Haley vs. Reagan - One Tree Hill

[kyegirl2001]

Nah, Nathan would never have married that girl.

[DontForgetOTH]

Wow... this video just proves that EVERY casting choice was made right for this show... Really puts perspective on things, doesn't it?

[BaileyRae52]

Omg, Reagan is awful. Thank God they stuck with Haley or OTH would've really sucked.

[x3Barca]

joy rocks =D shes a lot funnier!!!

[aMemoryxxRemains]

no one compares to Joy <3

[JennaKranich]

sam was alright...but hell yes!! JOY WAS BETTER HANDS DOWN!!

[rachelothfan2]

lucas and haley laugh more :) im glad they went with joy i cant picture reagan and nate lol

[bfnfamily]

Thank God the TPTB seen the mistake they were making. I liked Joy's character right away, but this Reagan character is boring and bland and doesn't have chemistry with Lucas or his mother. I also cannot see her and Nathan getting together.

[soccerstarr1128]

I love how well thought out this show is... Joey Dawson scenario, Chad was on Dawsons Creek. and An Unkindness of Ravens, thats Lucas' book!

[beanlovesledzeppelin]

wow where did you get the original pilot? could you post it?

i defo prefer the chemistry with Joy as haley :)

[AlJR95]

Can you imagine Reagan and Nathan dating? hahaha!

I can imagine Reagan saying some thing cute to Nathan but instead it would turn out soo cheesy!

[Pink4Kim]

The scene where Lucas and Nathan and Petyon are in study hall, Reagan is sitting next to him.

[delagrown]

ooooh.... i just finished watching the pilot..... after the game between lucas and nathan i was wondering who this red head girl was hugging on lucas after he won.... i guess they just used reagan's clips there instead of re-shooting .

[kissntellification]

can you imagine Nathan falling in love with THAT!?!?! ugh.

[kissntellification]

I AM SO GLAD THEY WENT WITH HALEY :)



[kimbizzler89]

OMG. All I can say is........thank heavens for Bethany Joy Galeotti!

[TeamPeytonSawyer]

@90210neTreeHill was this actually a video of it with reagan... was she suppost to be the haley or something?

[clarke332]

how did Samantha Shelton even get an audiotion compared to joy she is so rubbish joys amazing acting makes her look even more worst too also the other actors are better with joy too :P

[anna081193]

i dont get it was reagan instead of haley?

[BJGLOVE]

JOY IS SO MUCH BETTER,, let's be honest there was a obvious reason why they casted her instead and come on nagan.. dosen't have the same ring to it!!! :)

[xpeaceLOVEjonas221x]

that reagan chick sucked!! that god they casted joy! i mean could you picture nathan and reagan i mean seriously?!?!

[carolinagirl009]

Wow I'm so glad they went with Joy. Nothing against the girl but Joy is so much better and if they stuck with Reagan I doubt she would have been with Nathan and yes, the show would have been crap and Haley does have better chemistry with Luke.

[sackithard0x]

the show would be crap without haley. i mean all the actors are good and what not, but haley really makes it, shes so funny but shes smart and beautiful ugh lesbian crush right ovaa here.

[clairemig1]

haley is 2000 times better..... im glad they changed it from Samantha Shelton - Reagan to bethany joy lenz haley, haley all the way... i love haley :)

[PrincessMimifly]

I think Bethany in the Cast really better.

The chemistry between Lucas and Haley is perfect.

Samantha as Reagan is not really my think. Sorry

[lilali55]

i think reagan and lucas dont have good chemistry ... but haley and lucas do :)

[MegaShaylee]

I like both but Haley/Joy is better

[badgirlsisace]

OMG no wonder Joy was cast as Haley and thank goodness she was!! :) Joy/Haley = AMAZING AMAZING AMAZINGGG :)

[mileyemily2310]

ew reagan is OLD.

[bkelseyp4ever]

Haley

[lozzy3003]

Haley all the way!! She just lets the words flow naturally.. with Reegan it was like the actresswas struggling toget it out right and make it sound good.. could you imagine Nagan err No!! Naley all the way!

[escapeflyaway]

Yay Bethany :)

She puts so much more expression and meaning into her lines. :)

[HollisterCoSoCal]

HALEY!

you can see the friendship chemistry right away with Lucas & Haley.

Reagen is a terrible name firstly and second of all she didnt seem into the character.

thank goodness for BJG to save the show for 8 seasons(:

[renatastarzforeve21]

@90210neTreeHill sooo true

[23jjaass]

eww can not picture it being nathan and reagan -___-

thankgod for bethany :) love haley, she def makes the show complete<3

much better..well everything!

[renatastarzforeve21]

@23jjaass true i know i was like thank god reagan didnt get the part cuz she would have to kiss nathan which is not good because naley is tha best

[cndylo89]

Def Bethany Joy .. I didnt know they had somebody else to play the character of Haley ..Why did they recast (Not that Im complainging .. Def love Bethany more couldnt imagine the character played by anyone else ) Just wondering what happend since I always thought Bethany was first choice and was the character orginally named Reagen ?? Haley is so much better for her :)

[Kd23oth]

Haley / Joy is a million times better !

[Suckmykissxx]

I have a new appreciation for the awesomeness that is Haley

[littlemissartista]

Wow. I knew Joy had chemistry with the rest of the cast, but seeing her compared to Reagan just solidifies it even more! Joy is absolutely amazing, and I honestly believe the show wouldn't have lasted as long if it weren't for her! Yay Joy!!

[thetvaddict191]

HOLY CRAP! Shanna I just had a mind explosion moment about 1:35 into this video (which is now paused), because I got linked to this video from an OTHforums topic (which I'm on do to an OTH nostalgia session I've been on for hours now), and saw the "sb427" and just realized this was one of your videos haha

[thetvaddict191]

HOLY CRAP! Shanna I just had a mind explosion moment about 1:35 into this video (which is now paused), because I got linked to this video from an OTHforums topic (which I'm on do to an OTH nostalgia session I've been on for hours now), and saw the "sb427" and just realized this was one of your videos haha

[VictoriNoRisuu]

Bethany is so much sweeter! Sorry, but but Samantha seems so bitchy as his friend... And Beth looks doesn't suit freindly girl-next-door/little-sister at all!

That's great they picked Bethany eventually! She was just perefect! Reagen had no chance to be beloved character.

[KUiscaliente]

omg haley is so much better!

[oth330]

OMG Bethany looks SO much butter with Chad! I can't imagine how the show would be without haley !

And the Naley will be the regathan Eurk !

[Vaughany106]

HALEY!!!!! <3

Where did you get the Reagan clips from?? x

[kadialoka17]

should i add haley got an amazing chemistry with the rest of the cast

[kadialoka17]

haley of course way better look

haley = amazing voice beautiful hot funny good fighter good friend and naley all the way they look hot not rathan oe neagan or sceagan

[ashleysoccer6]

That Reagan chick is suuuper boring. Plus Chad Micheal Murray does better with Haley than Reagan

[MyPrivateGetaway]

This reagan girl is so boring, theres no magic in the little things she does, like the way she said hell yeah and the way she jumped away from the birds. Joy brings this magic to the the screen when playing Haley and its so enjoyable to watch and she's great with the comedic stuff. Reagan was bland. And as a major Naley shipper thank the lord for Joy!

[ginnymims]

that reagen name .. it means oregano in bulgarian :O

haley is much much sweeter and better than reagen

and bethany is soo nicer than samantha :O

[Dowsiewuwu]

If she had the same last name, she would have been Reagan James Scott after marriage. Sounds so vulgar. Ugh!

[mary3ll321]

I missed the sense of humor with reagan.  I guess I took haley for granted. NEVER AGAIN!

[csinygirlkiki]

hate reagan

[chloemack]

I just dont understand...so Samantha Shelton was in the cast but had to left...or something like that??? (and thank god..i prefer bethany..!!)

[MayrinhaHP]

Bethany ruleeeees!

[MissSullivan1]

OMG Reagan is terrible!!! This is the first time I have seem this - I don't think I ever would have feel in love with the show if she was in it. No emotion - she is awkward and boring!!

Go Naley!!!

[vicenciojill]

oye , haley... HANDS DOWN is way better !

[Mustangluvin0702]

I have seen this before, but I just watched it again.. Watching Samantha is so boring there is no emotion and its hard to Watch OTH would not be where it is today with her it would have never made it past 4 episodes.. So Glad they got rid of her and brought in Joy.. Could you Imagine her and James.. Yuck!!! And her chemistry with Chad was so off...

[sisterjohnson1555555]

If they had to picked her the show wouldnt lasted that long so happy Joy came around

[m3lan13r]

this video just shows how much haley/bethany are so underestimated !

i'm so glad they decided to go with haley...

imagine REAGAN AND NATHAN.. that would've been HORRIBLE !

[schaafesSchaaf]

omg, that samantha is so unnatural! look at 3:38 ... she was like "i don't know what you're talking about" and...she doesn't seem confused at all like haley does. she's just saying that line without any emotion and without even looking at lucas!

plus, she doesn't fit into the storyline at all! she looks so terribly old and...imo not so pretty. and like you guys already mentioned: she plays her character like the "be-mean-to-luke-person", u know? ^^ bethany is so much more adorable!!! ♥

[nancyrose23]

omg...samantha is horible...she makes the audience feel like she hates lucas and that she is insulting him or smt...Joy makes it look much more friendly and fun...Joy is a way better actrice

[AnnaPannaa]

Really don't like Samantha... She adds of course nothing specific to the character. It is just the same mumble all the time, without any feeling at all!

Bethany is great!

Hugs from Sweden

[kooljam23]

thats inda wired seeing another haley

i like haley better

think Nathan and Reagan

[SkivbarKaviar]

haha, just came to think of something.. It would have been fun to see the slightly emo Reagan with the old Peyton. Now, THEY would get along perfectly wouldn't they? lmao.

[SkivbarKaviar]

Both of them were great, but Joy is slightly better in some scenes. I doubt that Samantha would have romantic chemistry with James (Nathan)!! ;P

[hjbald]

wow i completely agree with everyone else...i never realized just how much Bethany brings to the character.

and is it just me...or does it feel like Reagan is kind of mean to Lucas?

[arbabygirlxo44]

Bethany is great at playing Haley.

[Xxmilkshake202xX]

Samantha was reagan...she never played haley

[LovingKind1]

I liked the blah,blah,blah.. I felt like that haha. Im soo glad they switched to Joy shes much more talented

[livexthexlife192]

OMG thank the LORD that this samantha/reagan chick wasnt hired! omg thank the LORD for Joy and Haley! lmao wow i cant belive that they even consiered the other girl. joy has the perfect chemistry with chad and haley is soo ub beat and cute, reagan seems emo and depressing.

[jns0202]

wow! bethany is so cute and has amazing chemestry with chad, when they have a scene together you can see there friendship. this samanthan chick is just so dead. betheny commited to the character and samantha dint put any effort to it at all. the audience would of hated her instead of Peyton in the baggining.

[AnaBebicFans]

Dude.. Haley's a 1000 times better..

and im not just saying it..

Shes amazing..

Samantha just ruins it.. she's stiff and serious..

Bethany's totally relaxed, fun, awesome :)

[doyouknowx23x]

Samantha Shelton is okay. I love Bethany thought. Plus, I couldnt picture Nathan being with a girl named Regan anyways and Bethany and Chad have that brother sister chemestry anyways. im glad that Mark decided on Bethany for Haley.

[camfan04]

Ew! I'm sooo glad Bethany (or Joy) got the part!! Such a difference! GO HALEY!!!!

[Ghostwriter14]

Lackluster. Not good, not bad, but...Bethany definitely. Great job. Catch ya on the flip side.

[CrazySexyrealCool]

Every time Joy is on screen my face lights up. The other girl is just boring.

[dantapisdance]

Haley's practically the only reason why I kept watching this show... I love Bethany, and this Reagan girl just kills the lines, seriously!!

(By the way: I started watching OTH because of Chad M., continued watching it because of Haley/Bethany and now I watch it 'cos it's the best show EVER!)

[LaurenWozzie2]

Samantha isn't a bad actress she just isn't as exciting as Bethany.

[woop13579]

yh its not the right part, im soo glad sam wasnt in it-she wunt right- bethany and nathan and lucus r pure g

CHAD-SEXY

JAMES-FIT

BETH-BEUTIFUL

and payton is mazi n

[cmrry211]

i dont think i would watch if they kept reagan. one of the main reasons i watch is for nathan and haley, and reagan & nathan would just be really weird. great vid, funny comments :)

[miss000sophie]

yeah, awesome video!!!i absolutely love your comments! hillarious and so true..joy is a much better actress and haley sounds just better than reagan!

[ytbber]

I think Bethany is really better in "Haley".

Regan is "stiff" in this.

[naleynaley23]

I love in the end they cut Regan off to show just Lucas but they didnt do that with Haley. :) Love Joy sooo much better

[Mcfly3]

people shouldnt be so mean to her shes a good actress i like haley too its just they changed the show when they got rid of her

[omgsushi6901]

Naw, samantha can't pull it off. Joy is who brings the spark to the show, she's the reason I kept watching it.

[sandralizzett]

HA! Great video! Love the comments!! Great job.

[winkipop69]

Bethany is like a zillion times better. Thank god she was the one to get the part.

[mandaalove]

dude, one tree hill would have sucked with 'raegan'

she can't even pull off the

[mandaalove]

sarcasm bethany brings to each scene she is in.

[danerae2011]

i cant imagine what the show would be like with samatha instead of bethany joy!! haley is the character that caught me right away. i love haley!! and samatha and nathan..eww..would soo not work!! go bethany joy go!! samatha is soo dull but bethany is so bubbly and ya wayy better bethany!! nalwy always and forever!!

[sillyx11]

ahaha love this video...Reagan (samantha shelton) blah blah blah...Haley<3 (bethany joy galeotti) ho haley go!!! we love haley!! THANK GOODNESSSS joy got casted instead of samantha...eww i can't picture her with nathan unlike joy and james lafferty who have amazing chemistry and joy and chad who have amazing chemistry

[diane16]

Haley is so much better in all of those scenes!!

Glad Reagen never got the part

Haley pulled those scenes off so much better than Reagen did!!

Go Haley!! :)

[freejdc1]

imagine her with nathan

[ytbber]

Bleh. o_O

[freejdc1]

What does that mean?

[ytbber]

"Ew". :-)

I don't imagine Regan&Nathan like couple.

btw Sorry for my English :P

[YagamiLightoo78]

OMG I HATE Reagan

Hayley rules!!

[Degrassi1Lover]

Bethany was way better than Samantha. Bethany all the way.

[1TreeHillRULEZ]

How close was Samantha to be cast instead of Joy? I wouldn't have continued watching if that was the change. Haley's the character that got to me.

And Samantha and Chad don't have chemistry... when you see Joy and Chad it's pretty much explosive. It feels like they're best friends :)

[NuzzyStar]

go Joy go! bethany is way better! love her!

her voice is amazing!

[gdfan38]

Bethany is so much better than Samantha. Haley more interesting and Reagan is soooo boring!!!!

[iLvSawyer]

Gawd I love Joy she's so much cuter!

Could you imagine Reagan with Nathan. Like Ew!

And I love when Haley tells her story "Slipped off the curb, totally bit it, face down, butt in the air"

But when they give him the book Haleys version is like a million times better!!

[sweety1901]

Bethany is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooo mutch better

[doonology]

B Joy is waaaaaaaaaay better than that Samantha girl! thank Godness for casting her insted :)

[naleynaley23]

joy is soo much better

[reneexnicole]

Agreed Joy > Samantha

[addiekins8502]

Joy! Hands down

[SwtAngel961]

Wow, the Samantha chick was horrible. Joy does everything better. I could not imagine the show without Joy and without Haley.  I could never see "Reagan" with Nathan.

[Emelaaij]

Joy is so much better!!! Samantha is very boring and a bad actress.....

[mcancsika14]

Love Joy <3 :)

[tmsvforeva]

I am so glad they went with Joy ... Samantha Shelton and CMM had no chemisty wat so eva!

Can you imagine, there would have been no naley ! :(

Where did you find that footage???

[xxraddyxx]

Joy totally rocks than Samantha Shelton! Sorry gotta to say that! It's the truth! ;)

Joy brings emotions to the show unlike Samantha does. <3

[bjoyfan]

Joy>>>>Samantha Shelton. Any day of the week.

Her presence adds so much to the scenes.