Added: 3 years ago
From: JohnMcQuilkin
Views: 60,168
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (361)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • you have a faint north dakota accent. i love david archuleta. he is sooo cool!

  • what happens here is that american idol is not a show many teens watch and so most people relate to cook cuz hes older but he should have not been the winner ARCHIE IS THE WINNER TO ME!!!!!

  • DAVID ARCHULETA! he shouls have won!

  • Oh so sorry mr.!You are wrong....David Cook won because he is extremely talented,versatile,amazing and great...David C. rocks....

  • Making a prediction at the Top 24? Not a good idea, was it? Unless it was all for the webhits and subscriptions, in which case it worked out just fine.

    I wonder, did the rest of the season ever change your mind on that prediction?

    Did you do it again for Season8, with the William Shatner style delivery too?

    Funny.

  • the 2 davids are equally good.

  • The love of my life.... david archuleta but david cook won but we still luv david archuleta ... i think he should have won in the first place buts ok (not really) cause he still became famous and the best singer in the universe

  • OVIOUSLY DAVID

  • no way david archuleta...hes sweet,talented,and amazing!definately him!!

  • The 2 Davids were great. Its not that David Archuleta was horrible its just that David Cook is a little better

  • david! david! david! is da winner

  • uh... you were wrong, lol

  • david cook has soooo much more talent then archuleta. i mean i like archie too but david cook sooo much better. check out david cooks' heroes compared to archies' barriers...there is absolutlly NO competition between them. (this is just an example of their songs ik their are a lot more & cooks are all better ) gooo archie & cook! this is just my opinion saying that cook is soo much better! byeeeeeeee

  • DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!!!!! he should have won =[, he has the most talent.

  • david cook will win

    =)

  • david cook won not david archuleta

  • david archuleta is sexy i love him i wish he won

  • fuck, david cook should win (he already won)

  • go PAUL! booo HEATHER!

  • I so agree :)

    David Archuleta should have won!

  • yeah,dc deserves to win..no doubt...

  • DAVID ARCHULETA WAS SAPPOSED TO WIN!!!!!!!!!!

    grrrrrrrrrrrrr i hate david cook!

  • You hate David Cook? Wow?

  • Why? is he THE GOD OF ALL GODS!???

    why should we ALL like him anywya?? he's TOO ARROGANT!

  • He doesn't seem like a mean guy. He's not that arrogant. He's smart. And he has a good voice. Also many David Archuleta fans like David Cook. They just don't think he should have won. And good spelling on the word anyway.

  • that was a TYPO.....

    Oh my God....do you have to say that?! it's a KEYBOARD. Sorry, I'm no master of all KEYBOARDS.

  • DAVID COOK PWNS!

  • Wow...You were close :o

  • this season was like the season with clay and ruben. they were both good singers but clay could only do sensetive or slow songs, whle ruben had a bigger variety. also ruben delivered much better to the audience just like cook. archuleta is still gonna go big though.

  • I agree, just like what he is now.....

  • Cook is deserving of the AI title. Turning that ugly R&B Always Be My Baby of Mariah's into a sexy Rock Ballad in ONE week should that alone win him a GRAMMY award. It is being played all over the world. Turning a boring HELLO song into a sexy Rock ballad should earn him another GRAMMY & I don't care if he covered Incubus. Turning SO HAPPY TOGETHER to current Rock should earn him a GRAMMY. His rendition of BILLE JEAN which is better than Chris Cornell's should win him a GRAMMY.

  • CC should thank Cookie for singing his song, it's a killer song! Cookie deserved to win ! all whiners, just keep whining heheheheh!

  • The wrong guy won.

  • pffttttt!

  • You mean David Cook DIDN'T WIN?

  • no david cook won he it was prediction

  • Cook hugged Archie and Cook whispered the following words to Archie, "I love you." Archie told the news this. Cook loves his lil brother, Archie!

  • what interview was that in?

    because i wanna watch it..

  • Lol it looks like he was wrong~!@#

  • Lol he was wrong!! that wasnt nice for him to say that there was midioker talent and i do LOVE david cook and im REALLY glad he won but david archuleta was good too

  • NOPE COOK HAHAHAHAHAAAA

  • david cook wins!! woo hoo!!! i knew he would beat david a.!! david a. just didnt have what it takes!! and i mean he is really young!!!!

  • you were wrong.>:|

  • your close! good job!!! i would know but david cook won

  • im not even going to rate this video

  • but it was david cookl dumb ass

  • But david cook is a better MUSICAL talent

    Archuletta sings whiny ballads that piss me off when i listen to them because 13 year old girls voted for him 8 times each

    Cook is a talented singer who proved that you can win american idol without being a annoying pop singer

  • That is not a very nice thing to say. While I was disappointed Archie did not win, Cook won fairly and that is fine. It is personal taste. Lets not be mean spirited here. Archie has a very nice voice and will do fine for those that like his musical style. Congrats to both. Hope fame does not corrupt them

  • david archuleta = watching paint dry/ watching the grass grow

  • David Cook will have the most successful career and you can quote me on that. Being a musician for 40 years gives you an awareness that those who aren't musicians will never have.

  • Did Archuleta the rectal-ranging-doughnut -puncher ....gargle with jizz before the final???? I guarantee - give it circa 4-5 years and he'll be offering inxpensive favours to 'macho macho men' down alleyways in Utah....

  • im rating this 1 star.

  • cook won by 12 percent

  • no jackass...he won by 12 million....

  • 12 percent, there were 100 million votes

  • your an idiot there were 96 million votes you stupid cockshiner...

  • he didnt win!!! cook won!

  • This is an OUTRAGE!!! The people may have voted for DAVID COOK but DAVID ARCHULETA will go on to be the true AMERICAN IDOL... and you may quote me on that!

    John McQuilkin - Hollywood Happens

    The Unofficial Spokesperson of Hollywood

  • Listen, David Cook took risks, always did his best, was versatile, and he was liked more in the older age groups. Get over it, David Cook was liked more by America.

  • Who voted? The American People....Who are you? Tsk tsk.

  • david archuleta is the best singer ever and for me the new american idol !!!!!

  • same here

    david a. american idol to me!!

  • Oh Yeah, I so not think Heather should have gotten so much of Pauls money. She was only with him 4 years. Goes to show she was into his money, otherwise the "Charity fake" would have walked away with a mil or 2...She didn't work for that money!!! She used Paul, she's a typical gold digger, so disguises there!!! Lindsay looked terrible as Marilyn, very bad choice, only few can glam as well as Marilyn...Thanks for your youtube dude!

  • Archie should have won, he has raw talent...Cook is a dime a dozen...

  • Congrats for picking one of the top 2 way back at top 24. He only missed winning by 12 MILLION votes.

  • Ok it may be that David Cook won by less than 10 percent of the vote, but considering that it totaled 12 million votes I'd say it wasn't exactly a close race.

  • cook won by 12 percent

  • lol 12 million votes is hardly a success?

    Damn, THESE grapes are sour...

  • hey fagot david cook wins

  • oh faggot? are you kidding me?

    fuckin david archuleta is the biggest homo on idol since clay aiken!

    archuleta can now join sanjaya and aiken in the all time flamers on idol!

  • FAIL

  • no my frined, that is the smell of SUCCESS

  • EPIC FAIL!!

  • cook please

  • i love david a..........HE SHOULD OF WONNNNNNNNNN

  • oh my are you wrong, 12 million votes baby!

    the right david won

    VICTORY!

  • Right on my friend, Right on.

  • david cook

  • vote for david cook or ill kill uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

  • you have been right all along, and i have thought david archuleta would be the winner ever since his audition i knew he'd be at the finale, and now today we find out who's gonna win. i think we are both gonna be right. david archuleta for the win.

  • both dc and da are AWESOME, but personally, i think Da always make his audiences feel so charmed by his cuteness and he is really GOOD at ballads and souls! But hey, DC is good too!

  • i love david a. he's going to win..yehey..

  • David A! I love david archuleta he STOLE IT FROM COOK!

  • David A is the big winner - David C comes second- very arrogant though.... just the opposite of David A.

  • I've said it before... I'll say it again, David Archuleta will Win "American Idol".  Please remember to Vote, Vote, Vote!

    John McQuilkin - Hollywood Happens

    The Unofficial Spokesperson of Hollywood

  • David Archuleta should win the title for the Next American idol for 2008. This is DA's dream let us make it happen!!!

  • ARCHULETA ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!! he is like amazing.. so ya

    VOTE 4 DAVID ARCHULETA TONIGHT!!!!!

  • all i know DAVID is going to win lol

  • get a life you 50 year old virgin

  • please tell me if you are gonig to vote for david archuleta

  • The more AI pushes a particular person the more the opposite will happen. Go DA. Vote for DA for 4 hours and get 4 others to do the same.

  • Cook gonna win!!he can sing anything

  • Simon Cowell was on Jay Leno tonight (May 19) and said that he wants David Cooke to win. That he "deserves it more" because he had to work in a bar for a living. He did not base his opinion on talent but on which guy had to work. He said the "Other guy is only 17" implying that is also why he should not win, David A is still in school. He hasn't had a chance to work full time. What a stupid thing for Simon to say. I read the producers are trying to make sure David C wins. It is rigged!

  • Wohooooooooooooo!!!! David Archuleta the American idol.

  • David Archuleta!!!!!!!!!!!

  • DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!

  • cook is gonna win!!

  • Nice Guess! I luv u david! you are awesome and i luv u! i can't even explain it. i just luv u. i am speechless when i see u. and if you read this comment, just know that i am not like any other girl. when i say i luv u, i mean it. i never felt this way before about anybody. i just luv u.

  • Cook

  • great job with guessing great job i want david to win! lol i want david A

  • david cook sux like shit

  • I think David A will win, for he has a giant fan base of teens that like him cause he is "cute", which automatically makes them think he's a good singer. Go Cook!

  • david a!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YAY

  • I am impressed that you called it for David Archuleta back when there were 24 and now he is in the finals.

  • Thank you EarthDude2005:)

    John McQuilkin - Hollywood Happens

    The Unofficial Spokesperson of Hollywood

  • david cook is the next americam idol

  • David Cook

  • Archuleta will win based on raw talent, he can sing anything. I think Cook depends too much on his guitar and arrangments. He has yet to prove himself as an actual singer, he changes every song so he can sing it but it never turns out right. Archuleta is the better talent, he should win.

  • um actualy david cook can sing ballads as well as rock songs.also he arranges the songs so he doesnt turn out to be a copy and he makes it work for his voice.

    while every single time david a. ALWAYS sings ballads and hes to lazy, uncreative, lame to make the song his own .its just to annoying.

  • As the season has progressed David A has sung other genres. Everytime he strays away from a ballad, the judges criticize him. There are a thousand rockers out there but David A is unique. I respectfully disagree with you. He has made changes in several songs - for one examle, he totally made "Think of Me" his own. He changed up Love Me Tender and others. His voice is incredbily pure and clear. He has an awesome talent! I read that the producers are making sure David Cooke wins due to D.A's dad

  • DAVID COOK. end of story.

  • David Cook.

    He deserves it.

  • DAVID ARCHULETA WILL WIN.

    cute boyfried of mine. I love him so much (L)

  • i think david cook, and i dont think i know, hes amaizing his voice goes over the top he will win and i knwo this 100 percent

  • Babii Archie All The Way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • DAVID ARCHULETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • I agree. =]

  • David Cook SHOULD win.

  • David will win, no doubt in my mind! I have all of Archie's Songs on my iPod, studio version and performance!

    VOTE 4 ARCHIE!

    Definition of an American Idol:

    David Archuleta

  • i want to vote buh im not in america. i want to vote for david. sowi to all people hu doesnt want david to win. his voice is like heaven. plz win and he'll be the 2nd guy to win american idol

  • I KNOW David Cook will win, though I feel horrible saying it. I want Jason to win, but he'll be #3.

    And for ALL IDOL, ALL THE TIME, subscribe to americanidolinsider. You won't regret it!

  • From the first song David sang, my wife and I agreed that he would probably win AI this year.

  • VOTE FOR DAVID A!!!!!!!!!

  • david a

    no contest!

    he is amazing and ALL girls love him.

    i no i do.

  • i'm all for david archuleta. looking at him as a person, i think he reflects that of a perfect role model for the younger, lost generation. i really don't care if he wins or not. at this point in the competition; he's got more popularity than he deserves. david cook is strong; originality wise, and would surely make loads of albums. i just think that david a fits the bill of an IDOL; not just someone talented, but worth admiring for his humility and personality. :)

  • David Archuleta will win. I think there's a three-way tie for runner-ups between David Cook, Carly, and Jason Castro. Honestly, based on pure talent, Jason Castro is not in their league but he's unique and charming and gooooooood lookin' too. I think David Archuleta and Carly are the true singers. David is cool and I love his style and he's good but vocally not the other two's level in terms of voice control.

  • David A is gonna win, but I dont like him.

    David Cook is much more talented!

  • !!!!!!!!!! David A rocks big time! NO WAY is david cook more talented!

  • U STINK! okay? david archuleta is soo gunna win!

  • Stelldude, That is purely your perception of how you see him. It is YOU that has a self esteem problem my friend.Maybe you were ugly growing up , maybe you're still ugly, physically I mean, you are certainly ugly in your heart. God don't like ugly, I will pray for you , the WORD OF GOD SAYS "THE LORD WEIGHS THE HEART" , Remember this: "some things are true whether you believe them or not". My advice to you is STOP LUSTING AFTER HIS MOUTH ON YOUR PRIVATE PARTS CUZ IT AIN'T GONNA HAPPEN.

  • It's going to be close, but David A. should and probably will win, David C. second, and Jason Castro third. People have to make sure they vote (for David A.)! Don't assume he is safe because he's popular. David C. is really popular too. VOTE David Archuleta!

  • what kind of question is thiss???

    duh david archuleta!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I feel Archuletta is going to win. HE is not as good as David COOOK> My future husband.

    But David. A. will probably win.

    David Cook is a fabulous singer.

    I think he could take it too? But most likely David A. will take it.

  • If he changes his religion he will probably win but if he doesn't women will want to marry him, good for him that he can marry 8 or more!!! Moreover the mormon church is a prety rare and lost religion....best wishes David !!!! Diana from Honduras

  • The most marketable person is by far David Cook. Just look at the Itunes sales.

    However, David A. is probably going to win... He's going to turn out to be another Taylor Hicks... Lots of votes, but a dud when it comes to selling actual albums... He might do better than Taylor Hicks due to his youth.... on album sales, but not that much better.

  • David Arculeta ALL THE WAY!

  • DAVID COOK all the way hands down he is going to win

  • I think David Cook should win, Archuletta is okay too....he's just too young

  • I think the winner will be David Archuleta. What an amazing voice.

  • David is DEFINITELY the winner.. as in Archuleta.. not cook! :)

  • I sincerely hope that David Archuleta wins. He is amazing. I think it will come down to David Archuleta and David Cook. I think David Archuleta will go far in the music world whether he wins or not. He is so talented and his voice is so clear and so pure.

  • Yeah thats what Simon said on Larry King Live. David is obviously going to win though. He has more teenage fans then Cook. I've been right since season 5.

    :)

  • david COOK all the way last time i was bummed when blake lewis didnt win but oh well i hope david COOK wins

  • david archuleta is defineetely gunna win!!!!

  • David Cook. He is pretty much amazing :)

  • I called Jordin last year, and I call David Archuleta this year. Man, I love him!

  • Hey yes, u are right... I greatly feel David Archuleta will win this year's american idol... predicted Jordin Sparks' win last year and she did win...

  • David Archuleta

  • david COOK.

  • DAVID ARCHULETA

  • i agree...

    i love david archuleta so much..

    very talented..

    and cute..!!

  • i agree...

    i love david archuleta so much..

    very talented..

    and cute..!!

  • david archuleta is just all hyped up.. and that's why a.idol sucks. he's talented, yes. but not the best there is in idol.

  • David Archuleta all the way!!! he's so cute

  • omgg yeaaaa david archuleta is going to win! yup i loveeee him

  • JASON CASTRO!!!!!!

  • You've got the wrong David. Cook is the next a.i. without a doubt. Archuleta is very talented but lacks the experience and charisma.

  • I hear that... David Cook has everything it takes...

  • Its a fucking popularity contest. & David has way more fans (kids & teenagers combined) then David Cook.

    Do you not hear the applause they give him? Even before he performs. Its the loudest.

  • GO DAVID COOK!!!!

  • COOK

  • Yep that's right! David Archuleta will win AI!!!

  • DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK! DAVID COOK ALL THE WAY!

    david archuleta seems so humble..and faking his nice attitude, and hiding his big ego. no offense, i still love him a lot :D dont hate me, fans! sorry!

  • yep david cook is so amazing i luv him and he has such an amazing voice

  • I think that you have it wrong about David Archuleta. I think he is a very sincere person. He definitely is not egotistic. I think people can express their opinion about who they think will win without badmouthing other contestants. It serves no purpose. I hope they will all achieve their dreams. They all have their special talents.

  • um what the hell. firstly david archuleta is gonna win. he has ten billion times more fans then david cook. even simon said "hes the one to beat" & simon is always right.

    david archuleta doesn't have a fake attitude. teenagers can be nice too he was just raised right & we dont see that very often. he most def doesn't have an ego either.

    btw you can't be a fan of someone when your bashing them on youtube.

  • JASON CASTRO

  • David Cook

  • A. not C.

  • david archuleta is gonna win.

    no doubt.

  • yeah of course. i wonder if hes going to cry when he wins.

  • I think it will be either of the Davids, but I prefer David Cook. Michael Johns was the best, I think, but he was eliminated. :(

  • D A V I D A R C H U L E T A <333333

  • DAVID ARCHULETA WILL WIN!!!!

  • DAVID ARCHULETA. Totally.

  • D A V I D  C O O K

  • david archuleta

  • DAVID ARCHULETA