Heard this yesterday in a bass and voice only version .. very delicate, very suspenseful, somewhat mystical. You people who play the bass - get a girl to sing this with you!
Thanks for intelligent discourse, not enough of that here. I have nothing more to add to your words, except to say i am so glad that Pat has had 36 years of recording now to try different things and get that fantastic tone- on modern jazz with Charlie Haden, and on his Pat Methany Group escapades(check out his 2004-5 stuff, as good as it gets), and solo, and so much more. And Jaco was a burning candle, sad in comparison.
Sometimes Jaco could be too busy - the bass should leave regular gaps in the bassline, to let the other instruments carry the song for a moment - he's kinda dominating the song here, though as usual in a virtuoso way - never thought I'd ever say "less bass" -
@SupernalOne I completely agree with you. Phenomonal virtuoso bassist, but he didn't play enough rest notes IMHO. Its the space before the sounded note that makes the note sound so sweet!
Joni, Jaco and Pat! Two jazz greats get into this song which is sort of rock, but really beyond genre (its a Joni song, she is her own genre).. What bass tones! My version of history: The electric bass was invented in the 1950's, then it had to wait so that Jaco could play it. I play both electric and acoustic bass, and whenever an acoustic bass purist asks me why I bother with electric (fretless) I sent them to this recording. Magic.
@marinman39 hello??? and Lyle Mays!!!! God I miss hearing his playing and I was so dirty on myself when I lost "Street Dreams" (on cassette) - a yummo album made with Metheny and a fistful of mighty, megafine musicians recorded at none other than Power Station in NY.
@marinman39 hello??? and Lyle Mays!!!! God I miss hearing his playing and I was so dirty on myself when I lost "Street Dreams" (on cassette) - a yummo album made with Metheny and a fistful of mighty, megafine musicians recorded at none other than Power Station in NY.
@marinman39 cheers to you! i say 'bah' to 'purism' of that sort. as an electric jazz oriented guitarist i would have NEVER played guitar if you couldn't get the BIG sound like pat, or jeff beck. that dry straight jazz guitar sound drives me nuts! unpleasant when using the 'listeners' ears. mostly only technical musicians listen for ideas above sound. there is a reason pat metheny has sold millions of albums - he SOUNDS good. staying true to some nonsense form of purism didn't get him there!
@jamesedwardtheobald Thanks. Purism is some kind of intellectual thing. Music is felt, and if it sounds/feels good you've succeeded. These musicians succeed, Jeff Beck wow, another great. Run into the purity thing with some roots types I play with sometimes, bluegrass purists, country swing purists, which is really funny because bluegrass was an invented music designed exactly to move traditional country music into the jazz age, ditto for country swing. Sounds good or it doesn't.
@marinman39 in this song jaco plays the fretted bass - but in other songs he plays his bass of doom too (i have the DVD here) ...who said he plays too much notes? ...remembers me in the "amadeus" movie - someone said this in the movie about mozart too ;)
@bassployer Wow, didn't know that. He somehow makes it between the notes, just like a fretless. Did he also play the fretted bass on some of the songs on Hejira by Joni? That last tune, Refuge of the Roads, has got to be fretless, totally inspiring tune and bass part in any case. After that album, every pro studio guy in the world tried to get that sound for years.
@marinman39 i haven't the hejira here (still not, but will order it tomorrow, thanks for the tip!) but listened to Refuge of the Roads on youtube - its definitely fretless, the singing-fretless-jaco-sound. these pro studio guys won't succeed - they'r not jaco - what did he say in an interview: its all in the hands :) btw i'm playing "In France.."(the jaco-line) on my fretless and it sounds great (never as great as jaco) - keep playing fretless - we don't need the cage-bar-fretts! ;)
CANADIAN FIESTA! OLÈ !!
Dreamofthereturn 2 weeks ago
Jaco, STRAORDINARIA la tua performance!!!!
Piero2374 2 months ago
Now that.
Is how you play bass.
PageTheFisherman 3 months ago
thanks for posting this
paulmeard 4 months ago in playlist paulmeard's favourites
This is the best version of a remarkable song. Pat Metheny's solo just lifts it up to a new plateau.
rosskolnikov 6 months ago
@rosskolnikov
Not to mention Jaco's astounding bass line.
Musicenthusiasm 2 months ago
This is the type of jam that cannot be easily be identified as this certain genre or that certain genre. That makes for the best music in my opinion.
AleekahTV 6 months ago
ジョニ・ミッチェル、傑作ライヴ"SHADOES&LIGHT"から、"フランスの恋人達"~終始弾きまくったジャコの代表作でも!~メセニーもイイね! #jazzm
blackandtanful 7 months ago
Joni and the bands she formed - what a force. Great music.
AlmostEthical 7 months ago
Timeless.
Bravo6Whiskey 7 months ago 2
@ 2:59 - unmistakably Metheny.....
Getsemwet 8 months ago 3
Amazing. What a combination of players and treatment.
SawleyExile 8 months ago 2
Heard this yesterday in a bass and voice only version .. very delicate, very suspenseful, somewhat mystical. You people who play the bass - get a girl to sing this with you!
gidolf 8 months ago
She has the most interesting voice.
darkfire79 9 months ago
Thanks for intelligent discourse, not enough of that here. I have nothing more to add to your words, except to say i am so glad that Pat has had 36 years of recording now to try different things and get that fantastic tone- on modern jazz with Charlie Haden, and on his Pat Methany Group escapades(check out his 2004-5 stuff, as good as it gets), and solo, and so much more. And Jaco was a burning candle, sad in comparison.
marinman39 10 months ago
sensational.
Everyvideo123 10 months ago
SHIT YEAH!
jamesedwardtheobald 10 months ago
what an epicly amazing combination of musicians
mattbrandwich 10 months ago
saw her at the Greek with my boyfriend/s brother.....bf didnt wanna go,,,,,,,I wasnt even 20 yet
shelleybobelly1 11 months ago
joni is bolada
Benteliciuos 1 year ago
Sick bassline...though I think while some people feel it is over-dominating the track is that it is quite loud in the mix
BassMusicUK 1 year ago
One of the greatest bass parts of all time
catalystdrums123 1 year ago 12
Oh my god the bass line is beyond sickness.
SaxMan7776518 1 year ago 2
Sometimes Jaco could be too busy - the bass should leave regular gaps in the bassline, to let the other instruments carry the song for a moment - he's kinda dominating the song here, though as usual in a virtuoso way - never thought I'd ever say "less bass" -
SupernalOne 1 year ago
@SupernalOne I completely agree with you. Phenomonal virtuoso bassist, but he didn't play enough rest notes IMHO. Its the space before the sounded note that makes the note sound so sweet!
POBox1999 1 year ago
A great song to start with, and Jaco rolling along underneath it all...what more could you want??
AriaSuperBass 1 year ago
Joni, Jaco and Pat! Two jazz greats get into this song which is sort of rock, but really beyond genre (its a Joni song, she is her own genre).. What bass tones! My version of history: The electric bass was invented in the 1950's, then it had to wait so that Jaco could play it. I play both electric and acoustic bass, and whenever an acoustic bass purist asks me why I bother with electric (fretless) I sent them to this recording. Magic.
marinman39 1 year ago 13
@marinman39 hello??? and Lyle Mays!!!! God I miss hearing his playing and I was so dirty on myself when I lost "Street Dreams" (on cassette) - a yummo album made with Metheny and a fistful of mighty, megafine musicians recorded at none other than Power Station in NY.
croon4u 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@marinman39 hello??? and Lyle Mays!!!! God I miss hearing his playing and I was so dirty on myself when I lost "Street Dreams" (on cassette) - a yummo album made with Metheny and a fistful of mighty, megafine musicians recorded at none other than Power Station in NY.
croon4u 10 months ago
@marinman39 cheers to you! i say 'bah' to 'purism' of that sort. as an electric jazz oriented guitarist i would have NEVER played guitar if you couldn't get the BIG sound like pat, or jeff beck. that dry straight jazz guitar sound drives me nuts! unpleasant when using the 'listeners' ears. mostly only technical musicians listen for ideas above sound. there is a reason pat metheny has sold millions of albums - he SOUNDS good. staying true to some nonsense form of purism didn't get him there!
jamesedwardtheobald 10 months ago 3
@jamesedwardtheobald Thanks. Purism is some kind of intellectual thing. Music is felt, and if it sounds/feels good you've succeeded. These musicians succeed, Jeff Beck wow, another great. Run into the purity thing with some roots types I play with sometimes, bluegrass purists, country swing purists, which is really funny because bluegrass was an invented music designed exactly to move traditional country music into the jazz age, ditto for country swing. Sounds good or it doesn't.
marinman39 6 months ago
@marinman39 straordinaria la performance di Pastorius!!!
Piero2374 7 months ago
@marinman39 in this song jaco plays the fretted bass - but in other songs he plays his bass of doom too (i have the DVD here) ...who said he plays too much notes? ...remembers me in the "amadeus" movie - someone said this in the movie about mozart too ;)
bassployer 6 months ago
@bassployer Wow, didn't know that. He somehow makes it between the notes, just like a fretless. Did he also play the fretted bass on some of the songs on Hejira by Joni? That last tune, Refuge of the Roads, has got to be fretless, totally inspiring tune and bass part in any case. After that album, every pro studio guy in the world tried to get that sound for years.
marinman39 6 months ago
@marinman39 i haven't the hejira here (still not, but will order it tomorrow, thanks for the tip!) but listened to Refuge of the Roads on youtube - its definitely fretless, the singing-fretless-jaco-sound. these pro studio guys won't succeed - they'r not jaco - what did he say in an interview: its all in the hands :) btw i'm playing "In France.."(the jaco-line) on my fretless and it sounds great (never as great as jaco) - keep playing fretless - we don't need the cage-bar-fretts! ;)
bassployer 6 months ago
Glorious tune...the "dream team" band, for sure
ongakubcn 1 year ago
Best record ever.
herbergunther 1 year ago
@herbergunther - not even close
pbl1 1 year ago
@pbl1 got a better one of this tune? please post it
ericoschmitt 1 year ago