It was broadcast live on network tv, Had it been a pre-recorded cable show where content warnings exist there would have been no issue with the incident, The Superbowl is advertised and promoted as safe family friendly entertainment not something people go in expecting to see exposed boobs and genitals being flashed into their tv sets live.
Barbara certainly looks like she enjoys being the hottest person in that room, and all the attention she gets for it from that grouplet of drooling misfits.
I miss the days when we really were the masses, and not just a handful of awkward geeks with horrid social skills.
@IrishFrisco why would they? socialism was never about being hungry. In fact it's about consume as much as you have worked for. As opposed to capitalism which is consume as much as other people have produced.
@canuckleful ...we didn't practise socialism, but appeasement of every crackpot pressure group in existance, from separatists, gays, feminists, to indians and new immigrants.....the working man was left abandonned after the 1946 steelworkers strike
@canuckleful i don't know the canadian economic system but unless you own the means of your production you are not socialist, a basic socialist tenet, you must control the workpolace
With all respect but if you would live for some time in Soviet Union or even People Republic of Poland not mention the North Korea, you would not like communism. I know what I am saying I am Polish. You know, we are not coming to the UK because its capitalism in Poland, but because we still have great economy problems which started before 1989. I read Marx I think its really noble ideas, but I am too afraid that it might repeat, economy depression, terror, no libery. Good Bless Great Britain.
If you really read Marx please don't use the term "communism" to refer to societies that are clearly not communist. Now whether they represented true "dictatorship of the proletariat" is debatable.
@SuperKam08 those regimes had nothing to do with communism. No human group ever could make communism reality simple because humans are unable to produce as much as they want to consume. You have communism in Star Trek but they have repilcators and virtually unlimited amount of raw material and energy
INTERNACIONALE bangunlah rakyat yg tertindas bangkitlah untuk melawan dalam ridho ALLAH yg kuasa kekuatan semakin besar lenyapkan diktator dan tirani rakyat mendukung dan sadar wajah dunia sudah berubah demi kemenangan kita perjuangan yg terakhir bersatulah kawan peri kemanusiaan jayalah didunia
Sung a bit slow and regardless I enjoy the billy braggs version more as its much more modern and easier to understand for those who cannot interpret older english.
Communism means oppression and suffering for the individual. It legitimises the enslavement of entire peoples and even justifies genocide. (Read Friedrich Engels: Der magyarische Kampf)
In the case of the US, it'sn not even money-grabbing politicians, they're now whores of the all-powerful, all-usury corporations who truly rule the country and even the minds of millions of people.
Communism and National SOCIALISM originate from the same source. Both totalitarian regimes committed genocide and inflicted incredible suffering on millions of people.
Marx's vision required a fundamental change in nature of the human condition. In that respect it's akin to all kinds of secular political extremism. While a small number of people might be capable of changing their personalities, the vast majority are not. Very few people either desire to be or are capable of becoming "Marxian man." It just isn't going to happen, so stop holding out for it.
Great, keep chasing an unreachable goal. Say, why is there no communism today? I'll tell you why: Because there will always be people who want power and luxuriancy and won't stop at anything in order to achieve this.
ya ya heard that before. Another case of the barbarous fascists/communists and socialists not taking responsibility for there actions. Marx in real life was practiced capitalism and preached communism just like all the hypocritical socialists and communists of today. In his life time he was known to be a idle bore living off the avails of others when NOT practicing capitalism.
@053bss You know, there were many countries that tried the Marxist experiment, in the 20th Century, and none of them panned out as you so described. Why?
I lived under the Soviet system and am proud of my parents for their courage in fighting communism in the 1980s and achieving independence for my country, from the soviet-russian totalitarianism. Social-democracy is one thing but soul-crushing, red-flag waving monstrosity, the Gulags, the stalinist terror - we had to live with that for 70 years and I wouldnt wish it on anyone. I burned by red pioneer tie in 1991, as they puled Lenin's statue down in Baku city square and I cheered.
Because capitalism doesn't exist. Capitalism is a economic and social "system" in which the means of production are in private hands. A government can't possibly be capitalist, indeed, it excludes capitalism. Western governments are actually corporatist/fascist.
What's all this silliness about looking forward to China's hegemony? You want to trade one screw for another? Why don't you want to be free? Freedom is not communism or capitalism - Freedom is Anarchy! Down with all these Statist solutions! They have brought us nothing but war, genocide, poverty, mental disillusionment, spiritual death and darkness. I will not answer to Corporate America or the Chinese Polit Bureau, I will answer only to myself. Liberty, Equality and Brotherhood!
It is human nature to want and strive for better things in life. Capitalism and free enterprise have been the building blocks of today's world of global technology and scientific infrastructure. In short, I would rather be dead than...RED.
Is it also human nature to bring other people down to get "the best" for yourself? No. Humans are intelligent. We are not simply like any other animal. A very good example is imperialist powers like America exploiting the labour in third world countries as much as they dare do so. If you think this is a good thing you're cold blooded and don't give a shit about anyone else.
It's human nature to want and strive for better conditions in life... for all. Capitalism has created a lot of things, but only grants it to a certain few. With the resources now created by this system, socialism can help distribute it and put good use to it by making it available for all.
Millions in Russia, China, Korea marched to their deaths in prison camps to The Internationale. "You're either with us, or against us" - the official term was dictatorship of the proletariat.
World Revolution is the only solution for Marx peace, order, dignity, justice, humanity & equality to vastly improve conditions for future generations. The less than 1% ruling class Capitalist brutality has failed the masses by betraying us into widepread chaotic poverty striving in declining desperation just to make ends while the elite continues to benefit in their regressive, right wing status quo dogmas in most countries like here, Mexico and Singapore where socialist voices are crushed!
So you guys are willing to nationalize your own property? ;)
Communism can't work it's against common human even zoological nature .We've seen that in many cases. Besides who can support something which defends and approves genocide.
Well maybe communism didn't work because it started in so called "racial trash societies", like post-feudal and not capitalist Russia or China, according to Marx.
I don't support communism or socialism, but to say "it goes against human nature" ignores studies of human societies.
Yes humans engage in conflict with each other to gain extra resources. But they also cooperate with each other and share with people in their circle, all the way from hunter-gatherer societies to a group of lads out on the lash and one of them gets a round for the group.
Saying that communism didn't work is to be ignorant of history. Communism helped millions of people out of starvation. Before it, Russia was 300 years behind Europe in development, afterwards it lagged only slightly behind. Maoism improved life expectancy in China from 35 to 65 years in a timespan of 20 years. People had job security, and the USSR printed 3 out of every 5 books in the world. There were problems with bureaurocracy and authoritarianism, but not ones which couldn't be overcome.
President Obama says he does not want the government to get into the business of making cars. Instead, he wants to put GM back into the hands of private investors within 18 months. This makes no sense. Private investors are not interested in the long -term needs of workers, our communities or the environment; instead they are driven by the goal of maximizing their short-term profit.
So you guys are willing to nationalize your own property? ;)
Communism can't work it's against common human even zoological nature .We've seen that in many cases. Besides who can support something which defends and approves genocide.
Well maybe communism didn't work because it started in so called "racial trash societies", like post-feudal and not capitalist Russia or China, according to Marx.
Not a society I would want to live in... ie one where corporations and profit come before the well being of people. Government acting on behalf of profit and not people is a terrible thought and anyone who thinks it is a good idea, in my opinion, has some sort of mental illness.
@nwsocialist very well-said. We have tolerated a system that has destroyed lives and blamed the victims too long. The corporate parties only serve their pay-masters, not the people.
I think it is hilarious the people who comment on how Socialism has failed or has led to millions of deaths. The deaths that Capitalism has brought on this world, the environmental destruction, the ignorance it wishes to impose, is a far greater toll. Socialism is liberation, socialism is democracy and not the illusion of choice that is petty bourgeoisie democracy.
Sorry it has taken so long to add some of these comments... for some reason they had come up on my computer as "approved" some time ago.
My policy is to approve comments as long as they do not insult those in the film. Political debate etc it allowed... personal insult and obscenities are not.
@nwsocialist LOL Censorship, I mean Socialism, at work. Now where do we find censorship. Let me think . . . Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela. Yep, that's the ticket.
Yet another example of hypocrisy by illiterate bourgeoisie reactionaries. What about wikileaks censorship? Is this the work of "child-eating commies"? I don't think so.
btw, There is no censorship in Venezuela. The bourgeoisie propaganda is still strong in Venezuela.
Anyone know where I can find a good mp3 of this song with the lyrics just sung? The Billy Bragg version I have is good but I want more traditional lyrics.
100% of Communist countries turned out to be oppressive dictatorships which gave it's people nothing but tyranny.
There was no freedom of speech, freedom of political thought, freedom of political parties, freedom of political thought, nor freedom of movement.
Yet, you still get plenty of priviliged people born in the luxury of the West, whom use their freedom of speech and political thought to defend "communist" countries which deny their own people the rights they so enjoy.
a poet appears at the moment of loss.this great song was written by one of the leaders of the paris commune who survived the masscre. a neocon columnist of a boulevard paper wrote that it shows a weakness in our race that everyone who has maid something important in this world has been on the left. indiviualism is dead wirh neolibralism.werner jaeger ends his ghreat work on the greek civilization that polis was the school which educated socrat,plato,aristotele-polis>politics>polite.,thx barb
Hahahah......Historically this idea has failed and will undoubtedly run its course to failure againSo much for creative critical thinking. ..Same old rhetoric, the faces change the story is the same.
nothing has died nothing is lost..i think we all have seen two days ago the rusians at the red square protesting with communist flags and banners with lenin's face on there shirts against the goverment because the goverment helps only the companies and the profit!
The goal of the red menace is world domination. Lenin had a term for his followers "useful idiots". And as he said "words are one thing, actions another" and "promises are like pie crusts, made to be broken". The communist plan for world empire is not finished, it's just intensified covertly.
@orkneymist
It was broadcast live on network tv, Had it been a pre-recorded cable show where content warnings exist there would have been no issue with the incident, The Superbowl is advertised and promoted as safe family friendly entertainment not something people go in expecting to see exposed boobs and genitals being flashed into their tv sets live.
Obasiliasfilosofos 6 months ago
Greetings Scottish Comrades from Mexico.
KGBspartan4 8 months ago
Thank you for socialism. If we had socialism in Czech Republic our living standard was better than in present in capitalism era...
Lance01011 8 months ago 6
solidarity for an independent socialist Scotland comrades*****
workergirls 9 months ago
Barbara certainly looks like she enjoys being the hottest person in that room, and all the attention she gets for it from that grouplet of drooling misfits.
I miss the days when we really were the masses, and not just a handful of awkward geeks with horrid social skills.
iVenge 9 months ago
The Internationale sung by Barbara Scott nwsocialist 64 videos Subscribe Subscribed
ac3761G 10 months ago
So comrades, come rally
And the last fight let us face
The Internationale unites the human race.
wesleysonic 11 months ago
Danke für das Video!!!
Rotfontler 11 months ago
The socialists of Scotland do not look like they have missed too many meals.,
IrishFrisco 1 year ago
@IrishFrisco What an idiotic comment.
snakemanmike 1 year ago
@IrishFrisco why would they? socialism was never about being hungry. In fact it's about consume as much as you have worked for. As opposed to capitalism which is consume as much as other people have produced.
sondano 8 months ago
In my nation of Canada, we used to practice wonderful Socialism. We're dwindling. God forbid we become capitalists too.
canuckleful 1 year ago 5
@canuckleful ...we didn't practise socialism, but appeasement of every crackpot pressure group in existance, from separatists, gays, feminists, to indians and new immigrants.....the working man was left abandonned after the 1946 steelworkers strike
jethro035181 11 months ago
@canuckleful i don't know the canadian economic system but unless you own the means of your production you are not socialist, a basic socialist tenet, you must control the workpolace
symphonythree 10 months ago
red front from korea/DPRK
paul476hong 1 year ago
With all respect but if you would live for some time in Soviet Union or even People Republic of Poland not mention the North Korea, you would not like communism. I know what I am saying I am Polish. You know, we are not coming to the UK because its capitalism in Poland, but because we still have great economy problems which started before 1989. I read Marx I think its really noble ideas, but I am too afraid that it might repeat, economy depression, terror, no libery. Good Bless Great Britain.
SuperKam08 1 year ago
@SuperKam08
That is not REAL Communism.
SAOS451316 1 year ago
@SuperKam08 So why doesnt your capitalism in Poland fix all your problems since 1989??? Why you leave your country for bankrupt Ireland????!!!!!
arakhachatran 1 year ago
@SuperKam08
If you really read Marx please don't use the term "communism" to refer to societies that are clearly not communist. Now whether they represented true "dictatorship of the proletariat" is debatable.
squathacker 1 year ago
@SuperKam08 those regimes had nothing to do with communism. No human group ever could make communism reality simple because humans are unable to produce as much as they want to consume. You have communism in Star Trek but they have repilcators and virtually unlimited amount of raw material and energy
sondano 8 months ago
@SuperKam08 Communism was only in prehistory... We had socialism in Czech Republic, and it was too much better than present capitalism...
Lance01011 8 months ago
@Lance01011 I think the greatest model of Communism was Native American tribes.
Grant691 5 months ago 6
regards comrades
simon1ftm 1 year ago
Just beautiful .Great performance .Glorious words.
Thanks uploader.
herbaissimo 1 year ago
Hail Comrades!
From Italy!
rememberhiswords 1 year ago
I feel a lot better for hearing that.
xx
moosey62 1 year ago
utopian dream....
Slimiuz 1 year ago
Uau, this was nice. would love to be there
ydox 1 year ago
keep the faith strong American comrades...
yancypelter 1 year ago
LAW IS THE RIGHTS OF THE WORKERS AND NOT THE PROFITS OF THE CAPITALISTS!
NO PASARAN
HASTA LA VICTORIA SIEMPRE!
Scatmanfi 1 year ago
Viva il comunismo!
yuri290583 1 year ago
saluti comunisti dall'Italia, viva il socialismo, lunga vita ai compagni
yuri290583 1 year ago
excellent! So many people watching this gives us hope for the future!
MsThistledo 1 year ago
RED FRONT AND RESPECT TO THE RED BANNER
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
RED FRONT FROM DENMARK:-)
SuperAcab666 1 year ago
free scotland. independence now.
TheFuckengland 1 year ago
cakgopar 1 year ago
black power
luckyD1993 1 year ago
One world, one humanity!
victorydayof91945 1 year ago 2
The party is always right!
wijse 1 year ago
Lotsa empty seats ...
JerseyExits 1 year ago
Lovely rendition - greetings to all Scottish comrades from Derby :)
avinabacca 1 year ago
Great song and performance.
Glory to the Red banner!
RKKAsoldier 1 year ago 3
greetings from greece my scotish comrades :)
MaRaX93 1 year ago 5
bankers ?!
Guevarist 1 year ago
@Guevarist Right? I thought the same thing. I hope they meant bank tellers.
martini1179 1 year ago
Sung a bit slow and regardless I enjoy the billy braggs version more as its much more modern and easier to understand for those who cannot interpret older english.
Aerolineas747 1 year ago
Great song and performance. Long live Socialism! Keep the red flag flying high!
RKKAsoldier 1 year ago
Great song and performance. Long live Socialism! Keep the red flag flying high!
RKKAsoldier 1 year ago
Great song and performance. Long live Socialism! Keep the red flag flying high!
RKKAsoldier 1 year ago
Great song and performance. Long live Socialism! Keep the red flag flying high!
RKKAsoldier 1 year ago
beautifull
sebidelpi 1 year ago
Did she just sing "criminals"? What the hell, isn't that what the line says, that they are prisoners even though they're NOT criminals?
Seriously... who let this woman sing the Internationale...
VintageJunior 1 year ago
blue shirt guy rises wrong fist :)
greatestdirector 1 year ago
good video. :)
MrRedFredSaid 1 year ago
Which fist up? Left or right???
nonix14 1 year ago
Great video
TreblePop 2 years ago
Great video.
TreblePop 2 years ago
What a lovely voice she has. Thanks for posting, Comrade
TreblePop 2 years ago
What a delightful video. She has such a beautiful voice. Thank you so much for sharing this.
TreblePop 2 years ago
Это есть наш последний
И решительный бой;
С Интернационалом
Воспрянет род людской!
Brothers ann sisters! We will struggle against worlds capitalistic sistem! Lets built new happy world!
databknight 2 years ago
Starvelings? They don't look like they're starving...
michalm2 2 years ago
Workers of the World, Unite!
Empyyrical 2 years ago
Ugga, ugga
OuryJalloh 2 years ago
She is so powerful...
***** for Barbara, the SSP and this song!!!
HierKommtMicha 2 years ago
excellent!
iLikeDragon 2 years ago
yeah its the woman if you listen all the people are trying to sing quicker lol
Rmg12 2 years ago
Could anybody let me know who Barbara Scott is, please?
blablabla1185 2 years ago
Who is Barbara Scott?
blablabla1185 2 years ago
Invented, Written by a French, music by a Belgian.
Zuxair 2 years ago 12
Long live communism!!
EmperorChiCheung 2 years ago 81
@EmperorChiCheung
Communism means oppression and suffering for the individual. It legitimises the enslavement of entire peoples and even justifies genocide. (Read Friedrich Engels: Der magyarische Kampf)
OstpreussenTV 2 years ago
capitalism and fascism are two sides of the same barbarian coin...
workers of the world unite against the money grabbing politicians...
Long live great communist revolutions !!!
Death to fascist and capitalist monsters !!!
workergirls 2 years ago 29
In the case of the US, it'sn not even money-grabbing politicians, they're now whores of the all-powerful, all-usury corporations who truly rule the country and even the minds of millions of people.
caliaa 2 years ago
@workergirls
Communism and National SOCIALISM originate from the same source. Both totalitarian regimes committed genocide and inflicted incredible suffering on millions of people.
OstpreussenTV 2 years ago
@workergirls Keep the world tidy: Kill fascists.
sabradan 2 years ago
capitalism and fascism are two sides of the same barbarian coin...
workers of the world unite against the money grabbing politicians...
Long live great communist revolutions !!!
Death to fascist and capitalist monsters !!!
workergirls 2 years ago
Communism is nice thing to sing, but very uncomfortable place to live
stasbsokolov 2 years ago
What was practiced in the soviet union under Stalin and afterwards was not communism, it was state barbarism and bureaucracy.
True communism, Marx's vision, is the purest form of democracy: freedom to think and freedom to learn.
053bss 2 years ago 107
what i learned whas that Lenin warned about stalin but he got killed in south america if true wonder who killed him ;)
metalcokka 2 years ago
Marx's vision required a fundamental change in nature of the human condition. In that respect it's akin to all kinds of secular political extremism. While a small number of people might be capable of changing their personalities, the vast majority are not. Very few people either desire to be or are capable of becoming "Marxian man." It just isn't going to happen, so stop holding out for it.
MJMedin 2 years ago
The only freedom democracy gives is the freedom to choose your own supressor.
myusernameisluc 1 year ago
Great, keep chasing an unreachable goal. Say, why is there no communism today? I'll tell you why: Because there will always be people who want power and luxuriancy and won't stop at anything in order to achieve this.
MoaiMaea 1 year ago
@MoaiMaea
No, there is no communism because of ignorant, selfish bourgeoisie reactionaries like you.
The failures of the socialist/anarchists revolutions are not the revolutionaries' fault. They failed because the reaction was stronger.
squathacker 1 year ago
@053bss
It would not, cause communism doesn't mean democracy also they were bolsheviks.
tanamshromely 1 year ago
@053bss
ya ya heard that before. Another case of the barbarous fascists/communists and socialists not taking responsibility for there actions. Marx in real life was practiced capitalism and preached communism just like all the hypocritical socialists and communists of today. In his life time he was known to be a idle bore living off the avails of others when NOT practicing capitalism.
deusimperator 1 year ago
@053bss You know, there were many countries that tried the Marxist experiment, in the 20th Century, and none of them panned out as you so described. Why?
TenderTrap86 11 months ago
@053bss
yeah, right. There is as much freedom in communism as there is privacy.
spiritmartyr009 10 months ago
I lived under the Soviet system and am proud of my parents for their courage in fighting communism in the 1980s and achieving independence for my country, from the soviet-russian totalitarianism. Social-democracy is one thing but soul-crushing, red-flag waving monstrosity, the Gulags, the stalinist terror - we had to live with that for 70 years and I wouldnt wish it on anyone. I burned by red pioneer tie in 1991, as they puled Lenin's statue down in Baku city square and I cheered.
Muradski 2 years ago
true true ... maybe one day people will uderstand the socialism as Marks uderstood it. But now i guess is impossible.
thisismadness08 1 year ago
Well, Stellarblue. If capitalism is so enterprising how come two thirds of the earth's population go to bed hungry every day.
You're right, people do want to better themselves, but it would be nice if everyone had a chance to improve their lot
without the fear of war crime or poverty
unclephil440 2 years ago 13
Because of barriers to free trade and political corruption and lack of safety.
MJMedin 2 years ago
@Unclephil440 -
Too damned true, Comrade!
GayTexanCommunist 2 years ago
Because capitalism doesn't exist. Capitalism is a economic and social "system" in which the means of production are in private hands. A government can't possibly be capitalist, indeed, it excludes capitalism. Western governments are actually corporatist/fascist.
myusernameisluc 1 year ago
FAKED
gregmitch 2 years ago
Workers of the world unite!
exatreide 2 years ago 7
Take God, Take Marx, Take Proletariat
SMASH CAPITALISM AND ITS FASCIST SERVANTS
mikirso 2 years ago 3
What's all this silliness about looking forward to China's hegemony? You want to trade one screw for another? Why don't you want to be free? Freedom is not communism or capitalism - Freedom is Anarchy! Down with all these Statist solutions! They have brought us nothing but war, genocide, poverty, mental disillusionment, spiritual death and darkness. I will not answer to Corporate America or the Chinese Polit Bureau, I will answer only to myself. Liberty, Equality and Brotherhood!
CapitalistAnarcho 2 years ago
We have nothing to lose except owr chains
good communism is JESUS Communism
theAmbrosian 2 years ago
Take God, Take Marx, Take People
SMASH CAPITALISM AND ITS FASCIST GUARDS
mikirso 2 years ago 3
to quote Marx
"Religion is the opium of the people"
so I will have to respectfully disagree with you comrade
arialchambersguitar 2 years ago
True :)
RSDRPtheGreat 2 years ago
But Marx was dreadfully wrong, look at the mess that Marxism did in Russia, where there was so much promise. Put the anticipation back 100 years.
That means 100 years or repression at the hands of our capitalist masters.
stanleymaiden 2 years ago
Are you familiar with the ENTIRE quote by Marx?
SouthPhillyHooligan 2 years ago
You realize this isn't a quote from Marx, right?
ick9192 2 years ago
Youtube,best place for communism cos it sure as hell doesnt belong in the real world.
nicebut670 2 years ago
It is human nature to want and strive for better things in life. Capitalism and free enterprise have been the building blocks of today's world of global technology and scientific infrastructure. In short, I would rather be dead than...RED.
stellarblue51 2 years ago
Is it also human nature to bring other people down to get "the best" for yourself? No. Humans are intelligent. We are not simply like any other animal. A very good example is imperialist powers like America exploiting the labour in third world countries as much as they dare do so. If you think this is a good thing you're cold blooded and don't give a shit about anyone else.
d06omtas 2 years ago
that's why our world is in such a great condition:
We have great technology, but also:
*) greed
*) earth destruction
*) poverty (caused by western countries)
*) corruption
*) torture
*) corporate dictatorships
*) children labor
...shall I go on ????
rezaroosi 2 years ago
It's human nature to want and strive for better conditions in life... for all. Capitalism has created a lot of things, but only grants it to a certain few. With the resources now created by this system, socialism can help distribute it and put good use to it by making it available for all.
awkwardhawk 2 years ago 11
Millions in Russia, China, Korea marched to their deaths in prison camps to The Internationale. "You're either with us, or against us" - the official term was dictatorship of the proletariat.
ortomortare 2 years ago
Evil american empire will collapse
in five years.
China will be next world hegemonic state after the United States.
The fall of the West and the revival of the
East.
windrunhiraken 2 years ago 6
World Revolution is the only solution for Marx peace, order, dignity, justice, humanity & equality to vastly improve conditions for future generations. The less than 1% ruling class Capitalist brutality has failed the masses by betraying us into widepread chaotic poverty striving in declining desperation just to make ends while the elite continues to benefit in their regressive, right wing status quo dogmas in most countries like here, Mexico and Singapore where socialist voices are crushed!
classickc 2 years ago 11
Long life all socialist partys let the people unite!
daco145 2 years ago 17
My God! I have fallen in love with her voice - but then it may be genetic.
Sempre Fi from the Veterans For Peace
redscott77777 2 years ago
Sempre Fi
from the Veterans For Peace
redscott77777 2 years ago
Sempre Fi
from America's Veterans For Peaces
redscott77777 2 years ago
Happy International Worker's Day from Las Vegas, Nevada, USA!
MrUnidyne 2 years ago
Happy International Worker's Day from Las Vegas, Nevada, USA!
MrUnidyne 2 years ago
So you guys are willing to nationalize your own property? ;)
Communism can't work it's against common human even zoological nature .We've seen that in many cases. Besides who can support something which defends and approves genocide.
Well maybe communism didn't work because it started in so called "racial trash societies", like post-feudal and not capitalist Russia or China, according to Marx.
SloveintzWend 2 years ago
I don't support communism or socialism, but to say "it goes against human nature" ignores studies of human societies.
Yes humans engage in conflict with each other to gain extra resources. But they also cooperate with each other and share with people in their circle, all the way from hunter-gatherer societies to a group of lads out on the lash and one of them gets a round for the group.
ccfc73 2 years ago
sloveintzWend, you have no idea. how does communism support or approve genocide?
anongoat 2 years ago 7
Communism and Corporatism - these are two sides of the same coin. Either way you are a slave.
CapitalistAnarcho 2 years ago
Saying that communism didn't work is to be ignorant of history. Communism helped millions of people out of starvation. Before it, Russia was 300 years behind Europe in development, afterwards it lagged only slightly behind. Maoism improved life expectancy in China from 35 to 65 years in a timespan of 20 years. People had job security, and the USSR printed 3 out of every 5 books in the world. There were problems with bureaurocracy and authoritarianism, but not ones which couldn't be overcome.
TheNomadicMonad 2 years ago 6
President Obama says he does not want the government to get into the business of making cars. Instead, he wants to put GM back into the hands of private investors within 18 months. This makes no sense. Private investors are not interested in the long -term needs of workers, our communities or the environment; instead they are driven by the goal of maximizing their short-term profit.
liamkeating95 2 years ago
So you guys are willing to nationalize your own property? ;)
Communism can't work it's against common human even zoological nature .We've seen that in many cases. Besides who can support something which defends and approves genocide.
Well maybe communism didn't work because it started in so called "racial trash societies", like post-feudal and not capitalist Russia or China, according to Marx.
SloveintzWend 2 years ago
And your point is...?
FellingPX 2 years ago
Not a society I would want to live in... ie one where corporations and profit come before the well being of people. Government acting on behalf of profit and not people is a terrible thought and anyone who thinks it is a good idea, in my opinion, has some sort of mental illness.
nwsocialist 2 years ago 11
@nwsocialist
Indeed!
NancyFrQC 1 year ago
@nwsocialist very well-said. We have tolerated a system that has destroyed lives and blamed the victims too long. The corporate parties only serve their pay-masters, not the people.
hollywoodartchick 1 year ago
Solidarity from NYC.
SAOR ALBA !
OrlopRat42 2 years ago 3
Long long life for Scottish socialist Party!
Greeting from China
jy00547037 2 years ago 5
Sa internacionalom ujedinit ljudski rod :D
solidarity from city of split
menstruacija 2 years ago 4
Je salue mes frères et soeurs écossais!
CrapaudReste 2 years ago 2
right hand.......
bauldfenian 2 years ago
solidarity from Portugal
Lisbon1906 2 years ago 4
What a voice! What a song! Well done the Scottish socialist Party!
plottracer 2 years ago 6
*sniff sniff*
DizzerJoz 2 years ago 3
Hi people , there are different extents of socialism, can somebody message me and tell me exactly how they view a perfect socialist state?
danceillusions13 2 years ago
Solidarity comrades!
BolivarianYouth 2 years ago 5
hello from the US my socialism brothers and sisters
Manbehinddemask 2 years ago 6
Deppen
m8484 2 years ago
Well I think in German and Russian it's much better.
getfreebeer 2 years ago
Long Live Socialism and Friendship among Nations!
Greetings to the Scottish Comrades!
IvanKolosnik 2 years ago 7
Viva Socialism!...from Washington, DC
somersetdc 2 years ago 5
Terve toveri!
greetings from finland
aktivisti92 2 years ago 4
though i am a Communist,i have doubt now..
jadebai 2 years ago
this is superb.
TheEqualiser00 2 years ago
I think it is hilarious the people who comment on how Socialism has failed or has led to millions of deaths. The deaths that Capitalism has brought on this world, the environmental destruction, the ignorance it wishes to impose, is a far greater toll. Socialism is liberation, socialism is democracy and not the illusion of choice that is petty bourgeoisie democracy.
DaBuschhof 2 years ago
Salutations, Scottish Comrades!
United we will break the chains of the Global Financial Capital!
IvanKolosnik 2 years ago
Salutations, Scottish Comrades!
United we will break the chains of the Global Financial Capital!
IvanKolosnik 2 years ago
you fascist! let me comment!!
cb82fan 2 years ago
Anyone where I can find an english version with the above lyrics? All I have is the Billy Bragg version.
cb82fan 2 years ago
Anyone where I can find an english version with the above lyrics? All I have is the Billy Bragg version.
cb82fan 2 years ago
Sorry it has taken so long to add some of these comments... for some reason they had come up on my computer as "approved" some time ago.
My policy is to approve comments as long as they do not insult those in the film. Political debate etc it allowed... personal insult and obscenities are not.
nwsocialist 2 years ago
@nwsocialist LOL Censorship, I mean Socialism, at work. Now where do we find censorship. Let me think . . . Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Korea, Venezuela. Yep, that's the ticket.
antinotis 1 year ago
@antinotis
Yet another example of hypocrisy by illiterate bourgeoisie reactionaries. What about wikileaks censorship? Is this the work of "child-eating commies"? I don't think so.
btw, There is no censorship in Venezuela. The bourgeoisie propaganda is still strong in Venezuela.
squathacker 1 year ago
@nwsocialist approved comments? oh thats right you dont believe in freedom of speech,
oiyabastard 1 year ago
Anyone know where I can find a good mp3 of this song with the lyrics just sung? The Billy Bragg version I have is good but I want more traditional lyrics.
cb82fan 2 years ago
100% of Communist countries turned out to be oppressive dictatorships which gave it's people nothing but tyranny.
There was no freedom of speech, freedom of political thought, freedom of political parties, freedom of political thought, nor freedom of movement.
Yet, you still get plenty of priviliged people born in the luxury of the West, whom use their freedom of speech and political thought to defend "communist" countries which deny their own people the rights they so enjoy.
Hypocrites
yington 3 years ago
Oh yeah y'all
Let the people die... let the greedheads take it all.
....
Let's see how y'all like living in gated communities hoarding the food and water... and gold... ha ha.
Have a good life idiots.
CleoPatricia999 3 years ago
a poet appears at the moment of loss.this great song was written by one of the leaders of the paris commune who survived the masscre. a neocon columnist of a boulevard paper wrote that it shows a weakness in our race that everyone who has maid something important in this world has been on the left. indiviualism is dead wirh neolibralism.werner jaeger ends his ghreat work on the greek civilization that polis was the school which educated socrat,plato,aristotele-polis>politics>polite.,thx barb
ronsku13 3 years ago
read none dare call it conspiracy
ayebretwalda 3 years ago
Hahahah......Historically this idea has failed and will undoubtedly run its course to failure againSo much for creative critical thinking. ..Same old rhetoric, the faces change the story is the same.
Long live individualism
outrider888 3 years ago
nothing has died nothing is lost..i think we all have seen two days ago the rusians at the red square protesting with communist flags and banners with lenin's face on there shirts against the goverment because the goverment helps only the companies and the profit!
jsoviet 2 years ago 4
The goal of the red menace is world domination. Lenin had a term for his followers "useful idiots". And as he said "words are one thing, actions another" and "promises are like pie crusts, made to be broken". The communist plan for world empire is not finished, it's just intensified covertly.
Jihadist 3 years ago
Where did you get those quotes? I am interested to know. I don't remember reading that.
SoveriegnLeviathan 3 years ago
And the capitalist plan for world empire is right there, all around you. In fact it's not anymore a plan, it's reality. You are not free.
Mournslay 2 years ago
sooo why don't you people move to cuba or north korea or even my own country vietnam already? fuck-heads...
minhtung91 3 years ago
I am not sure if you would want some of those people in your country.
SoveriegnLeviathan 3 years ago
My faith is the Communism
i am a chinese
451232007 3 years ago 10
you guys are doing it completely wrong
vainprop 2 years ago
I agree Comrade, China is not Marxist in any way.
Eddyking5 1 year ago
Proletariat of the world unite
451232007 3 years ago 10
Glory to Capitalism long live Freedom and Democracy!
tubub 3 years ago
bourgeoisie Democracy ;]
zania1993 2 years ago 4
This was in the days when the Scottish Socialist Party were doing well.Sadly now destroyed by the arrogance of it's former lead Tommy Sheridan.
joehughes9 3 years ago
Stand strong comrades world wide
Manchester, UK
ReesTVideos 3 years ago 4
Socialism = Equality which in turn can a Unified World ,One Nation,One Way to Peace on Earth.
Rivera1012003 3 years ago