American Idol Audition "Boy or Girl"

[Scotty9182]

is that a joke saying your a boy?



[mathclubgirl]

I feel so proud of myself, I was able to figure out it was a boy even without the audio. But that might be because a lot of my guy friends cross dress... mainly because my girl friends force them to....

[PrizePirate]

I think Zach would of done great if he was allowed in because everyone else is shit.

[Draco92Vendera]

AHHA! Simon is awesome.

[XxXsitarheroXxX]

hey . he tried . all of you can go suck a dick . 

[Linda7647]

@XxXsitarheroXxX  Hear, hear.

[Evanescenceloverr22]

heels :|

[Bartholomule01]

Zach said he didn't fir the vocal range of the song he chose to sing. It's a very bad move to choose a song to sing that you know you are unable to hit the range on. Because of you know it's not the best choice for you the judges sure as Hell will notice it too. 

[holl01]

You... are... gay, heheheheheh

[XxBrokenNeonxX]

o.o

[CaptainYourself]

wearing heels but?

[mirikiki128]

HAHA LOOK AT SIMON EYES HE LIKE- WTF YOU THINK YOU DID GOOD!!!!????

[beatlesXXXluver101]

no nono nno noooooo :( confusedddd

[HP123girl]

what the?

[jonnytsunamification]

how did none of you realize that faggot's mom is fucking SLAMMIN'

[gargoyle1701]

i feel bad for him.

[AWantedTaco]

What the hell is that??

[DontGetMudy]

shemale : i think i did awsome

simon : o.O

[HardyForever7]

ProofS that this was a girl: Girl clothes, boobs, girl voice, girl face, and trust me when I say: I know a girl when I see one! I can smell their flesh and blood from all over the world!

[britbopp216]

@HardyForever7 thts kinda creepy dont ya think?

[HardyForever7]

@britbopp216 about the boy and girl thing or that I can smell the flesh and blood of people from around the world? xD

[britbopp216]

@HardyForever7 the fact tht you can smell the flesh and blood.lol

[HardyForever7]

@britbopp216 its true! I can see people's hot bloody parts in their body too. If you watched the movie Predator, you will know what I mean. xD

[soniaaguilar112391]

- 0-o  o

[ZamboHD]

I think I did awesome ^.^

[Thosheenthinee]

he wears girls clothes..

[TTJBrothers]

That was a boy?

[LoveMetalAndScreamo]

I though he was a chick. Oops!

[BubbleGum81712]

@LoveMetalAndScreamo Same ;l

[windy123133]

i thought it was awesome OK NOW PLZ LISTEN TO THIS WHEN PEOPLE PERFORM YOU SHOULDNT MAKE FUN OF THEM BECAUSE IF IT WAS A GUYS HE LOOKED LIKE A GIRL IF IT WAS A GIRL SHE LOOKED LIKE A BOY BECAUSE BELEIVE ME IF PEOPLE MAKE FUN OF YOU OF THE WAY U LOOK THEN YOU WONT LIKE IT SO DONT MAKE FUN OF HIM I THOUGHT IT WAS AWESOME AND SO SHOULD YOU PEOPLE GO THROUGH ALOT OF PROBLEMS

[blahblah32117]

@windy123133 - Thanks, hippy!

[windy123133]

@blahblah32117 ok and wat the heck is hippy

[kagom34lif3]

his face was like wtf is u saying XD epicness u can never get enough of it

[TheMandarklaughs]

that guy would make a great whore in prison:))

[fuckingjudge]

1:38 WTF?!?!?!?!!??!!?!?!!?!?

[zharaberserker]

Also, have you ever heard Paula "sing"? Were this show her only ticket to stardom, she'd be an unknown forever.

[zharaberserker]

It's just proof that Mr.Cowell is a symptom a society that has bought into the notion that contempt is the same thing as sincerity. He's a straight shooter, he does not tell it like it is. Zack's voice is obviously NOT "atrocious". Cowell is a whore, a parasite. He's exploiting our collective delusion. He's playing for a crowd. That's his only power and it's not really his own.

[mcdanne222]

i like the Simon's Troll Face !

[jamf1video]

@ 1:41 that's my reaction when let said she was a boy....

[jamf1video]

did this person have a sex change or something??

[JustinBlottin]

Whitney is probably turning in her grave right now.

[jakobsgirl1]

Did he say racist?

[TimmyTheSheeep]

I like his singing. Could need a little bit more practice but has the attitude and everything c:

[XOSiren18XO]

Ok, he's pretty good at singing.. Seriously.

[TorrieMorgan]

hes not actually that bad

[alexandratf990]

HE TALKS LIKE FLAPJACK

[Dan00bindahouse]

He she it.

[arealisticpessimist]

You know he does gay porn now.

[bombstad94]

Ok, is Zachary a gay guy or a lesbian girl? Because if he really wanted to look like a boy, he should have worn boy clothes, not high heels. XD

[Aang1]

Well, to be honest, his range wasn't exactly made for the song he was singing. If he had transposed it down he might have done better, since his lower notes really were pretty good.

[TheZoestergirl]

he's pretty

[raposochloe]

transgendered

[babydwarfleprechauns]

@PitchBlueProductions wtf is your problem?

[LiveLoveOrDieTrying]

you are all rude as fuck!

[LittleDrummerGirlxxx]

If he doesn't want to be mistaken for a girl then he should stop dressing like one.

[LiveLoveOrDieTrying]

@LittleDrummerGirlxxx hes obviously gay and or transgenderd.

[PitchBlueProductions]

Um...Wow. I've Just Lost All Hope For Humanity. If You'll Excuse Me I'm Going To Go Hang Myself From My Doorknob With My Belt Now...

[eamber729]

@PitchBlueProductions lol

[ArcliteTANK]

Fuckin gay shit...

[momothemonkey100]

@ArcliteTANK oh, I'm sorry. is that a problem?

[Blagard12]

Ok, look, if ppl think you look like a girl.

1. Cut your hair

2.don't wear skinny jeans and tight shirts

3.don't sing something where you declare you're the "Queen of the night"

4.maybe stuff your pants?

[ironhell6]

You're surprised Paula said you suck? Well now we're all curious.....do you???

[rockinsquirrel111]

1:40 is the best look anyone gave anyone ever.

[Themintypattie]

omg...



[xeniosm]

"...they said i look like i girl..."

"oooohhh whyy??" ahahaha

[meamjustme]

Look up the kit kat dolls. They made the best audition ever XD

[ModItachi]

@ceb182 Gay jokes aren't funny, Cum on guys.

[ceb182]

@ModItachi Why do so many gays have mustaches?

To hide the stretch marks.

[tronmonitor]

@ModItachi yes they are!

[ohhStorm]

@ModItachi yeah they are :)

[MrsAckles09]

"I think I was awesome." SIMON'S FACE OMG HAHAHAHAHA

[salimball45]

should we cry or laugh for this? hmm...maybe just Shut Up would be better

[Roarlover34]

he would get raped so bad in jail

[byrnz35]

disgusting...was this a joke?

[phantomLOVESamy]

um...ew?

[MissMismagius]

Simon gotta stop being so synical. He is always being such a dick against people that are "different", like Derek. I think he's good otherwise, hard but fair. However just wanna punch him when he's acting so immature like he is here. Example 1:29

[MileHighCrusin303]

@MissMismagius are you kidding me if you are awful someone needs to tell you. The world isn't supposed to be bunnies and butterflies. Simon tells it how it is.

[gerlindezierschtight]

@MileHighCrusin303 "yeah and this is why music history proves that people that do not fit the societal measures of what real men and women should look, be and act like - regardless of if they actually wanna be defined in such measures - never had a chance to make it in the industry." -> and this is what i call denial/stupidity in means to defend one's own sexist BEES and FLOWER views.

[MissMismagius]

@MileHighCrusin303 Wasn't what I meant, I get frustrated because he makes fun of how he looks. Sure, he should be treated the same way as everyone else in the way of their performance, not their physical appearance and differences. And in there lies my problem.

[dostoyevesky12]

not bad singing 

[LizTheSinger]

As soon as I saw the video title, it reminded me of that annoying moment when you start a new pokémon game -__-

[koolzainski]

blame that boy's tramp loose mom, enabling that poor boy's delusions (that he supposedly has any talent) and stunting his manhood (encouraging his faggotry)

...

[cprfilmz]

my penis is confused o.0

[Cherub4874]

Ok, HE sounds like what HE is, a young guy w/ a nice singing voice. He needs help and whoever molested him needs to be convicted and imprisoned.

[oldiebutgoodie7]

he dresses like a girl and tries to look like a girl but dont like to be made fun of. please grow up people....

[gerlindezierschtight]

@oldiebutgoodie7 you dress like what and act like what and are pleasured with everyone making fun of you? you're a disgusting asshole - meant to be funny, hope you can laugh or at least "like it".

[NatalyaScarlett]

who fuckin cares! they were so mean because of how he was born

[cocoabunzrok110]

he is sorta good

[pwhite4652]

WoWzEr ........FREEEEEEAKY WEEEEEKY!!!!! If they had competitions for STRANGEST people, this girl, errrr, guy would win......... ;o)

[0000becca]

He's actually not that bad....

[BreeBreeIsAZombiexD]

damnn, hes pretty. :o

[TheSuperyogfan]

2:35 How does that make America racist???

[prettyfly4atransguy]

He is a good singer, and he's fabulous. What's up with the hating?

[sweetsgirl11213]

HE HANGS AROUND TO MUCH DAMN GIRLS IS WHY THE HELL HE'S LIKE THAT

[sweetsgirl11213]

he actually wasnt that bad. Honestly

[swordycatfish]

he needs to go on the VOICE!

[wntwgirl2u]

excuse me for thinking you were a girl because you wear your hair like a girl and wear girl clothes :l

[jgood1089]

maybe if you didnt dress like a girl people wouldnt think you were a girl. creep

[thisismyelement05]

that thing had the nerve to call us racist

[SuperCannonpenis]

trololololololol

[uccharihime]

lol Simon - "Sorry mate - I'm just not comfortable enough with my sexuality to deal with this today. Come back after I figure out whether I've got balls too."

[MakariousFarag2]

If he goes to jail ... lol

[KeystaffMaster]

At 2:14 you can see his father.

[msnhyves]

@KeystaffMaster Most genius comment ever! 

[KeystaffMaster]

@msnhyves I try my best as we all do. xP

[YukiKarasuAkuma]

The poor guy. I don' care what you others say, he's just trying so hard to live up to his dream. He wants to be like everyone else and practically ALL of you have turned him away. Well I have news for you, he might not be perfect but neither are you. He might not look the best in your eyes or sound the best, he thinks he's good and that should be all that matters.Put yourself in his shoes, people. He just likes what he does and he does what he likes. GET OVER IT.

[JaylCRieb]

@YukiKarasuAkuma Well if he thinks his singing is good and doesn't matter what other people think why would he go on American Idol where you are judged? Doesn't that make it kind of oxy-moronish? Be like me saying I will never sing infront of someone then book a live performance. Makes you sound retarded my man.

[gerlindezierschtight]

@JaylCRieb and never get a job and live as a loner in the woods, right?

[MrShakedown12]

what de fuck man

[BlazezThaPurp]

Simons face is priceless!!! lol

[TRAVL3R1]

THATS A GIRL. NO EFFIN WAY> SHE TRIED TO MAKE A BIG SCENE THAT"S ALL

[betshilton]

his voice is full of shit

[dobadriver]

I'd turn him down because of his looks lol. I can't look at him without wanting to burst out laughing and shoot him at the same time. Some people are just fucked.

[lalaland13ish]

the thing is, they didn't turn him down because he looks like a girl.. they turned him down because his singing was bad... that kid needs to get a clue & stop blaming "prejudice"

[Digijedi569]

i didnt have a dad growing up, i just watched Andy Griffith lol true story

[rel140]

zomg is that the baby of justin bieber and lady gaga (lol) jokes

[phoenixbluex]

this is what happens when you listen to justin bieber

[mega1Axelle]

look at simon @ 1:40 lol

[Vallenglam12]

he's awesome.

[debsIRL]

i think he's a good singer

[TheDonAK57]

maybe get a haircut, build some muscle, get out and ride fourwheelers

[popups46okay]

This person is called a Transvestitte. Not a Transgender, because a transgender is man who had male-female sexual reassignment surgery. He could be identified as a gay guy but not every gay guys like to wear clothes of women. So he's more of a Transvestitte. To me he's only 25% feminine, the voice is so manly, the body shape, etc. So I think Randy's just being respectful for asking "Are you a Boy or a Girl?".

[2fastg35]

because gay people are just simply gay

[dipstick3031]

I was like.. Boy or Girl?? What a BS. I can CLEARLY see she's a girl. LOL But he must want to look like one since he chooses the girl haircut, shoes, jeans, shirt.. 

[thecolaratlady]

lol and this FOOL claims racism, prejudice lol..that is def 1 fucked up, confused dude

[thecolaratlady]

@thecolaratlady dont go on these shows if you cant handle criticism, rejection

[EvilKris]

I think his mum's been slipping oestrogen into this kids coffee.

[lagpjc24]

oh lord..

[shakenbake1295]

this is what happens when you dont have a dad when you grow up

[Kimindigo]

( DYSLEXIC )..world leaders have turned this planet into a freakin zombie planet..why do this show called idol? ,more right to call it braindead zombie freak show.

[OriginalBloodPromise]

wow. had me confused....

[DunhillX1]

Slightly bizarre but then again each to their own.

[Datleco]

Wow, pretty good, too bad it's not going his way.

[BubblieDinosaur]

I've seen this guy, (: At walmart. Haha, he looks pretty cool. and he CAN too sing!

[VictumRoManius]

She sang actually quit well. Maybe she should have tried another song more suited for her female voice?

[kakairuislove]

@VictumRoManius calling him a she? are you really really really nice and accepting or are you just trolling lol 

[VictumRoManius]

@kakairuislove Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuh, Im accepting.

[kakairuislove]

@VictumRoManius -total air high five- lol to bad not everyone (including me) has your outlook even i laughed and ive scene some pretty cool trannys

[Freyaloulou]

maybe the first time she(or he) gets in the audition room, Simon got a negative impression about his appearance.

[Moleson3MC]

He talks, dresses, acts, sings like a transvestite, yet he says 'oh know im a total guy'.. something traumatic must of happened to him while he was young.

[thecolaratlady]

@Moleson3MC look at his mom lol

[OrganizationXigbar13]

Finally, a manlady!

[Pelka39]

one word: cross dresser

[JodieisPeche]

He wasn't too bad

[blackhole137]

He's prettier than most girls I see

[hadesflames5]

@blackhole137 You must live in a place where girls look like trolls, because even the ugliest girls in Miami look hotter than that "guy"

[conanhayle]

exterminate. exterminate .exterminate

[Rawrxitsxmegan]

.... he says he doesn't get why people mistake him for a boy.. yet he wears girl clothes and hair...?

[Aphex1son]

i would fuck him

[Dioltas117]

They did say no because he was a crossdresser. I hated this episode so much. My name is Zachary, I got so much flack for this at school that week. Honestly, I thought that for a guy, he did pretty damn well on a Whitney Houston song. Whoever said this kid can't sing, well...perhaps you need a hearing aid.

[GloriaGloryGirl]

transgender maybe? He look like a pretty girl

[Latresa87]

lol cant sing but hes pretty!!!! i thought it was a girl

[thecolaratlady]

This is what happens when the family tree doesnt fork, it goes straight up

[animalsrule1082]

if he's a guy, why does he dress like a woman 

[wannaknowit]

@animalsrule1082

Well, it is easy to figure out I guess...he must not be happy as a guy....there is a hungarian bloke in the hungarian megastar, watch him, he has had a gender change, now he is a 'she'...look for this: "Hegedűs Fatima a válogatáson - tv2.hu/megasztar"...3 years ago HE auditioned for megastar as a GUY, but now as a FEMALE. so ugly:)And has awful, atrocious voice! Greetings from Hungary mate:)

[bobekoktsmells]

i bet they said no just beacus of his look!

[dakielster]

So Justin Bieber isn't the only one....

[GloriaGloryGirl]

@dakielster LOLOL

[Athils]

Three adults giggling like that. That's really pathetic.

[imagineerboi]

It rubs the lotion on its skin or else it gets the hose again...

[worldpeace3000]

I thought he was pretty good, and somewhat right about what he said.

[DestructionOfAges]

It wasn't -that- bad.. it was decent ish.. I mean c'mon. We've seen some really bad shit... I mean.. -really- bad.. This one was decent compared to those.

[felixramsey]

Jesus.