@PeoplesWar yes that is Eric Avery on bass. he was their touring bassist for the Bleed like me tour. FYI he and Shirley have done a song together called "Maybe" and its on Eric's album "Help wanted."
Lol, wtf? The drummer when he jumps in is playing 8th notes...But the audio is doing 16th? Lol....And I love how punk kids hop up and down like retards. XD
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Good effin' god. I search for Eurythmics "Who's that Girl" and I get THIS?! FFS, youtube, until you learn your genres and eras, you should back away from music ENTIRELY!
SHE IS FREAKING AMAZING I SWEAR in my opinion no female lead vocalist is better and that band my god epic Butch is the genius...She is sooo hot on stage lol I wish I looked like her lol. I am a huge fan what more can I say ^_^
apparantly she likes pickled eggs after sex and in the morning she cleans her teeth with a victorian toothbrush dipped in the earwax of Tibetan orphans.
Yes I agree with you RomVlad. She has a lot of confidence, charisma and personality. I think the meaning of sexy is not only in the body, it is in the blood and in the soul too, she doesn´t need to have a great body. I love this woman!
since true happyness is strange to you that you can only be happy when you are sad
you can look up the lyrics and ask me any info on it or depression since I deal with depression everday and i try to give the link out but it didn't let me put in comments
Wow, what makes her so sexy? She's not exceptionally pretty. She seems strong, independent, smart and comfortable with who she is and her sexuality. I'm guessing she is who she is, makes no apologies, and if you don't like it, piss off. To me, that is what makes a woman sexy...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i didnt know that the lead singer is a chick... i first heard the metallica cover witch i think is at least a little better but its not any thing like the original because its on the accoustic guitar for the cover
Her voice sounds even better live :) I love shirley she's freakin awesome anyone see that she's gonna be on the sarah conner chronicles? I knew it was her :)
Supremo...
mossenrat 5 months ago
11 are Justin Beiber fans, who hate raining cause it ruins their stupid hairdo.
jkanini1 5 months ago 3
it rocks well.
EnteleiEchein 7 months ago
ist das nicht beim Rock Palast??
arnoldTambunan 9 months ago
She is "Hot"!!!! Great song too!
peterracer1 10 months ago 2
pour your misey down on me baby!
Coyote9Tnine 1 year ago
2005.she was 39!!! cor blimey. I'm DROOLING!!!
CoxandTanfield 1 year ago
My brother met her years ago through a friend. He said she was too nice.
peacemaker083 1 year ago 3
hey 410n5o if you add this to the tags: yt:stretch=16:9
it will make the video look a lot better
XMcEvilson 1 year ago
i love this girl
globalmanager 1 year ago 3
0:20: Is that Eric Avery on bass?
PeoplesWar 1 year ago
@PeoplesWar yes that is Eric Avery on bass. he was their touring bassist for the Bleed like me tour. FYI he and Shirley have done a song together called "Maybe" and its on Eric's album "Help wanted."
AmandaJaneSG1 1 year ago
what a morbid crowd
MuseandIncubus 1 year ago
shirley cuando te conozca te voy a embarazar bombonsote
TheFourtyninerfan 2 years ago 4
Awesome band!!
davidhooper100 2 years ago 8
i want this version on A CD !!!!
2837sharding 2 years ago 4
She and her band are so legit! They sound even better live and this video proves it! Kudos!
aetechllc 2 years ago 3
that hat and dress make her all the more smexy
marluxiamania75321 2 years ago 4
TE AMO SHIRLEY!!!
marianolombardia 2 years ago 8
Great!! But i think the instrument's sound is too loud and i can't hear her voice..
karibrasuka 2 years ago
@karibrasuka that's because youtube conversion sometimes compresses the audio a little.
lmull3 2 years ago
good! what a performance!!! I love you shirley i wanna meet you!!!!!
Bloody87Mary 2 years ago 10
cool
thanks !!
howlingsin 2 years ago 4
looove you Shirley!!!!!!!!!!!!!
penismightier1 2 years ago 9
She's the best! Tear it up!!!
DON'T TAKE TAMIFLU!
sbcruiser 2 years ago 11
haha wtf??
BOSOX9004 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Google....
Donald Rumsfeld + Tamiflu + Media censoring lethal side effects
sbcruiser 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol... tamiflu is prescripted for influenza treatment in every places... ah1n1=?
cokeINC 2 years ago
Im only happy when it rains
kirbyag 2 years ago
Lol, wtf? The drummer when he jumps in is playing 8th notes...But the audio is doing 16th? Lol....And I love how punk kids hop up and down like retards. XD
Bahaumet666 2 years ago
love garbage - great rock band
gordonlove34 2 years ago 3
she needs to take that hat off
theSTAR70 2 years ago
I love Garbage so much! I can't believe the audience remains so still...
penismightier1 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Good effin' god. I search for Eurythmics "Who's that Girl" and I get THIS?! FFS, youtube, until you learn your genres and eras, you should back away from music ENTIRELY!
pang5 2 years ago
SHE IS FREAKING AMAZING I SWEAR in my opinion no female lead vocalist is better and that band my god epic Butch is the genius...She is sooo hot on stage lol I wish I looked like her lol. I am a huge fan what more can I say ^_^
Leharasmind 2 years ago 9
I LOVE this amazing song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3
Costy87 3 years ago 3
Stunning performance!!! Shirley is looking mighty cute & sexy on this one too!! I am severely in lust with her!!!!!
RippingFleshFromBone 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
apparantly she likes pickled eggs after sex and in the morning she cleans her teeth with a victorian toothbrush dipped in the earwax of Tibetan orphans.
yetiflicker 3 years ago
You win the prize for the most bizzare post on YouTube!!!! :)
RippingFleshFromBone 3 years ago 3
i m only happy when it rains (rock)
sartalanska 3 years ago
she is the Queen~!
idontgive17 3 years ago 4
i love her in hats.
funkymusicluvr 3 years ago 3
Garbage ROCKS!!!!
The coolest band
bebe1001 3 years ago 2
HAHA Garbage Rocks xD Do you people even SEE what you write ? :D
zomglolbg 3 years ago
OMG- the mosh pit is fenced off!those who moshe to garbage will be saved for eterity!!!
baudenod 3 years ago
Shirley is super cute and her voice makes me want to kiss her to see how rough she really is. Yum.
JerryM1964 3 years ago 5
Absolutely great performance!
andimaniac 3 years ago 4
Shirley is the shiznit.
Cyclizen 3 years ago 7
Yes I agree with you RomVlad. She has a lot of confidence, charisma and personality. I think the meaning of sexy is not only in the body, it is in the blood and in the soul too, she doesn´t need to have a great body. I love this woman!
Megamusic2000 3 years ago 6
then why don't u tell us all the true meaning of the song
GoatBoySquanky 3 years ago 2
someone please thumbs up my post
it sucks to see 5 thumbs down on it for no reason
PunkySpunky 2 years ago 83
it is so sad that only a few people only know the true meaning of this song
PunkySpunky 3 years ago
then why don't you enlighten us oh wise one??
Archemedes1 2 years ago 3
it is about being only happy when you are sad
since true happyness is strange to you that you can only be happy when you are sad
you can look up the lyrics and ask me any info on it or depression since I deal with depression everday and i try to give the link out but it didn't let me put in comments
PunkySpunky 2 years ago 7
Cause she's a terminator
Jleighto32 3 years ago 2
Wow, what makes her so sexy? She's not exceptionally pretty. She seems strong, independent, smart and comfortable with who she is and her sexuality. I'm guessing she is who she is, makes no apologies, and if you don't like it, piss off. To me, that is what makes a woman sexy...
RomVlad 3 years ago 8
hey voice also, and i like her accent.
hadzimapango 3 years ago 6
her voice** i meant
hadzimapango 3 years ago 3
personally i find her exceptionally pretty as well but i agree with all the above too..not to mention talented =)
xxstarchildxx 3 years ago 2
my favourite Garbage song ^^
POUR YOUR MISERY DOWN ON ME!
MalaLac 3 years ago
I said it 10 years ago and I'll say it again today a decade later. She's still one of the best singers IN MUSIC!
1963asus 3 years ago 15
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Too damn hot, psychotic, dreamy , sexy and cool...
My favourite live performance of OHWIR! No doubt...
Too bad the crow were clearly there to see some other band and not realy fully enjoying this amazing concert and performace...
eyesor3 3 years ago
What other concert do you mean??
Anyway if I was there to see another band and I didn't know who garbage were , I'd fall in love with that band, even if it was just a mistake!
andrea111292 3 years ago 4
she is fuckin hot, psychotic, dreamy , sexy and cool....
dvo1st 3 years ago 65
she's too hot...
bdan073 3 years ago 9
that first sentence, so powerful <3
bamibambi 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i didnt know that the lead singer is a chick... i first heard the metallica cover witch i think is at least a little better but its not any thing like the original because its on the accoustic guitar for the cover
kingofcookies 3 years ago
I didn't realize what a great drummer Butch Vig is...
jimbailey69 3 years ago
Her voice sounds even better live :) I love shirley she's freakin awesome anyone see that she's gonna be on the sarah conner chronicles? I knew it was her :)
purplgoo 3 years ago 6
i'm only happy when it's complicated but not when it rains hahahaha
love the song!!
hajarock 3 years ago
Comment removed
andrea111292 3 years ago
i am only happy when rain but not when things are complicated
crayolamemorie 3 years ago
hey Shirley, You should cover a metallica tune.
omyajt 3 years ago
1458665, wtf thats GROSS!!!!! u pervert!!!!!! btw love the song
IHeartAnime21 3 years ago
she has such an awesome voice! it even sounds great live!
acousticgirl48 3 years ago 2
thank you shirley and band for the great moments
highofflifeforever 3 years ago 2
Shirley Manson , my sexy idol !
Sexy , from the hell , from the darkness of the world , but she is still clean and pure !
God,damm it ! I can not stop loving her !
我來自台灣 , I am Sevorlaga !
這一支MV真的很好看,真的有一點physical impulse,讓人百看不厭!
我只想說一聲,Shirley Manson,你太誇張了啦!
Merry me , please !
sevorlaga142 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Shirley Manson , my sexy idol !
Sexy , from the hell , from the darkness of the world , but she is still clean and pure !
God,damm it ! I can not stop loving her !
我來自台灣 , I am Sevorlaga !
sevorlaga142 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i would die to smell her pantyhose
14586665 3 years ago
LOL god thats hilarious
ilovefunnypeoplex 3 years ago 3
same
exile4646 3 years ago
OMFG!! Are you sick? [laugh]
MiH4ku 3 years ago 2
Garbage: I miglioriiiiiiiiiiiiii
fuacake 3 years ago 2
lol same here bunnyyears19. i had the song stuck in my head and right after that happened it started raining O.O
demonicangel7 3 years ago
now, were you clever enough to come up with that on your own? ;)
amysacrifice 3 years ago
Yes. I lover her to death
HoneyRoasted7 3 years ago
haha its raining now
bunnyears19 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm only happy when I'm laid
You'll wanna hear 'bout my new obsession
I'm ridin' high upon a sweet position
I'm only happy when I'm laid
Whore some misery down
Whore your misery down on me
HoneyRoasted7 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm always wild in the dark
My only comfort is the guys gone bad
I didn't accidentally tell you that
I'm only happy when I'm laid
You'll get the message by the time I'm pooped
When I complain about me on you
I'm only happy when I'm laid
Whore your misery down
Whore your misery down on me
HoneyRoasted7 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm only happy when I'm laid
I feel so good when things involve wet thongs
I only glisten 'til my ass backs out
I'm only happy when I'm laid
HoneyRoasted7 3 years ago
ohhh my fuckin god someone ask shirley if it hurt when she fell down from heaven beautiful angel
cats46meo9w 3 years ago
kicking!
probum 3 years ago 3
Best song ever!!!!
mcolon66 3 years ago 3
Why is there a screen infront of the drummer?
rookie4life 3 years ago
I think is used to make the drums sound not that laud and the other instruments and shirley's voice could be heard better
vagalindo0205 3 years ago
To keep him safe of the stuff the public will throw at him when they hear him playing.
wascaras 3 years ago
Just kidding, i don't have the slightest idea.
wascaras 3 years ago
Shirley you're gorgeous!!!!! you're so hot!!!! I love youuuuu!!!!
87Cinzietta87 3 years ago
I'M ONLY HAPPY WHEN IT RAINS (L)
Micelesunagarcha 3 years ago
The best group ever , Shirley is the most beautifull female singer love this song, maybe can be the best song for 90´s
joaquingarbage 3 years ago 9
that bald, skinny dude with the glasses sure can play guitar!!
MyAssCorp 3 years ago 2
fino
nikolazigic 3 years ago
waa...! and today i'm bad..!
i listen this song all time..!
i want to ber like before...
furcio92 3 years ago
Great!!!
solwolfpunk 3 years ago
shirley is so awesome.
aschenputtel85 3 years ago 2
Wonderful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
QUEERIDO 3 years ago 2
Sweeeeeeeeeettttttttttttttttttt
nickqliao 3 years ago 2
nice!
KurosakiMAN 3 years ago
simply the best!!!!!!!!!!!
xenocalimani 4 years ago 2
I only smile in the dark
my only comfort is the night gone black
I didn't accidentally tell you that
I'm only happy when it rains
LondonCalling870 4 years ago 2
SONZERA!!
palestra18 4 years ago
Is that Andy Fletcher from Depeche Mode in the crowd?
3:50 into the song (with dark sunglasses).
I know that Garbage remixed the song In Your Room.
fpmip 4 years ago
excellent performance... so confident
vergilg2 4 years ago 2
"AWESOME"! "AWESOME"! "AWESOME"!
tornmask 4 years ago 4
true godess:)
wildbabe666 4 years ago 6
wauuuuuu garbage is the best
sahirhilario 4 years ago 4
nice legs and boots
RippedJacket 4 years ago 4
cool cool song..damn ..yeeeeeeees..she looks damn cute...i also wonder what might be her beauty secrets??
Mirella1983 4 years ago 2
Shirley has such a great voice!What a cool song!I love it
darcyfrusciante 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't understand what she sings here, is it
"I'm only happy when it rains,
I'm only happy when I'm constipated,"
or what?
jacktheripperlondon 4 years ago
er, I think you'll find it's "complicated"
not constipated! :) Stunnibg version of the song!
RippingFleshFromBone 4 years ago
Well if you new the band and were shirley is from(Scotland)its rather a tounge and cheek kinda song cause its always rainy weather in scotland!
sohot269 4 years ago 4
Wow, I love this version! Shirley is so hot!
DrQuacky 4 years ago
yeah, she looks so gorgeous with that cap here..., I love her
NadimGawdat 4 years ago
Love this video...probably the best performance of this song (in my opinion!)
rachelmacpherson 4 years ago
if shirley is 40 here she looks fantastic.she makes fools of all those idiotic girl singers today.shes the real thing.love her.
habdon 4 years ago 3
Her 40 year old secret? You not know? DUDE - she gets it every morning and last thing at night. As this derelict content does. :P
And it ain't Pop, dic*head.
LadyDerelictContent 4 years ago
That's a nice little attitude you've got going there. But hey, it's the internet.
OriginalGuest 4 years ago
I don't think you do, dear Lady! The ones who shout the loudest, do it the least.
jacktheripperlondon 4 years ago
So what's her solo album supposed to be? Pop?
OriginalGuest 4 years ago
she's 40 and she still looks like
a collage student. I wonder what
her beauty secret is?
gxy10 4 years ago
OIL OF A LAY!
sohot269 4 years ago
It's "Oil of Ulay", dumbo.
jacktheripperlondon 4 years ago
they r awesome !!!!!!
just A W s O m E
ally20sey 4 years ago
Garbage rocks - Shirley's got such an awesome voice!
1234pernille 4 years ago
its cool to c this....in their firsts live performances shirley was kindof shy...it was so tender...
jego38 4 years ago
She's so cute and great voice too
AlXV 4 years ago
She sings better and better!
Nurikane 4 years ago
My favourite GARBAGE song, actually ...
-- Abbie
GimmeKitty 4 years ago 2
she's soooooooooooo HOTT...
khfan654 4 years ago
i find it amazing that the band now is as good as it was in mid 90s. Shirelys voice hasnt changed
ddmitry 4 years ago
just great!
dieghorock 4 years ago
i can listen it all day long
petuliq 4 years ago
SUUUUUUUUUUUPER! fuck my dog it's GREAT! Thousands of times I'm telling it to myself)
vodkaconnected 5 years ago
great great great performance! shirley looks beautiful
BiruteB 5 years ago
oh i love it!
GarbageForever 5 years ago
She still has a great voice.
msiman 5 years ago
This osng is really great!
kakalc 5 years ago
seriously, i feel old as well, haha.
emaecks 5 years ago
man I feel old has it been a decade already?
sinistergrin 5 years ago
I have to agree this is my favorite Garbage song. Can't believe it's 10 years old!
sanwh1 5 years ago
i love this song so much!
DuckyBG 5 years ago