Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (20)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love Poirot and Marple! Agatha Christie is just an amazing writer! I love herbooks and Julia McKenzie makes the perfect Miss Marple!

  • I love Julia! She has been brilliant in everything she has ever done. A very witty creative talented actress

  • what a great woman to have a lot of intuition.

  • She speaks only the truth!!!! Go Julia!!

  • Ms McKenzie is so sweet, but my, has she suddenly aged. It seems only yesterday she starred in Side by Side by Sondheim or was a beautiful Sally in Follies. Oh well, I guess it's just me getting old, wanting everything to stay as it was.

  • ^^ all Marples have their own style, and I like all of them: Joan Hickson, Geraldine McEwan and Julia McKenzie :)

  • I think that Julia McKenzie might be the definitive Miss Marple from what I know of the books. I imagine that Miss Marple would look very much like Julia and would have her demeanour as well. However, I prefer the episodes with Geraldine McEwan as the scripts and the overall casts seem to be more colourful and interesting that the McKenzie ones

  • @susuemikado YES! Totally agree with you.....I think when Julie joined they changed the setting and style of Marple to being a lot duller and darker. The Gereldine ones were waaaaay more colourful, exciting and dramatic. In my opinion Gereldine was MUCH BETTER than Julie. When Julie sits in a room you don't even notice her amoungst the other characters....she has no presence which Gereldine did. And I find that Julie is TOO NICE, and drippy wheras Gereldine had a big spark!! Miss Gereldine.

  • Julia's fine, but Joan Hickson's my favourite and I love David Suchet as Poirot.

  • Julia Mckenzie comes across as being a really nice lady. Her potrayal of Miss Marple is excelllent. Her and Geraldine Mcewan are the best ones.

  • I think she's good as Miss Marple but Geraldine McEwan is just adorable!

  • She is the best Miss Marple.

  • I prefer Julia McKenzie. Geraldine McKewan is too self-satisfied .

  • i LOVE Miss Marple. Poirots too annoying and arrogant. I love how everyone usually patronises Marple and when they eventually let her speak she bowls em all over by solving the case!!! 4.50 from paddinton is my favourite.

  • She's so cute. I first saw her as Mrs. Forrester in Cranford, so I was really happy to hear that she had been chosen to replace Geraldine McEwan (my favorite). :)

  • she hasnt filled mcewans boots for me

  • Julia McKenzie comes very close to my personal imagination of Miss Marple. She played her very well in 'pocketful of rye'.

  • joan hickson

  • I quite enjoyed this Miss Marple, although I missed Geraldine McEwan's more spunky take on the character. Ms McKenzie played the role well, she just didn't seem as sardonic/ironic as Ms McEwan, or even oh gosh what's her name that Agatha Christie herself suggested as Jane Marple, she played her in the 80's white hair. oh I HATE when I forget a name like that. I'll remember AFTER I hit "post".LoL!

  • Amazing episode and Julie McKenzie did an wonderful job as Miss Marple. Thank u Helenjames production for producing this gem.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more