You know, I just don't know why people are saying so much negativity about Tiah and Simone. They both performed well at the judges home and they were not nearly as awful as many people are making them out to be.
Y aurait-il quelque chose dans l'air de Saint-Trop qui puisse à ce point altérer ton jugement, Simon ? J'ai vraiment la sensation que tous les choix auraient du être inversés. Je serai très curieux de voir comment Mariah aurait influencé les décisions. Mais ça...
I predict this Tiah will STILL be a star. I would sign her in a MINUTE!!! More singing lessons, and she would be awesome. In a few years, she WILL BE FAMOUS.
I really think that Simon did the right thing! I mean... Tiah, REALLY HAS THE X FACTOR! I know that she doesnt have the best voice, but... when she is singing its impossible to look something that is not her, she really ownes the stage when she is on it and she really trust in herself, I think that Simon shoulda pick her over Drew...
@MsGiono Tiah deserved 2 make it through the wrong choice was picking Simone, Tiah has a great personality she jus needs work she's a good singer though but Caitlin was mean trust me ask the other girls on the show
Not only Tiah's voice needs A LOT of work, but her idk...I don't like her tbh. I would definitely not buy her records. Nope I wouldn't. I'm so disappointed at some of the decisions made on this show.
@SarahBathory Tiah is really nice she's a good singer who needs work all the other girls r happy Tiah made it through Caitlin was mean there's proof in her A.I. vid and when she commented on Tiah
@vkk19 lol I really like Tiah all the other contestants were happy Tiah made it through she's jus a diamond in the ruff if she got work on her voice she'd be amazing but however Kaitlin was mean ask the other contestants.
That's either the dumbest decision in the history of singing competitions, or the most ruthless heartless sadistic power move ever witnessed on national TV.
@sumoleguy1 Nah Nicole made the dumbest decision by choosing Dexter instead of Christa Collins. She won the price. But yeah this sucks Tiah should have been sent home.
@SarahBathory No she didnt she's super cool and talented she jus needs work the wrong choice was Simone over Tora, Caitlin was really mean if u look at her A.I. vid and when she comments on Tiah ask the other girls they know
SIMON UR NOT A BELIEVER UR AN IDIOT..U PICK THIS GIRL..AND U REALIZED THAT SHE WASNT GOOD ENOUGH ON THE LIVE SHOWS...SAME WITH SIMONE...POOR CAITLIN...SHE SHOULD IT BEEN ON THE LIVE SHOWS..REAT SINGER..WITH A LOT OF FANS....GO CAITLIN!!!!!!
This is new!!! Caitlin gets all positive responses, with her amazing voice. Even at the end simon accepted she connected with the song. !!!!! And tiah gets through??!!!!!
¡¡¡¡¡¡ She didnt even believe it !!!!. she was ready to go............. I guess is not enough to be good, you have to know the owner. What kind of a show is this???!!!!!!
@hahs4 come on she's really cool trust me I felt the same u did but I saw the nice girl she is trust me this was the right desicion caitlin was mean she jus had a good voice
One more really really stupid decision made by judges in the X-factor USA. I've watched the show in Finland and everyone even here is so dissapointed. Caitlin is so much better and more talented.
In the end of the episode I was hoping with my fingert crossed that Simon had chosen to take Caitlin back, but insted they took Melania.... Wroooong.
@1973luckyboy Tiah is a really really good girl she has a really sweet personality I've meet her b4 she deserves it I also liked Caitlin but she was mean if u've seen her b4
Simon has to take his decision based on the last performance and come on guys lets be honest in the last performance Caitlin was not that good. I am her fan number one , she is beautiful, great and amazing voice but she picked a bad song in her last presentation. I will miss you Caitlin
@alonsoddlvq Her last performance was awesome (in my opinion). She sounded incredible. Simon even said her pitch and her tone was incredible after the performance. She had the all the technical aspects down. Tiah couldn't even stay on the right key or control her pitch. It was a stupid decision.
i gotta say, i really dont like the way tiah sings at all, from the beginning to when she was cut i really didnt think she should have made it to the four let alone in at all from her first audition
no me parece justo en realidad tiah no canta mal pero de lejos caitlin era una de las favorita para ganar realmente se equivoco ojala regrese pero ya no para el grupo se simon si no para otro jurado
HORRENDOUS to let go of Caitlin Koch, she is true star..She got everything..voice, beauty, personality,attitude..that was one hell of a wrong decision by Simon..I DISAGREE TOTALLY..They'll regret it..
You all might not Read This, But Fuck It Imma Say It Anyway Because I Feel At Least 1 Person Will, Im A Young Rapper, I Knows Theres A Million Of Those But Not 2 Many With Ambition Dedication & A Unique Individual Style.
If You Just Take A Min And Give Me A Chance I'll Make You A Believer. I Would Love Nothing More Than To Have A Loyal Following On Youtube. If Anyone Who Reads This Could Press The "THUMBS UP" Others Will See It. Just A Simple Button Press Can Push Me Closer To My Dream
Coming from Buffalo, NY- I am and always will be Caitlin's fan. She's undoubtedly the whole package. I dislike other singers that made the show, but I do not approve how they were treated on last night's episode. I feel Simon brought them as expendables on purpose as part of a master plan to have a specific singer win. Caitlin was sacrificed at the alter of Simon's ego.
caitlin, even when she's crushed, is still so positive and sweet...i mean, look at tiah's posture - so droopy and unflattering, so not star material. what does simon "see" in her?
People, I don't know what are you talking about. Tiah's biggest mistake was to go unprepared to her first audition. She got labeled then and that was it. The public did the same to Katie Waissel.
Caitlin I think learned (hopefully) a few lessons the very hard way, and Simon is just disgusting. Paula, is better off with her two Chihuahuas.
I'm a mess, I feel sorry for both, Tiah and Caitlin. Regardless of this and that.... I hope they'll be Ok. Simone too... What a sad world, only this many ..... I don't even know what. Is anybody at all only happy
i think that Tiah and Caitlin are both amazing. Everyone has a different style and voice, how do you think it makes these girls feel when people say crap about them? I bet half of you that are commenting mean things don't even have half the amount of talent either of these girls have in their pinky finger. Maybe try being considerate of other peoples feelings before you start judging. Everybody has their own opinions, think of yours before you comment nasty things to these poor girls;
oh my...that was one bad decision. tiah is cute and can sing, no doubt about that...but caitlin is just light years ahead of her. she's got the best voice in that bunch. i honestly thought deciding which one to choose was a no-brainer. choosing tiah over caitlin? goodness, that's mind-boggling!
wrong decision again, just like when he didn't choose Melanie at first and then he realized that he's gone wrong, this is one of his mistakes, mistake and mistake again, i started to dislike him V_V''
Did any of you see the X Factor UK where they were either eliminating Jedward (could not sing, Simon hated them from the beginning but public loved their entertainment value) or some other nameless chick (OK voice, no presence)...Simon backed up Jedward because he could see their entertainment value = money...whereas he said the other girl had a ceiling which she'd already hit. I think this is what happened here. Caitlin = No fire... TIAH = Steel Eyes!
in the end, he has to make a decision... they both good but he had to choose which meant caitlin couldnt make it, which i dont totally agree with but he the guru here
I was surprized that Tiah made it and not Caitlin, but to accuse Simon of hitting on Caitlin is ludicrous. He's not an idiot. Why now? He's had plenty of chances with previous Xfactor contenstants. We would have heard something. If you don't like the decision, too bad, its done with but to make it sound like that WAS the reason for choosing Tiah and not Caitlin, is absurd.
Simon been in this business longer than any of yal. I sure as hell trust his decision more than any of u guys. This is the X Factor. Not American Idol. If this was Idol, Caitlin would have went thru but Tiah has way more stage presence and has talent and potential. She has something Caitlin doesn't and its unexplainable. Thats what the X Factor is so get over yourselves
Simon's ego is tooo huge... He chose only chose Tiah because he said she will be big. But when he found out she wasn't, he was to big of a baby to admit his mistake. Instead he took the easy way out....
TOO BAD Simon made a HUGE mistake by choosing ugly Tiah!!. I'm sorry for Tiah but AMERICA will NOT vote for her LOL. She will be the first voted off :D.
@manzana9127 beauty is superficial and either way, everyone has their opinions. Personally, I think she's gorgeous. I don't like her makeup, but she is very pretty and does have a pretty voice.
I don't know guys, if simon doesnt conenct with Caitlin, he won't be able to help her as much as he wants to.... On the other hand, he really connects with Tiah... I want to see Tiah's performance thuesday before I judge her, but I have to admdit: Caitlin has a better voice and a better look. Oh, and her personality... wow!
He was too stubborn to admit he was wrong by ever putting her through, so he ruined Caitlin's chances and she could've gone far. I doubt Tiah will go far at all, America will not vote for her.
Tiah has a mouth that looks like hotdog and i bet simon likes to eat hotdog.
Caitlin light years much better in singing than tiah.
during the first audition tiah sings out of key out of tune and simon "sees" that the hotdog maybe.......no wonder paula and nicole didnt see those lips
Love Thia..she may not be the prettiest but she sure is a cracker !! I know lots of people here hated her because he is not as pretty as the other girls but..Simon is hardly wrong and i agree with Simon..I think this girl is something and finger cross..she will go far !!!
LOL people. Tiah is an artist and Caitlin is the typical boring america's girl next door. besides that caitlin aint beautiful and i quite forgot she was in the competition. Learn something from this. By the way her mask broke when the news were delivered, she's fake.
hmmm i wonder why tiah got lot of haters.. maybe simon see what we cant see in her.. i mean behind her looks :p her voice is great and so as her stage present.. malas lang ni caitlin kasi beat ni simon si tiah :D hehehe
Caitlin Koch can sing all her little pretty soft songs till the cows come home, but if she was asked to really belt out a tune she would have been exposed. She is a one dimensional singer. Simone saw that.
@JigsawWill THANK YOU! You said exactly what I was thinking. If she made an album, it would be called Sleepy TIme. Tiah has so much more to offer, especially after she gets more polished by pros.
@SydneySuzanne13 Caitlin is so beautiful and maybe that's her problem, she relies on her looks more than she relies on her voice, although she has a very good voice, she doesn't use it. But I really hate Tiah, how could Tiah be chosen and Jazzlyin Little goes home?????
i meant can sing,sorry
Rana9218 6 days ago
ok,she can't sing but....she really has problems with the melodic line
Rana9218 6 days ago
I have just a thing... the songs type, wasn't help Tiah... maybe a kind of Lady Gaga's music...
alvarezjaaz 1 week ago
Big mistake Simon, I'd pay money to hear Caitlin sing, not that the other girl isn't good, but I'll just listen to her for free on you tube.
tinkertim360 2 weeks ago
TORA MELANIE RACHEL CROW AND JAZLYNN ARE THE REALLY TOP 4!
santiagohdz1 2 weeks ago 2
@santiagohdz1 I agree.
colincarneystudios 1 day ago
You know, I just don't know why people are saying so much negativity about Tiah and Simone. They both performed well at the judges home and they were not nearly as awful as many people are making them out to be.
Averic7 4 weeks ago
Kicking Cait was his worst decision not Mel!!
loveangelbliss 1 month ago
My people i thought should have gone through Drew, Rachel, Melanie, and Caitlin.
pokerfaceteehee 1 month ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
WHAT????!!! I really don't like Tiah and he made Tiah go off when he only had to pick 3!!! So what did he pick her in the first place!
pokerfaceteehee 1 month ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
Y aurait-il quelque chose dans l'air de Saint-Trop qui puisse à ce point altérer ton jugement, Simon ? J'ai vraiment la sensation que tous les choix auraient du être inversés. Je serai très curieux de voir comment Mariah aurait influencé les décisions. Mais ça...
Fredinotmercurybut 1 month ago in playlist Uploaded videos
This has been flagged as spam show
simon!!!! what the hell did you saw on this whore??? he left out melanie and caitlin here for HER!!! she probably sucked him before... -_-
CynthiaftMJ 1 month ago
Comment removed
CynthiaftMJ 1 month ago
@MimiNoBhiebaah That's a good 1 mine r
Tiah
Rachel
Rachel
Jazzlyn
Dolewis879 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I predict this Tiah will STILL be a star. I would sign her in a MINUTE!!! More singing lessons, and she would be awesome. In a few years, she WILL BE FAMOUS.
morgan699 2 months ago
It was a big mistake !
vihmerlim87 2 months ago in playlist Judges' Houses - The Decisions - THE X FACTOR USA 2011
I really think that Simon did the right thing! I mean... Tiah, REALLY HAS THE X FACTOR! I know that she doesnt have the best voice, but... when she is singing its impossible to look something that is not her, she really ownes the stage when she is on it and she really trust in herself, I think that Simon shoulda pick her over Drew...
NishidaMinami 2 months ago 3
Caitlin is SOOO much better.
1wishfulthinking1 2 months ago
There's a reason you didn't like that Simon..
kelvind09 2 months ago
I Love Tiah, she is much more talented than Kaitlin
guidosredhairedshow 3 months ago
he pick the wrong choice (n)
MsGiono 3 months ago
@MsGiono Tiah deserved 2 make it through the wrong choice was picking Simone, Tiah has a great personality she jus needs work she's a good singer though but Caitlin was mean trust me ask the other girls on the show
Dolewis879 3 months ago
alguien sabe como se llama el tema de fondo de este video??gracias...
theendnormal 3 months ago
@theendnormal Nobody Knows y es cantada por P!nk, esta incluida en el album "I'm Not Dead" para mi el mejor album de ella.
yeferssono 3 months ago
Not only Tiah's voice needs A LOT of work, but her idk...I don't like her tbh. I would definitely not buy her records. Nope I wouldn't. I'm so disappointed at some of the decisions made on this show.
SarahBathory 3 months ago
@SarahBathory Tiah is really nice she's a good singer who needs work all the other girls r happy Tiah made it through Caitlin was mean there's proof in her A.I. vid and when she commented on Tiah
Dolewis879 3 months ago
I stopped watching the show after this how could she not make to the finales !!!!! ?? Simone has a thing for black chicks.
footlovemachine 3 months ago
tiah? tian?!?!?!?!? come on! all the judges loved Caitlin. Simon..... I thought u made good decisions but this one was low. even for you.
vkk19 3 months ago
@vkk19 lol I really like Tiah all the other contestants were happy Tiah made it through she's jus a diamond in the ruff if she got work on her voice she'd be amazing but however Kaitlin was mean ask the other contestants.
Dolewis879 3 months ago 4
Oh my god. Caitlyn. Is Just it! The Look, THE VOICE... The x-factor!
HitchinARideProdz 3 months ago
i feel so bad for catalin....... catalin is so much better
kqmusic1 3 months ago
BOOO Tiah!
cornskii 3 months ago
Caitlin had it all! the looks, the voice....the Xfactor! WTF Simon, I dont understand what he saw in Tiah.....
babyshake81 3 months ago 2
That's either the dumbest decision in the history of singing competitions, or the most ruthless heartless sadistic power move ever witnessed on national TV.
Is it the X-Factor or the BS-Factor?
sumoleguy1 3 months ago
@sumoleguy1 Nah Nicole made the dumbest decision by choosing Dexter instead of Christa Collins. She won the price. But yeah this sucks Tiah should have been sent home.
SarahBathory 3 months ago
@SarahBathory No she didnt she's super cool and talented she jus needs work the wrong choice was Simone over Tora, Caitlin was really mean if u look at her A.I. vid and when she comments on Tiah ask the other girls they know
Dolewis879 3 months ago
When I see Tiah I think of the movie Gremlins! The girl, the singer in the 2nd one.....They have so much in common, only the Gremlin could sing!
NoTimeForBullCrap 3 months ago
it should have been caitlin...she's good
dHoyhee10 3 months ago
@Tao818 ....YEAH GOOD JOB PREDICTING THAT TIA TOLLIVER WILL BE IN THE TOP 3....U ARE A REALLY GOOD PRODUCER!!!! I DEFINETELY MARK YOUR WORDS LOSER
erwinoscar24 3 months ago
SIMON UR NOT A BELIEVER UR AN IDIOT..U PICK THIS GIRL..AND U REALIZED THAT SHE WASNT GOOD ENOUGH ON THE LIVE SHOWS...SAME WITH SIMONE...POOR CAITLIN...SHE SHOULD IT BEEN ON THE LIVE SHOWS..REAT SINGER..WITH A LOT OF FANS....GO CAITLIN!!!!!!
erwinoscar24 3 months ago
i dont like tiah toliver
molly200120019426 3 months ago
If she wins I sure I will kill Simon
CamiXDtvseries 3 months ago
Wtf man, obviously Caitlin shouldve went through..
MusicAndMe711 3 months ago
OMG! Another mistake in x factor, Caitlin do it better than Tia! One hundred better!
Saam2516 3 months ago
Simon has a penchant for black women, Leona Lewis, Simone, Tiah & Melanie
ZachGem 4 months ago
Steve jones went all in @ 3.42!!!!lol Any excuse!!!
BboyOP8 4 months ago
TOMATELA SIMON! todo por el orgullo
juestrellita 4 months ago
This is new!!! Caitlin gets all positive responses, with her amazing voice. Even at the end simon accepted she connected with the song. !!!!! And tiah gets through??!!!!!
¡¡¡¡¡¡ She didnt even believe it !!!!. she was ready to go............. I guess is not enough to be good, you have to know the owner. What kind of a show is this???!!!!!!
luis1982ortiz 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
NONONONONO
check my songs
Paula Lisa
mspaulalisa 4 months ago
i really dont like tiah
hahs4 4 months ago 16
@hahs4 come on she's really cool trust me I felt the same u did but I saw the nice girl she is trust me this was the right desicion caitlin was mean she jus had a good voice
Dolewis879 3 months ago
One more really really stupid decision made by judges in the X-factor USA. I've watched the show in Finland and everyone even here is so dissapointed. Caitlin is so much better and more talented.
In the end of the episode I was hoping with my fingert crossed that Simon had chosen to take Caitlin back, but insted they took Melania.... Wroooong.
PoisonYourHeart 4 months ago 4
wrong decision simon!
shellalalala 4 months ago
really scary
wolverine111388 4 months ago
Tiah scares me :(
zhilanhua 4 months ago 2
@zhilanhua ! she scares me too!
emilydouradoboo 4 months ago
Simon made the big mistake in her life by choosing a looser also hahahahaahha....
1973luckyboy 4 months ago 21
@1973luckyboy Tiah is a really really good girl she has a really sweet personality I've meet her b4 she deserves it I also liked Caitlin but she was mean if u've seen her b4
Dolewis879 3 months ago
Simon has to take his decision based on the last performance and come on guys lets be honest in the last performance Caitlin was not that good. I am her fan number one , she is beautiful, great and amazing voice but she picked a bad song in her last presentation. I will miss you Caitlin
alonsoddlvq 4 months ago
@alonsoddlvq Her last performance was awesome (in my opinion). She sounded incredible. Simon even said her pitch and her tone was incredible after the performance. She had the all the technical aspects down. Tiah couldn't even stay on the right key or control her pitch. It was a stupid decision.
weedy984 4 months ago
.this is ridiculous.
partyface1337 4 months ago
oh my god,I love Caitlin is a very nice voice. He was my favorite.
partyface1337 4 months ago
i gotta say, i really dont like the way tiah sings at all, from the beginning to when she was cut i really didnt think she should have made it to the four let alone in at all from her first audition
tudue 4 months ago
no me parece justo en realidad tiah no canta mal pero de lejos caitlin era una de las favorita para ganar realmente se equivoco ojala regrese pero ya no para el grupo se simon si no para otro jurado
mayranova1 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It proved Simon was very unpredictable judge and was stupid even during before American Idol times.
musicbreaker101 4 months ago
she reminds me of rihanna....sasha fierce.....lets trust simon!!
liavictoriadenisse 4 months ago
HORRENDOUS to let go of Caitlin Koch, she is true star..She got everything..voice, beauty, personality,attitude..that was one hell of a wrong decision by Simon..I DISAGREE TOTALLY..They'll regret it..
fayxaan 4 months ago 2
if there ever was a mistake that leads one to regrets, this would be simons biggest regret.
wordsone 4 months ago 2
I THINK SIMON LIKES TIAH!!!! HE EVEN CRIED WHEN SHE WENT HOME :(
reneeLuvmj1 4 months ago
@reneeLuvmj1 yea my aunt thinks so too she suck but she can be a model or something not singer.
hardknocksofg4 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You all might not Read This, But Fuck It Imma Say It Anyway Because I Feel At Least 1 Person Will, Im A Young Rapper, I Knows Theres A Million Of Those But Not 2 Many With Ambition Dedication & A Unique Individual Style.
If You Just Take A Min And Give Me A Chance I'll Make You A Believer. I Would Love Nothing More Than To Have A Loyal Following On Youtube. If Anyone Who Reads This Could Press The "THUMBS UP" Others Will See It. Just A Simple Button Press Can Push Me Closer To My Dream
nicowroy 4 months ago
in a couple of years when tiah is on top, you will all be saying you were with her from the start.
kidlucas18 4 months ago
Try again next year Caitlin. Maybe you'll get a fair judge.
steelcantuna 4 months ago
Coming from Buffalo, NY- I am and always will be Caitlin's fan. She's undoubtedly the whole package. I dislike other singers that made the show, but I do not approve how they were treated on last night's episode. I feel Simon brought them as expendables on purpose as part of a master plan to have a specific singer win. Caitlin was sacrificed at the alter of Simon's ego.
goodfellastlife 4 months ago 2
@goodfellastlife I didn't think about it but that makes sense.
Fredinotmercurybut 1 month ago
Simon made a big mistake here!!! Caitlin should've gone through!!!
noher1974 4 months ago
@noher1974 If she had, she would have still been out last night. No doubt she is better than many that made it though...
Suzisueful 4 months ago
she's better than dexter ==
iambeanlah 4 months ago
he should have picked Caitlin Koch
rockhead0524 4 months ago
caitlin, even when she's crushed, is still so positive and sweet...i mean, look at tiah's posture - so droopy and unflattering, so not star material. what does simon "see" in her?
chucklefox 4 months ago
LOLOL shes out
zoimz401 4 months ago
Tiah and Simone are out...! Good to hear.
talentinhiding 4 months ago 3
Comment removed
talentinhiding 4 months ago
good thing tiah and simone are out of the competition!!im sorry but i dont they are woth it...dexter out as well as phillip lomax
peachyjoaquin 4 months ago 3
I hate this. Can't believe Tiah is top 4. I don't see how Tiah can be better than Catlin. Catlin is very connective to her songs.
Ployjuss 4 months ago 2
People, I don't know what are you talking about. Tiah's biggest mistake was to go unprepared to her first audition. She got labeled then and that was it. The public did the same to Katie Waissel.
Caitlin I think learned (hopefully) a few lessons the very hard way, and Simon is just disgusting. Paula, is better off with her two Chihuahuas.
junisor1 4 months ago
stupid simon
missmaisueyang 4 months ago
Comment removed
missmaisueyang 4 months ago
wtf is wrong with simon -_-
silencez2324 4 months ago
I'm a mess, I feel sorry for both, Tiah and Caitlin. Regardless of this and that.... I hope they'll be Ok. Simone too... What a sad world, only this many ..... I don't even know what. Is anybody at all only happy
junisor1 4 months ago
so glad tiah got sent home tonight :)
7thwardgurl 4 months ago
@7thwardgurl really
pikachu5681 4 months ago
i hate simon
XxiHeart 4 months ago
What is this...... Caitlin is way better than Tiah..... ugh.
dkarent 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i think that Tiah and Caitlin are both amazing. Everyone has a different style and voice, how do you think it makes these girls feel when people say crap about them? I bet half of you that are commenting mean things don't even have half the amount of talent either of these girls have in their pinky finger. Maybe try being considerate of other peoples feelings before you start judging. Everybody has their own opinions, think of yours before you comment nasty things to these poor girls;
lizaxoxo7 4 months ago
Loool at the amount of dislikes. I preferred Caitlin. I know it can be difficult to sing acapella but her first audition was just too pitchy!
bdoti 4 months ago
I like Tiah's voice but she is not ready yet.
IRasecI 4 months ago
I here that Simon has to eliminate 2 of his acts on the first live show! Perfect! Bye-bye Tiah and Simone!
ninjaoftheocean 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
Ok another mistake Caitlin Koch shoul be back!!!
DrNttz 4 months ago
Aww. I actuallt really liked Tiah. unlike Simone :/
MarisolDeVino 4 months ago
oh my...that was one bad decision. tiah is cute and can sing, no doubt about that...but caitlin is just light years ahead of her. she's got the best voice in that bunch. i honestly thought deciding which one to choose was a no-brainer. choosing tiah over caitlin? goodness, that's mind-boggling!
karensunxiezhi 4 months ago
Comment removed
karensunxiezhi 4 months ago
wrong decision again, just like when he didn't choose Melanie at first and then he realized that he's gone wrong, this is one of his mistakes, mistake and mistake again, i started to dislike him V_V''
enfreedom 4 months ago
Why didn't he choose Caitlin?! Her performance was spectacular, Simon is just trying to keep his talentless favourites!
1wishfulthinking1 4 months ago
Tiah is being sent home after the first live show!
fusse3 4 months ago
omg catlin's voice is one in a million......
simon please watch this video so you know the opinion of the public
dramagirllover 4 months ago 31
Did any of you see the X Factor UK where they were either eliminating Jedward (could not sing, Simon hated them from the beginning but public loved their entertainment value) or some other nameless chick (OK voice, no presence)...Simon backed up Jedward because he could see their entertainment value = money...whereas he said the other girl had a ceiling which she'd already hit. I think this is what happened here. Caitlin = No fire... TIAH = Steel Eyes!
mindlesstupa 4 months ago
so now all of the girls that got in are black except drew
MooPoo851 4 months ago 3
@MooPoo851 Not sure what you mean by that. Is that a problem?
mindlesstupa 4 months ago
@MooPoo851 and melanie
pikachu5681 4 months ago
@pikachu5681 melanies black
MooPoo851 4 months ago
@MooPoo851 no, she may come from a black family but she is not black unless you are super white like sheamus.
pikachu5681 4 months ago
This is X-Factor, not SEX-Factor. Right decision Simon.
WhuckMeMofos 4 months ago 2
@WhuckMeMofos lol...Agreed !!! It seems like everybody is hating on Tiah because he is not pretty !!!
brian2010lal 4 months ago
in the end, he has to make a decision... they both good but he had to choose which meant caitlin couldnt make it, which i dont totally agree with but he the guru here
waleedtamimi1 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
I was surprized that Tiah made it and not Caitlin, but to accuse Simon of hitting on Caitlin is ludicrous. He's not an idiot. Why now? He's had plenty of chances with previous Xfactor contenstants. We would have heard something. If you don't like the decision, too bad, its done with but to make it sound like that WAS the reason for choosing Tiah and not Caitlin, is absurd.
graciegtxx 4 months ago
Simon been in this business longer than any of yal. I sure as hell trust his decision more than any of u guys. This is the X Factor. Not American Idol. If this was Idol, Caitlin would have went thru but Tiah has way more stage presence and has talent and potential. She has something Caitlin doesn't and its unexplainable. Thats what the X Factor is so get over yourselves
KDarius91 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
omg damn she is one ugly thing walking on two legs....smfh
Piimp310 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
I like Tiah's personality
hellojusty 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
She's better than x factor. She'll get a record deal some how.
TheRylanatorx 4 months ago
Simon's ego is tooo huge... He chose only chose Tiah because he said she will be big. But when he found out she wasn't, he was to big of a baby to admit his mistake. Instead he took the easy way out....
cheezelschan 4 months ago 27
@cheezelschan wait a minute I think you should see what happen before giving pronostics cause I'm sure you'll change your mind.....
Colsilky 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
If she got her gap fixed, she would be bad lol
bulziahebrand 4 months ago
TOO BAD Simon made a HUGE mistake by choosing ugly Tiah!!. I'm sorry for Tiah but AMERICA will NOT vote for her LOL. She will be the first voted off :D.
manzana9127 4 months ago 4
@manzana9127 beauty is superficial and either way, everyone has their opinions. Personally, I think she's gorgeous. I don't like her makeup, but she is very pretty and does have a pretty voice.
judygal86 4 months ago
What an awful decision.
abcd827 4 months ago
OMG caitlyn was one of the best! I had her, Melanie, Rachel in the finals! BAD choice Simon
Rangerwhat 4 months ago
I was really pissed that i didnt get to watch x factor this past week b/c of those stupid baseball games! Please TAKE OFF THOSE DAMN games!
Rangerwhat 4 months ago
I don't know guys, if simon doesnt conenct with Caitlin, he won't be able to help her as much as he wants to.... On the other hand, he really connects with Tiah... I want to see Tiah's performance thuesday before I judge her, but I have to admdit: Caitlin has a better voice and a better look. Oh, and her personality... wow!
TheRainbowSeer 4 months ago
Simon was SO wrong on this one. SO WRONG.
LovingTreasure 4 months ago 2
4:27 can u believe simon chose this?!?!?!?!?!?!?
TheNarkarox 4 months ago 27
caitlin is hot AND beautiful
winnerACE1109 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA 2
He was too stubborn to admit he was wrong by ever putting her through, so he ruined Caitlin's chances and she could've gone far. I doubt Tiah will go far at all, America will not vote for her.
kathchick7 4 months ago 4
I couldn't believe when he sent Caitlin home.
I think he just called Tiah for the live show cause he didn't want to admit he was wrong.
I'm not saying she's not good, but Caitlin has the most beautiful and sweet voice of the competition.
He made a huge mistake. That's what I think
AndreMatos89 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
let me tell you why tia and simone made it to the live show.
YOU SEE X FACTOR USA DONT WANT SINGERS WHO JUST HAVE A GREAT VOICE. THEY NEED SOME STYLE, DANCE AND SWAG. THANKS
emmanuel3159 4 months ago
@charlenekimara1 yeah!!
nellycher 4 months ago
oh gosh simon !i i dont belive you make such a decision??
Twooam 4 months ago 2
He made the wrong choice!!!!!!
m0kuahi 4 months ago
Usually I agree with Simon, but what the hell? He let Caitlin AND Jazzlyn Little go? That's just wrong.
iloveyou4ever30 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
Tiah has a mouth that looks like hotdog and i bet simon likes to eat hotdog.
Caitlin light years much better in singing than tiah.
during the first audition tiah sings out of key out of tune and simon "sees" that the hotdog maybe.......no wonder paula and nicole didnt see those lips
Tiah is really a very terrible singer!
yeshareutube 4 months ago
Caitlin was one of my first favorites because her voice is amazing..but i think her over-confidence backfired !!!
brian2010lal 4 months ago
Love Thia..she may not be the prettiest but she sure is a cracker !! I know lots of people here hated her because he is not as pretty as the other girls but..Simon is hardly wrong and i agree with Simon..I think this girl is something and finger cross..she will go far !!!
brian2010lal 4 months ago
at 3:04-3:06 I thought Simon said "I made a decision babe"
cuteepuff 4 months ago
@cuteepuff He did haha
MelodicMonicaMK 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
@cuteepuff He did say that, didn't he?
iloveyou4ever30 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
@cuteepuff didnt he?
lalalandsmileful 4 months ago
I can only get 1 thumbs down that is so sick, when i would make a hell of a lot more !!!
DENMARK7470KARUP 4 months ago
Yes,Yes,Yes !!!
MarisolDeVino 4 months ago
Comment removed
MarisolDeVino 4 months ago
that green like bar is FAR too big. WHAT A JOKE
Spadesandshades 4 months ago
mal malllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll
syuz999 4 months ago
LOL people. Tiah is an artist and Caitlin is the typical boring america's girl next door. besides that caitlin aint beautiful and i quite forgot she was in the competition. Learn something from this. By the way her mask broke when the news were delivered, she's fake.
RubenAlcobia 4 months ago
hmmm i wonder why tiah got lot of haters.. maybe simon see what we cant see in her.. i mean behind her looks :p her voice is great and so as her stage present.. malas lang ni caitlin kasi beat ni simon si tiah :D hehehe
Eeriess 4 months ago
WTF! CAITLIN WAS AMAZING! TIAH IS SO BAD! SHE WILL GET ELIMINATED IN THE FIRST LIVE SHOW. UGH SIMON IS GETTING OLD..
fluffylitty1995 4 months ago
tiah deserved .....seriously!! .....caitlin performance was boring.......!!!!
TheMellowWellow 4 months ago 3
@TheMellowWellow Word!
mindlesstupa 4 months ago
Caitlin sounds EXACTLY like Emma Stone
brushbarrisonreel 4 months ago
why, simon? why??
ryzu28 4 months ago
she's rude over tiah,now she gets what she deserve,,,go tiah!
infinitiborder 4 months ago 2
@infinitiborder So true. Her true colors were exposed and her singing was so boring. Simon saw through it. There was nowhere to take her.
naturalmystic33 4 months ago
Caitlin Koch can sing all her little pretty soft songs till the cows come home, but if she was asked to really belt out a tune she would have been exposed. She is a one dimensional singer. Simone saw that.
JigsawWill 4 months ago 2
@JigsawWill THANK YOU! You said exactly what I was thinking. If she made an album, it would be called Sleepy TIme. Tiah has so much more to offer, especially after she gets more polished by pros.
naturalmystic33 4 months ago 3
simon sure loves his pepsi
fubangwha 4 months ago
the deli girl ... I'm missing something .
mieleD 4 months ago in playlist More videos from TheXFactorUSA
HUGE MISTAKE! He let his pride get in the way of this decision.
jasba1983 4 months ago
@jasba1983 Exactly he pick Tiah becuz he begged for her to get thru her audition.
jba414 4 months ago
daaa!!! i hate tiah. simon should chose caitlin instead of the stupid tiah...
fungishit456 4 months ago
Simon made sure he got the girls to house because he knew the other judges would cut Tiah. What a rip-off.
steelcantuna 4 months ago
I hate Caitlin. She seems rude. But she does have a better voice than Tiah.
SydneySuzanne13 4 months ago
@SydneySuzanne13 Douche ;c How does she seem rude?
andersfriend5 4 months ago
@SydneySuzanne13 Caitlin is so beautiful and maybe that's her problem, she relies on her looks more than she relies on her voice, although she has a very good voice, she doesn't use it. But I really hate Tiah, how could Tiah be chosen and Jazzlyin Little goes home?????
Boodie1606 4 months ago