Added: 2 years ago
From: FreQuenczy
Views: 46,233
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (267)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i actually really enjoyed this game... plus i think jason griffith is a much better voice actor personaly

  • u do not no what fun or your bro and sis

  • I wasn't that bad once you get used to the controls

  • This game really blows the controls in my opnion were terrible and so was the gameplay

  • Ok this game is a mixbag as I have a love/hate to this game and I still play this but I can understand since on-rails is not much of a good idea.

  • Frequenczy, gameking53 likes this game and hates sonic and the black knight.

  • They changed the voice actor for Sonic again.

  • Even Sonic has to put up with Navi.....

  • now i normally agree with your scores but it deserves a 3.00 out of 5

  • Why do you hate the game I love it

  • @grimmers64 If you wanna see a review of this game. But has a positive reception. Then go see kNIGHTWING01 review of this game. FreQuenczy, here say's, that this is a bad game. This game. Got positive review's. So fuck him. And go see kNIGHTWING01 review of this game.

  • @grimmers64 Well some people will hate it since sonic is mostly free roaming then on-rails.

  • Why do you hate the game I love it

  • dude if i watched this like 2 days ago id completely agree with you, but i started to get into the game and its pretty good once you get used to everything but off the bat on playing you're right

  • your awesome

  • TWILIGHT PRINCESS WWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • @chaoslight11 yes, it is weird. Maybe you should be isolated and studied for this...

  • @cjimmy99 Funny, Iike all the Sonic games I have played. (Never played 06.)

  • I dont understand the point of the sonic/zelda comparison....zelda made a great game and sonic made a bunch of somewhat decent games...ok what else is new

  • this game have terrible grapphics

  • That's a bit unfair, sonic has multiple consoles while zelda must stick to nintendo

  • Secret Rings may have sloppy controls but I love the levels and difficulty in the platforming. Another smart feature is the ability to speed boost and slow down time. Definitely not a class but u really shattered my spirit with the review ::( Wish I could unkock the secret party characters

  • whatthe heck does zelda have to do with SONIC!!!!????

  • look at how many mario did the last 4 years plus 2012

  • i got this game iand i did not like just becuz it did not have enough day stages i wanted to do acts like sonic stage

  • make a sonic 06 review

    

  • @narutozmen He doesn't own a 360/PS3.

  • Is it weird I acctually like this game and party mode? Because I did enjoy this game a lot.

  • @chaoslight11 naah i like this game too i liked the gameplay and i also loved the party games

  • @federerfreak4 NIce to know I am not the only one.

  • @chaoslight11 I perfere Black Knight but this is a neat game too. I love the party mode expeicaly so I usualy play that. The game is chalenging too. Me I say on his ranking Good.

  • I got stuck on the level where you collect the dinosaur eggs

  • i disagree with frequenczy!

  • @redyoshi01 That's your opinion.

  • For once i disagree with frequenczy. I just got this game from a friend and i think its pretty good. The controls are kinda iffy, but after the first two worlds i got used to them. And when he said the thing about dishing out sonic left and right, only three of those were real sonic games, Riders is a racing game so i don't really count that or the olympics one. when you say 3D sonic games you should only include the action/platforming ones.

  • i liked this game

  • dude this is the best sonic game on the wii and maybe you suck at the game

  • grifitth is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­aaaaay better

  • Yesterday, I saw some kids at gamestop saying this game was great. I almost shouted, "Are you KIDDING?! That game sucks!"

  • I bet you already know this, but the reason why the original actors were replaced by the 4Kids Actors is because Deem Bristow, the original voice of Dr. Eggman, died in 2004. Although nowadays we have the Studiopolis actors like Roger Craig Smith. The only 4Kids actor that remains is Mike Pollock, the voice of Dr. Eggman.

  • @FreQuenczy Gameking53 and neverchris like this game. Why don't you like this game! Well, Shara can be very annoying.

  • come on!this game isnt that bad :p

  • jaleel white should have done the voice of sonic because he did the voice in all the old shows (if he still has the voice he did when he voiced sonic)

  • almost bought a will for this game when it first came out. i used to drool over this game as a kid lol. i got over it though after playing it at a friends house

  • Well the game is good if you get used to the controls. But the mini games are downright horrible. The single player is fun except for some annoying parts.

  • exactly a half rating

  • I know a lot of people don't agree with me but I say this is a slightly above average game. I'm not saying its a good game but if you take the time to get used to the controls which I know a lot of people don't have the patience to do, it's a surprisingly fun game with tons of replayability. I've had the game for a year and I've still got tons I can do in it. (Probably because the only time I get to play the game is when I'm home for summer vacation).

  • This is my 3rd worst Sonic game of all time! Losing to Sonic Labyrinth and Sonic the HEdgehog: Genesis (GBA)

  • well the main theme was good ^^

  • Well I can understand why you hate this game so much but to me this game is good at best and you could've change to the subs because the japenese voice actors are better than the english.

  • The reason why is because of the death of Deem Bristow, the voice of Robotnik.

  • You couldn't explore the game even if you wanted to, its so narrow.

  • if there is one thing i did love about this game is the music...atleast sega rarely fails with their music tracks

  • Dude Sonic shuffle pwned 

  • Nintendo is doing the same with Mario

  • did you hear next gen will be on 3ds?

  • WHAT? ARE U DUMB? the voiceacting is just great. If there is something good perfectly good of this game its the voiceacting. Tell me te reason why u say its horrible, or maybe u just dont understand how that job works. So limitate to talk about the game, would ya?

  • voice acting has been bad since sonic adventure -_-

  • I recomend Sega to get Gordon Freeman back for the voice of Sonic.

  • 4:21 you have no heart you son of a b....

  • okay, maybe the controls wernt perect but the game isnt that bad

  • Sonic FTW. 4:21 Later... 2.25/5 With The Title Of Bad >=( You Suck! (JK It's Just Think You Were Focusing To Much On The Bad Things So You Gave It A Bad Score But Because Of The Beautiful Graphics I Think You Should Give This Game A 3.50/5 With The Title Of Good...

  • lol u forgot sonic 06

  • I only play the main story too unlock party games & playable characters for them so far I have the first 4 then Shadow, Cream & Silver, I trying too get Blaze but the story mode is just crap!

  • can you do a review on punch out ? if not thats fine

  • Pardon me, but this game is crap! I kinda liked the mutiplayer, though I only play it because I heared you can unlock Blaze, Shadow & Silver too play as...

  • I can't believe I never found you, before. A game reviewer who reviews both GameCube AND Wii games? You've just won a new subscriber! lol

    Anyway... I absolutely HATED this game. This and Sonic 06 are probably the only 2 Sonic games I have played that I truly hated. The voices were, indeed, horrible... usually, I like the voice acting in the Sonic games, but... that was just plain awful. Even Dan Green, who is just plain awesome, sounded like crap. If it was me reviewing this, I'd give it a 1.

  • Hooray for invisible walls!

  • i disliked this game but i got it in a combo pack with super monkey ball (banana blitz) for only 30 bucks so it was a good buy i guess

    the biggest problem was the awful controls and the fact that its played on rails

  • really nice review :D

  • Ok so I just got this today as a gift and the controls are TERRIBLE!

  • Uhhhhh Ummm nvm im just gonna say i dont agree with this review

  • I HAVE THAT GAME IT IS OK

  • it wasnt that bad its just that u fail at sonic games :)

  • @TheCakeisawesome

    That's not true, I am a mojor Sonic fan since the very first Sonic the Hedgehog for the Genesis and I have beaten every Sonic game that I have ever played (including this one), but I still thought that the controls were pretty awful. :(

    I do feel that this year's Sonic games (Sonic Colors and Sonic 4 were both really great though). ;)

  • I agree 100% with your review Frequenzy, this game really is bad. :O

    It was the controls, they were just awful. :(

    Good review by the way. :)

  • review sonic heroes because its sonic for the gamecube one game that never gets old

  • Aww, love these reviews! On this one though I have to disagree, for me once you do a bit of customization and get used them they work a treat, especially with the ridiculously fast speeds you obtain later in the game ^^

  • I actually prefer Jason Griffith to Ryan Drummond. Imho, he just sounds more natural, and exhibits a broader range of emotion. From what I've heard of Roger Craig Smith, however, he is a suitable replacement as he still sounds natural, and makes Sonic sound older and more mature

  • wait are you saying that sonic heros had bad voice acting because i love those cutceans team rose vs theam choatos best cutsean

  • u are very lucky to have brothers and sisters,i dont have any. u can enjoy playing video games very much.

  • I hated this game so much. There's one thing I ask from a Sonic game and that is FULL Control over Sonic. The jumps were such a pain, but within the month Sonic Colors came out and I am now at peace.

  • Am I the only person who thought that this game was better than Black Knight? Yes, the controls could've been WAY better, but you can work with them. I thought that Black Knight was so boring, because its gameplay was too shallow, and has way too much waggle. You sometimes jump, but it's mostly just waggle, waggle, waggle, waggle. And although they are highly detailed & gorgeous-looking, the environments lack the imaginative, creative factor that Secret Rings has. And multiplayer might be worse.

  • @nerftendo005 Yes, yes you are.

  • @nerftendo005

    Yes =D.

  • @nerftendo005 According to my research, I think most people thought this game was better than Black Knight

  • @JaysPlace20 The critics do, yes.

  • I think Colours is going to play on rails isn't it?

  • @Snipertoaster It plays like Sonic Unleashed's daytime levels, and he said that they weren't on rails. I think what he means by on rails is your character automatically moving forward.

  • @nerftendo005 Oh OK I get it now

  • YOU SUCK AT REVIEWING. I BOUGHT THIS GAME AND I GOT USED TO THE CONTROLS. THIS REVIEW IS WRONG. I ALSO PLAYED BLACK KNIGHT AND THAT SUCKED. WIIVIEWER'S REVIEW IS BETTER.

  • @IslandBros15 WELL DON'T BE A PRICK ABOUT IT.

  • @IslandBros15 I agree, this is way better than Black Knight, which is poor at best. Secret Rings is passable.

  • so what if Sonic has a heart of gold? Eggman has a heart of pitch black burnt coal, so SEGA makes up for it by giving Sonic a heart of gold.

  • I love this game, and I love the Darkspine part too.

  • i like this game ;( but good review =D

  • It wasnt sega's fault really, 4kids took over the voice acting, and besides jason has left the role of sonic now and pased it over to some other guy

  • i think nintendo can't make that many games for 1 franchise since they have so many

  • I totally agree with this reveiw it was one of the worst games I've ever played

  • Oh come on! It wasn't that bad

  • sa2 theme for sonic............with a steadfast HEART OF GOLD get the point?

  • This game wasn't bad. I got past the horrible controls and I found it better than you said.

  • You forgot the great(ish) soundtrack...

  • 1:00 Look at Sonic's big mouth

  • 0:33 - It should be 5 (or 4 if you hate SHTH). I mean... Come on. M&S and the Riders Game included?

  • my bad. I meant the out wii sonic games. like this!

  • ummmmmm I'm not sure mario and sonic counts as a sonic game its a mario and sonic game! and I liked it like the other out sonic games.

  • What was the lowest rate u give to a game?

  • Sonic Adventure is the best 3d sonic games....All sonic wants is some motha fucking chilli dogs...

  • a tip for preforming the long jump without skidding is to preform a small jump and hold the two button in mid air. Sonic will stop in his tracks and this way you can charge up a long jump.

    Once I got this down it became a very fun game

  • Oh no, 6 games in 4 years. :/

    Anyone having problem with jumping...

    Press 1 to INSTANT stop. Also, you might want to equip better stopping abilities.

    Shes in the ring, but she can still communicate.

    Voice acting... Ugh, because Ryan was so great in Sonic Heroes. :)

    I found the minigames fun. Some games weren't too good. But I found a nice amount of them to be ok.

    I really don't get why people seems to complain about controls. Maybe because Sega makes them bad till you upgrade. ;_;

  • @autosaver no even with upgrades there is a learning curve with the jump mechanics. Though the idea of being able to make sonic slower is good for some missions

  • I paid 5$, felt ripped off, I give it a 2/10.

    NEVER EVER PLAY THIS GAME. I played flash games that made more sense.

  • @Blazeofdoom

    Alright maybe I was a bit harsh, but this game is for die hard sonic fans ONLY.

    if you still wanna buy it, wait for its price to drop 20$, if you know what I mean.

  • The voice acting is so bad its funny!

  • I couldn't agree with this review any more. The visuals and soundtrack are awesome but the gameplay and controls leave you feeling raped.

  • really the "upgrades" are abilities you should already have from the start

  • olympic games cannot count

  • This game was really frustrating but you forgot ocarina of time, wind waker ,phantom hourglass,and the new skyward sword

  • @superspinclaw You need to listen to it again. It was only for games in the past 4 years, from when this was uploaded, and that don't include DS games.

  • @FreQuenczy Sorry I get it now

  • @FreQuenczy What would you originally rate if the game wasn't 20 dollars and the visuals were not good

  • @brawlmaster234 Maybe a 2/5.

  • @FreQuenczy you know nobody seems to mention a very important thing about the voice acting. There is a japanese dub english sub option. you know so the voices don't suck

  • @FreQuenczy I'm sorry, but while I hate to admit it, this is your only bad review. (don't get me wrong, your a great reviewer, way better then the wiiviewr) you gotta accept this was Sonic's first Wii game. Surpringly enough, this game is better then Black Knight to the majority of people. But, I love your reviews. I don't really care since this review was made a year ago. Keep making great reviews, Frequenczy. :) Also, please review Epic Mickey if you can.

  • i hate the jumping in this game. i just gave up because of it

  • Why WOULD Sega test their games. They wanteed to get this game as an early release title so it would be a best seller. And it worked

  • wow, except the graphics, i don't think you included one good part of this game. good review. ugh, i ain't getting this game.

  • 1) Ur including The two Riders (SPINOFFS) and not including Crossbow Training? I mean Crossbow Training IS a 3D Games.

    2) Ur including MARIO AND SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC WINTER GAMES?! AND NOT CROSSBOW?!

    Now when its 4 over 2, ur point is somewhat true. But I think that Secret Rings was the ONLY rushed one; I think Sega wanted a $ advantage for a launch title. I understand why this game was rushed/not tested; they wanted it to be an early release title for $. And their strategy worked.

  • Can you review some fire emblem games?

  • 3:41 lol mario party 1 mini game rip off

  • The wind crest vs erazor is too easy.@FreQuenczy

  • The reason they replaced Ryan Drummond with James Griffin is because the voice actor who previously voiced Dr. Robotnik died, so instead of just replacing him, the entire original cast of Sonic game voice actors were replaced by the voice actors from 4kids who dubbed the Sonic X anime.

  • could you do shadow the hedgehog (gamecube)

  • can you review soul calibur legends?

  • This games needs a 4/5!!!

  • SONIC AND THE SECRET RING IS THE BEST GAME IN THE WORLD WII AND PS2 AND PS3 AND PSP AND X BOX AND X BOX 360

  • I doubt it that this game is worse than Sonic Adventure 2

  • @FreQuenczy I like this game. And I don't think J. Griff is as bad as people say he is. Don't you think that he's getting better?

  • @BigBossMan538 Yes, I think he's getting better, but I don't think this was is best work.

  • @FreQuenczy hay you no that sonic is multi platform and zelda isnt right

  • @FreQuenczy none of us have to worry about him anymore because hes been replaced by roger craig smith.

  • what about links crossbow training frequency

  • You should expect this kind of voice acting from 4kids voice actors :p

  • You know what I found weird? This game was a launch title and you gave it a bad review due to the bad controls and the minigames. The Wiiviewr gave Super Monkey Ball Banana Blitz, which was a launch title, a bad review also because of bad controls and the minigames.

  • @IslandBros15 this came out a week after launch....

  • I like sonic but i perfer Phantasy star Universe. By the way this "Game" is an ungodly abomination. Its probably one of the biggest failures since the Atari 5200!

  • this game was good

  • I hated Sonic Heros.

  • i got this for free with my wii. i never liked this game... its just bad

  • These statistics ARE biased if you don't include Crossbow Training.

    *Black Knight, Secret Rings, Unleashed and Next Gen/2006 are all legitimate. And so is TWP for Zelda.

    *But putting Sonic Riders, Zero Gravity and M&S@OG and not putting Crossbow Training; what the heck? THESE SPIN-OFFs? I mean I understand and beleive your point is correct, but please tell me why you think its fair to put in these 3 spin-offs and not Crossbow.

  • @Subscriber0101 Lol, you're right. I totally forgot about Link's Crossbow Training. Sorry about that. I'll put an annotation in. And for the record, I'm NOT trying to be biased here. Just trying to make a point that I believe Sonic Team rushes out their Sonic games.

  • @FreQuenczy - But your point that Sonic Team has consistently dished out the hedgehog too fast is true. It may have statistical mistakes, but I still understand what ya mean.

  • @FreQuenczy - No annotation. And I REALLY don't think MARIO AND SONIC AT THE OLYMPIC GAMES is a 3D Sonic Game. Zero Gravity/Riders are both racing.

  • @FreQuenczy I don't find it fair that you didn't include DS games as Phantom Hourglass and New Super Mario Bros. where on the DS and if you look at this, look how many mascots Nintendo has compared to Sega. Also what about Mario Kart Wii, Super Paper Mario, Mario Power Tennis, Mario Strikers Charged, Mario Super Sluggers, Dr. Mario Online RX, Mario Party 8, and Shadow the Hedgehog?

  • @GreenXcite Well I did say the statistics were just for the Gamecube, PS2, Wii, Xbox360, PS3, and PC. And Mario was never apart of it, so I'm not sure how he plays apart in it. I wish people wouldn't take it so seriously. The point I was trying to make is that Sonic Team tends to rush Sonic games, which a lot have just been mediocre at best.

  • @GreenXcite Well I did say the statistics were just for the Gamecube, PS2, Wii, Xbox360, PS3, and PC. And Mario was never apart of it, so I'm not sure how he plays apart in it. I wish people wouldn't take it so seriously. The point I was trying to make is that Sonic Team tends to rush Sonic games, which a lot have just been mediocre at best.

  • @FreQuenczy sonic team is just thinking of quantity over quality

  • @neznick13x no, they're thinking keep up with SEGA's demands and finish with a deadline

  • @FreQuenczy you forgot phantom hourglass

  • @goronable Phantom Hourglass is a DS title. I said that they were only for the Gamecube, PS2, Wii, Xbox360, PS3, and PC, at the time that I spoke that.

  • @FreQuenczy yeah but sonic is sega's mario not their link

  • @thesmashingbrawls No. You can't compare Mario and Sonic. When was the last successful Mario game?

  • @IslandBros15 you forgot to quote and unquote the wiiviewr and i was just saying that sega's MAIN and BIGGEST mascot is sonic and he compared him to zelda when mario is nintendo;s MAIN and BIGGEST.

  • 3:18 its beyond me why sega decided to replace jaleel white with ryan drummond

  • I really don't see how voice acting (in any game) should affect the rating of the game. It's just there to better explain the story.

  • @classicrockrockz I didn't demote it because of the voice acting. I was just stating that I thought it was bad.

  • 7 3d games, and what about sonic heroes?

  • @goronable Sonic Heroes was out longer than 4 years at the time that I uploaded this review, so it doesn't count as a variable.

  • 4:00 those are ur siblings? i thought those were like ur friends ur something

  • Have you ever given a game a 1/5 to a 1.5/5?

  • @FianderTV Not yet.