Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (219)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • it is a pity that the download link is not working... but thanks so much for sharing this fantastic cover

  • この歌は、スコットの集大成だと思います。

    彼の人柄はすばらしいです。

    I think this song is scott's best performance.

    I never forget.

    I love him.

  • though his blind.. he's voice is so powerful.. howow!

  • Wow Amazing The Doctor Detroit loves this cover!

  • he's good but sad he was blind

  • @leklek69 ok thumbs down if your gay, gotcha

  • @leklek69 i bet you're as gay as justin bieber.

  • Thanks for Posting. What an incredible and true musician. He was by far the best musician on the AI and if one listens carefully they can hear the incredible, rich nuances Scott delivers. I feel privileged to hear such a gifted human being. Great going Scott and thanks for sharing your genius.

    Best,

    Rick

  • hes ok....ehh...

  • @jbdanielle20 ffs you know nothing bring this to the royal academy of music anywhere or even to nashville and theyd all agree that his tonal quality is great except he could've done better in emotion

  • Scotty should have won!

  • @IKillzSlowly YES I know.

  • อูยยย .. เสียงเพราะฉิบหาย

    

  • I love you scott!!!!!!!!!!!! they should of used the save on him than on matt giraud. oh well he is AMAZING anyways!! :)

  • i love scott too.. i am so inspired with him.. he touched my life in a very sweet way..

  • I LOVE SCOTT!!! and i missed the tour... :( :( :( Scott, you are AWESOME and I love your voice!!!

  • My favorite studio version, and as Simon said, his best performance (though I also really liked his "Wild Angels" studio version)

  • Great voice, but the feeling that billy puts into this song is not there. But great perfomance though.

  • I LUV SCOTT!!!!!!!!!!!!

    I follow him

    on twitter idolscott

    He has an awesome voice

  • I love Scotty! I couldn't believe he got voted off of American Idol. He was my absolute favorite. This has to be my favorite song that he sang.

  • He has a recording contract?

    I guess, they aren't allowed to have on before Tour ends...

  • who's the loser? he has a recording contract and will have the money.....so he's not such a loser is he u stupid idot!!!!

  • he is awesome and you are the loser

  • His pre-AI CD "Somewhere Else" is now available online at cdbaby. His EP "View from Above" is available for download from amazon July 1st.

  • SCEUT MACINTAYA!

  • w0ah! his so good! I didn't appreciate him before but NOW, after I heard this, I totally support him. His so good. He deserves to be the winner.

  • he doesn't really have much of a higher register. Good enough to be on idol. He deserved to be a finalist but definitely not the winner. There's no need to be delusional IMO.

  • Krasnansky, i think the thing that he is blind (almost completely blind actually) is the ONLY thing you know about Scott. How about if I ask you, DO YOU KNOW HE CAN READ?

  • He is so amazing. That's why it made me feel sick that his AI Finale performance (piano duel with Matt) was cut because Billy Joel was not able to make it to the show (source: Scott's blog on his MySpace}. What a shame for AI. That was so unfair.

  • scott u have an AMAZING voice!!!

  • he's so inspiring :)

  • I WAS GOING FOR THIS DUDE TILL HE GOT VOTED OFF..THEN I STOPPED WATCHIN AMERICAN IDOL! i WANTED HIM TO WIN!

  • i thought it was so cool how he was blind and still got so far.

    he was really great.

  • courage and determination are nice...

    but you people think he honestlyyy

    should have won??

    Live, he was so inconsistant

  • oh my gosh is it just me or was anyone else scared that he would fall off the stage if he got to close?

  • haha, the finale was terrifying for me. Every step he took i expected him to go flying.

  • ME TOO! I was scared for him! I know he can see through a straw and stuff but still!

  • lol he's so weird. but in a good way. :P

  • i would b afraid if i was scott b/c i would b like i wonder what their facial expressions are at the end.scott is a great singer.scott will b remembered forever he is a great inspiration

  • hes a totall inspiration to so many people not just cuz his disability but bcuz of how talanted he is...its great that he didnt use being blind as a crunch in the competition hes an amazing person:) thumbs up?

  • i love you scott :)

  • I agree with radiohead

  • He did great for being blind

  • scott kicked ass!!

    he was my favorite from the beggining

    the way he plays the piano i could only dream to play it like that and i can see

    he had a decent voice

    but a huge soul

    MAY God blees him

    such an inspiration should be around to give people that you can accomplished anything!!

  • I feel EXACTLY the same way. I thought Adam was good, but Scott was the one I wanted to win all along. I thought he had such courage and determination. It was truly inspiring, especially since I'm a musician, to see him make it so far in the competition.

  • yeah

    we musician have to look up to those kind of people with such a talent!

    btw im soo glad kris won...

    dany was great he can make it on his own

  • the mix is not as good as when he performed live with the piano

  • Your an idiot and something vulgar

  • for stating my opinion????

  • actually, i agree with aesr3578. He would go flat quite often in his live performances. His studio recordings are excellent, but live is half the work. He needs to be fun to see live...and he just doesn't have the range.

  • your so fucking stupid feliciaariellecito simon didnt boot him america did you dumb bitch. Anyway badass song love it.

  • lol that's alot of anger for correcting someone's mistake lol

  • u cuss alot dont u????

  • he is really a good inspiration. i love the way he sings while playing his piano.

  • I think Scott is great!! I love this song!!

  • I've missed you greatly since your "leave" from A.I. I so enjoy your musical ability.  I appreciate your testimony of faith in Christ. In my eyes, you won!! What a voice!!

  • Now i remembered why I liked this guy.

    Such a comforting vocie.

    Keep on truckin scotty boy

  • i love him soo much !! and when simon kicked him off american idol i was soo mad !! i yelled at the tv saying for simon to mess with his own dream !! like scott is one of the best American idols ever !! and then only blind person who made it into top 10 so simon go screw urself !!

  • If I were from the states, I would have voted for him! Nevertheless, Scott MacIntyre, I wish you best of luck for the future and I wish you go on and produce your album! And thanks formerlyrusselites for posting this video!

  • I do not agree with ratmon19 ! People do not vote for him because they feel sorry for him! People love him for his good voice and his very talented piano playing! The fact that he's blind only proves that he's very talented: imagine playing the piano when you are blind(it would be multiple times harder than playing when you are normal sighted!) and producing such a "beau" voice!

  • Scott was simply brilliant and amazing singing this song on American Idol. Thanks for posting and sharing this.

  • WOW he's sooooo good!

  • I miss you Scott!</3

  • This is one of the greatest renditions I have ever heard of this wonderful Billy Joel song. Scott did one of his idols justice for sure! I must say, this country is a bunch of idiots. Corrupt by the scene of media to appreciate such pure talents such a these. This competition is obviously rigged. But one can only blame it on the lovely country we live it. What a joke. I hope Scott has good luck in the future.

  • @MegaMacTV he didnt win cuz um he fucking sucks adam is the BEST AND THE GREATEST american idol WE HAVE EVER HAD HELL HE IS ONE OF THE BEST IF NOT THE BEST VOCALIST THAT ACTUALLY SINGS WITHOUT AUTOTUNING OR COMPUTERS AND SHIT SO FUCKING STFU

  • @4EverAGlambert1989 Whoa, calm down there. Musically, in every sense of the word, Scott does not suck at all. I also didn't say anything bad about Adam, did I? He should have very well won...but my comment still holds true, doesn't it? Also, if you think Scott sucks, why in the hell did you come to this video? Honestly.

  • hater..

  • Can we say troll? According to your profile I would say so. Anyway, please go back to school and learn how to use proper grammar. Oh,and also your attempt at a blind joke wasn't even the least bit funny. Come on, you trolling haters need some new material.

  • Shows what you know about music. This man can see things you could only imagine. His senses are superb. I guess that you must be perfect. You probably can't sing a note. Two words; Shut Up.

  • Love u Scott!! U have such a great voice!!

  • Scott MacIntyre has a wonderful voice I miss seeing him on American Idol.

    God Bless you Scott!!!

  • i Miss him too! he had such a wonderful personality and his pink pants rocked! hahaha

  • Scott has a very beautiful voice!!! He can sing to me whenever he wants!!! I LOVE YOU SCOTT!!!

  • Scott, I am one of your biggest fans. You are wonderful in so many ways: your voice, your piano playing, your beautiful spirit, the special person you are.

  • Scott, How beautiful! I am one of your biggest fans.

  • Scott, you among all of the contestants since season 1 have affected me greatly. I love your personality, your positivity. :) I hope we'll get to hear more from you. Go SCOTT!! WE love you.

  • I completely agree. He has such a Gentle Spirit. I love listening to him. If he is ever in the Bay Area, I want to see him.

  • this is BEAUTIFUL!!!!!

  • anoop cant sing and if u think i am racest for saying that then you need to get out more and take a step in to the real world and see what raceism realy is

  • Umm, obviously he can sing or he wouldn't be on the show. Might wanna stop with the exaggerations--they just make you sound stupid.

  • I'm not a fan of Anoop but I think this is exaggeration.. :)Anoop can sing and he can sing well.

  • I love listening to him. He has such a gentle spirit you don't find in many perfomers these days.

  • True, true. :) I really really love this guy. :)

  • He is really careful when he perform and serious person. But, when he talk feels like he has a lot of words to say very active man! Scott, I salute you of being true to yourself! No matter what happen in this competition, Scott has trademark!

  • did he go home singing this song!?!?!?!?! i had this song stuck in my head for like the rest of the week after i listed to this!! :D GO SCOTT!!

  • Fantastic! I can't wait to buy his album. I have all his songs from itunes!

  • omg he was amazing! literly.

    isnt he blind or something?

    he can sing to me anytime<33

    (:

  • i see why they didn'tsave him, what if something happens where danny or matt is gonna get voted off early. They woul only have scott t show for it. I liked scott but it was only a matter of time before he left.

  • america what happened? he is greater than adam

  • The truth of the matter is, he cannot hit certain notes and is not at the singing caliber of adam and the rest; he is great however.

  • scottt NOOOOO i didn't want you to leave the show!!!! :(

  • yea they should have.

  • They should have saved Scott.

  • veeena, are you serious?

    first off, anoop needs to get his teeth fixed and get his eyebrows done, second he picks the wrong song every week, and thirdly scott wasn't the best but he was way better then anoop.

  • he waqs great.. simon is an idiot!! shoulda saved him... :(

  • simon sucks!

    scott doesn't deserves to leave!

  • i love scott...

    he's a good pianist as well as vocalist...

    it so sad that he elimanates....

    he should have w0n....

  • i miss scott so much. i wanted to cry when he left.

    he is so cute, and his voice is beautiful!!!!~

    he was a good to reason to watch american idol!

  • yeah i was sad when scott left too :( matt is our kalamazoo idol though :)

  • Scott is simply amazing and a genius! I love the way how Scott sang this song so beautifully. He put his heart and soul into it. Bravo, Scoltt!

  • not good enough to be american idol..but definitely brought more color to the competition..more than what danny gokey brings..

  • ima miss him!!!!

    he was one of my faves!!!

  • that picture is amazing. its like he's looking in your eyes...even tho he cant see it...

  • sooooooooo sad!!!! I want scott to stay on american idol!

  • go SCOTT! :)

  • I also cried. I was sooo mad and upset I just sat ther with tears running down my cheeks when they were playing his journey. LOVE YOU SCOTT. plus he will find some company that wants him and he will make hits and soon we will hear him on the raido

  • i cried hen he left i loved him it was soo sad

  • Scott is my absolute favorite. He has so much talent. He plays multiple instruments. He can learn songs on the piano SO fast. He can also play classical pieces beautifully. Music means so much to him and he is so inspiring. His singing voice is unique and pure. He is not a cookie cutter pop star and I wouldn't change a thing. Scott, your true fans love you "Just The Way You Are." Keep on singing from your heart!

  • i admire what scott achieved so far. but he deserved to go tonight if not earlier. america got it right this time.

  • I really don't know why the judges like ADAM. I don't get it...He's not a good singer !!!!

  • i didnt like guy either but im started to after each week. but ring of fire was absolute "indulgent rubbish"!

  • Comment removed

  • i noee rite!!!! finally someone agrees..i LOVE DANNY GOKEY!

  • I'm really upset and pissed off!!!! Lil is the one who deserve to go home coz from the very beginning of top 13 she sux!!!!

  • shes arguably the most talented on the show she just picks the wrong songs

  • Sut simon and Randy are attracted to her big butt

  • she can sing but she apparently cant sing well...i try to picture out syesha mercado but i really cant see it in her...(:

  • i agree dadyish

  • i'm so pissed off.

    anoop sucks, he's a fucking loser.

    scott deffinately didn't deserve to go tonight.

  • Scott has a way better voice than Anoop and is far more talented!

    Also, Anoop is very Cocky & Arrogant and those qualities definitely aren't admirable to say the least.

    It doesn't matter though because there isn't a chance in hell Anoop will win the competition so it is just fine.

  • i feeeel the samme way.

    i cried when he lefttt.

  • Anoop is not cocky and his not arrogant. You know why u don't like him? because of his nationality..common let's face it!! and plus you don't know him so don't judge..and in fairness if you are really looking for talent in this competition..He has it>>

  • Oh, yeah - Because you know the reason everyone has for not liking Anoop is because his nationality... That was one of the stupidest replies ever seriously.... I just am not a fan of his VOICE!

    Also, didn't say Anoop wasn't talented, I just said Scott has more talent, but that is just my opinion. We all know he isn't going to win, but to each their own I guess.

  • are you not aware of racism here in America??!! FYI that's not one of the stupidiest reply ever,OK! as what you said you have ur own opinion and I have mine..So lets leave it that way

  • I am from Canada.... and it was a very stupid reply because you assumed just because someone isn't a fan of Anoop they are racist which makes no sense.

    Alright now good day.

  • im so angry and upset that scott is gone

  • same here.

  • pennylou87, whatever adam sings, not even a single goosebump from me. i do not hate him, i just don't like his singing. that's all. i even tried to force myself to like his singing but it just doesn't work for me. standing "O" from simon and kara? well, good for him.

    but for scott, even for what others call as off-key notes still enter my ears as a good music.

  • my top 5:

    1. scott

    2. scott

    3. scott

    4. scott

    5. all the rest (except adam)

  • soo nice to hear someone else in the world is not a fan of adam!

  • Scott is awesome! He sang this so good! Go Scott!!!

  • Adam

    Kris

    Allison

    Danny

    Scott

    matt

    Lil

    Anoop

  • Lol Funny thing that hapapened to my uncle when watching this.

    uncle: Wow, this guy is missing so many notes on his piano

    cousin: well, dad, he is blind

    uncle:just because he can't see don't mean he cant hear.

    i lol'd alot when i heard them

  • No way, this is how its going to go

    Scott

    Danny

    Adam

    Kriss

    Allison

  • i dont get why people say he has a terrible voice. his voice sounds so good for some reason. I also like danny's voice too. for me its gonna go:

    Danny

    Scott

    Anoop

    Allison

    Adam

  • Adam

    Matt

    Kris

    Danny

    Allison

    Scott

    Lil

    Anoop

  • Danny

    Adam

    Kris

    allison

    Lil rounds

    scott

    matt

    anoop

  • Adam

    Danny

    kris

    those are my top three!!! AdAm is amazing!!! Anoop and Scott should be in the bottom two this week!!! im sorry but they rnt the strongest in the competition!

  • danny

    allison

    kris

    matt

    adam is a creeper i dont get y people like him! i used to, but then he sang ring of fire! if u agree please respond

  • I feel you RinxNara..I don't like Adam, he's not singing he's screaming all the time. I like Scott from the very beginning, He is so talented!! But I'm telling you, if you are looking for consistent voice in this competition I will vote for ANOOP, His voice is so amazing, its just that he don't know how to pick the right song for his voice..I still Love u Anoop!!

    Top 3

    Danny

    Scott

    Anoop

  • for me it's:

    danny & adam- a tie ^^lll (srry)

    scott

    kris

    allison

  • I think this was his best performance. He is getting better but not as fast as the others.

    I notice a lot of people have Allison in their top 5 but they're not voting for her because she keeps ending up in the bottom three. If you like her, vote for her!

  • it goes:

    danny

    scott

    adam

    allison

  • good performance but he's not in my top 5 either

    my top 5 is(not in order)

    Matt G.

    Kris A.

    Adam L.

    Danny G.

    Allison I.

  • hell yeah..!

    tats my pick too..

    i'll be very upset when they'll be voted off...but too bad though...its the way the contest goes...

  • i like him but he's not my fav....

    my fav 5'

    danny

    kriss

    matt

    allison

    adam ( but i don't really like him he's weird)

  • this was definitely his best performance and the recording is even better than live, but sorry, I don't like Scott and never have. I've been wanting him to leave.

  • This is the song that I'll play on my itunes when I'm on my bed or trying to relax. Not Adam's crazy screaming..

  • hes my 3rd fav

    top 5;

    alison

    danny

    scott

    anoop

    adam

  • he's my 3rd fav.

    top 5:

    danny

    kris

    scott

    adam

    matt

  • I really like Scott - hes amazing and I really like his voice. You can feel the emotion when he sings <3

  • thank you for the killing comments of me .... He has no tempo! he's not a good singer and i dont like him at all! its MY opinion and im going to keep it that way ... if you disagree, thats fine .. but i dont like getting killed with your comments of how he's so "cute" and a good singer and i "suck" cause' i think differently

  • i agree, i dont like him at all :/

  • Think you =) That makes 2!

  • the judges think he should get up and move more... he cant but i think this was good. HES A REALLY GOOD SINGER!!!!