This is a terrible performance, with Robbie Maddix's drumming being especially piss poor. They all look and sound like they can't be bothered, and this marked the beginning of the end of the Roses first time around.
This is the studio session for the 'Help' War Child charity record, bands had 24 hours to record a track. Roses did this... was also the first time Lucky appeared from Radionhead, fact fans.
W/o comparing the Roses to Oasis, let's be clear on one thing -- while Liam owes his persona to Ian, in this case, the student has clearly surpassed the teacher.
@utrapzab In my opinion, Liam's a much better singer, which is particularly apparent in live recordings. For ex, check out his singing on the live-in-the-studio cover of The Jam's Carnation. Peace!
@LeGrandeOrange id probably go with that, ians voice is pretty crap tbh, but the band far and away exceeds what oasis could do, they were too formulaic and as a result only their first album really had any worth, by the time whats the story came out they were a firmly established chav band with no real innovation
...time will tell, my guess is my son will play waterfall but wont play digsy dinner
thats like a class jam they must be ragin they canny teleport back there & work out a way2 succeed cos they woulda totally a been more than JUST legends. they really woulda been across the board special if they hadda....& fish shoulda stuck with marillion tooooooo
thats like a class jam they must be ragin they canny teleport back there & work out a way2 succeed cos they woulda totally a been more than JUST legends. they really woulda been across the board special if they hadda....& fish shoulda stuck with marillion tooooooo
Cant believe it... click on this video and I still see the words 'justin' and 'bieber' somewhere on the screen. Fact is.. the fact the Stone Roses were as successful as they were with someone completely incapable of singing is extraordinary.
I think the beauty of Stone Roses' music is in the contrast between the absolutely brilliant and talented music and Ian Browns almost effortless sounding vocals, although effortless isn't the word I'm trying to chase here. Guy does his best and sounds great, maybe it's just that he's not too keen into trying to be so technical.
@saracen09767 Also your intelligence seems to be low because you immediatly call me names. Something only the people with fewer brain cells do. So get lost. Oasis isn't a great band because they only made 2 great records and only continued their music career because of the money involved. Their was no love for music. The absolute low was Heathen Chemistry, one of the worst records ever.
@saracen09767 So you think every record with a lot of sales is a quality record? If you know anything about music, then you know that is not always the case. Offcourse there are records that completely deserve their large sales numbers. The comparison you draw here is incorrect because the time is different, The Roses weren't 'hot and cool' anymore and Oasis was. That explains the difference in sales. The truth is Oasis can never make a track like Breaking into Heaven. To good for them.
@ianbrownshairdo Yes, all Robbie Maddix seemed to do was play the same drumbeat to whatever Roses song he happened to be playing on. After hearing this, I reminded myself of how good Reni was by listening again to the proper version with him behind the kit. Doesn't compare.
The Roses were over when Reni left, and this version of Love Spreads shows why. Robbie Maddix sounds really sloppy compared to Reni, and the added keyboard player only makes things even worse.
oasis were the shit man the best of an era m8 but i also luv the roses iv got footage frorm 95 in mancher with liam and ian singing i dig a pony by the beatles so there couldnt have been that much hatred
I know they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery....but cmon, Liam fucking ripped off Ian Brown's whole persona and singing style to some respect.
@MrScottBach It's your opinion and all what I can do is respect it. I love Oasis and I know lots of their songs sounds bit like Beatles... and bit like Stone Roses. But I also love these two bands. Love Spreads is such a genial song and John Squire is guitar hero
@DannyMadFerIt Dickhead! thats not Reni!! Reni is one of the best drummers of all time they say he's like Keith Moon!! this guy Robbie Maddex is shit! they had this drummer for 12 mouth or so till they split!! because Reni quit first!!
this is gold. And not fool's gold, mind you. This is 24fuckingK GOLD. Absolutely brilliant. Thanks for posting mate, I owe you one.
sickboy3883 1 week ago
Ian Brown actually sounds really good live here....I knew he had it in him!! stay off the fags for heatton park brownie
matthewvaughan1 1 month ago
Got to love a bit of 90s editing
davidmar43 1 month ago
I love teis song , thnx
shahrammajd 1 month ago
this kicks ass! thanx
rikydee6 1 month ago
Great!
mashugac 2 months ago
I would have writen a differnt vocal to that riff.
desasterz 3 months ago
@desasterz Go on then.
BlackRoysWhiteWife 2 months ago 2
from 0.00 till o.31.00 its impossible to match,enjoy
benchillred 3 months ago
0:16 why is the guy from renford rejects sat in the studio lol? (I'm joking I know who it is)
WillBaxter93 3 months ago
funny drummer
MrFeelgood95 3 months ago
yeh yeh yeher, who cares who on drums. enjoy
benchillred 3 months ago
Let's play nicely together CHILDREN! Its's the ROSES!
umbudamidlun 4 months ago
i like the piano bits that u dont get on the album
1861robertelee 4 months ago
What is Maddox up to now, anyone know?
1861robertelee 4 months ago
This is a terrible performance, with Robbie Maddix's drumming being especially piss poor. They all look and sound like they can't be bothered, and this marked the beginning of the end of the Roses first time around.
paulph12002 4 months ago
@paulph12002
I think Maddox drumming is good in this..
hofsteveO 4 months ago
Comment removed
paulph12002 4 months ago
Where the fuck does mani get those bass lines from?
ShazzbotBlue 4 months ago
@ShazzbotBlue Perhaps he went down to the crossroads. :)
Silaxian 3 months ago
not the same without Reni, should off just ended it when he left, he was the heart and soul off the band......
anginman123 4 months ago
This is the studio session for the 'Help' War Child charity record, bands had 24 hours to record a track. Roses did this... was also the first time Lucky appeared from Radionhead, fact fans.
adeyboy 4 months ago
Fuck off Kasbian, Oasis and Beady Eye. These are the Stone Roses
oneilexpress 4 months ago
The Roses were and are inovators of music .....oasis copy .....Kasabian even more
caribbean02 4 months ago
W/o comparing the Roses to Oasis, let's be clear on one thing -- while Liam owes his persona to Ian, in this case, the student has clearly surpassed the teacher.
LeGrandeOrange 4 months ago
@LeGrandeOrange in what way?
utrapzab 4 months ago
@utrapzab In my opinion, Liam's a much better singer, which is particularly apparent in live recordings. For ex, check out his singing on the live-in-the-studio cover of The Jam's Carnation. Peace!
LeGrandeOrange 3 months ago
@LeGrandeOrange id probably go with that, ians voice is pretty crap tbh, but the band far and away exceeds what oasis could do, they were too formulaic and as a result only their first album really had any worth, by the time whats the story came out they were a firmly established chav band with no real innovation
...time will tell, my guess is my son will play waterfall but wont play digsy dinner
utrapzab 3 months ago
@utrapzab agreed!
LeGrandeOrange 3 months ago
@LeGrandeOrange at the end of the day its not where your from.....
utrapzab 3 months ago
Letz not slag either The Roses are Legends Oasis Were and Will Be Legends again Beady Eye are a good band Blur are shite....
Marky1888 4 months ago
@Marky1888 beady eye are like runny poo
ogfunk187 4 months ago
@ogfunk187 shit then
joydivision808 4 months ago
That's the recording for the HELP benefit album around '95.
ptrcktrnr 4 months ago
thats like a class jam they must be ragin they canny teleport back there & work out a way2 succeed cos they woulda totally a been more than JUST legends. they really woulda been across the board special if they hadda....& fish shoulda stuck with marillion tooooooo
jaysus i hate oasis too........ but liam is ok
seamusbonner 4 months ago
thats like a class jam they must be ragin they canny teleport back there & work out a way2 succeed cos they woulda totally a been more than JUST legends. they really woulda been across the board special if they hadda....& fish shoulda stuck with marillion tooooooo
seamusbonner 4 months ago
90's nostalgia staple that is a must-have for any soundtrack played during a heist.
flyinglionbg 5 months ago
Where in the hel did you get this? This is awesome.
alexpesek 5 months ago 6
@alexpesek - I had a bunch of old VHS tapes with a bunch of Britpop on there and finally got around to converting them.
cardifanscom 5 months ago 6
Squire is so smooth man. That guy rocks.
tubingtheworld 5 months ago
liam and ian suck just as that stupid drummer. stone roses were more than beatles and oasis
TheVisitorsClub 6 months ago
Cant believe it... click on this video and I still see the words 'justin' and 'bieber' somewhere on the screen. Fact is.. the fact the Stone Roses were as successful as they were with someone completely incapable of singing is extraordinary.
mooghead 6 months ago
Comment removed
mxer145 6 months ago
Comment removed
mxer145 6 months ago
@saracen09767 stone roses piss all over oasis. And justin bieber is getting a lot of record sales. quality has nothing to do with sales ya nob
campbelllovescock 6 months ago
Comment removed
campbelllovescock 6 months ago
we don't care, i love ian et liam. 2 great band and it's cool.
anonymeprod 7 months ago
THE STONE ROSES IS THE 2nd BEATLES who fade away like a butterfly
BrianJones1888 7 months ago
Nigel Ipinson on Keyboards everybody!!
ucla4eva 7 months ago
Nice language, idiot.
Now FUCK OFF
twattybollock 8 months ago
@twattybollock fuk me man u hav the best name ive EVA seen
i hope ur not a 12 yr old boy or there cud b trouble...???
bratstarr 6 months ago
And people think Liam G is original............
Ian B copied Tim Bugess, who copied Mick Jagger, who copied little Richard.
All this music comes from....................Bluetones started it.
twattybollock 8 months ago
@twattybollock ian copied burgess ??? the roses were formed years before the charlatans you knobhead
you're a top dickhead . or you think you're a smart cunt which you aren't
goonchistaw 8 months ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
I think the beauty of Stone Roses' music is in the contrast between the absolutely brilliant and talented music and Ian Browns almost effortless sounding vocals, although effortless isn't the word I'm trying to chase here. Guy does his best and sounds great, maybe it's just that he's not too keen into trying to be so technical.
jore0806 8 months ago
Comment removed
jore0806 8 months ago
Comment removed
jore0806 8 months ago
@saracen09767 Also your intelligence seems to be low because you immediatly call me names. Something only the people with fewer brain cells do. So get lost. Oasis isn't a great band because they only made 2 great records and only continued their music career because of the money involved. Their was no love for music. The absolute low was Heathen Chemistry, one of the worst records ever.
Sndrtj 9 months ago
@saracen09767 So you think every record with a lot of sales is a quality record? If you know anything about music, then you know that is not always the case. Offcourse there are records that completely deserve their large sales numbers. The comparison you draw here is incorrect because the time is different, The Roses weren't 'hot and cool' anymore and Oasis was. That explains the difference in sales. The truth is Oasis can never make a track like Breaking into Heaven. To good for them.
Sndrtj 9 months ago
@saracen09767 Sales have nothing to do with quality, you should realise that.
Sndrtj 9 months ago
@saracen09767
So what ya fuckin numpty.. Spice girls got number 1. Does that make them first class band ?
Eh Naw.... Grow up ya bawbag. Oasis are shite next to the roses. FACT
rebelbhoy1888 9 months ago
@saracen09767
Nah m8.. No chance. The second coming blows any oasis album away. The roses havnt got a bad tune man.
And Mani said nothing of Oasis being better.. I respect Noel.. But the rest of Oasis are fuckin crap.
rebelbhoy1888 10 months ago
@saracen09767
Oasis are cack compared to the roses m8.
rebelbhoy1888 10 months ago 2
I dig the Roses but they were well past their best by this point. No Reni, No roses...And those fucking keyboards...shame.
matrags 10 months ago
quality, never seen this before, best british band of the past 30 years, each element of the roses all legends
be1here1now 11 months ago
sack the sticks.
ianbrownshairdo 1 year ago
@ianbrownshairdo Yes, all Robbie Maddix seemed to do was play the same drumbeat to whatever Roses song he happened to be playing on. After hearing this, I reminded myself of how good Reni was by listening again to the proper version with him behind the kit. Doesn't compare.
paulph12002 11 months ago
Was this by an chance recorded for the War Child Charity album,"Help!", in 1995? I know the band did a version of this song for the album.
c0bbl3rs 1 year ago
@c0bbl3rs Yes. This is the War Child version, I used to have that CD.
paulph12002 1 year ago
The Roses were over when Reni left, and this version of Love Spreads shows why. Robbie Maddix sounds really sloppy compared to Reni, and the added keyboard player only makes things even worse.
paulph12002 1 year ago
loved it!
hopebgood 1 year ago
Robbie Maddox on drums, not Reni.
andreasegde 1 year ago
pakuly and sambitou"!
mistico2307 1 year ago
Great stuff man!
XHeath86 1 year ago
Check out that joker maddox
lol @ him
rebelbhoy1888 1 year ago
@rebelbhoy1888 robbie maddox got the hardest job in britain stepping into renis shoes... give him a break lad
123Agentorange 1 year ago 2
@123Agentorange
Aye suppose yer right m8. Still could never take to him
rebelbhoy1888 1 year ago
Never the same without Reni.
trixwivstix 1 year ago 2
bad performance they had lost it at this point sad to see
leedumett444 1 year ago 2
oasis were the shit man the best of an era m8 but i also luv the roses iv got footage frorm 95 in mancher with liam and ian singing i dig a pony by the beatles so there couldnt have been that much hatred
jeebagreen 1 year ago
I know they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery....but cmon, Liam fucking ripped off Ian Brown's whole persona and singing style to some respect.
fuck oasis.
Fakieflps 1 year ago
@Fakieflps Ian himself would probably give you a slap for that one. And this is coming from a Roses fan.
oce1989 1 year ago
@oce1989 ian brown didnt like oasis when they first came out and said himself that they were just copying off others and not doing there own thing
MrScottBach 1 year ago 3
@MrScottBach he was just jealous because they were more successful
DannyMadFerIt 1 year ago
@DannyMadFerIt naaa he is right oasis are shit and all there stuff is copied off beatles
MrScottBach 1 year ago
@MrScottBach It's your opinion and all what I can do is respect it. I love Oasis and I know lots of their songs sounds bit like Beatles... and bit like Stone Roses. But I also love these two bands. Love Spreads is such a genial song and John Squire is guitar hero
DannyMadFerIt 1 year ago 15
Who's singing the second voice in this song?
Thinkingjelle 3 months ago
@Thinkingjelle I think it's the drummer - Reni
DannyMadFerIt 3 months ago
@DannyMadFerIt He sounds like when george kooymans sings the second voice of the golden earring.
Thinkingjelle 3 months ago
@DannyMadFerIt Dickhead! thats not Reni!! Reni is one of the best drummers of all time they say he's like Keith Moon!! this guy Robbie Maddex is shit! they had this drummer for 12 mouth or so till they split!! because Reni quit first!!
handsomedevil98 3 months ago
@handsomedevil98 Okey okey sorry my bad. Seems like you're bigger fan than me. I'm also just a human being.
DannyMadFerIt 3 months ago
@Fakieflps yes but liam was a better singer than ian brown both bands are amazing but oasis are better
bigSlide94 1 year ago
@bigSlide94 fuck you. Ians the man liam just copies him.
favoriteworstnightma 1 year ago 17
@favoriteworstnightma Liam and Ian are two gods. End of it.
maravillamdq2 6 months ago
@maravillamdq2 Liam's a dickhead and Beady Eye are shit! End of it.
budgethemusicsponge 4 months ago
@bigSlide94
Away n stop talkin yer shite. The Roses are fuckin well better than oasis.
Liams a knob. I like Noel. But he couldnt string squires guitar.
rebelbhoy1888 1 year ago
@rebelbhoy1888 I have to say rebelbhoy1888 is right on the money with his comments here. To be fair to Noel, however, he can pen a tune...
Tapiola2007 1 year ago
THIS is brit pop! thanks for the upload!
gaboweepingwillow 1 year ago