So I was watching Star Trek and heard Lore quoting this particular poem and found it tickling my interest to such extents that I had to hear the whole deal.
this was before the russians were (dirty commies) and arabs (dirty terrorists).
as an arab, i'm glad to see how american culture can beautifully describe others as chivalrous and brave, violence notwithstanding. off course bigotry did exist against blacks, women and gay people then.
this poem advocates both bravery AND the futility of violence. what a profound message.
Well done, sir! A wondrous little diddy from the land of my ancestors. You not only keep it alive but do it justice yourself. Glad to know that when I finally get to Europe there may be people there that I can share things like this with. Found this entirely by accident! Cheers!
I am a student from one of the best public schools of India, St. Joseph's College, North Point, Darjeeling, India. This song was taught to us by our music teacher, the very brilliant Col. Braganza, among a great variety of Irish, Italian & Country songs. I am hearing this after a very long time ... 23 years to be exact !
Thank you ... you brought tears to my eyes. And happiness to my heart !
I found the words also on searching the 'net. A late friend, Mr. Willard Munroe of Rangeley Maine and Tucson AZ. used to recite it as a poem, sans music. He apparently learned it while in West Point, class of 47. The fun part is that it is Abdulla Bulbul Amir, but most folks sing it as Abdul Abulbul Amir. Nice job, thanks
He said then, my friend, Your remarks will not soften your end, For my pastime and passion is war. And none will deny, on the day that I die, so did Abdul Abulbul Amir.
Are these the original Percy French words? Also, can i just say that i first found your videos when searching for a version of Ilkley Moor Bah'tat and since then i've discovered that you've done brilliant versions of almost all my favourite folky songs, for that i have to thank you.
@hitthatperfectbeat Yes, these are the Percy French lyrics. Frank Crummit had great success singing them, so much so that he made three follow ups which he wrote, but each followed the template of the French original.
One of my favorite 'old-timey' songs ever! And one that always causes my wife to look askance at me when I play or sing it. Then again, I don't have a voice like yours, so maybe that's it. Good to know this gem is not forgotten! Thanks for posting.
@threelegsoman It was an MGM cartoon. It's there on YouTube - in fact, I was watching it when I noticed the link to your video in the list on the right.
Great! My father taught me this poem/song. He was a Ukrainian-American soldier who served in WWII and whose father was buried w/ a medal received from Franz Josef of Austria for service in war (I don't recall which). I commend you for keeping up these songs, which few know anymore!
I could tell your from some celtic nation. Your voice kinda sounds like Jethro Tull (Cornishman). Idk if people from the isle of man sound like Cornishmen. But your singing sounds like it!
@darkmachete Must be a throw-back to my maternal great grandfather who came to the Isle of Man from Cornwall for the mining in the late nineteenth century. My accent is not broad Manx.
What a charming song, and a perfect style in which to render it! Ever since a character on Star Trek sang its opening line I've wanted to hear it performed in full. Thanks!
@threelegsoman Ah, it is a classic. The episode is titled "Brothers", and it is the third episode in the fourth season of Star Trek: The Next Generation. I think it's available online through sources of dubious legitimacy, or through Amazon. In any case, you sing it better than the character did!
Nice job on the song. I also remember a cartoon based on it - from MGM in the late 1930's, I believe. However, I did not know the origins of the song until I saw your posting. Thanks very much.
Thank you, I am always pleased when people enjoy my offerings. There are three sequels to this song if you are interested and they can be found on one of my playlists simply called Abdul Abulbul Amir.
Enjoyed listening to this very much (and singing along to a few bits)... thank you for making it
hebemis 1 week ago
So I was watching Star Trek and heard Lore quoting this particular poem and found it tickling my interest to such extents that I had to hear the whole deal.
Now it seems I have to learn to play the guitar.
FieryRivers 1 month ago
we sang this at scout camp in the early 60"s. I have not heard it since then glad to listen to it again. It takes me back to my youth.
dlee1947 2 months ago
how i enjoyed this. thank you.
this was before the russians were (dirty commies) and arabs (dirty terrorists).
as an arab, i'm glad to see how american culture can beautifully describe others as chivalrous and brave, violence notwithstanding. off course bigotry did exist against blacks, women and gay people then.
this poem advocates both bravery AND the futility of violence. what a profound message.
mkgill 5 months ago
NIce!
6eadgbe1 5 months ago
Not the Crimean War, but the 1877-78 Russian-Turkish war.
royalcourtier 5 months ago
@royalcourtier Thanks for the correction. I will amend the info accordingly.
threelegsoman 5 months ago
Well done, sir! A wondrous little diddy from the land of my ancestors. You not only keep it alive but do it justice yourself. Glad to know that when I finally get to Europe there may be people there that I can share things like this with. Found this entirely by accident! Cheers!
DoctorBenway316 6 months ago
Sir,
I am a student from one of the best public schools of India, St. Joseph's College, North Point, Darjeeling, India. This song was taught to us by our music teacher, the very brilliant Col. Braganza, among a great variety of Irish, Italian & Country songs. I am hearing this after a very long time ... 23 years to be exact !
Thank you ... you brought tears to my eyes. And happiness to my heart !
bhagelawala 8 months ago
@bhagelawala Thank you for your message. I am always happy to bring back fond memories
threelegsoman 8 months ago
really enjoyed this video, thank you!
littleuglyeddie 8 months ago
I found the words also on searching the 'net. A late friend, Mr. Willard Munroe of Rangeley Maine and Tucson AZ. used to recite it as a poem, sans music. He apparently learned it while in West Point, class of 47. The fun part is that it is Abdulla Bulbul Amir, but most folks sing it as Abdul Abulbul Amir. Nice job, thanks
pabobfin 8 months ago
He said then, my friend, Your remarks will not soften your end, For my pastime and passion is war. And none will deny, on the day that I die, so did Abdul Abulbul Amir.
SaphirBlackMoon 10 months ago
Are these the original Percy French words? Also, can i just say that i first found your videos when searching for a version of Ilkley Moor Bah'tat and since then i've discovered that you've done brilliant versions of almost all my favourite folky songs, for that i have to thank you.
hitthatperfectbeat 10 months ago
@hitthatperfectbeat Yes, these are the Percy French lyrics. Frank Crummit had great success singing them, so much so that he made three follow ups which he wrote, but each followed the template of the French original.
threelegsoman 10 months ago
One of my favorite 'old-timey' songs ever! And one that always causes my wife to look askance at me when I play or sing it. Then again, I don't have a voice like yours, so maybe that's it. Good to know this gem is not forgotten! Thanks for posting.
bdazzled08 10 months ago
@bdazzled08 You're welcome. Have you checked out the follow ups which are on my playlist Abdul Abulbul Amir?
threelegsoman 10 months ago
@anklesocksbitch Glad you enjoyed it.
threelegsoman 11 months ago
@threelegsoman well done. Nothing quite like the sound of a 12 string properly played.
testy462 9 months ago
wow cool voice!
jallelind 1 year ago
@jallelind Thank you young sir.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
Awsome my friend, well done, I only wish you could teach me how to play it on the fiddle :)
1986zls 1 year ago
Bravo! Nicely done. I appreciate the effort.
andylarson19591 1 year ago
Thanks so much ! My father used to sing this song to me.
52topper 1 year ago
@threelegsoman It was an MGM cartoon. It's there on YouTube - in fact, I was watching it when I noticed the link to your video in the list on the right.
v=2Be7tMdz75Y
tjdrico 1 year ago
@tjdrico Thanks very much for the link. It must be over 50 years ago that I saw it at the local cinema.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
nice story.
alihammadshah 1 year ago
Great! My father taught me this poem/song. He was a Ukrainian-American soldier who served in WWII and whose father was buried w/ a medal received from Franz Josef of Austria for service in war (I don't recall which). I commend you for keeping up these songs, which few know anymore!
52topper 1 year ago
I could tell your from some celtic nation. Your voice kinda sounds like Jethro Tull (Cornishman). Idk if people from the isle of man sound like Cornishmen. But your singing sounds like it!
darkmachete 1 year ago
@darkmachete Must be a throw-back to my maternal great grandfather who came to the Isle of Man from Cornwall for the mining in the late nineteenth century. My accent is not broad Manx.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
BRAVOOOOOOOOOOOOO WELL DONE I LOVED IT
TYYYYY
U HAVE AN AWESOME VOICE!!!
heartsungs 1 year ago
@heartsungs Thank you for your effusive comment. You are very kind.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
Thanks for the upload. Great singing.
rommantic2020 1 year ago
@rommantic2020 Thank you for the comment.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
enjoyable, well done. Once saw it done on TV by Bert Parks -- would love to see that again if it happens to be around anywhere.
apenny4urthots 1 year ago
What a charming song, and a perfect style in which to render it! Ever since a character on Star Trek sang its opening line I've wanted to hear it performed in full. Thanks!
allenshulman 1 year ago
@allenshulman I must have missed that one! Thanks for the comment.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
@threelegsoman Ah, it is a classic. The episode is titled "Brothers", and it is the third episode in the fourth season of Star Trek: The Next Generation. I think it's available online through sources of dubious legitimacy, or through Amazon. In any case, you sing it better than the character did!
allenshulman 1 year ago
Nice job on the song. I also remember a cartoon based on it - from MGM in the late 1930's, I believe. However, I did not know the origins of the song until I saw your posting. Thanks very much.
LAdave65 1 year ago
@LAdave65 Thanks for the comment. Have you seen the sequels? I have posted them as well.
threelegsoman 1 year ago
Truly brilliant! I only ever knew a shorter version, it's great to hear the fuller lyrics. Beautifully performed as ever: fives stars!
1690ftp1 2 years ago
Thanks Deborah. Have you checked out the sequels in my playlist called Abdul Abulbul Amir?
threelegsoman 2 years ago
Cool! I have not seen an Eko guitar in years.
Great song - and a great voice!
GodsFavoriteBassPlyr 2 years ago
boy that's a good song. Thanks for posting sir!
dougfr007 2 years ago 2
Thank you. I refer you to the reply below to 400PoundsFrank
threelegsoman 2 years ago
Very interesting song. I really liked it becouse of the difference from other patriotic songs about the crimean war.
400PoundsFrank 2 years ago
Thank you, I am always pleased when people enjoy my offerings. There are three sequels to this song if you are interested and they can be found on one of my playlists simply called Abdul Abulbul Amir.
threelegsoman 2 years ago
You are welcome
threelegsoman 2 years ago
Interesting song I didn't know before. I like it!
neoclassicism 2 years ago 2
There are two more on the same subject which I will upload at some date in the future
threelegsoman 2 years ago
Excellent work keep your videos coming!
banjodano 2 years ago 2
Will do
threelegsoman 2 years ago