Added: 5 years ago
From: user20061
Views: 251,749
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (504)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This song really sends me.

  • just sublime , just so good !

  • Is about her mons or her clitorus?

  • i can hear the inspirations of Minnie Ripperton and Kate Bush and all the songs her dad used to listen to with the family absolutley fantastic, my little girl was singing BATTERY instead of BLACK CHERRY today in the car..........

  • She's on a whole another level of awesome.

  • To say she is sex on a stick would do Alison a disservice as a singer. But she's sex on a stick.

  • No less than ... Goddess !!

  • ...listen to loads of music and this song hits many notes

  • Goddamnit, I love this song. So good.

  • ADORO GOLDFRAPP E BLACK CHERRY! ESSA MÚSICA FAZ MEU ESPÍRITO FLUTUAR!

  • I never liked electronic music very much but i will die a Goldfrapp fan to the core! Fan-f%&#ing-tastic music.

  • She's not always "on", but this was great

  • Alison is of the greatest musicians and performers around - we are so lucky to have her. Her music is beautiful and she's definitely a looker. Turned many people on to Goldfrapp from this tune... Gorgeous...

  • CLASS

    

  • Gorgeous!

    

  • Greatly underrated Band! Their latest album is by far their best, in my opinion.

  • @musicsugar76 Oddly they truly are underrated. Everyone I have hear them love them instantly though.

  • Excite me , ignite me oh and you know

    I Miss you I kiss you Oh and you know

  • I love this track.

  • Goldfrapp- my great discovery this month. It has begun with the video "Rocket". Then I started to look after Goldfrapp as a singer and I found many interesting songs of her. She is a really awesome interpret as an artist and a very attractiv women as a human beeing. So, if she only wants me to do to her everything, what a man can do to a women, I will be hers. I love Alison. She is my 100% women.

  • man, i can't help but tear up every time i listen to this track or watch this clip. it's such a sublime and moving song to me. i just love and am in awe of Allison and Will.

  • jesus christ, this is massive. i keep coming back to it. love the new record, but this performance pulls me back again and again.

  • I love Goldfrapp!! I had never heard of her till I first heard her song "Strict Machine" on that cell phone commercial, lol!! After that I looked up her music and I love it! This song is very sweet ;-)

  • What's wrong with people? You like it or you don't. As the lord god Frank Zappa said "Do as you want, do as you will but don't mess up your neighbours thrill"

  • @lesterpiglet1 Preach it brotha' Frank.

  • man this song just melts into my heart especially the "i miss u" part

  • iSaid it before and i'll continue saying it.... You're just so gay, dude !!!

  • i said it befre and i'll continue saying it :X:X:X

    i'm just.. soooo.. in love with this song :X

    makes my heart melt :X:X

  • How old are you dude?

  • if you had half a brain you would know my age look at my name u retard.

  • Gayfey, you should get a life dude....and take that anal prove out of your ass.

  • another troublemaker here starting crap online ok mr tough guy since u like to start crap give me ur name and address lets see u do it in person its easy to do it online put up or shutup.

  • u start crap with me and u tell me i should get a life?i knew u wouldnt give me ur name and address u chickenshit dont start crap online unless ur willing to back it up pussy.

  • How many time do we have to flush before you go away Gayfey !!!

  • Are you guys having your period???

    It's seems it's time for you to get your fucking dolls a comb their hair... faggots !

  • shut the hell up troublemaker that jerk started with me as did you so put up or shutup easy to start shit online lets see u do it in person tough guy give me ur name and address otherwise shut the hell up coward.

  • both of you sound like twats.

  • and you sound like a troublemaker started crap online with someone who never said one word to u easy to start shit online lets see u do it in person give me ur name and address put up or shutup pussy.

  • @JollyGreenJ Agreed

  • Alison looks sooooooo sexy .. but those whispery sensual vocals, just make you m*e*l*t.....! I'd love to snog her!!!! lol

  • she's to good to be true, i'm proud to live

    in the same moment as that she does otherwise i would never have seen her

    on stage, and thus i can say : SHE'S THE

    BEST AND ALL FOR REAL !

  • Agh!

    Goldfrapp's music just makes me melt!

    Alison and Will are awesome musicians!!!

  • and i wonder too,would you be so willing to say the same of bjork? the whole argument is ridiculous...you would think you were talking about beyonce.

    i just find time and again,female artists are pre-judged if they don't come out with a guitar strapped to their chest or in front of a piano.

  • Comment removed

  • i wonder if this person would say that lady blahblah had more talent than alison just because she plays piano? who,imo,is essentially miss kittin in bjork's clothing and britney spears' words. just saying...

  • @scottjhnsn I like Alison AND Bjork, but I also like Orianthi

  • and she's not just a voice that sings words but she uses her voice. it's really funny to me how people can be so ignorant and outright judge somebody without any sort of substance whatsoever.

    and another thing,you keep saying she is or isn't this or that but goldfrapp is not just alison it's alison AND will. there are two people and both of them contribute.

  • alison doesn't use instruments therefore she's not an artist? what a bunch a dribble! for one thing you apparently are not a real goldfrapp fan otherwise you'd realise instruments aren't all the traditional. she not only has played(studio and LIVE)synthesizers first and foremost which she learnt to play way back during her years in antwerp but she's played the heavenly melodica,cowbell,tambourine(su­pernature)....and above all else her voice is an instrument.

  • music like this makes the pain melt away

  • check out utopia live by her,the voice is amazing

  • No doubt about it!

  • so how do you explain a choir then.they have no instruments but seem to make very good music with just their vocals.

  • you are comparing apples to oranges a choir isnt a pop music group you fool,people in pop music like nsync and spice girls and pussycat dolls and blay eye peas arent real groups cause none of them play music,they have someone play the music for them,and choirs dont use music like these groups do so comparing them is stupid.

  • i just love it :X:X:X no need to compare to anything/anyone.. just "mind blowing". thnx for uploading it

  • Thanks for these comments- what a contrast to the ridiculous bickering of the people who posted comments before you. Alison Goldfrapp is a star, and her changes of look and image between albums and performances is fascinating.

  • ;)) she is indeed.. she is often copyied (watch goldfrapp's- ride a white horse and then lady gaga's- poker face)

  • compare allison goldfrapp to the spice girls and pussy cat dolls is a really stupid thing. Godfrapp is a real band, who wrote is music. allison don't play instrument, but she deserve the title of co-writer, because she involve herself in every composition she sing.she don't sing a song composed and writen by an anonymous composer far away from her, like girlsband. goldfrapp os close to portishead in the way the work.

  • yeah they are a real band but she isnt,i wasnt comparing the band to the spice girls just her cause they cant play music either,and if she can write songs she wouldnt have to have help,the spicegirls all have cowritten credits on their songs so do the pussycat dolls and ur gonna tell me they write songs?haha dont be so stupid,people who write songs dont need help,michael jackson couldnt write songs either all his songs are cowritten or he didnt write them at all like thriller.

  • actually, thank to the small book inside "felt mountain", i learn that allison play keyboards, but only on recording, not on scene. and thank to the same source, allmost all goldfrapp song are writen by will gregory and allison goldfrapp, and no one else.

  • nsync had credits saying they could play too but they never did in concert so dont be such a fool that is proof that she cant play or she would do it here in this video like the real musicians,and if she could write songs she wouldnt need help and have it cowritten,real writers dont need help writing songs she didnt write crap they just gave her cowriter credits same with michael jackson thats why he didnt write thriller cause he couldnt write or play either.

  • @jayfey77 Are you a musician? Have you recorded music? A song? An album? Have you appeared on stage? Do you know what a session musician is/does? Just to give you an example - The Beatles co-wrote their songs. Look up George Marin's input with Sgt. Pepper. Your logic says they weren't true musicians, in that case.

    But the best is you arguing the defence for Nsync. They had CREDITS that they could play but, what, they didn't want to? Mess up their haircuts? You're funny. Bonehead funny. Fool.

  • you truly have no idea

  • just more endless, angry hot air. you have SO TOTALLY missed the point of what i was saying; were so wide of the mark of it's intent and so wrapped up in getting a torrent of personal attacks in (not aimed just at me, either) that you have blinded yourself to what i was trying to say. take a deep breath, read it again and chill out. easy on the retard remarks as well. people in glass houses and all. ok?

  • why has everyone on youtube gotta slag each other off just enjoy the music or fuck off

  • the spice girls don't sing.... hahaha

    they dance.

    dummy.

  • i like how all the non writers have cowritten in the credits like the spice girls and michael jackson and ringo of the beatles anyone with half a brain knows they couldnt write or they would write their own songs and not have people writing for them and then they get half the credit same goes for alison.

  • A singer isn't a musician?

    You know fuck all mate.

  • no a singer isnt a musician you retard or the spice girls or pussycat dolls would be considered musicians and wouldnt have real musicians behind them in concert are you really this stupid?apparently you are.

  • Nope. You are wrong. Girls Aloud, Pussycat Dolls.. whatever. Are shit musicians. But still musicians. Plenty of people love Goldfrapp because they enjoy good music. Capiche?

  • nobody in the real music world considers the pussycat dolls real musicians,they would laugh at someone like you who says they are musicians,you are an idiot.

  • You fail at absolutely every conceivable level. Are you this stupid outside of Youtube?

  • i never met anyone as stupid as you all my friends are laughing at how anyone can be this stupid for saying people like pussycat dolls and the spice girls are real musicians haha you must have rocks for brains.

  • Who gives a fuck what you think? Shut up and enjoy the music or jump off a cliff you retard.

  • its not her music you retard thats the point she cant play or make music you idiot.

  • Where's your music dickhead?

  • sounds magical

  • Me encanta Goldfrapp, pero esta canción no la conocía, si alguna vez vuelvo a hacer el amor, voy a poner esta música de fondo.

  • Comment removed

  • Si no te gustó mi comentario ve y mámale la verga a tu padre puto como la ves?. Well i'm go to fuck your girl in the meantime you write again in this place headsheet!!

  • Silly little boy. Grow up.

  • this song is beautiful and makes the hurt i feel bearable with it's potential to console, thanks goldfrapp

  • I don't know what to tell you . . . But THAT'S why I didn't reply to you! haha! Anyways, I don't want to hear about any more dumb bands like the P Dolls or N'sync or the beatles because they're irrelevant. I still don't believe that Alison isn't a musician based on the facts you've repeated, you need to find actual proof instead of placing the P Dolls in the same sentence as her. All I know is you're confusing the street connotation of musician with the denotation of instrumentalist. Keep Going.

  • I don't think she's a musician, I just proved it! hahahaha! Your other problem is you can't have proof of her not playing an instrument on a video, because she does play an instrument in a video! So that just means she doesn't in this one, which you've never even watched. See! I even said you think the P Dolls and Goldfrapp are in the same category, ha! You need to look up soloist, musician, and instrumentalist, cause you're getting them ALL confused. WOOP! THERE IT IS AGAIN!! GayFag77: 0 Me:2!

  • there is hundreds of videos of her here on youtube and not a single one showing her playing anythign you retard,youtube has proven you wrong not just me,and if singing makes a musician to you that means the spice girls or the pussycat dolls are musicians too you see how stupid you are.

  • it doesn,t matter that she can,t play an instrument.thats why she has a backing band to play for her.her voice is her instrument and she can hit every note with precision (even live),something which i doubt the pussy cat dolls or other manufactured artists or groups could hope to do so dont even put her in the same brackett as them i.e dont be stupid !

  • she is in the same bracket as them because they dont play music either they have to have a band behind them doing it.

  • The problem is he thinks Alison can't play an instrument, categorizes her with the fake bands, and I think he maybe a little on the "koko" side! [Goldfrapp pun]

    Personally, I think Alison's more properly labeled an Artist, not musician, which is understood as a downgraded term anyway. FYI, since we all like using the dictionary so much, a "soloist" is defined as a singer or OTHER MUSICIAN [AKA same thing] Woop, there it is! All I have to say is, who the hell are the Spince Girls?! LMFAO!!!!!!

  • calling alison a musician is like calling nsyn or the pussycat dolls musicians you see how stupid you are.

  • she cant play an instrument look at all the vidoes of her here on youtube not a single one of her playing anything,and since you think alison ios a musician that means u think the pussycat dolls are musicians dont be so stupid.

  • DON'T REPLY TO JEYFEY77

    DON'T REPLY TO JEYFEY77

    DON'T REPLY TO JEYFEY77

    DON'T REPLY TO JEYFEY77

    DON'T REPLY TO JEYFEY77

    (seriously... not worth arguing with.)

  • simpleandclean, i've been where you are. i've come to realize that even bothering to argue with someone like jayfey will get you nowhere. let him be because the more attention he gets, the more he'll annoy you.

    but do expect a reply in about a month. it seems to take him about a month to think of a comeback.

  • i dont understand how u can argue when this video proves me right u say she is a musician but look at this video she isnt playing anything look at all the other videos here on youtube she isnt playing anything either so you have no case,i provide video proof and you still are in denial.

  • and what?

    get over it.

  • i dont want attention in case youve forgotten you started talking crap to me on here i never talk to anyone on here i only respond when they start talking to me,i dont go starting crap with people like you do.

  • get over it now.

  • i'm aware of that now. i just don't understand what's so difficult about it. i honestly think he's stupid. i really didn't think there were people that naive and dense. i'm sick of trying to make a point to someone who is like a broken record.

    "i can't believe you argue these facts i make" - "you sound like those retards who think nsync could play because they said they could" blah blah blah. i'm glad he doesn't like goldfrapp. i feel better knowing someone like that doesn't like them. :)

  • nobody more naive and dense than you i dont understand how you can even argue with mke about someone who cant play when there is proof of it all over youtube including this video right here,and i do like goldfrapp just not her you retard.

  • are you actually still here? nobody cares saddo.

  • you just show how much of a loser you are that you like people in music who cant play music,how can you have respect for people in music who cant play it ur as bad as those fans of the pussycat dolls or nsync or all the groups who dont make music in history from the spince girls to the supremes you name it.

  • how do you work that out.she,s singing.the voice is probably the most important instrument in music.you keep playing your piano or guitar and see how far you get without a singer.

    no i thought so!

  • I tried telling GayFag77 that voice is the most difficult instrument . . . He just delt out more crap and insisted I was wrong =]

    [what a surprise]

  • yeah sure it is thats why the pussycat dolls only sing same with nsync if singing was the most difficult thing to do then those losers would have been able to play guitar or piano.

  • did you ever think about playing and singing at the same time like real musicians do,that requires talent though something alison doesnt have thats why she cant play she has as much talent as the spice girls or the pussycat dolls who cant play either.

  • Are you honestly comparing her to the Spice Girls? I'm amazed.

  • im comparing her to anyone in music who just sings and doesnt play musical instruments,like the pussycay dolls or the black eyed peas people in music who dont make it or play it.

  • She's still making music.

    And honestly, so are the Black Eyed Peas.

    (But obviously it's not on the same level as this ;))

    But they aren't doing it alone.

  • how are black eyed peas making music when none of them can play music,thats why they have a real band behind them when they are in concert,same with alison.

  • The Black Eyed Peas aren't a good example because the write shitty songs. Allison Goldfrapp writes poetic, rich songs that have so much more substance than a lot of musicians. Just because she isn't holding an instrument in her hands doesn't make her not a musician. A persons singing voice is an instrument.

  • if a persons singing voice was an instrument the pussycat dolls would be considered musicians dont be so stupid.

  • She wrote the music in the studio with Will Gregory. How is that not a musician?

    I'd love to live a life like yours; talking shit on Youtube about artists you hate.

  • thats bullshit since there is hundreds of videos on here of goldfrapp and she isnt playing in any of them dont be so stupid,nsync said they could play too but they never did in concert yet their fans believed them.

  • So you deny she is writing any music in the studio? There's loads of videos of Will and Alison writing music.

    Why does she have to play an instrument to be a "musician".

    BTW, you are well beneath me, you should be thankful I even responded to your incredibly ignorant comment.

  • so according to ur logic nsync the spice girls and pussycat dolls are musicians even if they cant play an instrument you see how retarded you are,you are the one who is ignorant for even believing she can write if she could write she wouldnt need any help you fool.

  • Jayfey 77 stop spouting bullshit. If you don't like piss off. Goldfrapp are ok in my book. You can't put them in with or compare with Pussycat dolls, Black Eyed Peas crap. Your profile isn't too bad I give you one up for the Kinks,Beatles etc. and you don't like rap -Cool! At least you got something right. Oh, Ziggy is GOD! CLASH, KJoke, Siouxsie Rule. ROCK ON AC/DC

  • bullshit huh?are u retarded?i wasnt comparing goldfrap to black eyed peas or the pussycat dolls u fool i was comparing allison to them because like them she cant play music either,her band can but not her.

  • Your full of shit. Who cares if Alison can' t play music - she sings so who gives a fuck retard. What's the point? FUCK OFF and leave this site alone. If you don't like piss off. Your profile I have to take back - you obviously just some stuck up musical snob who dislikes Alison. Come on - you really like the pussycat dolls etc. YUK! See I can be a snob. See you later - NOW PISS OFF!

  • everybody in the field of music cares people who take listen to musicians only not people like pussycat dolls or nsync or spice girls or black eyed peas anybody who cant play music like alison u fool,i dont like the pussycat dolls u retard i hate anybody in music who cant play music maybe if u get ur head out of ur ass u would notice thats what i implied on my last statement or ur just to stupid to figure that out.

  • jaygey77 get the hint from others - NO ONE WANTS YOUR OPINION - now Fuck off with your tail between your legs - music snob! If you don't like go elsewhere to spout your shit. I bet you can't play or compose much yourself. I HATE PEOPLE LIKE YOU who HAVE THE OPINION that people who can't play music - Thank GOD for PUNK - people like you just don't get it. John 'Rotten' Lydon couldn't play music but that didn't matter - As he would Say PISS OFF!

  • i can play bass,guitar and drums,and since u like people who cant play music that means idiots like u consider people like the spice girls and pussycat dolls real musicians even though they cant play music you see how stupid u are,and since u started crap with me on here cursing at me lets see u give me ur name and address its easy to start crap online i think ur a pussy and cant do it in real life and if u dont reply with ur name and address u prove me right,remember u started with me.

  • JShit - I don't care what you can or can't play - go & play with yourself for all I care! Your a snob a pain in the arse! GET OFF THIS SITE You Deserve a PUNCH IN THE MOUTH - I DON"T CARE WHO YOU ARE, you are a irritating piece of shit. AS I SAID BEFORE PISS OFF. NAME & ADDRESS TO YANK PSYCHO SHITHEAD LIKE YOU WHO JUST RAVES ON FOREVER ON THIS BLOG ANNOYING & BORING people to death NO THANKS BUT IF YOU KEEP IT UP I MIGHT RE CONSIDER SO I CAN PUT YOU OUT OF YOUR SNOBBY EXISTENCE - NOW F OFF!

  • if u dont care then why were u accusing me of not being able to play anything i was just defending myself from ur stupid lies u fool,ur a fucking scared little pussy ur all talk u start shit on here with me then are to chicken to settle it in person ur a pathetic chickenshit i knew u wouldnt give me ur name and address ur all talk.

  • Jay don't give me this American tough bloke Crap. All that high school jock shit. You watch too many yank teenage films mate. I am in AUSTRALIA - idiot - anything else - PISS OFF THIS SITE. YOU TURD. I am so bored with the USA (Clash 77) At least some Yanks are Ok Iggy, etc. You started the shit - just look at all the people you argue with - take the hint - you said your piece NOW SHUT UP but you no doubt won't and will irritate others like you normally do. I tired of this. BYE

  • you started with me u jerk as did those others,they are chickenshits like u thats why they start crap online cause they cant do it in person i knew u wouldnt give me ur name and address i dont give a damn if u are in aUSTRALIA,if u are tired of this why did u start with me u jerk,ur nothing but a troublemaker then u back out of it like the coward u are,put up or shutup.,dont start crap unless ur willing to back it up.

  • Look jerk PISS OFF! You started it irritating others & never shutting up! Down under all you big Yank talk is considered bullshit mate. We aren't so impressed. Where do you want to meet arsehole? Half way across the Pacific Ocean - idiot? Leave the topic alone and go elsewhere -people are sick of you. I bet you couldn't face a lot of these people you accuse of being chickenshits. Bye crap artist! That's it from me. As another said don't answer or correspond with jayfey77!

  • no i will come to ur house unless ur willing to come to mine then i will give you my name and address,and u still started with me u retard,these chickenshits didnt give me their address i gave them mine ur nothing but all talk u dont back up anything u say thats why ur so pathetic cause u start shit then cant back it up.

  • Jay I leave you to argue with the others - I am sick of this. I bet you did arrange to meet others - will travel across the globe to other cities, countries etc. easy said than done unless you got loads of cash and i'ts not local. BYE YANK ARSEHOLE!

  • i dont start crap like you but i finish it ur nothing but a pathetic loser who starts crap online with people cause he cant do it in person.

  • Jay! Your pathetic Loser raving on here! You start crap putting down others ARSEHOLE! Your very brave when your thousands of miles away aren't you? TAKE THE HINT - PEOPLE ARE SICK OF YOU DIP SHIT. BYE YANK!

  • u starteed with me u retard i didnt put anyone down until after they started with me,and i asked for ur name and address which u havent given ur a pathetic troublemaker who starts shit online cause he cant do it in person ur all talk coward.

  • Jay, yes you did put people down - Alison Goldfrapp for one and all the others you CLASH with! Trouble maker HA - just look in the mirror. Coward as I said it is easy said when your sitting miles away! Shit online - look at yourself - same old comments retard! Why would I want to give you my address no thanks you would never shut up only got look here and see how you rave on to others. BYE YANK

  • none of the people here including u are allison u retard all i did was state a fact i wasnt putting her down all i said was she cant play music which is true and thats what she has in common with pussycat dolls and black eyes peas u retard,i didnt say one word to u,yet u come on here and start name calling me so thats u starting it with me yet u dont wanna meet in person and settle it like a man u are pathetic.

  • Jay re read some of your comments! As for settling like a man are you coming to Australia? So don't give us this manly shit. All Pathetic bullshit. Bye Yank, oh this is final had enought of this crap agrue with someone else like you normally do. Have a nice day!

  • yeah i will if you give me ur address iget to fly for free it wouldnt cost me a cent,u started with me u jerk u need to be taught a lesson.

  • Comment removed

  • Well give me your address then. Don't give me this college boy American jock shit. BYE ARSEHOLE!

  • i have given my name and address many times on this comment video,scroll through it its on here more than once,unlike u im not all talk,unlike u i dont start crap with people and then ask them for their address when ur ther one who started shit,i knew u wouldnt give me ur address and name ur a pathetic coward

  • Whatever your an arsehole Hope to make it to the States dickhead. I HATE LOUD MOUTH IDIOTS LIKE YOU! Always calling others idiots. A know in all who knows fuck all! PISS OFF and leave people alone. Some like goldfrapp or whatever you obviously don't - you said your piece over and over. No one wants to here your opinion forever anymore dickhead. Get it? So PISS OFF! Bye musical snob ARSEHOLE! Killing Joke

  • You sound just like an annoying stalking delivery guy. Get a girl and ask her for addresses, names and all that shit you need to be some1.

    Besides, you won't be a tough acnekid tryin' to threat people on a GOLDFRAPP's comment box !!!

  • i dont hit girls just guys and remember u started with me dipshit im not a kid and i dont have acne fool ur just a chickenshit thats why u start crap online cause u cant do it in person.

  • why would u give ur name and address away? do u know if people will actually stalk u and harass u?

  • ur a fucking pussy,and what makes u pathetic is u start crap with people online who never said a word to you,then you are to chicken to settle it in person.

  • Jay - don't give me that bullshit. People think your an arsehole. Always putting others down. Look at all the others you piss off. BYE FINAL.

  • The Pussycat dolls ARE musicians you idiot. They're just nowhere near as talented as others, but they're musicians none the less.

    kirkfnw said it the best:

    The Pussycat dolls are musicians, but shit musicians.

  • they arent musicians because they cant play anything you retard neither can alison thats why they arent musicians you idiot.

  • You just went to far by calling me and idiot and a retard. That's really immature.

    I don't think you realize that singing is playing an instrument, even though it isn't a physical object.

  • seriously!

    and he says that I talk crap about people when he's here calling everyone a "retard" and "stupid." too bad those are the only insults in his vocabulary. i guess it's from listening to all that nsync and pussycat dolls. lmao he's such a jerk off. he says he "likes goldfrapp just not her you retard." lmao! isn't that the most ridiculous thing you've ever heard?! someone's logic is backwards. lmao

  • i dont like her because she cant play she doesnt make music you retard,how can you respect someone in music that cant play it,that shows how stupid you are for supporting people like nsync or pussycat dolls who fall under that group.

  • your opinion doesn't matter to me. please, don't concern yourself with whom i choose to respect.

    seriously. get over it now.

  • Jay you're technically correct.

    musician - n.

    One who composes, conducts, or performs music, especially instrumental music.

    But it's not worth the effort. It's a technicality to most. She's a very good singer and that's gonna be more than enough for most.

  • what he insists, is JUST because she doesn't play an instrument live... she's not a musician. alison goldfrapp and will gregory are the ones who compose the music in the first place. i'm not trying to be hostile toward you, & i apologize if it's coming out that way, but believe me. you can't be civilized with this asshole.

    this should have been over more than a month ago. he just decides to keep digging it up, even when he's been proven wrong by other people as well. he's pathetic.

  • if she could play she would be playing live,you sound like those nsync fans who said they can play they just dont play live,truth is if she could play she would even madonna plays guitar live even if she isnot that good at it.

  • i really don't know what to tell you anymore. what the fuck do you want? not everything is as black and white as you make it out to be. she knows how to play, but doesn't play live. what's wrong with that? just because you have some twisted idea of how an artist is supposed to perform doesn't make it correct. i've given you proof and you still act like an asshole about it. so you're either doing it on purpose cos you have no life, or you're seriously stupid. pick one. frankly, i'm done.

  • she doesnt know how to play if she did she would play live you idiot,whhy do you think nsync didnt play live you fool all their fans said they could play too dont be so stupid.

  • Okay now you're just making up shit just to seem smarter. This is actually kinda interesting how your mind works.

  • i state facts and you are in loser denial about it there is actual video proof here on youtube of everything i said either ur blind or just to stupid or both or you just are in denial like i said cause there is hundred of videos here proving im right and ur wrong.

  • singing isnt playing an instrument or the spice girls and pussycat dolls would be considered musicians and they arent nobody in the field of music considers them musicians only retards like you.

  • Yeah. Just me. And several other people.

    They're musicians, but less of a musician than Alison Goldfrapp because they don't write any of their music.

    And only "retards like you" say that this woman in this video isn't a musician because she isn't holding an instrument.

    And stop calling me a retard. It's wicked immature.

  • they wrote all their own songs you fool but they are all co written like alison songs,thats what u fail to realise that these people cant write songs or they wouldnt have to have help and have cowritten in the credits.

  • hang on,how do you work out that the voice isn,t an instrument?

    how do you think people went on before instruments were invented did they fart to the music or something?

  • before instruments music hadnt been invented,but instruments go back almost as far as man goes back,and the v oice isnt an instrument or the pussycat dolls and the spice girls would be considered musicians and they arent in the music world by real musicians.

  • where does it say singer in that musician you just posted read the fine print.

  • Comment removed

  • if she composed and performed music she would be playing here in this video you cant compose music unless ur a musician you fool and this video and all others of her on youtube prove she cant play.

  • i guess this is proof how stupid goldfrapp fans are to be putting down the beatles,and to call alison a musician might as well call nsync or the spice girls or the pussycat dolls musicians while ur at it idiots.

  • This song gives me goosebumps.

    I love Goldfrapp.

  • excellent!!

  • I do it all the time in person. If you were someone i knew i'd punch you right in the eye for being such a moron.

    You've been proven wrong many times now by lots of people.

    Now do us all a favour and SHOOOOOOSH!