Ah, in this performance, I feel like I can begin to understand how something so delicate and sweet drove Proust to spout off 4000 pages about beauty and life and death.
Lugansky, what monstrous talent, he wasn't even looking at the music most of the time. Notice how he doesn't even respond to the page turner as she just turns it for him. I guess it's not surprising since he memorized a Rachmaninoff concerto in three days and performed much more technically difficult works before.
@th3wing3dpaint3r so whats your point? Lugansky is a great artist and has the right to behave like a great artist, compared to a note-perfect computer. (same sense in other words)
@tirolerhut79 I was obviously referring to Horowitz's alleged quote. That's sort of why I wrote it between quotation marks...to clarify exactly which part I thought was vain.
Repin is simply superb, but somebody needs to say here that the piano part is beyond difficult not only technically but also musically. Lugansky's musicianship is what I enjoyed the most. Bravo Maestri
@h4x3dby1337 Yeah I always bowed then stepped back and applauded my pianist after playing this. I was lucky enough to play a lot of the big sonatas with the same pianist Franck, Brahms, Grieg, Faure, etc it's a joy to work with someone who can play these montrous piano parts and play them well.
I love Repin's suond in this movement... both powerful and extremely expressive! Luganski also plays very well, the basses are well-defined, the phrasing is really easy to understand, though the music is not easy at all, like almost every French late-romantic composition... Wonderful!
There's also a bit of child-like naiveness in Vadim Repin's sound in this particular movement. This is how it's supposed to sound like! Except for the pianist, i don't particularly like him...if not to say, I don't ..like him:)
I just listened to many of the postings of the Frank 4th movement by other performers and I like this one the most. It seems cleaner, better recorded, but most of all it's faster and is better articulated..... oh and the pianist can play too!!!
The "all's right with the world" sweetness at the start is just perfect; too bad that other violinists make this so strident. Later, when the music requires a bit more muscle, both players have it in abundance. All in all, a most artistic performance, and it PAINS me not to be able to find this recording to purchase online!
@Mezzotenor ; Repin and Lugansky recorded this and other sonates with Deutsche Grammophon... I don't think the recording of the concert is available. It would interest me too... their interpretation of "Fratres" is wonderful!
@Mezzotenor I would also like to get an official recording. But well, you can convert this video in mp3 to listen to it. That's what I did for the entire sonata. It's better than nothing. Anyway, my favorite version of this masterwork.
Give me chills every time I listen to it
StarRadiance 1 day ago
amazing rapport and understanding between piano and violin!!! what a fantastic performance!!
jin12345678 1 month ago
Ah, in this performance, I feel like I can begin to understand how something so delicate and sweet drove Proust to spout off 4000 pages about beauty and life and death.
noolsy 2 months ago
Bien melifluente, un placer oir una y otra vez
isolani 4 months ago
i fucking love this cant stop istenign to it...!!!!!!!!
brahmsian1steve 4 months ago
stunning...
brahmsian1steve 4 months ago
Lovely canon--the melody is so childlike--not easy to compose.
windstorm1000 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
That was wonderful - I popped over to Amazon and bought their DG album. That's sincere praise.
quixolotl 6 months ago
Comment removed
quixolotl 6 months ago
Beautiful but a bit too fast and hasty (especially piano)
violinoamore 9 months ago
I'd like to use words to express my feelings, but they could bring no justice to this interpretation.
Zuxilbaja 11 months ago 3
there's something so passionate and appealing about this movement! i love it! it goes perfectly with the color and smell of the daffodils next to me.
lmfviolet78 1 year ago
Noted that this is now on DG. Thanks, fellow music fans!
Mezzotenor 1 year ago
Lugansky, what monstrous talent, he wasn't even looking at the music most of the time. Notice how he doesn't even respond to the page turner as she just turns it for him. I guess it's not surprising since he memorized a Rachmaninoff concerto in three days and performed much more technically difficult works before.
IVlr3vil 1 year ago
I have to play it but...I'm not LUGANSKY!!! He is the best! And this Violin sonata is brillant!
pianistpedro 1 year ago
Saw Mr Repin playing live in ChCh - unbelieveably amazing
baiba6 1 year ago
The entire sonata by Franck are breathtakingly beautiful played!!
Tjid7ske 1 year ago
Mezzotenor---the recording is now available in UK, by DG (4778794)
juliayclruss 1 year ago
the best
enma15ai 1 year ago
Very nice, but tiny bit too fast for me ... It loses its majesty a bit ...
violinoamore 1 year ago
The ending is so lovely! I just loved the way Lugansky sort of jumped!!!
xujia1001 1 year ago
I love the 3:15 - 4:08 part.........it is simply strong, beautiful and lyric....this part dosen't have words or feelings to be explained...
Pianista061292 1 year ago 2
What's that going on in the piano part at 4:54??
ConservatoryGuy 1 year ago
@ConservatoryGuy Lugansky slipped over a wrong note. I take it with Horowitz who said: its the good right of the genius to play some wrong notes.
tirolerhut79 7 months ago
@tirolerhut79 "its the good right of the genius to play some wrong notes" Rather vain!
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 month ago
@th3wing3dpaint3r so whats your point? Lugansky is a great artist and has the right to behave like a great artist, compared to a note-perfect computer. (same sense in other words)
tirolerhut79 1 month ago
@tirolerhut79 I was obviously referring to Horowitz's alleged quote. That's sort of why I wrote it between quotation marks...to clarify exactly which part I thought was vain.
th3wing3dpaint3r 1 month ago
Excellent interplay between piano and violin, a true collaboration.
cakiefuti 1 year ago
wow, Golden sound !!
powerpiano 1 year ago 2
Amazing.
bramobali 1 year ago
this is the best in youtube..
sofronitsky80 2 years ago
Repin is simply superb, but somebody needs to say here that the piano part is beyond difficult not only technically but also musically. Lugansky's musicianship is what I enjoyed the most. Bravo Maestri
danielito1979 2 years ago
@danielito1979 indeed, the piano part is obscenely difficult. The violin gets the lines, the piano gets the notes.
h4x3dby1337 2 years ago
@h4x3dby1337 Yeah I always bowed then stepped back and applauded my pianist after playing this. I was lucky enough to play a lot of the big sonatas with the same pianist Franck, Brahms, Grieg, Faure, etc it's a joy to work with someone who can play these montrous piano parts and play them well.
MoesTube1 1 year ago
I love Repin's suond in this movement... both powerful and extremely expressive! Luganski also plays very well, the basses are well-defined, the phrasing is really easy to understand, though the music is not easy at all, like almost every French late-romantic composition... Wonderful!
ThorgarManowar 2 years ago 6
There's also a bit of child-like naiveness in Vadim Repin's sound in this particular movement. This is how it's supposed to sound like! Except for the pianist, i don't particularly like him...if not to say, I don't ..like him:)
yoonjuli 2 years ago
no likey lugansky? this is actually one of the best piano part done i've ever heard. he reacts really well to the easy part of the violin. E-A-S-Y
clem4705315 2 years ago
Lugansky does a great job -- great dynamic contrast and ensemble, melodic. This is a very brisk interpretation!
JEP177777 2 years ago
I just listened to many of the postings of the Frank 4th movement by other performers and I like this one the most. It seems cleaner, better recorded, but most of all it's faster and is better articulated..... oh and the pianist can play too!!!
BeammeupSpotty 2 years ago 5
Very good violinist ,interesting interpretation and wonderful sound of his instrument Great performance .Thank You Greetings Martin
marcin8942 2 years ago 6
merveilleuse sonate;merveilleusement exécutée !!
robynsalain 2 years ago 5
The "all's right with the world" sweetness at the start is just perfect; too bad that other violinists make this so strident. Later, when the music requires a bit more muscle, both players have it in abundance. All in all, a most artistic performance, and it PAINS me not to be able to find this recording to purchase online!
Mezzotenor 2 years ago 28
@Mezzotenor Just released on Deutsche Grammophon. Hooray
chopin2815 1 year ago
@Mezzotenor ; Repin and Lugansky recorded this and other sonates with Deutsche Grammophon... I don't think the recording of the concert is available. It would interest me too... their interpretation of "Fratres" is wonderful!
nvcaster 6 months ago
@Mezzotenor They have just recently recorded this sonata. You can happily purchase the CD now!
robinleems 3 months ago
@robinleems Oh, is that so ? I'll certainly go look for it.
Zuxilbaja 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Zuxilbaja 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Mezzotenor I would also like to get an official recording. But well, you can convert this video in mp3 to listen to it. That's what I did for the entire sonata. It's better than nothing. Anyway, my favorite version of this masterwork.
Zuxilbaja 3 weeks ago
really great...
powerpiano 2 years ago 13
great great duo
Masmorra84 3 years ago 6
Comment removed
cushpajz 3 years ago
Impeccable phrasing, gorgeous tone and the music spoke!!!
tonecolor 3 years ago 9
Great, both.
Volodya1988 3 years ago 8