The Stanford Memorial Church has 3 organs. The G. Donald Harris organ is suitable for music from the late 19th-early 20th century. The Fisk organ is suitable for music from the 17th-18th centuries, and can switch between equal temperment and mean-tone temperment. There is also a positive organ.
E major isn't not an easy key...for anyone, even an hautboy d'amore. I'm guessing this was a Leipzig transposition; the band plays in E and the organ in D. Where did I stick that 460 instrument *looks around*. Do you know the d'amore version?
Has anyone noted that there is an organ playing witht he strings and such. Now take a look at the organ console - No one is there. Imagine building an organ with two console, one is electric. So why did anyone waste time building a tracker organ if it is played with pull down magnets?
Indeed the organ behind is a tracker organ, but the organ that is played is a [pipe] chamber organ built by Robin Jennings who also built "Bach Organ" for John Eliot Gardiner and two chamber organs for Robert King (of The King's Consort). The small organ was used here because we perform at Baroque pitch A=415 Hz, which is 1/2 step lower than today's modern pitch. The big organ behind is built to play at 440 Hz, and it would be difficult to play it 1/2 step lower.
I See. Interesting. There are so many of these Pseudo-trackers being built in the Neo Baroque style (whish is to say Not Baroque and anything but tracker) with limited use and very harsh sound. I am of the old school and rather like a more Universal style so the church doesn;t have to buy 4 organs to play 4 different styles of music. Thank you for the info. Nice job with the music
LOL It sounds like your from the school that says to hell with authenticity; let's play all music of all periods on modern instruments, without any regard to authenticity, so that musicians don't have to learn to play period instruments or period styles.
WC - With 400 years of changes in form & process of making instruments how do we have Authenticity. We must also have the same acoustics in which the original music, and instruments on which it was played. How far can Authenticity be pushed before it becomes impractical or impossible? Can an orchestra have complete sets of instruments to play each piece in a concert? Must all buildings duplicate concert halls built in 1700?
Should the performers also where period costumes since these might also affect the acoustics?
You seem to be making the absurd suggestion that unless we can reproduce all the acoustics down to the buildings, then we should abandon all efforts to achieve authenticity.
Bach's music is quite effective on modern instruments, even though he never intended it so. I'm sure the piece would sound interesting if the organ part were played on a Hammond.
Oh, I've heard Bach on so-called "modern" instruments. Funny that the only concession they make to authenticity is a harpsichord.
But I don't like the sound of metal strings (1950s). Or the articulation of "modern" 19th c. bows. Or the bland, blended sound of "modern" 19th c. winds.
It makes no sense to me for a 21st c. ensemble to play 18th c. music on mid-late 19th c. instruments.
Modern & period instrument sound quite different & I don't like the sound of modern instruments.
With so many excellent, historically informed, period instrument ensembles to choose from, we no longer need to settle for the so-called "modern" instruments, which really aren't modern at all; they're late 19 th. c.
We could play viol consort music on "modern" 19 th. c violins, violas & cellos strung /w wire or nylon.
But silly us, we actually use viols strung /w gut or wire spun gut.
I think the Leipzig council that hired Bach to provide their church music, and with whom he struggled with just to get the minimal resources needed to perform it, would agree with your idea about a one-size-fits-all organ to play the music.
What a great version! Thanks for posting this, it's my favorite Bach Cantata. I know it's been recorded with piano instead of harpsichord. Does anyone know who released that version?
Thanks be to God, Who gives us the eternal victory in our Lord and only Saviour Jesus Christ! Romans 5:1-2 (KJV). Sola Fide, Sola Gratia, Sola Scriptura, Solus Christus, Soli Deo Gloria! What beautiful praise resounds!
+ Fr. Philip Mullen, Orthodox Lutheran Christian Pastor, Columbus, Ohio, USA.
beautiful <3
KerryAbernethy 10 months ago
Easier on a guitar with 1/2 step lower; beautiful organ sound but volume lower or played pianissimo !
Sylvain894 11 months ago
If someone coughs, I'm outta here
luridplanet 1 year ago
ahh there's nothing like bach
quinn244 1 year ago
Lovely performance...but it's time to knock down the concrete wall that hides the musicians!
SilverlakeDehners 1 year ago
@SilverlakeDehners That's there to keep the people in the mosh pit from colliding with the musicians. Makes it harder to stage dive.
Renshen1957 1 year ago
Un regalo como lo es la obra de Bach entera.
moreak 1 year ago
Perfecto, nítido, dulce... ¡genial!
pepitho 1 year ago
ahhhhh que buen bach calido y armonico.felicitaciones
javierpe9103 1 year ago
Hermosa viola da gamba, la combinación tímbrica con los violines y el oboe es perfecta.
quetzalandino 1 year ago
Beautiful performance by musicians that love their art. Inspiring. We should all have such passion for our art!
rscott77x 2 years ago
Beautiful performance of such fantastic music.
owatson322utube 2 years ago
A true feast of Bach, played at its best. Thanks again.
Raymondo30837 2 years ago
Organ score performed by E. Manual Pedalle.
gingervytis 2 years ago
is this an Electronic organ?,I do see organ pipes,
rudly 2 years ago
A never tiring sound---I want to bring you all home with me. Thanks, again
jimbobboyorganist 2 years ago
Amazing live performance--I need to look for more videos by the New Trinity Baroque...just a very lovely sound, folks!
jimbobboyorganist 2 years ago
Just awesome... He was the best Musician in the history of Music in this world.
EsperanzaGalera 2 years ago
Great video !
This cantata exists as concerto in F for oboe, strings and continuo (it's exactly the same but the oboe play the organ's part)
It's great too but very hard for the oboe, who can't breathe ! ;-)
magafable 2 years ago
Super interpretation of this cantata. Thanks
Raymondo30837 2 years ago 2
real deal
phillynn79 2 years ago
Very popular. It is easy to see why.
toml714 2 years ago
Spiffingimo
9Kolbe 2 years ago
Magnificent!
barrister79 2 years ago
Bach a tutti!
oboistCONDUCTOR 3 years ago 2
BACH, GRANDE
jorgealbertobaron 3 years ago 2
GRAN OBRA DE BACH
jorgealbertobaron 3 years ago
I think the performance and sounds from the whole ensemble is a pleasure to listen to and watch. Thank you
Raymondo30837 3 years ago
The Stanford Memorial Church has 3 organs. The G. Donald Harris organ is suitable for music from the late 19th-early 20th century. The Fisk organ is suitable for music from the 17th-18th centuries, and can switch between equal temperment and mean-tone temperment. There is also a positive organ.
BayAreaBiker2001 3 years ago
E major isn't not an easy key...for anyone, even an hautboy d'amore. I'm guessing this was a Leipzig transposition; the band plays in E and the organ in D. Where did I stick that 460 instrument *looks around*. Do you know the d'amore version?
fagottehautboy 3 years ago
The only "d'amore version" I know is a reconstruction of the original.
It's not clear what key and solo instrument were actually used in the original.
Some say woodwind. Others say viola.
I'd love to hear it on viola!
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
The original I mentioned is, of course, lost.
I don't have the scores, but I believe the left hand part of this organ version in D merely doubles the bass line of the continuo.
But in the later version in E for harpsichord, when the left hand part is often independent of the continuo bass line.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
I meant to say that in the later version in E for harpsichord he gave the harpsichord and independent left hand part.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
al this exists in Atlanta but not in westPalm Beach despite previous efforts atBaroque opera ! amazing to me.
lovesGenet 4 years ago
You can see this little organ and it's specification by doing a search for "continuo organ for new trinity baroque"
Branchporter 4 years ago
Has anyone noted that there is an organ playing witht he strings and such. Now take a look at the organ console - No one is there. Imagine building an organ with two console, one is electric. So why did anyone waste time building a tracker organ if it is played with pull down magnets?
octave4 4 years ago
Indeed the organ behind is a tracker organ, but the organ that is played is a [pipe] chamber organ built by Robin Jennings who also built "Bach Organ" for John Eliot Gardiner and two chamber organs for Robert King (of The King's Consort). The small organ was used here because we perform at Baroque pitch A=415 Hz, which is 1/2 step lower than today's modern pitch. The big organ behind is built to play at 440 Hz, and it would be difficult to play it 1/2 step lower.
newtrinitybaroque 4 years ago 3
I See. Interesting. There are so many of these Pseudo-trackers being built in the Neo Baroque style (whish is to say Not Baroque and anything but tracker) with limited use and very harsh sound. I am of the old school and rather like a more Universal style so the church doesn;t have to buy 4 organs to play 4 different styles of music. Thank you for the info. Nice job with the music
octave4 4 years ago
LOL It sounds like your from the school that says to hell with authenticity; let's play all music of all periods on modern instruments, without any regard to authenticity, so that musicians don't have to learn to play period instruments or period styles.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
WC - With 400 years of changes in form & process of making instruments how do we have Authenticity. We must also have the same acoustics in which the original music, and instruments on which it was played. How far can Authenticity be pushed before it becomes impractical or impossible? Can an orchestra have complete sets of instruments to play each piece in a concert? Must all buildings duplicate concert halls built in 1700?
octave4 3 years ago
Should the performers also where period costumes since these might also affect the acoustics?
You seem to be making the absurd suggestion that unless we can reproduce all the acoustics down to the buildings, then we should abandon all efforts to achieve authenticity.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
Some of the music Bach wrote for the court at Coethen, he later performed in Zimmermann's coffeehouse!
I doubt the coffee house had the same acoustics as Prince Leopold's court.
In Bach's day, his music was never performed in concert halls.
Original instruments DO exist, and faithful copies CAN and ARE made from originals.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
Bach's music is quite effective on modern instruments, even though he never intended it so. I'm sure the piece would sound interesting if the organ part were played on a Hammond.
BayAreaBiker2001 2 years ago
Oh, I've heard Bach on so-called "modern" instruments. Funny that the only concession they make to authenticity is a harpsichord.
But I don't like the sound of metal strings (1950s). Or the articulation of "modern" 19th c. bows. Or the bland, blended sound of "modern" 19th c. winds.
It makes no sense to me for a 21st c. ensemble to play 18th c. music on mid-late 19th c. instruments.
Why settle for mere effectiveness
when I can hear something that sounds better?
wcbroccoli 2 years ago
Modern & period instrument sound quite different & I don't like the sound of modern instruments.
With so many excellent, historically informed, period instrument ensembles to choose from, we no longer need to settle for the so-called "modern" instruments, which really aren't modern at all; they're late 19 th. c.
We could play viol consort music on "modern" 19 th. c violins, violas & cellos strung /w wire or nylon.
But silly us, we actually use viols strung /w gut or wire spun gut.
wcbroccoli 2 years ago
Or how about the organs rock bands use?
An electrifired violins like Yanni?
wcbroccoli 2 years ago
Crap. You made me throw up my expensive dinner all over the floor. Thanks a lot, dude.
bachkirche 2 years ago
And the Beatles. You can only use Vox.
TheBitterWeed 2 years ago
Your comment makes me want to throw up...you are boorish.
1113agm 2 years ago
I think the Leipzig council that hired Bach to provide their church music, and with whom he struggled with just to get the minimal resources needed to perform it, would agree with your idea about a one-size-fits-all organ to play the music.
wcbroccoli 3 years ago
What a great version! Thanks for posting this, it's my favorite Bach Cantata. I know it's been recorded with piano instead of harpsichord. Does anyone know who released that version?
OapostropheC 4 years ago
Are you in this symphony, newtrinitybaroque?
ShatteredScarlet 4 years ago
Bach is also a sexy beast ;D
ShatteredScarlet 4 years ago
For me, this is YouTube at its best! Superbe,
Merci pour partager.
Raymondo30837 4 years ago
divine music and the players
bumblebee122 4 years ago
amazing
diesiraestudios 4 years ago
I return to this video often, a favorite. Magnificant interpretation of this cantata. Just simple pleasure. Thanks again for sharing
Raymondo30837 4 years ago
Excellent! Excellent!!!
melman74b 4 years ago
What glorious sounds resound from God's Word -- and from God's Elect, such as St. J. S. Bach! Soli Deo Gloria!
+ Fr. Philip Mullen,
Orthodox Lutheran Christian Pastor,
Ascension Orthodox Lutheran Fellowship,
Columbus, Ohio, USA.
frphilipmullen 4 years ago
Refreshing and uplifting music beautifully played
IanH39 4 years ago
I love this piece, it's cool!!! I love it!!!! Thank be God and Bach!!!!!!
romanz90 4 years ago
Simplement magnifique. Merci pour partager.
Raymondo30837 4 years ago
amen to that dbomb6.. this is so awesome
strait33fan 4 years ago
thank you lord for such beautiful music
dbomb6 4 years ago
Thanks be to God, Who gives us the eternal victory in our Lord and only Saviour Jesus Christ! Romans 5:1-2 (KJV). Sola Fide, Sola Gratia, Sola Scriptura, Solus Christus, Soli Deo Gloria! What beautiful praise resounds!
+ Fr. Philip Mullen, Orthodox Lutheran Christian Pastor, Columbus, Ohio, USA.
Helios00017 4 years ago
Amen, thousands of amens, brother...salutes from Peru
jvc2410 4 years ago
Elegent!
tm37gl 4 years ago
beautiful simply magnificent
be3eu 4 years ago
Soli Deo gloria.
totogabi 4 years ago