09 Shiny Toy Guns Don't Cry Out SxSW March 20 2009

[RaVeNoUsRaFFy]

Man that Sisley chick FUCKING SUCKS!

[notsokewl]

No, that isn't The lovely Carah no sir-e

[HanHanLouise]

@notsokewl ooo i know! i ment "fuck me" (rip my ears off) not fuck me (this is the best thing ever) haha, you cant compare this girl to Carah :')

[HanHanLouise]

Fuck me im glad Carah is back !!

[uopook]

this is like some terrible terrible karaoke

[CLPinky04]

I am a complete Carah fan....sisley is ok on the second album but can't do live like Carah can!

[Zares28]

That high note he reaches reminds me when Teen Gohan turned super saiyan 2......Oh goddamn what a rush those screams are

[StrawberryBottomz]

I liked Sisely and all but I do not like her singing this song.....This song was meant for Carah and Carah alone to sing....

[yaathisismyusername]

wait whose the chick singing? that cant be carah can it????? im so confused!!!!

[radiotete1e2]

@yaathisismyusername no, it was their singer when they kicked carah out. luckily carah is back, because sisley sucks.

[yaathisismyusername]

@radiotete1e2 why the hell would they kick carah out? Shes frickin amazing



[MELONIEG]

I love it

[homicidalmonkey]

Carah is back now

[thuperdupertheven]

sisley does ok on the higher stuff but has a really hard time with the lower parts. slips in and out of the key a lot O_o

[crystalmonday80]

Some of you are deaf because carah is WAAAAYYYY better than sisely. whatever carah is back and i dont have to listen to that swine again.

[pigbeenis]

Argument is officially over, sisely is going back to the crap music career she came from and we're getting our Carah back.

[mandorocks10]

she killed this song

[AYTCH303]

oh-oh.reality check. this music was NEVER "NEVER" (NEVER), NEVER meant to be any good performed live. wait a minute...never meant to be performed live. period. who gives a fuck what the fat chick sounds like when you're 17, half naked, rolling your brains out with 5k other 17 yr olds, half naked, rolling their brains out in some steam filled laser show at 128 bpm. this shit KILLS it, out of the studio. but DOES, AND ALWAYS WILL, SUCK ASS LIVE. unless your rolling!!!! now...get back to class!!!

[blunk2007]

this is the 1st time seeing a song sung by both girls live and Sisely sucks and so does her stage presence/energy.

[tygolf11]

3:15 to 3:35 is my favorite moment in music history

[lesstalkmorecock]

wowza chad is getting a chin there.

I love this song when it was by Carah

but now the new vocals makes me WANNA CRY OUT! lol

[blacku96]

Chad is the man. Rock solid.

[provision02]

I love this so much!!! <33 they are you good live i wanna see them so bad!! you cant help but wanna cry to this song, now this is a real band sing live and doing their best to should they be a real band!! fuck yeah, i love shiny toy guns for life!!! <3

[plasthiqqdoll]

oh god! sisely is just as good.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

stop your bitching!

carah is NOT coming back.. deal with it! atleast sisely she has more energy on stage than carah

[TheMaidenBlackRoses]

I'm saying the truth...sisely is really really really bad...someone bring carah back

carah is better on stage trust me I know ...I was there

Sisely screamed really loud that burst my ears out of my eardrum...I'm a good singer I know these fucking things

[RcUniverseGuy]

@TheMaidenBlackRoses sisely is a real artist she puts real emotion into her performance unlike carah

[RcUniverseGuy]

i dont know why this chick is so hot to me LOL maybe its the purple spandex

[chuy655]

she can feel the noise better than most bands

[sevenarmy1]

I think shees cool!!

[fa4rm2er0]

mikey martin is a bad ass

[terrifried]

oh lord. wtf is this? i miss carah.

[XXTheXRecluseXX]

and tword the middle of the song sisely looks like shes teaching a workout video

[XXTheXRecluseXX]

now that carah is gone this band isnt good at all.

sisley seriously cannot sing at all... she yells

[califsu]

hits the right notes? you must be tone deaf.

[Antisaint46]

are you kidding me? sisely is shouting to hit the notes that carah sang carah never had problems hitting notes.. sisely squeels to hit the notes she did. I'mnot bashing on anybody I think they both sound good but sisely should always just sing and not shout like she does on Major Tom because she actually sounds good

[orangejuiceninja6661]

@Antisaint46 I agree. A lot of people think this sounds good...they should clean their ears out and try listening to it again. Sisely's a screamer, not a singer (she should sing though.)

[orangejuiceninja6661]

@781230xy Are you crazy? Carah has a good voice, she would even hit the right notes (I would know, I've been singing since I was six years old) Sisely...she really really over does it...or just sucks. I'm not sure which. She stands up there and screeches. Maybe Sisely should try singing. Sisely sounds better though the studio where as Carah has real talent. Clean your ears out and learn a thing or two about music.

[781230xy]

Crap, I messed up on one part. I meant that Sisely SUCKS when doing Carah's songs.

BUt Carah wouldn't be able to do Sisely's either.

[califsu]

i agree. also i think that sound engineer should be fired!

[781230xy]

hahaha! me 2

[visualkei72]

i believe Carah was using effects in the live performances as well.. auto-tone and whatnot.

but i like their version of this song at the roland namm performance the best to be honest. the male vocal with female backup mixed with the stronger synth is really powerful.

[Antisaint46]

lol I like both of them in there own way but Carah was a way better singer sisely isnt really hitting the right notes at all lol shes straining to hit everything

[level22productions]

@781230xy ...Hate to burst your "live in the future" bubble but... Carah's back :) Booyah!

[phishman58]

This is an embarrassing performance. Now I do agree that Carah made a huge difference in the quality of this group. Awful.

[hernandeznathan50]

Nope! Simple answer! She did not make the band!

[sofalof14]

ok i love their songs, but only when there voices are fixed up. They sing horrible live. insane

[nycstmarks]

oh god... are they tone deaf?

[gaae2000]

I love this band man, and the new singer, they all rule. Plus, the setting everyone facing forward in line, never seen it at any concert.

[starterrn]

3:25 when he reaches the high note... oh man!