God Knows - Aya Hirano

[aikamoyo]

かっこいい！すげぇ！

[mono430]

いいけどアレンジ感がつよすぎますよね？

まったく原曲聴いたことないひとが聴くとすごい違和感あるって思­います。

[bvcx8765432]

her sound is wavy ~~~~

[AafreakA]

god knows shes good in bed

[cutie235100]

Cool :) but rock version ftw

[kojiro1812]

このアレンジは素晴らしい！！！！

[Oldstockshop]

sound better than rock version...

good job

[starth123]

Nice

[FlowrellikTS]

She has a beautiful Voice.

She reminds me of a friend of mine.

Rock on!

[08sirai80]

いいんだよ？いいんだけど......

やっぱバンドじゃないと迫力に掛ける(^^;)

でも可愛いから許す！

[MissMoonlight095]

This is epic. :D

[laharl2k]

she has a beautifull voice yet she's such a attention whore outside her job xD

[livelinez]

great

[takuzo1105]

これはこれで結構好きかも♪( ´θ｀)ノ

[nihongoguitar]

@takuzo1105 うん!

[otakuxeditor]

gosh i hate this song...oops..dont get mad at me...i hate it bcoz i love it...its soooooooooooo damn good

[GHIECUTE287]

oh,,, i didn't know that there was an orchestric(if there ever was this word) version. It's great all the sm. but I'd prefer the rock version, the one used in the Haruhi Suzumiya series.

[6neko2neko8]

綾ちゃん歌うまっ!!

しかも可愛いとか…ほんと最高や＼(^o^)／

[6neko2neko8]

綾ちゃん歌うまっ!!!

しかも可愛いし…最高や＼(^o^)／

[NookeRzii]

アレですね

いし歌うまいしうまいし最高です！

ですね

でも可



[BreinStijn]

This would sound so much better with a good drum kit : l

[dozou35]

耳を気にしてるのがちょっとアレですね

でも可愛いし歌うまいし最高です！

[JIYOism166]

maybe she sang better here cause it feels calmer than having to rush with all the drumming xD

[Popausi1989]

in my opinion its her best live version <3 its really good 

[nekomar1]

高城みたい

[12345YouareBEAUTIFUL]

i think we all need to realize that most japenese girls/anime girls/anime lovers/freaks try to make their voices all high pitched and it pisses me off. theirs a difference in being a high pitched good singer and sounding like alvin and the chimpmunks on a sugar rush.

[12345YouareBEAUTIFUL]

shes a good singer

[xXxCakeIsKawaiixXx]

whoa.

[Aleelpran]

I LOVED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!*-*♥

[as1andude2]

At some point of the video I expected some wings to pop out :L

Still great though :D

[ONeilTD]

Better than rock version. Still not good.

[o0Dome0o]

@ONeilTD you know that ayo hirano was haruhi's speaker?

[ONeilTD]

@o0Dome0o

Yeah, still she can't sing.

[o0Dome0o]

@ONeilTD and why listening to that if you dont like the versions?

[ONeilTD]

@o0Dome0o

Cause she's freaking hot <3

[PurpleNinjaOMG]

God knows Aya Hirano, because she's an angel. :'D

[Xtoffer87]

*Goosebumps*

[nekomar1]

クラシックもいいね

[Jocke337]

99 999th viewer

[benzzzsa]

ไอ๊ย๊ะ

[KanadeIsRaven]

WOW!!!

[MrKonekochan]

*Increible!! super Aya-san!!

[ric123abc]

genial me encanta hirano aya genial

[whyareyouyelling]

shes soooo amazing and pretty!

[MaTtY123HaRdie]

y did this giv me shivers down my back...?

[magicstix0r]

ギターでなきゃだめなんだ！＞＿＜

[MrKosinus12]

@magicstix0r ああ...アニメでは、すべてがはるかに優れています。

[punnix]

อายะตันนนนนนนนนน

[NookeRzii]

คนไทย ยึดทุกคลิปครับ ช่วงนี้ 555

[KamiNoKazoku]

lol this song must be matched with a guitar , otherwise it doesnt sound like god knows anymore

[asgsos]

สุโค่ยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยยย­ยยยยย

[Sleepingsong01]

very embellishment

[BobS1771]

WOW loved it before this, but WOW!!!!!!

[TaDuc098]

amazing



[SHINININI]

Sugoi!!

[ManowzZness]

ชอบมากเลยเลยค่ะ

[46090216]

ライブだと下手になる

[hayabusakichi]

この動画のおかげで、「例の動画」が音ハズしまくりの理由が

自分の声が聞こえなかっただけというのが確定しました

モニターできずに音程を合わせて歌うのはプロでも難しい

[LightningRainbow]

she is singing much better here <3

sorry to be rude but she sang horrible in her rock version LIVE

but i'm still a big aya fan!!! aya-chan ganbatte~

[Kiseirusama]

I like rock style better but this wasn't bad too ....

[kumeyaki]

テンポがゆるくなってるのが残念

[ClbSioux]

Oh god, this is great!! :D

[teron610]

なにこれ、かっこよすぎやないかい＞＜

[MsMiikaz]

Wowww !! Excellent .

[tokihisa38]

すごいな・・・・

[kaminotakuto]

うまいな＾＾

[GANTZ0314]

ブス

[TheGblaze707]

luuuhhhvv!!!!!

[1234okya]

いいねｗ

[cockerspanielowner]

AYA WE LUV U from otakus like Konata

[Bobownzall1]

this...is absolutely amazing!

I actually feel like this may very well be better than the original...

Good job Aya!

[MusicTaylorSwift1]

I wonder why this live is better than the the rock live?o.O

[PlagueXRoamer]

@MusicTaylorSwift1 Personally I credit it to the epic orchestra back-up, as well as partly due to the more controlled singing.

[aripck]

@MusicTaylorSwift1

She just realized how much she sucks in her rock live ver. so she decided to train this song every day for one year to improve her skills and pay for her sins.

[furzle1552]

a classical "god knows"?

[imouto11]

It's a pleasant surprise to see Aya-chan singing with a very controlled voice this time around.

[EchoSEAL101]

This reminds of some kind of epic scene from final fantasy or some other awesome RPG! XD The Goddess Hirano sure does have a beutiful voice! XD

[oakTree1234]

nice :D

[japang77]

歌と楽器演奏が合ってないよね

[dynelol]

I prefer Yui Horie's singing.

[AnimeXFreawk671]

This is actaully frickin` awesome x]

[ReneRobertoCh]

Aya "canta bien", en realidad tiene un registro muy bueno, pero no es cantante, donde se la puede apreciar es en el Riot Tour (live), ahi si canta y no exagera ni hace mucho vibrato.

En el animelo summer live 2009 rebridge cantan discoteque junto con nana mizuki es muy buena la version, y despues cantan jutnas monstar... ambas tiene registros diferentes. son geniales las dos.

[BeethovenLife]

No fue esta la que trato de copiar a pikachu? No me gusta como canta :/

[xyaayaayax]

props for still getting the right tone even when the background is not exactly follow-able.

still.....it doesnt sound good.....unfortunately......

[AnimeMasterxGamer]

orchestra! ;D

[DivineIkari]

ahh symphonic version, not bad at all. quite a refreshing change.

[Liezzzjehvj]

I know the life of a singer is hard; but i really want to sparkle just as she does.

[UnusualyDifferent]

@Liezzzjehvj so do I

[paragonD6]

honestly, this sounds terrible

[Kagome4247]

amm no se escucha tan bien tiene buena voz pero la exagera mucho en mi opinion Nana Misuki canta mejor pero mi preferida es Ayumi Amasaki en especial cuando canta la de dearest.

[KuroiAmane]

Honestamente,prefiero a Mizuki Nana... pero es Aya que exagera un poco a la hora de cantar, asi y todo canta genial :3!

[starsora1]

this needs to be added to kh

[Dragoon30100]

@starsora1 kh, as in Kingdom Hearts?

[Nikoru1999]

Amazing!

[beau2556]

so cute >///<

[crusifizer]

น่ารักสาสสสสสสสสสสสส+!!!!!!!!!­

[llltonysk8lllhotm]

tiene una gran fuerza de voz eso nadie lo puede negar pero ese tema creo q solo tiene un ritmo y es la del rock, esta version le cae muy mal al tema ¬¬ y como dijo cris arriba Mizuki Nana xD

[ryoko159]

@llltonysk8lllhotm tienes razon prefiero la otra vercion aunq esta tampoco esta mal viva hirano aya!! :D

[SoSaySab]

สวยงาม มากครับ 

[Chrisxpo]

canta mal nu me gusta -,- no cambio a mi mizuki nana

[Talhos]

@Chrisxpo Pues la verdad es que si canta mal yo no me he dado cuenta. Y aunque la verdad es que si que me gusta mucho mas Mizuki Nana, Aya Hirano también me gusta, tiene una voz muy característica.

[Chrisxpo]

si igual tiene voz buena hirano pero no en vivo XDD solo cuando le areglan la voz en cambio mizuki nana canta jenial de las dos formas en vivo y en cds LOLLLL eso pz

[carem1993]

Hirano Aya si es una gran cantante pues aun con filarmonica tiene una hermoza voz

y no se si la han oido hablar en español bueno lo poco que habla se oye muy bonita su voz

bueno que buen video gracias por subirlo

[nicolasrull]

@carem1993 me pone to bruto jajajaja oirla en español xd.

[andycave73]

Espectacular!, formidable la presentación con la orquesta filarmónica.

[yuki13izumi]

why r the top comments in a language that i can't speak!! :(

[Stargrey]

@yuki13izumi Cos' life never is fair ;)

[TheJimiSlayer]

@yuki13izumi Maybe 'cause the ones who speak spanish, make the best comments

Quizás porque los que hablamos español, hacemos los mejores comentarios

[Tunechi241]

@yuki13izumi because the song too lol

[aaa159]

@yuki13izumi The channel of the person who uploaded this, and the description of the video are in spanish. So, what did you wait? Oh, I forgot Youtube is only for english-speakers... ¬¬ And you have more than 20 thumbs up, wtf is happening in this world?

[aaa159]

@jamescuacatan Thanks, captain obvious. Do you think I care what is your opinion about my english? Bye :D

[aaa159]

@jamescuacatan Btw, you understood me. So, it's not that bad :D

[rktguy]

@yuki13izumi not anymore :P assuming u speak english

[yuki13izumi]

@rktguy ;P

[mizukisc]

this is why i play violin... <33333333

[saraissara099]

@mizukisc ME TOO!!! T.T!

[knifegkn]

Sugoi!!!

[yuki13izumi]

why is there a guy who swings his stick when they have sheet music?? never got the idea of it....I mean they're not even looking at him....:\

[realtremil]

@yuki13izumi well if you get off beat. the way they move is in time with the music and you can get back on track. and also know when to get louder or softer.or when theres a pause. his there for a lot of reasons XD

[yuki13izumi]

@realtremil oh okay I totally get it! wow seriosly you've got alot of information about this while I just keep wondering looking like a fool I envy you! anyway thanx! :)

[realtremil]

@yuki13izumi well im in band at my school so i kinda have to know these things. your welcome.

[pgmfuentes]

@realtremil by the way, there's this person called a concertmaster right? Is he in charge of the violins only? or the whole?

[realtremil]

@pgmfuentes sorry i wouldnt know about that. thats an orchestra only thing i think

[yuki13izumi]

@realtremil A Band?! wow thats super cool..I wish I was at a fucking band! :)

[oliviasandra]

wow classical version. o.o awesome... (;

[blueMizore]

jajaja xD es gracioso escuchar esta cancion version instrumental xDD, desps de haber escuchado la version rockerona jojojo pero esta genial ;D

[WallE2512]

So lovely!

[EzeWong]

OH my god, she is so off sync. God Knows why it's so bad.

[liukolun]

@EzeWong Please wait until you can do it better than her then you criticize her

[EzeWong]

@liukolun Poor basis of the bar. Who's to say I can't? You've never heard me sing. And it doesn't take a garbage man to know the difference between caviar versus junk. She IS bad and the only reason people can't tell is because they are so hooked on animes they'll like her because the song's catchy but ignore their senses of auditory virtuoso. Nana Mizuki is a real artist, she at the very least has background in enka and can oscillate. Hirano cannot control her vibrato, pitch, sync or tone.

[liukolun]

@EzeWong That is why I am asking you to post a video singing this song. They you can prove once and for all "You have the skills and knowledge to criticize her." It is as simple as that. So, once you are able to show with video prove that you are better and more knowledgeable, then I will submit to what you say.

[EzeWong]

@liukolun Then why wouldn't I ask you to also post a video to defend her? If you're going to imply she is decent or validate your opinion, you'll also have to post a video. Her vocal abilities are not synced to the conductors, anyone can tell that. She's off cue in many instances. 1:25 to 1:40 is a mess. She even cups her ears, the headphones are a psychological desire of cognitive recollection. She's mentally trying to go back to the recording studio because she knows somethings not right.

[EzeWong]

@liukolun Also, don't get me totally wrong. She's pretty good in some of her songs.... (not the live guitar version that's even worse) Her recorded version is very good, which maybe why I'm so critical of her live. She's almost as starkly divergent as Ayumi Hamasaki, from recorded to live. (Ayumi's f***ing the worst live). So far the best I've seen of Hirano (AND out of her element) is discotheque with nana.

[liukolun]

@EzeWong Right now the person who is attacking is the one who needs to have evident. Right now your evident is your knowledge of music, which I am not saying you are wrong. However, just like all great papers, you have to one demonstrate your skills by applying your knowledge OR you will have to get evident from someone who has a degree in music that has wrote a paper on how to sing. There are many more other ways to prove it but you have to have something to back it up.

[liukolun]

@EzeWong So far I would agree with you that her sing in the recording room are a lot better. However, you would have to keep in mind that a lot of people choose to be a voice actor because their face won't be seen. It would take a lot of courage to step out into the open when you are used to the recording room.

[Melablood]

@liukolun sadly, he is right. aya does not perform well on stage. at least, not yet she hasn't learnt how.

[masnak1994]

@AW9CCC

なにしにこの動画に来たの？

聴きたくないなら聴かなくていいし、他人をけなすのは暇人だけだ­よ・・・　自分見直して

バラエティーで平野綾の顔みたくないんならチャンネル変えればい­いことだし。

暇な時間を使ってボイトレしてみてはどうかな？

不快な気持ちにさせたのなら改めて誤るよ。

あ、それともう一つ。歌は誰にだって歌える（平野綾でもキミでも­）。トレーニングしだいだよ＾＾　人の自由さ～

歌が上達するよう応援してるよ。がんばってね！　長文でごめんね＾＾；

[Willyserapio]

Solo una diosa se le puede comparar en belleza y talento

[TheMarcechan]

Dios es lo mejor de lo mejor casi lloro AYA HIRANO FOREVER!!!<3<3<3

[crisshinto]

Alguien sabe donde puedoi bajar el mp3 de esta cancion en esta vesion?



[69karuno]

esto es lo mas perfetcoo qe e escuchado y visto :DDDDDDDDDDDDD AYAAAAAAAAA ERES UNA DIOSAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA <3

[villaltita]

Aya Hirano es una Diosa y es la mujer que mas respeto y amo viva aya hirano!!