 1 year ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What fucked thing is this shit?
Julen1998 1 year ago
Comment removed
Julen1998 1 year ago
Is this Kurt Bowie or David Cobain.
dualisticnature 1 year ago 36
BOWIE IS ZIGGY ZIGGY IS GOD thats why wee cobainy sings it so much he`s tryin tae sound like the thin white duke.....its s Bowie universe
TheBowieman 1 year ago
Interesting....Bowie my 1st love but I Love Nirvana's just as much....see you can be across many generations & love them all!
Kurt said it...that was a David Bowie song.
pinkdreamz07 1 year ago 4
bowie is shit
kurt rocks
joker4705 1 year ago
HAHAHAHA you r so pathetic
gicooll 1 year ago
@joker4705 Bowie is ALIVE.
markthewhalekiller 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
any idiot can cut out bits of text from a magazine and write the lyrics to a song, Bowie does look queer as fuck and should know better for an old git
davejb23 1 year ago
This would have sounded better if they both played in the same key.
secular555 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
How could you even compare? I wouldnt listen to this song if it wasnt redone by nirvana and i probably wouldnt even know it if it wasnt, colbain has a way better voice, hes gota unique sound, and its grunge and i fuckin love it, bowie just sounds overly queer and retarded. Hands down Nirvana.
sandcrawler22 1 year ago
you sound homophobic.....maybe your scared of your own sexual feelings,your a pure gay boy lol
ThePistolpete1963 1 year ago
Bowie is good and all but Kurt's is way better sorry
SithAssassin91 1 year ago
bowies version is much better than curt cobains by a longshot....cobain over-rated shite!!! terrible
ThePistolpete1963 1 year ago 2
you Siirrrrr smell like an overzellar pile of feceus, baking casually in a hot California sun. I SAY GOOD-AY SAAIIRR!!
sandcrawler22 1 year ago
your a prat ,we are all entitled to our opinion no need for the abuse,i dont like curt simple as
ThePistolpete1963 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
awfull, sorry....
Pierrot7991 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is the worst video EVER!
ratbastrd669 1 year ago
APESTA ESTA VERSION
ivnvandyk 1 year ago
fuck bowie it sounds stupid when he sings lol
EgagLatsev 1 year ago
your an idiot bowie does not sound stupid
thexfiles214 1 year ago
@thexfiles214 not to his fag ass fanboys..... but to us "idiots" who prefer a guitar to a synth YES he does sound pretty stupid....
kurt made bowies ramblings sounds like an actual song
EgagLatsev 1 year ago
Well at least bowies not constantly mumbling the song when he sings it. Its pure preference who you like better but you dont need to say stupid things ok LOL
thexfiles214 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This was bad to mash up. Nirvana played and sang it tuned 1/2 step down so it sounds way out of tune when it changes between the two of them.
thanas1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Why would you do such a terrible thing?!?!?! I'm crying now...so wrong man! I couldn't go past 19 seconds!
KrazySpydrLady 2 years ago
wow... if your crying over this you must be an emofag
rodneytheincontinent 2 years ago
-__- You troll so much,
iSorrowproductions 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
david bowie is so fucking gay nirvana is way better
applecody 2 years ago
faggot
wutzi2004 2 years ago
lol based on what?
Pufflelumps 2 years ago
@applecody: David Bowie wasn't the one who gave a shotgun a blowjob.
LeeHasNoImagination 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LEFTY HANDED ,FTW :D
slakchen4ever 2 years ago