Added: 3 years ago
From: MindChatterFilms
Views: 5,040
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You actually do sound a lot like David Gilmour!

  • That is one of the funniest things I have seen in a long time...but not for the reasons intended. Thanks for further demonstrating the futility and narcissistic arrogance of atheism to me. In addition, if there truly is no God, then why the hell do you can what someone else believes about it? Freedom is a two-way street, genius.

  • don't make parodies

  • screw u! god is real! how would u be here if there wasnt.

  • wow you raped a Pink Floyd song...

  • Floyd for life!!

  • This Needs More Views Than it Gots!!!!!! TAA And Cody And Everyone else Should Hive this A Shoutout

  • God does exist.

  • @SummerSunshine1988 Ah, right just because you say it does. That is the alpha and omega of xian beliefs. That is all you have.

  • @SummerSunshine1988  Ah yes, simply because you say god does exist. This is the alpha and omega of xian faith. That is all you have.

  • @beihou : Do your research, my friend. There's plenty of evidence for God. Check out ChristianAnswers[.]net

  • @SummerSunshine1988 Yeah, I've seen a few of the so called answers given by xians. There is no evidence that God exists. None. It's all based on faith and emotions. The rest is spin. Alpha and Omega, that's all you got. And for the record I am not your friend so don't call me that.

  • @beihou : I cannot force you.

  • @SummerSunshine1988 I just wished the other xians in the USA would say the same. Neither can I help you to understand that, again, that there is no proof of god. A person with such religion is the same as a person under the influence of drugs. I'm just sick and tired of fools simply spouting the nonsense that somehow 'god exists'. I wish to be part of the forefront of people attacking the so called 'facts' of xianity. To try and pull as many people from that cancer as possible.

  • @beihou : Do you truly believe God to be that toxic to humanity? Why are you fighting so hard if He isn't real? Are people suddenly going to revert back to the horse and buggy because people believe in God? Are doctors going to suddenly lose all of the knowledge they've gained over the years?

  • @SummerSunshine1988 Wow! Thanks for the innately stupid reply. Your assumptions are showing. PS it's beyond the realm of belief and disbelief, just to try to clue you in.

  • @beihou : Actually, I was sincerely curious.

  • @SummerSunshine1988 Good. Curious is better than a numb unquestioning existence. 

  • @beihou : There is not a Christian alive on the face of this Earth that does not question. We are human too. We have our occasional doubts and questions about life and why things are the way they are.

  • @SummerSunshine1988 Interesting, and honest. Many of the xians I've met would rather die a painful death rather than admit any doubt. It's that doubt that I had a long time ago that led me away from the church to search for answers that are true. I'm so very glad I'm not a xian any longer. I have found some of the answers, not ones that please me but that's besides the point. I hope you find some of the answers to your questions as well.

  • @beihou : One thing we all have in common is that we all have doubts, fears, and questions. I went through about a three year period where I was convinced that God didn't love me. Then I learned, in school of all places, that God does love me and He does know who I am.

  • "At the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus C. is L-rd, to the glory of G-d the Father."

    There is power in that name and all will soon see and weep....He is alive and will return again!

  • As old as this video is, it's still brilliant!

  • Thats awesome!

  • Oh I love this Video Crosis this is the best , your a true artist, he needs his own TV Show ,, I cant quit laughing,,, Love it Crosis : )

  • well done

  • great and probably not too far off roger waters own views on religion so I doubt he would mind at all.

  • this was amazing im not totally anti religion but i am against religious dogma and the control of the masses crap so i say again. well done

  • My dog, this is really an amazing video. I loved it.

  • lol. hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha­hahahaha

  • OMG, this was awesome! Very well done.

    Going to go to your channel and see what else you have. And I am sharing this with my friends if they don't already know about it!

  • That was funny. ha ha ha

  • totally fuckn awsome i love this vid im gonna like this channel

  • Awesome. An atheistic remake of a Pink Floyd classic. Love it. As for religion, evidence or not, I totally reject it due to lack of interest. I know that fundamentalists make it out to be some kind of universal moral compulsory order but the truth is that it's a universal afterthought. Like not forget that its idealogies are morally and intellectually bankrupt. All that is a good enough reason to reject it. Good video.

  • This is just fantastic, I wonder why It has so few views.

  • @MelodeathAddict

    Probably because there are about 90 million videos about atheism on youtube.

  • Thank dog for that! heheh

  • YOU are a Genius !!! This is the most awesome thing I have seen on YouTube. YOU ROCK !!!!

  • why do your eyes change demonically throughout this squeel?

    pretty cool idea though.

  • HAHAHA!! THIS IS GENIUS!!!!

  • Aww you are still butthurt that I pwned you sooooo bad.

  • very good! 5 stars!

  • You sir, win at everything forever

  • No comments... no fucking comments... You sir just pwned the world !!! Congratulations for this awesome video-song ! Subscribed faved 5star. That was so inspiried ! Congratulations again ! Simply brilliant

  • I like this, great video. 5/5 stars.

  • Hilarious Parody, thanks for posting this!

  • Oh man, the beginning of that song cracked me the fuck up lol

  • i'll be laughing all day, i think pink floyd has to proud of this

  • FUCKING AWESOME! I love the song choice you used for the video. Though the original Pink Floyd Lyrics would have worked as well. Still, 5 stars and i am featuring this video for a while :)

  • i laughed the whole time man. It's funny to see you as a christian....lol

  • btw you are comfortable dumb

  • the man that abuses Pink Floyd.

  • nah he doesn't abuse Pink Floyd, just kind of....misusing them. I think it works, though i will say Roger Waters singing it would be better, but not everyone can be Roger Waters.

  • Nice work, Crosisborg. Not the greatest singing, to be bluntly honest about it, but you made up for it with lyrical creativity and visual editing. 5 stars, fav'd.

    ..and for the record, it's better singing than I can do.

  • Hey people. Watch Kifli's "Atheist comedian on prayer in school". It needs 10k views for another vidoe to come out. Its funny. Cheers.

  • You can be a critic

    or you can be a critical thinker and find evidence for God.

  • You're afraid to stand without your magic plan. You have become comfortably dumb, rusty. You have become comfortably dumb. Why worship a God that's so obviously sick?

    Can you wake up?

  • Yes I awaken to the complex garden who gives evidence of the Gardener. If you think love and long suffering a sickness then the comfortable blinders of confirmation bias has taken you to the outer darkness.

    The plan is as magic as the complexity you find in a infinite cosmos of eternal exploration. We are stardust and we have to get back to the garden where life is forever..

  • you can't find what isn't there

    any critical thinker can see that the bible is a collection of impossible hypocritical bullshit written by men with an agenda.

  • If your view of the Bible where reality I don't think many would be interested in such a book. Much less want to debate about it.

    So reality would say you are wrong about the bible as it is the most studied and read book in history.

    But hey any critical thinker can see you have a fallacious agenda now can't they?

  • And exactly what is that evidence that you speak of, rusty?

  • Fantastic!

  • you are awesome. i love your videos. youre my favorite subscription!!!! right on!!

  • This vid deserves much more hits. Just a little better on the vocals and it would be one of the best on YT.

  • Haha this is fuckin' class. Pink Floyd + these lyrics/singing = epic win! :D

  • Awesome.

  • ~*~ Bright Blessings! ~*~

    I Am A Green Celtic Wiccan Witch Dedicated To My Goddesses & Gods &

    I Absolutely Enjoyed Watching This

    Fantastically Creative Video! I Love Pink Floyd's Music & You Singing Your Own Lyrics To The Comfortably Numb {Dumb} Song Sounded Perfectly Like The Pink Floyd Song! At The End When You Are Rolling On The Floor You Reminded Me Of The Band REM Song "Losing My Religion" Singer. A Combo Of Pink Floyd & REM ~ GREAT STUFF! So, I'm Mystical & Magickal & I LOVED It!! )O(

  • WOW! I love Pink Floyd and that parody was epic!

  • Awesome.

  • Good video, glad I found it.

  • aww Thanx Tommy..You really know how to cheer somebody up :)

  • I want to lay on the floor and rock back and forth like you did, after the day at work and then home I have had, lol.. I want a hug :(

  • Here ya go !!! HUGS Francie !!

  • You know, about 2:15 you should have started randoming the song lyrics.

    "Taste the brick of life" or "Make sure to sleep for roughly 7 hours a day"; something like that. MindChatter is creative though, and I dig that.

    Peace Crosis.

  • *Dies laughing* =D

  • this is awesome. great job!

    and lol at 5:10, with you on the ground shivering next to the buy-bull. i like how there's lots of picturesque imagery to go along with the song.

  • I LOVE IT

    Xd

  • Excellent! Well done!

  • great!

  • Genius, man! Fabulous!

  • I love Pink Floyd, and I love you...5 stars.

    Great parody, great voice, great expression of your feelings.

  • Now that is an honour

  • wow that was so much better than I expected!

    You surprised me there!

  • Nice revamp! Love it!

  • Fantastic work.

  • Instant favorite! I love Pink Floyd and I didn't think that song could be improved upon. I was wrong. lol lol lol!!!

  • fav'd

  • Amazing!

  • Kick ass song. Pink Floyd Rocks

  • this was awesome. i gotta say though yout voice isnt meant to sing those higher notes during the pre-chorus since it was quite off during those times. but the lytics were great and just the fact that you parodied Comfortably Numb, a classic.

  • I'll second that.

    Exactly what i was going to say.

  • Well sir, you can't sing worth a shit but the song was quite funny.

  • His sining skills weren't the point of the video, dipshit.

  • I'm aware of that, idiot. The video was quite funny and I got the point. I'm not trolling by pointing out his lack of aural aptitude, merely stating a fact. Also, it's spelled singing, not sining, please learn to spell before you troll other peoples comments, thanks.

  • Okay, sorry.  I thought you were only trying to insult Crosis. And my spelling is usually flawless. I must have typed it too fast and forgot the G in the word "singing". That happens sometimes, but not too often. It was a simple and very common mistake that many people make on occasion. I haven't made any spelling mistakes since that one, and the one I made before that one was about a month ago. So it's not a frequent event.

  • yay look at me.. I can spell.. crown me queen of the universe... I've only had 2 spelling accidents in the last 10 years... time to lower my speller's insurance.

  • Pineapple.

  • I enjoy the challenging nature of your satirical, short films..

  • i enjoyed this :)

  • Honestly, you captured the torture a Christian feels when they realize everything they had believed was a delusion. This is exactly how I felt. This should be a featured video. What can we do to make this happen?

  • Awesome vid, plus Pink Floyd are atheists. Or at least Gilmour and Waters are.

  • you're not that bad a singer, you kept to the pitch pretty decently

  • more...more...more!!!!!

  • Nice, Crosisborg. That was intense. Comfortably dumb is a great loaded phrase.

  • Wow

    I don't care how bad you think your singing is, this was great.

  • lol! Fucking great.

  • By the way excellent video!! 5 stars!!

  • Crosis , man , all i got to say is 1 word !!!

    BRILLIANT, all around , great job !!

  • Obviously this is Tommy lol,

  • Thanks bro.

  • i missed films from you guys. glad to see your back

  • I like the original song... but DAMN this was so great!!!

    I DEMAND this song be put up for upload someplace! (pretty please)

  • side note: Crosis sings better than i would've expected. Now I'll know who to bring to karaoke from the youtube atheist community. LOL

  • * i meant DOWNload.

  • Sorry Skippy but there is no evidence for the existence of any god outside of imaginitively assigned evidence.

  • Ridiculous! What bullshit. Show us real evidence.

  • Typical. You don't want to look at the evidence or you try to say it isn't evidence.

    Fact is, its whether you want to view it as being from God or not. You can say it is or that it isn't but it doesn't disprove God either.

    Just like there is no evidence for evolution, but ya'll believe it to be true. Why? because you'd rather believe there isn't a God.

  • There is more evidence for evolution than there is for gravity Skippy. No one has to disprove god. God is a myth by default and willbe so until he is proven to exist.

  • LOL thanks for showing all the people here how childish you are with that one.

  • One of your favorite songs? Then i suggest you listen to Pink Floyd bassist Roger Waters solo album "Amused to death", with songs about the hypocrisy of religion on it i know you'll love it.

    And existence is evidence of existence, i don't know where you got god from that, you make quite the assumption there.

    And even if it is proof of a deity, what makes you think its the christian god?

    pwned bitch

  • Yes there is alot of hypocrisy in religion, I never said there wasn't. People will always try to twist truth to their own preconcieved ideas of what it should be instead of adhering to the Bibical law of comparing scripture with scripture.

    I don't know where you got that any of Mr. Waters songs have to do with a disbelief in God, I see it rather as a questioning of hypocrisy in the faith. Jesus questioned the high priests of that day in much the same way, calling them full of dead men's bones

  • I apologise, my beef is not with religion itself, but with fundamentalism, which is where hypocrisy arises.

    Whether Waters is religious or not i don't care, he understands the errors in fundamentalist religion.

    And yes, you are a fundie

  • "People will always try to twist truth to their own preconcieved ideas of what it should be instead of adhering to the Bibical law of comparing scripture with scripture."

    That's what makes it hypocritical! You can't possibly live up to the Biblical law without having to kiss God's ass and ask for forgiveness every night.

    The same ministers who con people, lust after men and women, preach to their audience that the Bible says not to do that... that sounds like hypocrisy to me.

  • Why do I think God is the Christian God?

    Because I know the Bible to be God's word and the Bible says He is a God of mercy, truth, love and judgment. The Holy Spirit applies God's word in my life and verifies these truths through the reading and hearing of His word the Bible.

    "Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word of God".

    It's like identifying with that which is true, I recognize it as truth as God applies it to my life.

  • 1. And your evidence that the bible is credible is?

    2. You make a subjective claim, how do we know you're not hallucinating?

    What makes you any more right than a hobo babbling incoherently on a street corner?

    3. The christian god, loving? Not according to deuteronomy he ain't, and yet again you assume this because its what the bible says.

    How do you know that God isn't evil and is only deceiving you?

  • And don't say, "he wouldn't do that" or something to that effect, the whole thing about being crazy or being lied to is that you don't realise you are crazy or being lied to.

  • Just because God is a God of judgment doesn't mean He's not a God of love.

    I don't believe God ever killed anyone but rather He removes His mercies in which are very abundant.

    That the cause of death and pestilence in the Bible is a result of disobiedence to the law of God. What part does God have with those who reject Him? Their blood is on their own hands.

  • Don't blame the victims.

  • They refuse the sauce, so it's their own fault that the Noodly Appendages Stick Together. Oh the humanity.

  • And I believe in wonderful fairies with fluttering wings. Oooooh it's so beautiful. Please pass me that reefer.

  • You just asked how god can possibly be involved with his own law and his own creation's rejection in a world run by himself.

  • "That the cause of death and pestilence in the Bible is a result of disobiedence to the law of God. What part does God have with those who reject Him? Their blood is on their own hands."

    so what you're saying is that in order to be a good person you need someone to threaten you with death and judgment? What kind of masochistic paranoia is that?

  • Your god's system is totally fucked up. I could do a better job with one hand behind my back.

  • "The Holy Spirit applies God's word in my life and verifies these truths through the reading and hearing of His word the Bible. "

    impressive another victim of confirmation bias (google it up if you don't know what it means)

  • Then please present your verifiable, critical, robust evidence for your brand of God! Please also provide verifiable, critical robust evidence for "us being here" as evidence for God! If the evidence is so strong where is your Nobel Peace Prize for finally putting this discourse to rest?

  • you still haven't explained the definition of God.. if God is the universe, then yes.. you win and crosis is delusional

    "Just like there is no evidence for evolution, but ya'll believe it to be true."

    genes mutating to the chemicals of the environment... sounds a lot truer than a sky daddy

  • Sheila says that Laura says that Linda's bff Georgia heard that God is real.

    UNDISPUTED PROOF.

  • No, there clearly was evidence. Evidence known only to Uaz31, who has denied to share it with you, because God/Allah/Satan has Not yet chosen to reveal himself to you/hardened your heart/lead you astray. To assume that the universe was somehow NOT created just for humans, by a superbeing who takes the time to listen to them think really hard so he knows they want from him, that would be arrogance in the extremist sense.

  • First, there is as much evidence for God as there is for the flying spaghetti monster. And less evidence than for the Greek gods.

    And the bible is not evidence for Jack's shit.

  • Can you describe God? What do you mean when you say the word God?

  • I like Crosis' singing better than some actual celebs.

  • excellent crosis

  • Awesome, well done.

  • Out *fucking* standing, Crosis! You really out did yourself on this one.

  • glad everyone enjoyed it

  • Fucking superb Crosis! That was excellent. Thanks.

  • Fantstic work :D

  • Genius.

  • Wow, great work !

  • Wow, that was awesome.

  • I wish I had a lighter right now.

    Fantastic work Crosis, 5 stars. :3

  • Sounds like youre holding back man. Fuck the neighbors, let it rip!!

  • Rodger Waters would be proud, great work.

  • Pink Floyd FTW

    well done

  • For some reason I thought of the serpent in the Garden of Eden when hearing this.

  • Awesome video crosis! Plus your voice sounds cool to me =)

  • well done, crosis.. i love it :)

  • One of my fave songs...Pink Floyd=woot!

    Very well done!

  • That was an awesome parody!

  • Awesome. Way to go, Crosis. Dispite what you might think, you did very good. Pat yourself on the back.

  • FANTASTIC JOB CROSIS!

  • You really have the voice for this kind of thing!!

    Nice!

    5*****

  • Nice! I enjoyed the lyrics, they were awesome at some points but at others I could see the struggle to find a word or words that worked.

    I think this is going to turn out to be a really good channel! Kudos to the both of ya!

  • Good shit man.

  • I really wish I could find a singer to do this shit for me.

  • Your voice is good enough.

  • > I really wish I could find a singer to do this shit for me.

    Dude, there are lots of singers hanging around YouTube and elsewhere who could do a collab. Put up a video asking, or do some searching through some videos of people doing covers.

    Singers are out there.

  • bro, it wouldnt be the same if anyone else sang your stuff !!

  • Yeah, it would actually sound good LOL

  • You should hold a contest.

  • Good video. I assume Tommy was on lead guitar?

  • YAY!

  • Stunning stuff.