Taiwanese singers and their mandarin (putonghua) songs are always very popular in HK. HK people don’t speak mandarin well but a lot of people know how to sing mandarin songs. It is only natural local HK singers are more popular.
BTW, Jane has won award(s) every year in HK since 2006; go check it out.
It isn't that HK ppl doesn't accept jane, it's we don't understand Putonghua very well, hence Putonghua singers don't before overly popular here. I like Jane for her English songs nayway.
That's why HK people needs to go eff themselves if they can't understand mandarin and doesn't accept such a good talent. The market is so goddamn small they still listen to that Sammi Cantopop crap. even Khalil says cantonese market is way too small. HK 's good for international english song market. but even good HK based "western style" music artists gets ruined in HK, they better off goto Taiwan where people would appreciate real music.
@eesyeesyxx I don’t know what make you think Hong Kong people don’t accept her. Her song Painted Heart for the Hong Kong film Painted Skin won the Best Original Song in the 28th Hong Kong Film Awards in 2009. I'm a fan of her too.
Taiwanese singers and their mandarin (putonghua) songs are always very popular in HK. HK people don’t speak mandarin well but a lot of people know how to sing mandarin songs. It is only natural local HK singers are more popular.
BTW, Jane has won award(s) every year in HK since 2006; go check it out.
pmbl542 5 months ago
It isn't that HK ppl doesn't accept jane, it's we don't understand Putonghua very well, hence Putonghua singers don't before overly popular here. I like Jane for her English songs nayway.
shannondoahminiskirt 10 months ago 2
@shannondoahminiskirt
That's why HK people needs to go eff themselves if they can't understand mandarin and doesn't accept such a good talent. The market is so goddamn small they still listen to that Sammi Cantopop crap. even Khalil says cantonese market is way too small. HK 's good for international english song market. but even good HK based "western style" music artists gets ruined in HK, they better off goto Taiwan where people would appreciate real music.
bigfatdick5000 4 months ago
"A very relaxing song. I'm a big fan of her. I always wonder why most Hong Kong people don't accept her and criticize her songs without "感情" :-("
eesyeesyxx 1 year ago
@eesyeesyxx I don’t know what make you think Hong Kong people don’t accept her. Her song Painted Heart for the Hong Kong film Painted Skin won the Best Original Song in the 28th Hong Kong Film Awards in 2009. I'm a fan of her too.
nptr9195 1 year ago
A very warm song. I'm a big fan of her. I always wonder why most Hong Kong people don't accept her and criticize her songs without "感情" :-(
eesyeesyxx 1 year ago
沉默安靜的在等
你轉身回來的
MsYumo4 1 year ago 2
聽起來有輕鬆 舒服的感覺 ><
shawnwei88 1 year ago 4
希望她來香港後, 会有更好的展
jensenau 2 years ago 4
@jensenau 去香港干什么~去日本发展了~香港娱乐圈比内地好点吧~当年家驹不也去日本发展了吗~
qwer19912255 1 year ago
這首歌若是現在才推出 得到的回響應該會更大 而且很適合作為小品劇的主題曲
chan808yuen 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
chan808yuen 2 years ago
這麼好的聲音,真需要一個好的作詞/曲人...
不然會浪費 這麼好的聲音
brucelin945 2 years ago 18
很喜欢她的声音。
Teddypigyyy 2 years ago 7
旋律很有味。
Winni7925 2 years ago 11
曲子是根据《牧羊曲》改编的,但成就了完全不同的意境。靚穎的诠释完美之至。
yingchaozhang 2 years ago 20
非常厲害的歌手
ycrd 2 years ago 37
同意..不斷外形好,唱歌的唱功和感情都令人很著迷的說...
mscandysugar 2 years ago 6