Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (700)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • does her mirophone look like a wart at first to you?

  • Nbbb

  • How can people say this is horrible? Are you deaf or what gosh you just don't understand what music means then I guess. This is just awesome. A broadway-like song. Mandy Moore's version is great, but well, they're in a whole different area. A broadway-like and a pop one? Get real, guys.

  • They are both good singers. Many just does a better job at Rapunzel's role because she sounds more innocent. BUT, this girl does an awesome job at singing as well.

  • They are just 2 different ways of singing - Mandy Moore & Zachary Levi sang it in a more "pop" way whereas this one is just more of a "musical" type way of singing. Let's just appreciate the talent all these people have! Kudos to them :) Beautiful !

  • THEY SUCKS!!

    this is an insult for tangled fans!

    no offence meant.......

    :)

  • The way she sings this kinda bothers me, her voice isn't bad but it sorta seems rushed a bit.

  • I actually almost prefer this version. But she sounds more mature and perhaps less innocent.

  • I like Mandy Moore and Zachary Levi's better. It's always disappointing when other people sing a Disney song. But...did they really get to have floating lanterns!?

  • @SaltwaterAir1 Uhhh- I think this was a Disney performer on one of their cruise ships?

  • rubbish!!

    absolutely rubbish!

  • Definitely not as good. Sorry She should sing opera not Disney.

  • It's good singing, just REALLY CRAPPY RECORDING

  • OMG her dress is gorgeous!! I'm so jealous... I would love to wear a dress like that...

  • She can sing, something is missing. I think it is the emotion, she didn't have enough emotion, Thumbs up if you agree

  • @kendrap204 mandy's was more innocene and flyns part was really rushed. They should of really took their time to sing

  • @kendrap204 She put so much emotion in her voice == What are you on about? Mandy Moore and this chick is both amazing at singing, everyone should stop complaining/hating.

  • @linhiexD Did i say,she could not sing. You are just putting words in someone elses mouth, i clearly did not say she could not sing. she can sing, very well, i just prefer mandys performance. Next time actually read someones comment properly, without making stupid assumptions

  • Comment removed

  • I can understand why people don't like the girls performance. It to heavy for the character. Punzel is a very light nieve character and using a full belt and lowering the tone, which she does on her parts, makes it lose that young just discovered love feeling that makes this song so very very amazing.

  • omg!!~~ she has a wonderful voice!! :D of course Mandy Moore sounds younger and fits Rapunzel better, but still - pretty awesome!!

  • Her voice is beautiful!! So is the guy's voice. (:

  • This is awesome!

  • <3 Golden Mickeys! Still remember that show from my cruise trip seven years ago!!

  • She's amazing. Beautiful voice.

  • Who is singing? The actors, I mean. And is it just me, or does it feel like they rushed Flynn's part?

  • This girl is singing live and i think she sounds young and lovely! Jodi Benson sang Ariel the Mermaid, Lea Salonga sang Mulan and many other brilliant Broadway stars have sung characters younger than their ages and made those characters and themselves legends.

    Mandy Moore may sound young but she definitely can't pull off a broadway show, last time i checked she got swallowed up at Oscar by the background music, would you pay to see the singers struggle on stage? Stop complaining!

  • Mandy Moore's version sounds so much more innocent..

  • wow! i do really love this song!

  • This is so much better than Mandy's version.

  • Barbie

  • She sounds just like Sierra Boggess (sp). Is this her?

  • Nothing against the quality; both singers had excellent voices.

    But this was a lot hammier than the gently romantic tone of the original song...it felt almost forced, as opposed to the natural, intuitive feel of the movie version.

  • @ingonyama70 Remember that the music in the video also went through processing and was most likely changed quite a bit. This is unaltered singing at it's best.

  • @ingonyama70 That is very true, they are great singers, but they do sounded very forced, and it just take away that warm feeling from the song.

  • 0:53 lol

    

  • TOO FAST. TOO OLD SOUNDING. still, she CAN sing....just not this part of Rapunzel...

  • I think she sang beautifully. She's also singing on stage. That's different from singing in a recording studio. I give this video a thumbs up for her talent!

  • Her voice is pretty, but too "mature" for this role.. this is supposed to be an 18 year old girl. She sounds too young. I think the original is flawless!!

  • @redwillow88 I meant she doesn't sound young enough. lol

  • Mandy moore sang it better!!!!!!!!!!:(

  • I THOUGHT THE MIC WAS A MOLE AT FIRST

  • She sings it way better than the original mandy moore.

  • she has a great voice!

  • This actually was a good song, but people who dislike this have no heart

  • I think she did pretty good:) Idk why everybody Is hatin .

  • I can understand why its liked and disliked. She's using a stage voice, which has to be much much louder sometimes, and seems like she's shouting, when she is merely projecting because she isn't mic'd. Her voice is also much more mature than Mandy Moore's. But she does sing very well. Great open sound and a big voice.

  • She's a good singer! I do not understand the dislikes at all.

  • i really dont like it!! hey girl go home and eat rice! mandy moore is better! and her partner

  • i dont like it... she and the guys voice sounds forced and holding the notes to long lol

  • I love her voice. : )

  • I think the reason there are so many dislikes - apart from you lot not realising it's a different style of singing - it's also the fact that Rapunzel doesn't sound as sweet an innocent as she did in the movie. Her voice is too powerful for her character.

  • I like it! She's not mandy Moore so of course she won't sound exactly the same, duh

  • How can people say that she can't sing? Just because they heard Mandy Moore and now are so rigid in their belief it can't be done any other way? They're both doing well, but I'm surprised nobody had an issue with Flynn, seeing as we're apparently hating on people for no reason now.

  • These are a classically trained theater singers doing a pop-star song. Of course it won't sound the same, derpderp.

  • i dont like how she sing's it :/

  • this isn't rapunzel because rapunzal's voice is mandy moore

  • Comment removed

  • I don't think they have bad voices. I just don't think that they had any chemistry. The song sounded like they were just singing. It didn't sound like they really cared about the song other than the notes. Doesn't feel like they loved singing it. Which makes their rendition bad, IMHO

  • how can ppl say she sucks wow it just most ppl r not used to dramatic broadway singing i love it they r both amazing

  • I am disappoint.

  • fjvgfxsvgfrtyfr5gyu8yutgyuhfbv­gvfvcccccccccccccccccccccccccc­cccccccccccccccccccccc6ty7ftfs­trhj

  • If anyone cared to notice, this is pretty much completely different from the original. You can't expect it to sound the exact same, silly children. :)

  • Ooh! This is very Broadway :D love it. Guys, stop complaining that she's not Mandy Moore! Obviously, she's not, and she doesn't sound 18, but who cares? She sounds terrific! :)

  • i cant hear her singing happy you know with the happy voice like mandy moore boo you !!!!

  • Boo!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ................ not impressed 

  • wow she sounds almost exacly like mandy moore really good really good

  • I don't get why everyone's making such mean comments about her singing!! I actually think she's pretty good!!!!

    But it is true that Mandy is better (:

  • she has a big mole hahahaha :)

  • @sr7280 Are you serious? That's her microphone.

  • she's not bad at all. no she sounds nothing like Mandy Moore. But who can sound like Mandy Moore but MANDY MOORE?

  • her voice sucks not because she doesnt sounds like mandy moore, but because she DOES sucks. she cant sing. admit it.

  • Mandy Moore is better

  • facepalm hic hic

    

  • Disney would not cast them if they were bad ppl! good grief! it's not going to be perfectly like the movie so i think people need to take a chill pill please.

  • I don't see how they are supposedly singing bad AT ALL. There are FAR WORSE singers out there pretending to be amazingly good singers (*cough* rebecca black *cough*)

  • All of you saying she sucks because she doesn't sound like Mandy Moore or doesn't fit your

    "idea" of what rapunzel should sound like are fucking stupid.

  • @222toogoodforu actually i think it's because she's singing it too fast and she's slightly flat. just saying.

  • the interesting part for me is that she kinda sounds like the person that voiced rapunzel's mother in the movie :D

  • The outfit and hair are so pretty! And the singing is good!

  • JUST STOP.

  • Yodeling and off beat. No ones perfect. And not as good as movie version.

  • GOD!! i love this song

    

  • they did a pretty good job

  • @LadySpellcaster I agree that they sing very good, but I have to disagree with you when you say that This version is infinite times better than the movie. They sing too fast...The movie version is better than this, and I know 474 people think like me.

  • @minhquan9x i agree and mandy moore has a much younger sounding voice and with rapunzel being like 18 in the movie, not 40, this voice just isnt the same

  • They should have did a playback of the song from the movie and lip singed in my opinion. They sound horrible they sound like they are straining to sing!!

  • well...she LOOKS the part...kinda

  • They did an awesome job!

  • I have heard plenty of things live and I am sorry, but this is just sad. >.>

  • who the fuck is this bitch?

  • i HATE that scary eye AD thing at the right! kind of distracts me.. ugh! Dx

  • at the beginning I dont like the her voice...its like screaming...

    at the end is ok...

  • i don't like it. It's too operatic. On Her Part anyhow. This Song is suppose to sound sweet and light. Though This chick can sing! Just leave it to Mandy Thou. :]

  • Thumbs up if you hate the advertisments at the begginingg!

  • I think she did an alright job. If we didn't have Mandy Moore's interpretation, more people would like hers. But then again, remember Mandy got many tries at it and had a lot of help with the technology. : 3 I applaud her. the only thing I wish they kept the tempo the same. I think it's a little fast.

  • they did a pretty good job but the reason why most of you have an issue with is it because they are over-singing some parts that don't sound good when they do that

  • she's really pretty but she sounds too old :S

  • Actually, no. I completely DISAGREE with maggiebj1989, it can be very difficult to sing live with Stage fright. So, if you have had sooo much experience you would know that. Also, MusicEqualsLife1293: Everyone has there opinions, and i agree slightly....A simple peaceful song, just turned into an Opera. :P beautiful though!

  • As much as I love Mandy Moore, this girl was really wonderful too! :-)

  • Wow. What is with all the hate? I feel like I listened to something completely different than everyone else. The audio quality is crappy but the performers far from. I don't hear any flatness. She CAN sing, and she interpreted the song differently to suit her voice better. A lot of the negatives sound like the type of complaining that if it isn't like the original, it sucks.

  • @sockstealingnome She is pretty flat

  • Um. Yeah. This was not a very good live performance. It's like she was trying to add too much to a simple and beautiful song. And her "powerful" parts sounded like she was just screaming.. Plus, she can't sing.

    The guy was alright.

  • she looks like rapunzel... too bad she doesn't sing like her

  • You guys DO know this is a live performance not a cartoon, right? They only get ONE chance in this UNO ICHI ONE! So what if they don't sound exactly like the cartoon? That is a good thing. A character can be taken many ways. Look at the difference between the Broadway and Cartoon Ursula. They two completely different characters. Some things work better on the stage, and some things work better on the screen. Either way, this performance was great.

  • Y'all can say what you want, but I got goosebumps. :/

  • her voice would be better for arielle

  • Shes WAY worse than Mandy Moore!! I love Mandy's voice, but this woman is too flat or something.

  • Um... Am I the only one who hears this woman singing very very flat?

    I didn't like her singing... And being on a stage and acting and all that is not an excuse- I've been singing for many years, and i've done musical theater... I know that a singer who can't sing live- is not a good singer. Period.

  • When she sings, she speeds it up a bit from what the original is. It kinda sounds like she has an english accent as well.

  • i love Flynn in this <3

  • Does anyone know who sings Rapuzel? She kinda sounds like Sierra Boggess :)

  • @Elizannchan Here or in the actual movie?

  • @MichaelaLeAnn Lol here. I'm talking about this video. I know it's not Mandy Moore

  • @Elizannchan Lol, oh okay. I was kinda confused at first. Lol!

  • She's beautiful but she's a bit too "Broadway" in her singing style to match Mandy Moore's version. Not that she sings bad, because she's very good. But not the more quieter, pop singing style of Mandy Moore.

  • She'd make a good Belle. But, she sounds too mature for the bright-eyed and adorable Rapunzel. And just my opinion, Flynn would be a much sexier as a cartoon character if he had a lower voice. LOL.

  • I like her voice! Just not for this song. I'd love to hear her as Belle, though. :)

  • ok, whatever people say, after hearing this, if you compare her to kristin chenoweth (my idol, so i'm biased), she's not as stable... :/

  • she looks like rapunzel, but obviously mandy moore sounds more like one :DD

  • Her voice doesn't sound like a princess... It sounds more like a middle aged woman who's having a mid-life crisis. The Prince sounds great though!

  • the picture at 0:57 looks like she's screaming

  • I saw this when I was on the ship this summer! It was so good!

  • way too fast but they have good voices

  • She looks like a Rapunzel barbie XD

  • i'm not gonna talk about the singing, but she is so beautiful, like a real life Rapunzel!

  • I'm not very keen on the female vocals, sounds too Broadway and not Disney. The male voice though, I do enjoy.

  • I like her voice, though honestly she sounds alot more like Belle though.

  • Mandy Moore was much better

  • WHAT!!! the boy is ugly....

  • Great proformance, but her voice is too deep

  • I love this version! I think it's lovely.

  • they should've got the real rapunzel to sing :D

    

  • @officialkeenkeen The real rapunzel?

  • @Danizwatching Yeah, Mandy Moore

  • She sounds very good! But I gotta agree this piece is not for her.

  • she sings fantastic!! but i thin kthis is not a song for her....

  • They have really great voices, but they're voices are trained for musical theatre, while the original song is much more pop. Of course it's going to sound a little weird, they're entirely different types of songs! Considering the circumstances I think they did awesome! Plus, it's really not easy to sing live, speaking from experience.

  • chill out people...they are trained broadway singers in a live show...it's not gonna sound like mandy f'in moore....that doesn't mean they are bad. a lot of the shows disney do live on the ships and park have very well trained broadway type singers....not the pop stars they use for their movies

  • being a choir kid I know how singing live can be. they did a pretty damn good job :/ you know how hard it is to sing and move and under all those hot freaken lights?! geebus! YOU try doing THAT and in COSTUME and MAKEUP!

  • @xoluvan1meox oh trust me i understand your pain Q.Q i'm a theater major and I live by that rule :<

  • @MewIchigolove ugh i know right? it takes a lot of courage and guts to get up there!

  • @xoluvan1meox *nods*Agreed.. :)

  • @xoluvan1meox I did and I sounded way better than this chick...

  • @xoluvan1meox THATS NO ESCUSE!!!!!

  • @Coovex you can´t make it better.

  • @xoluvan1meox I KNOW THATS RIGHT speak it please they just dont know....it really is not that easy

  • @xoluvan1meox Since when does wearing makeup make it harder to sing?

  • @wickedphant0m It makes it really hot with the amount you put on and it's really (Un-comf-terbal)

  • @ISuperGenXI I've done over a dozen plays and musicals...it's really not that bad. Unless you're doing something with prosthetics like Phantom of the Opera or Beauty and the Beast, you don't even notice it.

  • @wickedphant0m never... At least as long as I've been acting

  • No, the problem is, is that Moore and Levi have very pop voices! These two have extremely well trained music theater/ classical voices! Their voices are beautiful! But they didn't sing it properly for this song! It doesn't mean they don't have good voices though!

  • -3 not happenin

  • What's wrong with it? It's live...it's pretty good, if you ask me....

  • She's good but not for rapunzel....Rapunzel is like a teenager and she isn't suposed to have a adult voice..

  • she shouldn't be shouting, she should be singing, and if she had proper professional training she would know this.

    he's great, he just needs to keep a steady tune.

    that is all.

  • Yeah good voice but not Rapunzel

  • dont u dare compare ariel to this chick. :P jk

  • she sounds like ariel :P

  • She is singing opera?

  • Her voice is not for a musical live like this , it's just my opinion , I think the piece was good with Lea Salonga the one who voiced Jasmine :D

    Just my Opinion :D

  • I thought it was really good, the only bad (not exactly bad) thing is that the tempo was faster and how they portrayed the song was different (idk how to describe it, maybe more happy like than it should have or there wasn't a lot of character)

  • Okay anyone who thinks THAT girl is fat has some serious body issues... What is with bashing the singers? Hope you know that your wonderful voice actress in the movie....probly was 50% tech team. Those people in the recording are fucking LIVE, listen to a recording of your own voice and you will understand! 50 years old lol really?

  • I saw this show live while on the Disney Dream (beautiful boat by the way) and I fell in love. Being actually there is much better than this recording, you're part of the magic!!! I loved it and the other singers were amazing as well. When they were in the gondola it was just magical and the actual princess was beautiful. The male actor wasn't too shabby either. But like I said beautiful show, beautiful song, and beautiful actors. <3

  • i like her voice.. but for this piece it sounds too shaky.

  • These singers are better trained than the ones in the movie, and have fuller voices; I find Mandy Moore's voice airy and lacking. The only aspect(s) that's noticeably "off" is that the tempo is a bit fast, and maybe Rapunzel is scooping her notes a bit too much. I don't understand the fuss in calling them BAD, though--the singing in the movie is mediocre and badly supported in comparison.

  • why are the real life disney costume prinesses REALLY FAT???

    NO OFFENCE.....