some keys were a bit flat. but at her age, we can't ask more. The way she played shows she really melted into the melody. I wish she will be a master.
I think she has a lot of talent, and I do agree with others that she has some intonation problems, so yes, scales. [: I bet in a few years she'll amaze us with an even better performance.
I agree with the others. If she just practices her scales all the time non stop and etudes. She will be invincible. The piece is way too much for her. The intonation is a biggie...
She has strong stagepresence and she's really good for a girl this age. I think most of the pieces she plays are too hard for her and the intonation is not always nice to hear, especially fast parts. In Europe where almost all classical music comes from,I think people are more critical. Children only perform for audience when they play pieces (almost)perfectly, otherwise they play less difficult pieces. I am sure that this girl would play less difficult pieces perfectly.
I agree with you. She shouldn't have been given this piece yet. Scales and etudes are very important. A really good teacher wouldn't do it this way. It's a pity, because she does has a lot of talent. Watch Shin Sihan perform for. example Kreisler, you can hear the difference.
Not a good recording quality; violin may be in part responsible. Interesting to note the mute's on. Player is incredible, magnificent, and knows exactly what she's doing. She understands and relates to beauty from her soul, and that's why age doesn't matter. My God, her playing is exquisite!
Granted that this girl is very talented, her expression is not what I would call professional. She does have stage presence, but her musical expressions are something that have purely been taught by her teacher, it's very obvious. In other words she may not know completely what she is doing.
I think it's important to note that everyone begins playing musically by imitating others. Later, musicians develop their own ideas for the music. It works the same with a language - we imitate the sounds we hear until we are comfortable with them enough to form words and sentences as we choose.
I'm not doubting her potential, I'm just saying that rosinagurl has given her a little too much credit for having expression that is better than some professional players.
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Who can tell from a 7 minute video clip what's really going on behind that stage. Caezura does make a good point about the communication learning process. Also, go check out Valerie's other videos (especially Salut d'Amour and Bruch) an also watch her playing the piano. Her expressions look like she understands it's part of communicating through music. Just MHO.
How can emotional expressions be taught? Do you mean to say that some teachers actually teach acting to kid musicans? It doesn't sound like the right/ethical thing to do. Expressions in music should come from within each indivual, not just an act.
9? My dear Valerie, there is no limit to your talent.
chobeethaninov 8 months ago
Oh...my....goodness....
melodyofLeCygne2 1 year ago
..,taLented fingErs....hehehe wOw she's ReaLLy giftEd.....!!!!!
tatz26don 1 year ago
Comment removed
evgenygorobtsov 1 year ago
nice staccato, young lady!!)
evgenygorobtsov 1 year ago
I'm sure, that you will be the queen of violin XD
pvstar08 1 year ago
haha i think the intonation problem was the violin lol but we cant ask more at her age =] niceeee
dogpaw814 2 years ago
some keys were a bit flat. but at her age, we can't ask more. The way she played shows she really melted into the melody. I wish she will be a master.
iamoliverwong 2 years ago
So adorable child.
I just love her so much.
Such a treat.
bless you Valerie!
rosinagurl 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not as refined as Gabriella Chou's... But amazing nonetheless!
mikomiko321 2 years ago
9? God danmit... This girl has a future of pure awesomeness.
Arathornbr 2 years ago 10
is she chinese,korean,japenese or vietnamese?
Nileyrocks9 3 years ago
KOREAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
mae8318 2 years ago 12
lol korean
tiffi0000 2 years ago 2
For a nine-year old, Val sure does play professionally.
colfranz1278 3 years ago 20
Excelente, Valeria es una genio del violin, la admiro mucho, felicidades.
anzdf 3 years ago 12
Talented!
Darkie007 3 years ago 13
Valerie Kim's music always brings some
magical sparks that makes the music alive.
I can see that she has a very bright future
in musical career.
Best wishes! ^^
musicbringsmagic136 3 years ago 17
she is quite a challenger!
i wouldn't pick on her intonation. don't expect too much, she is a child. she will grow to be a big musician with her talent. i m sure.
joosangbai 3 years ago 10
I think she has a lot of talent, and I do agree with others that she has some intonation problems, so yes, scales. [: I bet in a few years she'll amaze us with an even better performance.
quynhho2002 3 years ago 10
I agree, too. But she is amazing at this age!
musicbringsmagic136 3 years ago 9
Esta niña es increíble! Perfecta la interpretación.
MelySam08 3 years ago 4
She plays fearlessly!
OriginalMoonbeam 3 years ago 6
I prefer the other video of the same piece.
But anyway, Valerie, you're great !!
koubache 3 years ago 6
O.M.G! I almost cried soooo much!!!I couldn't do this really good !!!
I hope in future I could do this :D
LuckyAnimeGurl7 3 years ago 8
Good!
This piece is very difficult!
It'd better to you to play concertos a bit easier. Instead of that, you desrve my congratulations.
:)
FilipeBarrosAlves 3 years ago
I agree with the others. If she just practices her scales all the time non stop and etudes. She will be invincible. The piece is way too much for her. The intonation is a biggie...
gbritaney 3 years ago
She has strong stagepresence and she's really good for a girl this age. I think most of the pieces she plays are too hard for her and the intonation is not always nice to hear, especially fast parts. In Europe where almost all classical music comes from,I think people are more critical. Children only perform for audience when they play pieces (almost)perfectly, otherwise they play less difficult pieces. I am sure that this girl would play less difficult pieces perfectly.
giada660814 3 years ago
This is going to be my reason and backup for asking my parents to let me take violin lessons...I basically learned by myself and I sound like crap
dracomalfoyzgirl01 3 years ago 6
She is very showy and all, and really very good for her age, but it's still out of tune. I think she needs to practice etudes and scales first.
Tsz001 3 years ago
I agree with you. She shouldn't have been given this piece yet. Scales and etudes are very important. A really good teacher wouldn't do it this way. It's a pity, because she does has a lot of talent. Watch Shin Sihan perform for. example Kreisler, you can hear the difference.
1408CM 3 years ago
so young so good,
amazing!
joosangbai 3 years ago 8
My mouth dropped when I heard that first scale. Wow! She is excellent!
JadoreKouture 4 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Tymur Melnik is excellent, Valerie is good.
Sibelius2000 3 years ago
omg...she's so good! she must have learned violin since she was little! or maybe a violin GENIUS...maybe im overexagerrating...(spelling wrong)
mewberry123 4 years ago 11
darn....
she's about nine and i'm like 11..
migod! I can't even play that!!
She's really really goood.
And i'm like... urghhh
My scales are out of tune!!!
D*** it!!
musiqismalife000 4 years ago 4
Can't wait to hear her in five years' time !
derbysg 4 years ago 10
0.0
oh my damnn.... shes so goodddd
better than me and my adition is tomorrow T -T
JackieLee524 4 years ago 4
She is very good for her age. I am working on that song now, and I'm 15. She did much better than I can on the left hand pizzacato.
DarkZodiark 4 years ago 7
bravo!!
saibels 4 years ago 2
wow.. very showy
ellegin88 4 years ago 4
Bravo! :D
tubaingunn 4 years ago 2
Not a good recording quality; violin may be in part responsible. Interesting to note the mute's on. Player is incredible, magnificent, and knows exactly what she's doing. She understands and relates to beauty from her soul, and that's why age doesn't matter. My God, her playing is exquisite!
bluedoughnuts 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She is musical...but she needs to play a lot of etudes and scales to to fix the intonation problems.
luckintown73 4 years ago
Nt bad-/A BIT out of tune ....
at tis age she can play SARASATE AREADY very PRO IN FACT I TINK I SEEN TIS IS THE SMALLEST AGE TO PLAY SRASATE
bountyhanz 4 years ago 3
I AGREE with you it is OUT OF TUNE!
espicially in teh end
violinfreak123 4 years ago
Well done! Such awareness and verve. Valerie, you exude passion and love for this. Thank you! The Humberstones
KathrynHumberstone 4 years ago 3
omg,she plays so beautiful! so artistic! it's scary that her expression actually better than some professional players. love it , well done girl!
rosinagurl 4 years ago 2
Granted that this girl is very talented, her expression is not what I would call professional. She does have stage presence, but her musical expressions are something that have purely been taught by her teacher, it's very obvious. In other words she may not know completely what she is doing.
adidas01003 4 years ago
I think it's important to note that everyone begins playing musically by imitating others. Later, musicians develop their own ideas for the music. It works the same with a language - we imitate the sounds we hear until we are comfortable with them enough to form words and sentences as we choose.
I think she played great. Lots of potential here!
caezura 4 years ago 3
I'm not doubting her potential, I'm just saying that rosinagurl has given her a little too much credit for having expression that is better than some professional players.
adidas01003 4 years ago
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. Who can tell from a 7 minute video clip what's really going on behind that stage. Caezura does make a good point about the communication learning process. Also, go check out Valerie's other videos (especially Salut d'Amour and Bruch) an also watch her playing the piano. Her expressions look like she understands it's part of communicating through music. Just MHO.
bostonmusicfan 4 years ago 5
How can emotional expressions be taught? Do you mean to say that some teachers actually teach acting to kid musicans? It doesn't sound like the right/ethical thing to do. Expressions in music should come from within each indivual, not just an act.
opusluv 4 years ago 4