Added: 2 years ago
From: goronhandmc
Views: 38,427
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (129)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ギター素晴らしい。けどやっぱりマーキーが良かったなぁ。

  • I think Halca does a good job with this song - she brings different emotion to it than Maki did. 

  • In my opinion, HALCA, although a decently strong vocalist, doesn't make a good fit for this song simply b/c her vocals are not as "Pop-ish" as Maki's. She fails to hit those high notes as well.

    As for stage presence, Maki was a lot of fun. I remember those days of her hopping around the stage. haha. <3 She really was a ball of energy!

    R.I.P. Haikara *tears*

  • I asked Halca is how does she feel when her haters wants Maki. She said she doesn't mind at all.

  • I still love this song.. the comment box if full of my comments xD

  • people who kept criticizing and comparing halca to maki are I think the ones to blame for the disband....... maybe a little ......... you guys happy now -.- .... why won't you guys just be content back then and accept the slight change.. now they're gone... I hope they get back together....

  • @distortish A disband band will always have a reunion.. I'm actually annoyed to Halca Haters. I actually like Halca... I mean she's trying her best..

  • Halca is great she's just nervous

  • Comment removed

  • @ascendead1 How can you say Maki is annoying? Do you know her very well? She's nothing in what you said. Because Maki's band mates think of her as a sister. Maki is the vocalist that's why she's like the main character/heroine of "H&MC" along with the hero Yusuke. Don't judge the person that you don't even know very well. :3

  • maakii maki maki maki maki maki maki maki ;D

  • Ha, 8 people accidentally clicked dislike.

  • 0:00 - 0:44 the mic have problem?

  • this was one of her very first performances~ and i think she did well for a girl who was under intense pressure.

    check out her Sakura Con performance to see how much she improved in such a short time :).

  • she's the true rock artist unlike maki who suited for nico nico cutie thing. the sad thing is that HMC has the vocalist they been waiting for that fans will look HMC as a whole band fairly and square not just the girl vocalist alone but the disbanded.

  • Halca scares me... Shes like... The true gothic punk artist...

  • Yuusuke's microphone isn't working XD

  • @zabgab you could be right in that...anyways i still think that she looks to sad or apathic for the band...never the less...i still like them

  • i've been listening to HAMC since 2005 i still remember their first single, pride..

    but to be honest Halca has a more powerful voice than makii (i favor halca strongly) although some songs doesn't suit halca.. but halca is halca and makii is makii the only person you can't replace in HAMC is Yuuske and mackaz (coz mackaz is my fave XD) ,v,,

  • this is really cool

  • i miss you maki TT Halca's!! nice but i like maki

  • @luvyukirin as much as I like Maki's version better, I think Halca suits better for this type of band, Maki looked displaced.

  • i dont like

  • Halca isn't better singer than Maaki nor live nor studio i won't say she has a awful voice but i mean Maaki not only had a great voice she also had energy, life, an innocent feel and she really had fun in their concerts, she's just standing there with a super serious face and pose...Maaki just get a divorce and come back if u want i can make u company :p

  • @EoTMagni halca is loads time better at singing live but maki did have more energy makis voice was only decent in studio versions imo. maki couldnt hold a steady note to save her life.

  • @UlquiorrasMurcielaga well that's your opinion mate...i prefer maaki's voice over halca's i mean PRIDE be it live or studio is amazing with halca's still surprising but not amazing and dude count the pro-maaki comments and the pro-halca comments i'm not the only one saying this...

  • @EoTMagni I don't think Halca lacks of energy..I just think she was nervous because she's not used to it. she doesn't have the experience that Maki has. Also, she has to deal with the fact that everyone expects her to be as good as Maki so I think she looked more like she was focusing. If she had more time she would have been a really good performer because she already is.

  • Halca ruined this song for me D: Maki come back!!!!

  • @cheesemanjeff You are so right!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Ok this is my all time favourite HIGH and MIGHTY COLOR song and Halca has ciompltely ruined it for me, her voice doesn't suit old H&MC songs and im so angy they didn't do how they did with ACDC and not play old music with a new singer.

    Her voice sounds terrible for this song, whether shes tired after a large concert or not, its so flat, dull and not hiugh enough compared to OVER with Makii, im dissapointed in her and im kinda glad they are disbanding

  • I like Maki's soft voice instead of HALCA's deep voice

  • It's Halca's voice. It's very deep... Meh..

  • its nice i think but i prefer Maki in the older songs of HandMC... sorry, Halca can't sing correctly the tones... it sounds terrible, I can't listen anymore to their old songs with Halca version... I really like her voice but in the songs from their latest album... So bad this band broke up few days ago :(

  • halca looks so uncomfortable loosen up girl!

    looks like HIGH and MIGHTY COLOR lost their energy... this saddens me greatly.

    not a halca hater just saying :) i honestly like the tone of her voice.

  • yeah.. halca has a deeper voice. She's pretty good in this. However Maki won't be forgotten :).

  • Halca>maki.

    Halca Haters can GTFO

  • I really miss Maki.. but even with halca in the band right now.. its sad that they are breaking up... and i have to admit.. the atmosphere in the live is different then when maki was in the band..

    +i also think halca should move abit more and not b so still

  • maki or halca! I don`t care! as long as the their music stands....

  • Maki e Halca,as duas fizeram Haikara ser uma banda mega foda!

  • i really like maki.. Maki is better than Halca . ^_^

    Halca was so stiff, she must show some real performance. hehe. I THINK that only Yusuke and other band members are entertaining the people :D

  • i really like maki.. Maki is better than Halca . ^_^

  • This is my first time hearing Halca and I love it >.<. Don't get me wrong I miss Maki but she is gone sadly. Halca rocks! Too bad they are disbanding soo soon wish they would keep going ppl need to give them a chance.

  • OK, look, I like both Maki and Halca... But Halca's vocals directly clash with Yuusuke's. See, Halca's vocals are lower-pitch, but also also significantly clearer. Yuusuke... Sounds like he has a vocal style influenced by Zack De La Rocha, his vocal tone is fairly gritty. It's not about the vocalist per se, it's about how a band functions as a group. don't get me wrong, i LOVE the new H&MC, but I'm used to hearing Maki's slightly-less-than-perfect vocals.

  • Maki was not very good live performances. But Halca is great)) In addition, Maki looked like j-pop star and reminded me of Aya Hirano x)) A Halca fits perfectly into the group.

  • gawds people. all of you witching about "maki". do you realize this amazing group is no longer together? partially, likely, because you can't accept change? Halca is a fantastic rock singer in High and Mighty Color ~ she hella fits their style better than Maki's pop'ish rock did

  • @keizokate thats what happens when a member like a vocalist or lead guitarrist leave the band, its over.

  • @MeisterStyx yeah i understand, it's just awkward. few weeks ago i got Re:ache in the mail, and the change, how halca worked herself into the group, is beautiful. there's so little need for them to break up, in my opinion, as their music is good, halca or maki

  • i prefer Maki than Halca

  • halca voice is so bad

  • @MeisterStyx yeh right, you're just a little jealous faggot. She's amazing

  • @wxyztobem halca is so good so amazing that the band is done for

  • She has a more solid voice than Maki. 50 year old husband ftw! Disgusting!!!

  • HALCA Is a B!TCH but she can sing good..........

  • @extransor12 HEY HALCA IS NOT A BITCH! >=O

  • I love Maki and halca, but halca fits the band better with her powerful deep voice.

    god I'm gonna miss them, such an awesome band like them shouldn't break up. H&MC forever

  • Halca's voice was very on par with Makiis!

  • Man a lot of people hate on Halca..give her some credit guys...There's only one Makii and no one can imitate her, but as a repalcement Halca is more than decent and can still hit the high notes...I prefer Makii, but I do think that Halca is a good replacement for her...she is a little bit stiff but her voice rocks, not as well as Makii, but can i ask something for all the haters: Can you even sing like her? I fnot then stop whining...she's the best they can do...and she's doing fine...

  • Maki was one of the best female rock performers I've ever seen. The reason is that, for pumping up a crowd, female perfomers are often at their best when they dance around like Madonna, Beyonce. Maki was actually like having Namie Amuro front a rock band (a good combination). But Halca is a real metal singer and women rock singers are usually more stiff like kiddie punk singer Avril Lavigne. Maybe it's the too cool rock attitude or maybe they literally dont feel like moving around.

  • she has nice vocals but i can't imagine her singing for example ,,hot limit" and it would be a great pity if they stopped playing it, 'cause in my opinion it's one of their greatest songs. Nevertheless i also don't think that people should compare her with Maki. They're totally different when we match their voices. But yea, she should move a little bit more in other way she will look too statically especially when compared to her band mates ;)

  • ...................I hate her deep voice

  • LOL timoteobrasil !

  • My god.. she doesn't move at all... Come on, she could move a little bit more! I know she will improve...

  • i like halcas voice better in Over

  • Legal... Demais!

  • Wow, just as good as Maki!!!

  • there performing today at Sakura-con!!!! they are awesome

  • i miss having someone wearing (kinda) colorful outfits on stage with them>>maakii

  • oh bad... her voice isn't good for the old songs .__.

    shes so emotionless... oh oh

  • Halca Is so Bealty "¬"

  • Halca so cute with that strong voice <3

  • OMG!!!!

  • Halca is like a statue... she doesnt move that much.

  • @UtopiaPoet Think of it this way, she has or had practically no experience onstage, so she tries her best as possible. She can be stiff, i'll admit it, but she has a powerful voice, u got to give her that much at least. She'll adjust eventually.

  • halca's voice is hot in this vid.

  • maki brings a nice balance to the songs, cos they are v hard rock and maki's sweetness balance them out a lil.

    but halca's voice is better at live performances

    both girls are good, just different

    halca mite look less harsh if she dyed her hair brown, maybe with a typical japanese fringe (altho then she risks looking like maki), n wear less black! u cant SEE her on stage!

    mite

  • Makii and Halca are both great. :)

  • i wan't makiiiii!!!!!!!!!!

  • Think she is still not used to performing...and she is really young compared to Maki....she need some time to break out of her shell

    Go all the way Halca!!!

    GO GO HMC!!!!

    One of the Best bands ever!!!..XD

  • Halca is good :) I feel like Maki puts more emotion to her music but they are both great!

  • Yusuke is a kick ass singer. Halca and Maki are both good :D Halca, however, is too stiff live.

  • I just noticed something, did Yuusuke's mic broke or something? At the start he used the wireless mic, but his voice didn't come out, then he changed to the wired mic.

  • HALCA more hardcore but stiff.. =_=

    I prefer Maaki's sweet voice and awesome stage presence. ^_^

  • Maki's voice had a disarming quality to it that lent this band mystery - they are heavy, and melodic for it, and Maki's voice, so oddly playful at turns, made it hard to really pin the band to any category, which I really appreciated about them. I admit that Halca is good at the technicalities of singing - she belts the notes rather effortlessly, but she, and the way she looks, just plays too neatly into the hard rock image. I wish she were less stiff too.

  • Although this is still good, I prefer Maki for this song. In the part where they sing 'High and mighty ryuu de!' (2:30), they changed how they sung it since Halca's voice is too deep to sing like how Maki used to, and it sounds kinda weird for me. But the rest is just fine though.

  • when they sing "High and mighty ryuude!" they should let the audience sing it, :)

  • get over, get over, get over

    and move on.

    that's all I can say. Halca ROCKS :D

  • you all crazy halca is so much better than maki. her voice fits there new style so much better and even the old songs like this one

  • her voice doesnt fit in this song.. her voice is to big and low

  • Halca ,voice power ,and carisma.

  • luv halca's voice. it's low. actually, i hate it when maaki tends to baby her voice. hahah..

  • xD!!!se queda sin micro

  • halca needs to be more active she looks bored

  • @1080terrieh yeah. thats what i also notice. she doesnt have stage presence. . maybe thats her style but still she needs to have her own signature

  • @1080terrieh too concentrate on singing. xD

  • ハルカ歌声はかっこいいけど、声量が無いのがなぁ

  • I prefer Maaki =p

  • halca is so much better live then maki ever was

  • Halca needs to loosen up, too tense, no emotions in her vocals, maybe in time. But she has the voice to power through all the old songs.

    Great job overall. Like Maki's version better though.

  • I kinda like it :) But watching it is kinda boring... no offence she needs to like walk around or something

  • halca's voice is lower than maki!

    good but maybe i just miss maki a lot!

  • No trying to be mean or anything maki kinda looked like a bird lol but halca is way hotter than maki!!!

  • HALCAAAAA Halca is a better singer in live than Maki *-*

  • @Dearbrotherx

    That's true. Did you see that one live performance where Makii was singing in an extremely low voice for Ichirin No Hana? I think it was just because she was tired, but still.

  • @fpsFALSE hey she was pregnant remember

  • @fpsFALSE hey maki was pregnant remember

  • @Dearbrotherx I like Maki better

    she is less Vampireish

  • @Dearbrotherx i agree maki's voice is more beautiful but for the H&MC songs haruka's voice fits better. more charisma and power.

  • @Dearbrotherx buy new ears ¬¬

  • @Dearbrotherx you can say that again :)

  • is halca a vampire?

  • now that you mention it......i wonder?

  • @timoteobrasil

    most likely

  • DAMN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...i like it........

  • Halca's singing is surprisingly awesome....

  • wow! super..rock..halca is so great vocalist..

    i have a video of this.. we covered this song..Over..

    ^_^

    hehe

  • I like the new songs with her. but it look like she's in the wrong place when she just stand still like this.

  • i agree, she has the voice but she needs to loosen up like maakii

  • Just as long as she doesn't do the "bouncy-hips-in-a-skirt" thing. That's Maki-chan's move.

  • @atjnAdfhhjea Yeh, no-one else does that do they -.- Being a fanboy seems to cause you to lose perspective. Maybe she needs to loosen up a bit, but vocally she is virtually faultless.

  • Only if you don't compare her to Maki, she has her good parts, but Maki's voice was incomparable

  • Thanks for the videos!! I like more live please...^o^...XD

  • fuckin awesome!!! keep 'em comin

  • DAMN!!!! Even it seems they got some mic. issue at the beggining the did it great....well I must say i like Makii version more for this song ^_^ coz of the energy she got ^_^ voices sound a LOT the same xD !!!

    Thanks for the videos!! u know where we can download it full?

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more