I can't think of any specific examples, but friends fighting against each other works best when the two friends both have a valid goal, but the two goals are in conflict with each other. Note this only works when both goals are understandable. If either goal is based on say being evil for the sake of being evil then it doesn't count.
Hearing the theme in Allistal reminds me of the beginning of this lp,it may not be over yet but it sure has come a long way,It almost slipped my mind about the other timeline
It was fairly challenging when I played through, but immensely satisfying, because I abused Aht's traps to nuke everything that could be shoved around. Also Viola has something nice to steal iirc.
Alao, here's a good twist on the whole ideal: You have to fight one of your friends because BS brainwashing, but it turns out you were the one brainwashed, and he was only spying on you and snapped.
@inukirby992 It's one of the best RPGs of all time, if you ask me. The translation's somewhat spotty, and a lot of things are implied, so I'd recommend watching it over playing it for your first time, at least. GetDaved did an amazing LP of it, and I'd give his the nod over HCB's, mostly because Dave really focuses on making the story an experience for those that haven't seen it before.
Flyn vs Yuri in Tales of Vesperia. Even though the don't really "fight to the death" but they were friends just on different sides and different views.
I dunno. Professor X and Magneto had a pretty good "friends on the opposite sides" thing going on. But Americans were always better at coming up with ways to make both sides of a war sympathetic. Japanese culture just have our cultural language for violence.
The only good example of friends fighting each other in a JRPG that I can think of is in Tales of Vesperia. Yuri(the main character) and Flynn are friends even though their ideals are opposed. No mind control and neither of them are completely right or wrong. They simply choose opposite sides of a conflict based on their personal beliefs.
Poor Alistel. Hugo lied to the people and manipulated them to fight for the wrong cause. He really is an evil man. If you were a representative of a past Savior, you would not want to lie to people like that. That's cruel. It even happens in our world.
HCBailly you need to play Suikoden 2 then. Best use of why friends have to fight each other. One of the best JRPG stories out there. Agreed with LPTheGabriel.
Meteor----next LP?! I since a Final Fantasy LP coming up. Only ones I can think of you haven't done yet are. FF IV on PSP (The After Years), FF XII or FF X and X-2.
@HCBailly When I fought Viola it was really hard for me. I don't know how many turns it took, but the battle lasted for minutes, and after I won, it felt epic. I don't mind a really overpowered party, but I think it is a pity that you killed her so fast HC =\
@raddudeguy considering the title for the episode, Im highly hoping for HC to do that and may consider other related strategy type of game not as much as for example tactics ogre, but for example advance wars or its sequels. I expect HC for him to at least consider them in the near future at least. Oh, well....
a good not BS friend battle would be chaos rings where you have to kill the friends around you a few times in the game because otherwise they'll kill you
Try Suikoden 2, the entire game revolves around 2 best friends fighting each other, with reasonable explanations why (at least, by JRPG standards, anyway)
In the first Shin Megami Tensei the hero has the option of choosing to join one of two different sides , none of them necessarily bad, and depending who he joins he will have to not only fight but also kill one of his friends who joins the opposite side. No mind control or anything they just choose the other side because they think it will be the best for the world. If the player chooses no to join any side it will have to fight and kill both friends.
you were saying that none of the party members seemed to be as devout in their belief in Noah, but I got the impression that Stocke himself was, what with lashing out physically at that dummy in Granorg...
@shadowrose8907 Actually it felt more like he was frustrated that people were used this entire game/storyline to believe that the Prophet Noah was still alive and asking his country to fight a 'holy war', when Hugo was simply using it as leverage for personal gains. Not sure if Stocke is a huge follower or not.
@LPTheGabriel That is exactly what I thought of too. It's kind of the quintessential example in this case. Suikoden has a lot of similar situations of that too.
Hmmm. most of the time it is mind control, but when you were talking about it I was thinking of Wufei and Trowa from Gundam Wing. Also, have you played Valkyria Chronicles then HCBailly?
Well, there was the fight against Shinon in Path of Radiance, where Shinon joined the Daein army, which was previously your friend. He left your group and ended up at the enemy side.
2:10 SMT Nocturne had some very nice friend betrayals
adadd567 3 weeks ago
I can't think of any specific examples, but friends fighting against each other works best when the two friends both have a valid goal, but the two goals are in conflict with each other. Note this only works when both goals are understandable. If either goal is based on say being evil for the sake of being evil then it doesn't count.
HolyAjora 1 month ago
2:30 HC in kingdom hearts they have a pretty good reason
Jerrezzz 1 month ago
Can someone direct me to the video where HC gets the last of Stocke's and Aht's pacts? I need to complete that last mission before I beat the game..
Niqes 1 month ago
Final Fantasy XII Get here already! DDDDDD:
Caenogenesis 1 month ago
Hmm, I think tactics orge might have a good reason (lawful route)
XRuglia 1 month ago
Hearing the theme in Allistal reminds me of the beginning of this lp,it may not be over yet but it sure has come a long way,It almost slipped my mind about the other timeline
KentoKaima 1 month ago
HCBailly Save the world and become a king? You do mean Dragon Quest 6 don't you? ;) lol
L3WCore 1 month ago
A good reason to fight a friend, eh? They have created a third faction and wish to eliminate you and your enemy.
Waterwish545 1 month ago
It was fairly challenging when I played through, but immensely satisfying, because I abused Aht's traps to nuke everything that could be shoved around. Also Viola has something nice to steal iirc.
gigaslave 1 month ago
Riou vs. Joey... Suikoden II.
Enidx10 1 month ago 2
The whole friend vs friend thing....
*COUGH* FLYNN VS YURI LOWELL *COUGH* Tales of Vesperia. *cough cough*
DDTPZX 1 month ago
You know what game gives you a good reason to fight your best friend? Yeah, that's right... Suikoden II.
axemranger 1 month ago
"dias was a man"... before the sex change operation?
lol :P j/k
KuroroSama42 1 month ago
"if only we had Viola"
i know where this is going.
ShadowWolfRising 1 month ago
"a friend joining the bad guys, WITHOUT MIND CONTROL"
theres a entire game series that does this, in each game with like 1 exception.
fans of the series likely know what series i speak of 'Hint: its my favorite series'
ShadowWolfRising 1 month ago
tut thats a terrible word of the day
jackachugaming 1 month ago
OK, Raynie and Marco joined the party, but where are they? Did they e-mail Stocke to join the party again?
labradoido 1 month ago
Anyone who can't tell Dias is a guy needs to play more JRPGs
sillykatmeows 1 month ago
just this timeline is enoguh for 1 DS game
jackachugaming 1 month ago
A really good reason for friends to fight...Code Geass.
RyuuSeichi 1 month ago
13:36 Dragon Quest III reference?
ValisHD 1 month ago
@5:55 "Sometimes you go hours without a save point in [Final Fantasy XII]." And then you find a save point... and it attacks you.
LockeStockeAndBaryl 1 month ago
Alao, here's a good twist on the whole ideal: You have to fight one of your friends because BS brainwashing, but it turns out you were the one brainwashed, and he was only spying on you and snapped.
inukirby992 1 month ago
@inukirby992 Final Fantasy VII was close to that.
TehBrawlGuy 1 month ago
@TehBrawlGuy Hm, never played that one.
I should check it out then?
inukirby992 1 month ago
@inukirby992 It's one of the best RPGs of all time, if you ask me. The translation's somewhat spotty, and a lot of things are implied, so I'd recommend watching it over playing it for your first time, at least. GetDaved did an amazing LP of it, and I'd give his the nod over HCB's, mostly because Dave really focuses on making the story an experience for those that haven't seen it before.
TehBrawlGuy 1 month ago
Well, HC, there's Mother 3, which was really good.
inukirby992 1 month ago
Flyn vs Yuri in Tales of Vesperia. Even though the don't really "fight to the death" but they were friends just on different sides and different views.
walkernintendofan 1 month ago in playlist More videos from HCBailly
Forever alone Viola -_-' nuts!
ValisHD 1 month ago
Kiel should be alive in this timeline as well, where is he?
Noarcs 1 month ago
another good friend vs friend boss fight was lucas vs claus in mother 3
cobaltscarf 1 month ago
@cobaltscarf He said without mind control. That kinda counts I think.
KirbyChan 1 month ago
I will be shocked if the next episode is titled anything other than "Magitek Factory."
JohnRayJr 1 month ago 2
@JohnRayJr Actually, I have a related, but slightly better and obvious idea.
HCBailly 1 month ago 2
@HCBailly "Devil's Lab"?
DLane814 1 month ago
@HCBailly Devil's lab
F1nalHeaveN 1 month ago
I dunno. Professor X and Magneto had a pretty good "friends on the opposite sides" thing going on. But Americans were always better at coming up with ways to make both sides of a war sympathetic. Japanese culture just have our cultural language for violence.
udsuna 1 month ago
League of Legends.
IronGarchomp 1 month ago
how many parts do you think this LP would be if the 10 minute time limit was still intact? Over 150? more?
nintendoplay 1 month ago
@nintendoplay Approximately 50% more.
CastlePokemetroid 1 month ago
HCBailly in this game its pronouced: "You Noble Scum!" :P
Made4542 1 month ago
Viola has a Vesper Ring, +60 HP +30 MP, which I like to give to Marco so he can do more out-of-battle healing
ArchetypeGotoh 1 month ago
The only good example of friends fighting each other in a JRPG that I can think of is in Tales of Vesperia. Yuri(the main character) and Flynn are friends even though their ideals are opposed. No mind control and neither of them are completely right or wrong. They simply choose opposite sides of a conflict based on their personal beliefs.
Rollo427 1 month ago
The thought of you doing an LP for Valkyria Chronicles puts a smile on my face. :)
scorptatious 1 month ago
star ocean the last hope may have a good reason
goldenblade2002 1 month ago
Y U NO BRING VC3 SEGA ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)
HeWhoEnjoysTehVids 1 month ago
Kingdom Hearts - Riku. He somewhat switches sides a few times, but is your best friend
ChronaMewX 1 month ago 2
@ChronaMewX Well, He was mind controlled by darkness and Ansem so it is pretty much mind control.
walkernintendofan 1 month ago
Reason to fight your friend: One of you is brainwashed.
caterpieofdoom 1 month ago
the friend fighting question pokemon 3rd gen does it correctly.
MegaKidicarus 1 month ago
This is a damn long game, isn't it?
advancedpillow 1 month ago
@advancedpillow Same length as all his main LPs
dpbj602 1 month ago
@advancedpillow It has a lot of depth to it.
HCBailly 1 month ago
@HCBailly I originally thought a DS game wouldn't, or rather, couldn't, be this deep. I'm pleasantly surprised.
advancedpillow 1 month ago
@HCBailly I blame the time travel XD
Galax1809 1 month ago
Poor Alistel. Hugo lied to the people and manipulated them to fight for the wrong cause. He really is an evil man. If you were a representative of a past Savior, you would not want to lie to people like that. That's cruel. It even happens in our world.
Blackdrake1 1 month ago
So there has only been one point in time where all of the party members have been in the same party? That's different.
Shika1929 1 month ago
In Legend of Dragoon at a certain point I won't spoil, there's a good reason to fight your friend.
treyhyde1 1 month ago
A civil war
rsguardian81 1 month ago
HCBailly you need to play Suikoden 2 then. Best use of why friends have to fight each other. One of the best JRPG stories out there. Agreed with LPTheGabriel.
omensoffate 1 month ago
comb the desert! xD
Efrolof 1 month ago
Stocke's a bad person using time travel to strengthen your enemy for 23000G
ZergofImportance 1 month ago
the title should have been valkyrie profile
brainjuice654 1 month ago
"Come to me, dark warriors, battle awaits us!"
gregdrako 1 month ago
Love the title for this video. Could this posssibly be hinting at a new lp? I sure hopes so
mhall47685 1 month ago
Those stones behind Viola are probably einherjar considering how she's a Valkyrie.
Flashflame00 1 month ago
Eh, not as much of an HCCliffhanger today.
ThePigKnight 1 month ago
suikoden series
pokethepenguin2 1 month ago
...You fought Pierre for a pretty damn good reason in my opinion.
1andonlyWojjan 1 month ago
were friends, but grew apart? Umm... Stocke and Marco... :3
ShyBoy6D9 1 month ago
I always thought "Musou" was pronounced, "Moo-So" and not "Moo-Sal" I think you're doing it wrong HCBailly :(
JDude042 1 month ago
@JDude042 Actually looking at the word it would probably be pronounced like moose-ow which is how HC is pronouncing it.
ultrazeldafan 1 month ago
@JDude042 It is, and he is. Don't let it bother you, though. He pronounced ether wrong for a long time. :3
ShyBoy6D9 1 month ago
fft ramza and delita. friends fighting due to diffewrent goals
j0llyblackgiant 1 month ago in playlist More videos from HCBailly
@j0llyblackgiant Except they never fought each other.
HardToFindGoodNames 1 month ago
Valkyria Chronicles as one of the next LP. Please, please, please, please, please, please, please
grjfdk 1 month ago
10:36 Count da Money?
De Monet!
PianoManT 1 month ago
4:38 10,000 DEATHS ARE NOT ENOUGH FOR HIM!
3ajku 1 month ago
Lol Pokemon? Blue is your rival, but also your friend. Reason is they both want to be the best Pokemon trainer
blackwaltzko 1 month ago
@blackwaltzko Blue was sort of a prick. He was your rival, but I don't think he was your friend.
ShadesOfArthur 1 month ago
Meteor----next LP?! I since a Final Fantasy LP coming up. Only ones I can think of you haven't done yet are. FF IV on PSP (The After Years), FF XII or FF X and X-2.
sbcmarine81 1 month ago
@sbcmarine81 He has said that FF4 on the PSP was his next LP for a while now. He did a blog on this.
KirbyChan 1 month ago
@KirbyChan
Cool I'll be looking forward to it.
sbcmarine81 1 month ago
@sbcmarine81 It also says so on his channel
GamingIdiot42Neo 1 month ago
Well In Tales of Vesperia, Yuri and Flyyn eventually fought for old times sake.
Turbotails08 1 month ago
Well, technically Xenogears counts, but going any further into that is spoiler territory.
ddgafd 1 month ago
Ramza never fought delita? not a good reason but a reason xD
adryanus9 1 month ago
@HCBailly When I fought Viola it was really hard for me. I don't know how many turns it took, but the battle lasted for minutes, and after I won, it felt epic. I don't mind a really overpowered party, but I think it is a pity that you killed her so fast HC =\
guilhermetaichou 1 month ago
If you like the Dragon Quest-style endings, you really should give Earthbound another try. Hell, everything about that game is like Dragon Quest.
Ocson 1 month ago
i spoiled the game for myself and watched the ending... all i can say is, god damn it HCBaily... you made me love the game.
XxUnitedAsiansxX 1 month ago
Marco and Raynie don't seem to be important anymore, huh? They're barely even in cut scenes now.
Tempest329 1 month ago
Reading the title for this episode REALLY got my hopes up for a Valkyria Chronicles LP.
raddudeguy 1 month ago 18
@raddudeguy considering the title for the episode, Im highly hoping for HC to do that and may consider other related strategy type of game not as much as for example tactics ogre, but for example advance wars or its sequels. I expect HC for him to at least consider them in the near future at least. Oh, well....
gokart000 1 month ago
@raddudeguy sucks that game isnt for ps3
Musicgod76 1 month ago
Viola just wanted to die on the field of battle rather than die of her disease. It is as simple as that for me.
KatharosOmbre 1 month ago
One would assume that Hugo was killed in the alternate history. I never really understood exactly how the histories converged myself.
HuwLightfist 1 month ago
hcbailly
a good not BS friend battle would be chaos rings where you have to kill the friends around you a few times in the game because otherwise they'll kill you
i won't spoil why but it's not a BS reason at all
Dsilink 1 month ago
Try Suikoden 2, the entire game revolves around 2 best friends fighting each other, with reasonable explanations why (at least, by JRPG standards, anyway)
lecmg 1 month ago 2
In the first Shin Megami Tensei the hero has the option of choosing to join one of two different sides , none of them necessarily bad, and depending who he joins he will have to not only fight but also kill one of his friends who joins the opposite side. No mind control or anything they just choose the other side because they think it will be the best for the world. If the player chooses no to join any side it will have to fight and kill both friends.
thunderblast234 1 month ago 2
im guessing that final fantasy 12 is the next main lp
MoustachioGuy1996 1 month ago
@MoustachioGuy1996 dont forget ff4 psp. :)
TuxedoRay 1 month ago
you were saying that none of the party members seemed to be as devout in their belief in Noah, but I got the impression that Stocke himself was, what with lashing out physically at that dummy in Granorg...
shadowrose8907 1 month ago
@shadowrose8907 Actually it felt more like he was frustrated that people were used this entire game/storyline to believe that the Prophet Noah was still alive and asking his country to fight a 'holy war', when Hugo was simply using it as leverage for personal gains. Not sure if Stocke is a huge follower or not.
ElectrolyteGaming 1 month ago
@ElectrolyteGaming I dunno, that was just the impression I got; it's kinda vague without voice acting or different character portraits
shadowrose8907 1 month ago
If you want a game without the correct amount of save points, try Shin megami tensei 3 - Nocturne.
I'm not joking. So many times I have turned the game off because I didn't want to continue.
TheMoonlightJester 1 month ago
A good reason to fight your teammate is if she wants to steal your Materia.
skyknightdragon 1 month ago
A good reason for a friend to fight you: Discover that his love interest is a spy.
Eincrossfire 1 month ago
Fight your friend for a reasone...
You never played Suikoden 2 have you HCBailly.
LPTheGabriel 1 month ago 30
@LPTheGabriel That game's a masterpiece.
skyknightdragon 1 month ago
@LPTheGabriel That is exactly what I thought of too. It's kind of the quintessential example in this case. Suikoden has a lot of similar situations of that too.
membou 1 month ago
my example is ramza and delita fron Tactics
yoyo6934 1 month ago
@yoyo6934 But they never fight each other.
HardToFindGoodNames 1 month ago
when your fighting rosch, TWICE!
hiimthenewguy 1 month ago
Sephiroth wasn't mind-controlled, or anything like that. He attacked his friends and everyone else on his own free will.
GeraltzRivii0 1 month ago
@GeraltzRivii0 yeah but he went insane thinkin that hes a god
MoustachioGuy1996 1 month ago
'Dias is a man!'
It's Kuja all over again.
KoldsnedLP 1 month ago
Hmmm. most of the time it is mind control, but when you were talking about it I was thinking of Wufei and Trowa from Gundam Wing. Also, have you played Valkyria Chronicles then HCBailly?
andrewsallee 1 month ago
@andrewsallee Good god, everyone in Gundam Wing would fight each other for sooo many reasons I just forget all of them xD
ZeryusAgain 1 month ago
Well, there was the fight against Shinon in Path of Radiance, where Shinon joined the Daein army, which was previously your friend. He left your group and ended up at the enemy side.
Is that a good reason for you Mr. Bailly?
TheShepardSaga 1 month ago
You should try Valkyria Chronicles if you haven't already. It's a fun game.
JanusHoW 1 month ago
Will o´ Wisp is obscene.
It is really hard wíthout all these abilities...
Experienced it myself.
TheShepardSaga 1 month ago