Very welcome to have a listen to AirwavesJoxfields Vegetable (Elephant ) Man with Joxfields tribute-to-David-Gilmour's-ca-1971-playing guitar at 1.59. If you make a visit; hope you enjoy it! Cheers!
Gilmour & Mason are the vocalists, not Waters. Gilmour sing always the first phrase "Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg" and Mason the second "he won it in the war in 1944" etc...the phrase "are they really sad for me..." is sung by Gilmour...Wright & Waters sing "miss Clegg another drop of gin..." etc..
Syd Barrett didn't write this or play on it. This is from Saucerful of Secrets, in which there is only one Syd song, "Jugband BLues' at the end of the album. I think Waters wrote this. Even if I didn't know this to be fact, you can just tell, this isn't Barrett's songwriting style at all.
@dreekd80 It is indeed a Waters song, with the theme of war and loss being the give-away. subsitute leg for life and it is yet another (sarcastically) resentful song about his father. As for this not being Barrett's style, i disagree, i think Waters tried to do a calque of that style on Saucerful of Secrets when they felt they had to somehow fill Syd's shoes. While it's not a perfect imitation, it's definitely Waters' jab at being Barrett and i think he did a pretty decent job at it.
@ledzeppize while this is, i think, the only Floyd song where Mason gets to sing lead, all of them but Waters sing lead at some point on the album version. however, this here is an early unfinished recording of the song and the "dear oh dear..." part is sung by Waters (Gilmour sings it on the album version). the ending is also radically different. i could use some help though: who sings the "had a wooden leg..." parts, Mason or Wright? Wright doesn't break his voice like that on other songs.
@lazark Gilmour & Mason are the vocalists, not Waters. Gilmour sing always the first phrase "Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg" and Mason the second "he won it in the war in 1944" etc...the phrase "are they really sad for me..." is sung by Gilmour...Wright & Waters sing "miss Clegg another drop of gin..." etc..the song is the same version of ASOS, they are in playback...the difference between the two version is that in this version there's no kazoo in the final part of the song..
If you think this is good well...Introducing the next big thing, and its some real quality tracks. Click my channel to open your mind up to a whole new world of musical truth. Promise. Don't forget to subscribe =]
Oh shit I just posted this and didn't even realize that the uploaded had called himself Arnold Layne lol, that wasnt a ref to you mate lol just me having a laugh lol. I love the Floyd
Corporal Clegg had a wooden dick , he won it in a game wasn't it a shame that they wrote this sooonnnggg. arnold lane had a strange hobby! Collecting womens soiled panties so he could sniff them at night! Lol lol ha ha
It depends on which one you're talking about... the wah quarter notes are definately Gilmour on guitar, but the eerie sounds in the background I'm not sure about.
Roger Waters wrote the song. David Gilmour and Nick Mason sang it. Nick sings the parts like "he won it in the war, in 1944", the rest is David. Syd only played on 3 tracks on Saucerful of Secrets: Set the Controls, Remember a Day and Jugband Blues (which was also the only song he wrote on the album).
Lo bueno es que llegó alguien del calibre de David, que lo que siempre digo: "David no llegó a sustituir a Syd, solo llegó a dar un sabor diferente a la banda".
To be honest The Beatles had "Tomorrow Never Knows", "She Said She Said""Strawberry Fields Forever, Sgt Pepper title track, and "A Day in the Life" in the bag before Pink Floyd recorded their first single "Arnold Layne". That does not mean Pink Floyd were copycats. No one was creating songs like Astromony Domine or Interstellar Overdrive. Interesting Sgt Pepper and Corporal Clegg have a similiar guitar riff at the start of the song.
gomektampa (1 month ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam This must have been the day after they kick Syd out of the band! His voice is still on the recording.
sparklerdims (3 days ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam syd didn't sing at all on this song, if anything he might have played some guitar, but most info points to it only being dave.
I hate to say it but I think Ween borrowed heavily from the early years of Pink Floyd. Especially this song, Scream Thy Last Cream, and Vegetable Man.
Actually, there is a lot of Rick in there too, especially on the chorus. There isn't a lot of Roger, but I do think he sings the "he won it in the war" part. I've heard people say that Nick or Syd is in there--funny, because depending on who you talk to, all 5 of them sang on it! Nick's voice might be in there on the chorus, but I think it's mostly Dave on the verses with Rick in the background, Rick on the chorus with everyone else singing backups, and Roger on the funny bits in-between.
I've always heard that it's nick saying "he won it in the war" "in 1944" etc. etc. Syd only took part in 2 songs on "A Saucer Full Of Secrets", He played guitar for some parts in "Set the controls for the heart of the sun" and wrote "Jugband Blues".
Try to compare song like Help, love me do, and I wanna hold your hand from the early beatles with music from the piper at the gates of dawn and you will see the difference.
the beatles began producing their "psychedelic" material after their famous trip to india, songs like Lucy in the Sky with Diamons (LSD) and I am the Warlus, but thats in the 70's..the pink floyd has been producing that since the mid 60's
The Beatles didn't go to India until after Sgt. Pepper's and the songs you're talking about. They starting writing the White Album in Rishikesh in '68
in those times, the beatles were just another boy band, the backstreet boys without the gay dancing and actually playing instruments. but what the floyd did was innovating, it was something new, never before seen in the history of england..the material included in the piper at the gates of dawn and in the early singles is very different to the type of songs that the beatles wrote in the 60's
"just another boy band" ??? Sgt. Peppers - Corporal Clegg. Interesting coincidence. "Try to compare song like Help, love me do, and I wanna hold your hand" ?? Are you for real? Your expertise (or lack of it) is exposed in your comment: "the beatles began..., but thats in the 70's" THE BEATLES BROKE UP BEFORE THE 70s!!! Try again.
1 person voted this video down, while 478 like! (including my last vote, if i've not voted up, it would have been 477 like.)
HateIronMaiden 5 days ago
well 1 person is clearly retared
Mrlogan2914 1 week ago
Pink Floyd is my biggest inspiration to my trippy music. So check it out I would be much obliged.
BohemienGypsies 1 week ago
The only thing better than this song is this video :)
mcsavage89 2 weeks ago
Pink Floyd isn't Pink Floyd without David Gilmour
Xav48 2 weeks ago
@Xav48 but gilmour is on this video .___.
Nick666Metal 1 week ago
Sad that people need drugs to be be happy...
BloopBloop213 2 weeks ago
Nick Mason rules on shared lead vocal !!!
zapspace 3 weeks ago
Iam alloverthe Internetweb
Chancestodolak 3 weeks ago
If you don't play kazoo Fudge you
Chancestodolak 3 weeks ago
He won it in the war
In 1944
Chancestodolak 3 weeks ago
pink floyd makes me happy especially when I'm on drugs!
MrBubblegumballs 2 months ago 17
@MrBubblegumballs Dude, everything makes me happy when im on drugs lol, but pink floyd especially makes me happy
mattmann35 1 month ago
so if you ever needed to name a song that uses the kazoo...(along with yellow submarine, and rollercoaster of love :b)
fakecandyheart 2 months ago
NGC-2999 (SRD)
YoyoCarlanie 2 months ago
Caracaaaaaaa !!!!!! Que RARO !!!!
bixudomato 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Very welcome to have a listen to AirwavesJoxfields Vegetable (Elephant ) Man with Joxfields tribute-to-David-Gilmour's-ca-1971-playing guitar at 1.59. If you make a visit; hope you enjoy it! Cheers!
fdsvenskvisslare 2 months ago
NGC-2999 (SRD)
YoyoCarlanie 3 months ago
my favorite
Jewels122973 3 months ago
I love The Verve but their psychadelic music gives me headaches, so I came here to listen to this old gem instead :)
Donkeyn00b 4 months ago 3
Pink Floyd makes me happy. I don't need drugs
jneil2007 4 months ago
@jneil2007 I don't need drugs, but their always useful :)
silentwulfsfan 2 months ago in playlist silentwulfsfan's favourites
This was recorded for BRT (Belgian Dutch tv) in 1968 on the site of the 1958 World fair in Brussels. There were 5 songs all of them play back.
sjeesto1 5 months ago
History Repeats: Riots in London August 2011
Another Mass Hysteria episode like 1944.
Don't eat the ergot-laced rye bread, England.
Meanwhile in Americal, downgrade to AA- by Standard & Poors.
Some dude on The news named Clegg talking about the riots in London today. i don't know what to think!
SuperMegaUberGenius 5 months ago
Gilmour & Mason are the vocalists, not Waters. Gilmour sing always the first phrase "Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg" and Mason the second "he won it in the war in 1944" etc...the phrase "are they really sad for me..." is sung by Gilmour...Wright & Waters sing "miss Clegg another drop of gin..." etc..
sermax75 5 months ago
JUSTIN BIEBER TIRATE A UN POZO
marceloelperry 5 months ago
@marceloelperry que tendra que ver... ganas de hacer bardo nada mas
IriMuse10 5 months ago
@IriMuse10 hacer bardo implica que estoy bardeando a alguien y no pues que no ai nadie quien lo reciba y solo doy mi opinion
marceloelperry 5 months ago
@marceloelperry pero la pregunta es ¿que coño tiene que ver con pink floyd?
IriMuse10 5 months ago
I bought a kazoo because of this song seriously
BadtasteBraindead 6 months ago
isn't that syd's voice on this song?
flowerlove79 6 months ago
Comment removed
joewalshinjamesgang 5 months ago
This song makes me jolly.
e3ruisdead 6 months ago
Syd Barrett didn't write this or play on it. This is from Saucerful of Secrets, in which there is only one Syd song, "Jugband BLues' at the end of the album. I think Waters wrote this. Even if I didn't know this to be fact, you can just tell, this isn't Barrett's songwriting style at all.
dreekd80 6 months ago
@dreekd80 It is indeed a Waters song, with the theme of war and loss being the give-away. subsitute leg for life and it is yet another (sarcastically) resentful song about his father. As for this not being Barrett's style, i disagree, i think Waters tried to do a calque of that style on Saucerful of Secrets when they felt they had to somehow fill Syd's shoes. While it's not a perfect imitation, it's definitely Waters' jab at being Barrett and i think he did a pretty decent job at it.
lazark 6 months ago
Nick Mason on vocals, LOL
ledzeppize 6 months ago
@ledzeppize while this is, i think, the only Floyd song where Mason gets to sing lead, all of them but Waters sing lead at some point on the album version. however, this here is an early unfinished recording of the song and the "dear oh dear..." part is sung by Waters (Gilmour sings it on the album version). the ending is also radically different. i could use some help though: who sings the "had a wooden leg..." parts, Mason or Wright? Wright doesn't break his voice like that on other songs.
lazark 6 months ago
@lazark Gilmour & Mason are the vocalists, not Waters. Gilmour sing always the first phrase "Corporal Clegg had a wooden leg" and Mason the second "he won it in the war in 1944" etc...the phrase "are they really sad for me..." is sung by Gilmour...Wright & Waters sing "miss Clegg another drop of gin..." etc..the song is the same version of ASOS, they are in playback...the difference between the two version is that in this version there's no kazoo in the final part of the song..
sermax75 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you think this is good well...Introducing the next big thing, and its some real quality tracks. Click my channel to open your mind up to a whole new world of musical truth. Promise. Don't forget to subscribe =]
AbsoluteZeroMusic 7 months ago
Oh shit I just posted this and didn't even realize that the uploaded had called himself Arnold Layne lol, that wasnt a ref to you mate lol just me having a laugh lol. I love the Floyd
macrobioticman 7 months ago
Corporal Clegg had a wooden dick , he won it in a game wasn't it a shame that they wrote this sooonnnggg. arnold lane had a strange hobby! Collecting womens soiled panties so he could sniff them at night! Lol lol ha ha
macrobioticman 7 months ago
Great promo, love this song very much. Thanks for this video :o)
StefBarrett1976 7 months ago
Syd, we miss you
MegaSpalman 9 months ago
@surreydodger Syd isn't in this video at all. That's Dave with the whistle. (^_^)
warmswarm 10 months ago
Syd isn't playing a Kazoo in the video, it's a whoopie whistle. That said, the instrument we can hear sounds like a Kazoo
surreydodger 10 months ago
@surreydodger first off its a slide whistle not a "whoopie" whistle and second off theres no syd at all hahaha!
clashboy1977 9 months ago
I wonder if Dave felt silly with that kazoo in his mouth. Fuck it, it's still awesome.
Nolan012345 10 months ago
That is one cool riff. Hendrix worthy.
ThePaulpFiction 10 months ago
So heavy.
hilvldruid 10 months ago
IMPORTANT NOTICE-thankes for playing your insturments
comandernuf 11 months ago
This song shows the eternal brighting flame of Pink Floyd. What a pleasure of men.
thedarkglobe 1 year ago 2
The Floyd, Baby!!! Nothing is better.
todd291022 1 year ago
I fjasijdawpóe jijijiji
zetsu654 1 year ago
Is this remix well known? It is so different from the album version - it's terrific.
nyu6697 1 year ago
@nyu6697 it's the mono version
MrFloydTube 10 months ago
@nyu6697 it's the mono version
MrFloydTube 10 months ago
yes it's mason who sings the overly british sounding lines...
marnold6879 1 year ago
lmfao gilmour rockin' that kazoo like it's nobody's bizness
marnold6879 1 year ago
Without LSD is already trippy imagine using acid.
MrDodstink 1 year ago
LSD,LSD
moonchield365 1 year ago
LSD,LSD
moonchield365 1 year ago
The music in this video is better quality than the one on the album.
darkincinerater 1 year ago
Sober people don't write music like this
It's trippy as hell and I love it
ChrisRane 1 year ago
@ChrisRane people with severe bad musical taste affliction don't like this song or kind of music either...
moxie96 1 year ago
Nice song!
Pink Floyd rules!!
gustiydiego15 1 year ago
awesome! greetings from holland
MickBirdPF 1 year ago
david gilmour isnt here
Watchman5169 1 year ago
@Watchman5169 thank's God!!!! Syd legend.....
sickpoola 1 year ago
@sickpoola luckly!!
Watchman5169 1 year ago
i am fortunate to know this song and many like it.
ropebelldinglin 1 year ago
freakin' musical genius's .........
DanielJoseDiego 1 year ago
Is a Classic Song... The legend of Rock...Pink Floyd
MrCrisDav 1 year ago
don`t you think that david gilmour kinda looks like david bowie?
k0stil 1 year ago
@k0stil ?? no...
elinmagg 1 year ago
@elinmagg i agree....
Sixtiesera 1 year ago
My dad was Corporal Clegg in 1945- probably no connection...
Cleggs1000 1 year ago
is that Gilmour?
EvilRedGoose 1 year ago
yea this was like the only time nick mason sang, that's why you can't tell who it is. he never sang again did he? not too bad of a voice.
derekdeprator 1 year ago
@derekdeprator He did actually, in "Scream thy last scream"
Klindza 1 year ago
@Klindza Also in "One of These Days"!
amtlpaul 1 year ago
Comment removed
slipdrum80 1 year ago
@slipdrum80
No it wasn't. It's David and Roger. Other videos show them lip-syncing to Syd's vocals, but this ain't one of them.
wgb01001 1 year ago
@wgb01001
My mistake!
slipdrum80 1 year ago
What a band they were then
kenfig 1 year ago
LSD song !
seweryne30 1 year ago
FOXY LADY!!!!
Burbah 1 year ago
@Burbah
DAAAAAAAAM
psyc rock is the best!
maxim2266 1 year ago
best track on that album i always skip from this to jugband blues. have no time for the other 2 (only 2) shit tracks on the album!
clashboy1977 1 year ago
That key change at the end... it's not on my album Saucerful, it just stays the same and there is more kazoo shenanigans
JimmyRimsphere 1 year ago
i wish i had a ruffle shirt
1967DodgeVan 1 year ago
Love seeing Gilmour shred that Kazoo!
ZeppelinFloydRoses 1 year ago
@ZeppelinFloydRoses
Only David Gilmour can squeeze those kazoo notes out of a slide whistle
JimmyRimsphere 1 year ago
needs more cow bell
Hhound 1 year ago 3
who sings this song?
by the way one of my favorite pink floyd songs
Traydon3211 1 year ago
@Traydon3211 David and Rick sing it, and Nick sings the "He won it in the war..." and "From her majesty the Queen..." lines
herbleus 1 year ago
@herbleus I thought that those funny parts were sang by Waters, i'm quite sure about that
napomania 1 year ago
@napomania I'm sorry but you're wrong. Water's doesnt even sing in this song, I checked that on a Floyd related website. Nick Mason sings that lines.
herbleus 1 year ago
@herbleus then whats the part that syd sings???
skinnyhell94 1 year ago
@skinnyhell94 Syd doesn't sing in this one. The only song in A Saucerful of Secrets in which he sings is Jugband Blues
herbleus 1 year ago
Comment removed
slipdrum80 1 year ago
@slipdrum80 No, he doesn't. He has nothing to do with this song.
herbleus 1 year ago
This Song seems really out of place on the Album. Sound, vocals, everything.
mujuma 1 year ago
yes so proud of him
richysst 1 year ago
"His boots were very clean."
apacolipps 1 year ago 2
@apacolipps ... Mrs Clegg you must be proud of him, Mrs Clegg another drop of gin.
zed0469 1 year ago
Best kazoo solo in a rock song, bar none!
apacolipps 1 year ago 51
@apacolipps Beck did one on "Steal my Body Home" , at the very end of the song, it's creepy check it out
Justen1980 9 months ago
@apacolipps he's actually playing a slide whistle but squeezing kazoo notes out lol cuz david is awesome
XxscenekidzrulexX 7 months ago
anyone eva seen tv comdey black books with bill bailey??>..intro sounds like music to that
lovesclareybum 2 years ago
see what you mean
genesisrock43 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, could this be any worse?
miamad 2 years ago
what is wrong with you i love this song!!!!!! haha kazoo i love it!
hangmanneal 2 years ago 17
This is Roger Waters trying to sound like Syd.
rokysyd11 2 years ago
however, it's an awesome one
sasybee 2 years ago
another drop of gin????
pigonthewing1972 2 years ago
Comment removed
navidivan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is before Gilmour became a fatass.
miamad 2 years ago
ahah lol
sasybee 2 years ago
i love to listen pink floyds when im high...
Amunooo 2 years ago 3
syd <3
Whippettussi 2 years ago
Best kazoo solo in history!
ZeppelinFloydRoses 2 years ago 2
psych good
bla647 2 years ago
Syd was very talented, how many different instruments could he play?
ILLKRILLKILLER 2 years ago
i think theres also slide kazoos
greenfuzzz16 2 years ago
Is there any reason the kazoo solo is being played on a slide whistle in the video?
themccookinator 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the piper at the gates of dawn?
decendeded 2 years ago
is rick doing that guitar sound on the keyboard in the mrs. clegg chours?
greenfuzzz16 2 years ago
It depends on which one you're talking about... the wah quarter notes are definately Gilmour on guitar, but the eerie sounds in the background I'm not sure about.
themccookinator 2 years ago
yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!!!
britdemmen 2 years ago
Arnold Layne.
The version they filmed in Britain.
FurryOwlet 2 years ago
arnold layne
roflcopter804 2 years ago
the one where he yells "why cant you see" is arnold layne :)
rileyhisteria 2 years ago
The riff sounds like jimi hindrix foxy lady
tylerbob94 2 years ago
yeah i was thinking the same thing man
popwarskatemore7 2 years ago
haha thats weird because I was trying to think what it reminded me of now I see.
rach6st 2 years ago
David Gilmour is singing
Epicous 2 years ago
Good song!
LesPaulGoldTop21 2 years ago
no thats david singing it. same thing on see emily play. syd has a little deeper voice.
acidman135 2 years ago
so syd is singing this song right?
and roger wrote it?
strawberrypicker123 2 years ago
I don't think wrote this song. He didn't write much until after Syd Barrett
jesus201866 2 years ago
Roger Waters wrote the song. David Gilmour and Nick Mason sang it. Nick sings the parts like "he won it in the war, in 1944", the rest is David. Syd only played on 3 tracks on Saucerful of Secrets: Set the Controls, Remember a Day and Jugband Blues (which was also the only song he wrote on the album).
Cgrrp 2 years ago 3
@Cgrrp you're right but this song is definetly watres writing in syds style in keeping with the band's "direction" if you could call it that!
theres definetly some syd in this song even though he had absolutely nothing to do with it haha!
clashboy1977 1 year ago
water's actually wrote this song, its where you begin to see him exserting his influence.... and where you see where the band is sort of headed.
sleepers1124 2 years ago
They call me Mr Tinkertrain
goodperson656 2 years ago
Wicked song. Though I guess now we know where Austin Powers got his frilly shirts from: he stole them from Nick Mason's attic, haha.
JackSharks74 2 years ago 31
thats right baaaabee
AdamMoss13 2 years ago
1:19 it goes a bit chorlton and the wheelies
dazzera112233 2 years ago
ay, pero falta syd.... NO.
anitasseo 2 years ago
eso es lo peor.
Lo bueno es que llegó alguien del calibre de David, que lo que siempre digo: "David no llegó a sustituir a Syd, solo llegó a dar un sabor diferente a la banda".
Pasala chévere Anita.
; )
lou2406892 2 years ago
gracias.. sí, por lo menos gilmour es un copado..sinó con el amargo de waters solo no sé qué hacían. je
anitasseo 2 years ago
All hail the allmighty floyd!
PS: Gotta love 1:18 ! =P
uberrobi 2 years ago 6
Triffic
squarepyramid99 2 years ago
LMAO look at mason and gilmour there so young lol...
goodperson656 2 years ago
wow.... thanks, nice video
rudmarul 2 years ago
Hi, matildamothers ;)))....u ma sista??
matildafloyd 2 years ago
To be honest The Beatles had "Tomorrow Never Knows", "She Said She Said""Strawberry Fields Forever, Sgt Pepper title track, and "A Day in the Life" in the bag before Pink Floyd recorded their first single "Arnold Layne". That does not mean Pink Floyd were copycats. No one was creating songs like Astromony Domine or Interstellar Overdrive. Interesting Sgt Pepper and Corporal Clegg have a similiar guitar riff at the start of the song.
Matildamothers 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
Matildamothers 2 years ago
This a brillant song.
gomektampa (1 month ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam This must have been the day after they kick Syd out of the band! His voice is still on the recording.
sparklerdims (3 days ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam syd didn't sing at all on this song, if anything he might have played some guitar, but most info points to it only being dave.
marios745 2 years ago
I hate to say it but I think Ween borrowed heavily from the early years of Pink Floyd. Especially this song, Scream Thy Last Cream, and Vegetable Man.
0hmprakash 2 years ago
syd didn't sing at all on this song, if anything he might have played some guitar, but most info points to it only being dave.
sparklerdims 2 years ago
The video is pretty old, but I still love this song and all others from the same album. ^^
dartagnanv 2 years ago
This a brillant song.
frEEturk 2 years ago 2
didnt nick sing this song?
Flote666 3 years ago
yes
axzck 2 years ago
no, it's dave and roger. it's rumoured that Nick sang Scream Thy Last Scream, otherwise only offically he 'sings' on One of these days
sparklerdims 2 years ago
Actually, there is a lot of Rick in there too, especially on the chorus. There isn't a lot of Roger, but I do think he sings the "he won it in the war" part. I've heard people say that Nick or Syd is in there--funny, because depending on who you talk to, all 5 of them sang on it! Nick's voice might be in there on the chorus, but I think it's mostly Dave on the verses with Rick in the background, Rick on the chorus with everyone else singing backups, and Roger on the funny bits in-between.
mabewa 2 years ago
I've always heard that it's nick saying "he won it in the war" "in 1944" etc. etc. Syd only took part in 2 songs on "A Saucer Full Of Secrets", He played guitar for some parts in "Set the controls for the heart of the sun" and wrote "Jugband Blues".
ElliotSpencerBassett 2 years ago
no he plays leads in tis song
aidanofbuses 2 years ago
Hmmm, I've heard he only played those two songs in that album, but I could be wrong.
ElliotSpencerBassett 2 years ago
i do believe syd played on "remember a day", that was supposed to be on piper at the gates of dawn.
ttuu01 2 years ago
Rick was a cutie :D
converselovex 3 years ago 7
you can say OTHER bands copied the beatles, the hairstyles, only 4 band members, the dressing but not pink floyd.
elmanuele 3 years ago 6
Try to compare song like Help, love me do, and I wanna hold your hand from the early beatles with music from the piper at the gates of dawn and you will see the difference.
the beatles began producing their "psychedelic" material after their famous trip to india, songs like Lucy in the Sky with Diamons (LSD) and I am the Warlus, but thats in the 70's..the pink floyd has been producing that since the mid 60's
elmanuele 3 years ago
The Beatles didn't go to India until after Sgt. Pepper's and the songs you're talking about. They starting writing the White Album in Rishikesh in '68
jonchapple 2 years ago
it's funny how everyone wanted to be the beatles, all of their early stuff is like beatles but with a hint of crazyness from syd.
wolfmoon2682 3 years ago
I am not sure I agree. What do other views think?
I think the Beatles copied Pink Floyd around the time of Sgt. Pepper. Paul McCartney was in the studio while recording The pipe at the gates of dawn.
The beatles pre-1967 were more pop and I do not hear anything that sound like anything pink floyd has ever done.
greattools 3 years ago
actually, nobody copied the beatles..
in those times, the beatles were just another boy band, the backstreet boys without the gay dancing and actually playing instruments. but what the floyd did was innovating, it was something new, never before seen in the history of england..the material included in the piper at the gates of dawn and in the early singles is very different to the type of songs that the beatles wrote in the 60's
elmanuele 3 years ago
"just another boy band" ??? Sgt. Peppers - Corporal Clegg. Interesting coincidence. "Try to compare song like Help, love me do, and I wanna hold your hand" ?? Are you for real? Your expertise (or lack of it) is exposed in your comment: "the beatles began..., but thats in the 70's" THE BEATLES BROKE UP BEFORE THE 70s!!! Try again.
yesmuseum 3 years ago
agreed with u elmanuale
DaveJonWaters 2 years ago
Best of lyrics.
kookietur 3 years ago 3
never heard that ending before..
bolivianex 3 years ago
LOL My last name is Clegg, and my father was a Corperal b4 he got dishonerable...discharge...but its still cool!
QponFILMZ 3 years ago 4