That's a damn good and powerful interpretation Melanie and that long sustain at the end was wonderful. From Steve with goose-bumps, and thanks for the song Mr Cohen.
hi Melanie,long time no chat ,i hope you are well keep up the good work ,hope you had a nice xmas and may i wish you all the best for the rest of the year ,regards Neil...ps you still happily marrried lol x
Lovely inside and out. Thanks for this, love that song. I have to agree 100% with Steve Fallon though, and i do hope that you can read his advice without defensiveness, as you do have much potential, more than many i have seen here on utube.
You remind me so much of Norah Jones...only better. However, I agree, the piano is covering up the beauty of your exqusite voice. Your talent is breathtaking....
You have too much potential to hear only compliments. First of all, the piano is too damn loud! I can't hear what you're singing--only a pretty voice that reminds me of Joannie Mitchell. The piano volume must be half that of the vocal. The voice must BE the song. The piano is too busy, too many notes. Simplify the accompaniment and sing as though your voice alone must carry the melody and convey the meaning.
Thank you for this advice. I really do appreciate it. My piano has a very bright sound. I guess I should decide whether I'm a pianist or a vocalist. I will consider your advice before I do more recording. Best wishes.
I agree most of the songs, the piano is way to loud. I don't know why she keep doing it like that. I saw a duet with her and a violin. Well the piano was so loud that it was a piano show not a duet lol. too bad
Ohhh Melanie, I had to come back too, to listen again! This time it has brought me to tears though! I'm know just a little emotional this week, but its just so beautiful Melanie and I thank you so much for sharing your Beautiful and Amazing Talent with all of us!!
You Are Truely Gifted and sing and play with such Love & Passion!!
melaniejsnow: MoC: We just had to return..So much here to watch and listen to..As Celebbb has always said..your abilities are second to none.YOu have given so much here..so much for the viewer. A gift to us all Thank you thank you. As always...love this performance, love all your work. big E huggies to you and your family. Hope the little one is still playing We remember our past promotion on your channel. many many many starz***************** sincree god bless meriah.jason. [ i c o E
Hi Melanie,how is the classiest looking lady on youtube today,hey dont get worried about my name,im not a stalker,its a long story lol,your one classy lady.p.s nice dress by the way,your English admirer
this is really an outstanding rendition! I've to appreciate evry performance that leaves the trotted paths of the well known... and this one does..thankyou! ;o)
Thank you so much. The joy of music is interpreting it the way you feel it. I'm glad you can appreciate that about my rendition. Have a great night.:)M
Good morning melanie,ive just woken up and thought what better wat than to take a look at the classiest lady on youtube,so here i am again,that husband of yours i hate him grrrrr,hes such a lucky lucky man lol
You are too cute. Thank you very much! You do flatter me so. I'll make sure I remind my husband about how lucky he is lol:)) Have a wonderful night!!-Melanie
Hi Melanie .... this is such a lovely version of a much beloved song. You have an outstanding voice and piano style...great presence! Piano is one of my favorite instruments.. beautifully done! Suze
You are a very talented lady, but I wonder if you are too talented! Your piano playing seemed way too comlicated for this song, which is a simple folk hymn.
Also, you sing in a "high class" accent, which spoils the rhyme of the words - "Do you?" and "outgrew you", "out drew you" should all be pronounced "Yah" to rhyme with "Hallelu-Yah"
Don't let me put you off - you have something very special :-)
Wow Melanie, I just saw this...it is brilliant. The piano is beautiful and your vocals are amazing. Your whole performance is absoloutly heartwarming! You made my day!
Great version, Melanie. Sounds better than Leonard Cohen's song. You added a touch of class to it. A beautiful woman elegantly playing the piano and singing like an angel. What more can one ask for? Five stars. Faved.
Hi George, You are such a sweetheart. I'm so glad you enjoyed this song. It's a pleasure for me to share my gifts. It warms my heart to think I might warm another's heart. Have a great day!
Simply wonderful, Melanie. Coindidentally Dutch TV show X Factor winner, Lisa also sang it last Saturday in the finals. I watched a few interpretations on youtube and liked Jeff Buckley's best. Well, and yours, but as your fan I might be somewhat biased...just slightly.
Great Melanie, beautifull voice and great pianist!! congratulations, it´s a very special song for a very special voice!! regards, from argentina , Diana
So worth the wait Melanie. Glad to see your doing well and your voice as strong and gorgeous as ever. Thank you for sharing this wonderful performance with us. Hope to hear more from you in the near future. Once again, amazing Melanie.
OMG! I've been begging a few friends to do this on piano, so this was a Giant treat for me! Absolutely incredible Melanie! Your piano skills are extraordinary and your voice was tremendous, can you tell I loved it? :)
the vocals are nice but certainly academic :) so this song sounds quite strange here. cheers!
Shizoeid 1 month ago
Beautiful thighs...
mortonbaychestnut 11 months ago
hey dear awesome vid & song .. kool tiffany lamp =))
joaquinR1stargate 1 year ago
I like the religious feeling of this song, you have a nice contralto voice! :)
uutbchh 1 year ago
That's a damn good and powerful interpretation Melanie and that long sustain at the end was wonderful. From Steve with goose-bumps, and thanks for the song Mr Cohen.
toonmunger 1 year ago
Very nice :)
michaelamiles 1 year ago
Hallelujah Beauty !
Peter1945 1 year ago
wonderful.....and you are very good looking too ! Did you make some DVDs ?
Halleluja !
Peter1945 1 year ago
great job, we enjoyed your version! thx for sharing.
StsSunnyCharlie 1 year ago
hi Melanie,long time no chat ,i hope you are well keep up the good work ,hope you had a nice xmas and may i wish you all the best for the rest of the year ,regards Neil...ps you still happily marrried lol x
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
very nice voice... 5*****
ERICROBILLARD1 2 years ago
Christmas is forever, not for just one day,
for loving, sharing, giving, are not to put away
like bells and lights and tinsel, in some box upon a shelf.
The good you do for others is good you do yourself.
Thank you Angel for your loving light
Rab x
RabAdamson 2 years ago
You have a beautiful voice - also very well controlled. That is a really pleasing combination of rich piano and voice.
karlmahlmann 2 years ago
Lovely inside and out. Thanks for this, love that song. I have to agree 100% with Steve Fallon though, and i do hope that you can read his advice without defensiveness, as you do have much potential, more than many i have seen here on utube.
Gr8stuffis 2 years ago
Thank you so much. I do welcome constructive advice without defensiveness. I will always be a student of music. Best wishes-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
You remind me so much of Norah Jones...only better. However, I agree, the piano is covering up the beauty of your exqusite voice. Your talent is breathtaking....
csereix 2 years ago
A very special talent.
CINEMAN8 2 years ago
Thank you very much!!:)
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Made this a fav
Great song
Love it
Terry !!
gherkamum 2 years ago
Love this track
Great vocals
5*********
atb Terry !!
gherkamum 2 years ago
Hi Terry! Thanks for making my day with your encouraging words!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
5 amazing friend ,,your an angel,,,absolutely ,,,FANTASTIC,,,YOUR PERFECT,,,,
bryanoverturf1 2 years ago
:)))Thank you!! Smiling ear to ear!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
You have too much potential to hear only compliments. First of all, the piano is too damn loud! I can't hear what you're singing--only a pretty voice that reminds me of Joannie Mitchell. The piano volume must be half that of the vocal. The voice must BE the song. The piano is too busy, too many notes. Simplify the accompaniment and sing as though your voice alone must carry the melody and convey the meaning.
SteveFallon1 2 years ago
Thank you for this advice. I really do appreciate it. My piano has a very bright sound. I guess I should decide whether I'm a pianist or a vocalist. I will consider your advice before I do more recording. Best wishes.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Comment removed
ulujm 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@SteveFallon1
I agree most of the songs, the piano is way to loud. I don't know why she keep doing it like that. I saw a duet with her and a violin. Well the piano was so loud that it was a piano show not a duet lol. too bad
ulujm 8 months ago
Wonderful playing wonderful singing
beautiful congratulations
Friedhelm
Piano541 2 years ago
I had a good feeling that you would enjoy her Friedhelm, what not to love, Melanie is Absolutely Gifted!!
CousinSusie 2 years ago
Melanie, its also in my Favorites now!!
CousinSusie 2 years ago
Ohhh Melanie, I had to come back too, to listen again! This time it has brought me to tears though! I'm know just a little emotional this week, but its just so beautiful Melanie and I thank you so much for sharing your Beautiful and Amazing Talent with all of us!!
You Are Truely Gifted and sing and play with such Love & Passion!!
This is Truely Remarkable!!
CousinSusie 2 years ago
Celebbb 2 years ago
Wonderful Melanie...You play and sing beautifully :-)
LadyWeaver 2 years ago
I love this song with all of my heart, Melanie! You perform it excellently, full of emotion!
zappatero7 2 years ago
Beautiful version!
Nos parece maravilloso tu trabajo, eres MUY TALENTOSA, excelente interpretación del Hallelujah y de todas las canciones de tus otros posts!
Gracias por permitirnos conocerte,
Congratulations!
Ruffo
SIETE SEGUNDOS
Sietesegundosgroup 2 years ago
Thank you so much for leaving me such a kind encouraging comment. Many blessings to you.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Ottimo davvero!!!
italianoettore 2 years ago
Just lovely playing and singing. Wonderful performance. Tracy
basicband 2 years ago
Thank you very much!! I appreciate you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
First rate!. Greetings from Miami.
EVELYNEMIL 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Have a great day!-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
You have an amazing body.
iRewel 2 years ago
Melanie,
I loved this performance!!!!! :) It is one of the best songs ever written and you just made it even better. Keep up your great talent!
-Nick
NADAgostino 2 years ago
Hi Nick, Thank you so much! What a very sweet comment. You keep up your great talent as well!-M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Absolutely Beautiful Melanie!
You play that piano so beautifully and your VOICE is the VOICE OF AN ANGEL!!
AWESOME VIDEO!!
I'm comin to sub you now!
CousinSusie 2 years ago
Hi Susie! Gee.. Thank you so much. I'm so flattered! I hope you are having a lovely Thursday!-:)Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow That was magnificent!!! Thanks Colleen for sharing!
jes941 2 years ago
You are just amazing Melanie! Love your cover of this. Love, Colleen
AuntieColleenxx 2 years ago
You are so sweet. Thank you, Colleen. I hope you have a wonderful day!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
such a wonderful job Melanie, I love your playing and your voice and your not hard to look at it either. Reg
jhaley12 2 years ago
Thank you Reg for making my day with such a sweet comment. Have a beautiful day!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Beautiful song and a beautiful lady there on piano!
Peace
Massy
bluebeardit 2 years ago
Thank you so much Massy. Have a great day!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow, really impressing!
Baumwollfell 2 years ago
Thank you so much!! I hope you are having a wonderful day!
AniXtremeStudios 2 years ago
Hi MELANIE you deserve so many more views,you are a true talent,maybe you should look like Susan,no im not going to say that,its just nasty lol
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
great version Melanie 5****Mel
amazongift 2 years ago
Thank you so much, Mel. Enjoy the day!:)-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Hi Melanie,
What a beautiful Voice, and you make the piano talk. A great video, of a great talent 5x1000***** no doubt at all
God bless you.
Your friend,
Tommy
1916Tom 2 years ago
Hi Tommy, Thank you so much for your kind comments. You are too sweet! Have a wonderful day.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow You Sound Awesome.
Midnitefantacy 2 years ago
Thank you so very much!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
WOW! Great Job! Awesome delivery! KUDOS & *****
ib2fast 2 years ago
Thank you so much. I appreciate your kind words. Best wishes!-M:))
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
What a wonderful voice, Melanie, one of the sweetest I ever heard... And nobody could not sing better this beautiful song.
All stars for this talented job. ******
ritacosgame 2 years ago
This is lovely, you have such a beautiful and smooth voice!! Wonderful and heartfelt job!:) 5******
sayalessandra2 2 years ago
Thank you so very much! Have a wonderful weekend!!:))
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
melaniejsnow : hi dear..Celebbb has lost touch with you...
melanie: this version .. as only you can do...percise..exact with personal emotion..richness and desire. Flawless.
We can only sit, watch and listen....dear as we have always known you for....
[ comforting to the mind....proffess.
melaniejsnow : thank you for this share ..this beautiful contribution to the world....
many many many many starz***************..Featured!
Excellent !!!
sincere
god bless
meriah.jason. [i c o E
Celebbb 2 years ago
Thank you, I am so flattered. You say the kindest words. I am glad you liked it. Your words of encouragement made my day. Best wishes:)-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Hey just because i aint posted you a good morning or anything dont think im not looking lol
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
:)))-Hope you are doing well!-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Hi Melanie,how is the classiest looking lady on youtube today,hey dont get worried about my name,im not a stalker,its a long story lol,your one classy lady.p.s nice dress by the way,your English admirer
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
wow Melanie - that is extraordinary. thanks!
See you soon? Susan
suezen52 2 years ago
Hi Susan, Thanks for dropping by my channel. We really need to stop talking about getting together and actually do it. Have a wonderful evening!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
this is really an outstanding rendition! I've to appreciate evry performance that leaves the trotted paths of the well known... and this one does..thankyou! ;o)
frozenwhitebear 2 years ago
Thank you so much. The joy of music is interpreting it the way you feel it. I'm glad you can appreciate that about my rendition. Have a great night.:)M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Oh my goodness! You are so talented! I love this cover! :) You are so great at piano! :) -Tiffany
TiffanyAnneMusic 2 years ago
Thank you so much Tiffany! I hope you have a great day. I always look forward to seeing/hearing your new postings!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Good morning melanie,ive just woken up and thought what better wat than to take a look at the classiest lady on youtube,so here i am again,that husband of yours i hate him grrrrr,hes such a lucky lucky man lol
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
You are too cute. Thank you very much! You do flatter me so. I'll make sure I remind my husband about how lucky he is lol:)) Have a wonderful night!!-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Hi Melanie .... this is such a lovely version of a much beloved song. You have an outstanding voice and piano style...great presence! Piano is one of my favorite instruments.. beautifully done! Suze
suuzzee5 2 years ago
Hi Suze, Thank you so much. Your thoughtful comment means a lot! Have a great weekend!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Very beautiful!!!!
laurianni 2 years ago
Beautiful voice and performance:)
*****
:)
Hilde
Lillemy1 2 years ago
beautiful.......stars...and smiles...:)
Kappa
Kappadanielson 2 years ago
Thank you! Smiles right back at ya!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Im in love lovely song,sung by a gorgeous looking lady.
Mrphantomstalker 2 years ago
I am so flattered! Thank you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Hi! Saw you in Rob's top ten.
You are a very talented lady, but I wonder if you are too talented! Your piano playing seemed way too comlicated for this song, which is a simple folk hymn.
Also, you sing in a "high class" accent, which spoils the rhyme of the words - "Do you?" and "outgrew you", "out drew you" should all be pronounced "Yah" to rhyme with "Hallelu-Yah"
Don't let me put you off - you have something very special :-)
Bill
gassyoldman 2 years ago
AWEEESOME hun!!!!
sistermoonshine13 2 years ago
Thank you VEEERy much!!:))
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Really great!
MNag70 2 years ago
Thank you so much. Best wishes.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow Melanie, I just saw this...it is brilliant. The piano is beautiful and your vocals are amazing. Your whole performance is absoloutly heartwarming! You made my day!
TTLYPerfect 2 years ago
Thank you so much. You are so sweet to leave me such encouraging comments. Have a wonderful day. You made my day too!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Too much piano! drowning your brilliant voice
daveshaw197126 2 years ago
Maybe you're right. I am really more of a pianist though, trying to be a vocalist. I'm glad you liked my vocals.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Exquisite and powerful,Melanie,your playing and vocal are flawless...Hallelujah! *****
tps607 2 years ago
Thank you so much. You made my day today! I hope your day is wonderful!-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Very wonderful cover!!! Thanks Tadeo!!!
Gaby.
pili2255 2 years ago
Hi Gaby, Thank you so much for viewing/listening and commenting. You're so sweet! I'll look forward to checking out your channel soon! Best wishes!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Great cover of one of my favorite songs, good job ! 5* A.D. :)) Thanks for sharing Tadek
4DRY4N 2 years ago
Thanks so much for checking out my video and for your kind comment.:)Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
OH! Tres Magnifique! You sing divingly! Wonderful song! BRAVO!
coolanddark 2 years ago
Thanks for your sweet and flattering comment. My best to you.-M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Exceptional :) xxx
mentalmoomin 2 years ago
Thank you so very much!!x-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Lovely singing and video!......Thanks for sending Rob! ;)
KarenEng 2 years ago
Hi Karen, thank you so much for viewing and your encouraging comments. Best wishes.-M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Fantastic performance and great voice and the beautiful version of this song
Bravo !
5*****
Thanks for share jugnutgut2 !
Tadek59 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Have a great day!:)
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
wow, this is amazing.
you are great!
boybrushedbrown 2 years ago
Thank you so much. you are sweet!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Una maravilla. Gracias, Melanie. Lino Bugallo, La Plata, Argentina.
linobuga 2 years ago
Used es tan dulce para dejar un comentarro tan amable. Tienen un maraviellosodia!!:)Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
exelente!!!! y felicitaciones.
saludos
pablo asnaghi from argentina
pabloasnaghi 2 years ago
gracias tanto! Me alegro le gusto esto. Felicidades!-Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Great version, Melanie. Sounds better than Leonard Cohen's song. You added a touch of class to it. A beautiful woman elegantly playing the piano and singing like an angel. What more can one ask for? Five stars. Faved.
EstebanChurches 2 years ago
What a sweet comment! Thank you for making my evening!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
beautifull feeling, beautiful voice ande beautiful legs. :-) Jo
brixia58 2 years ago
Hi Jo, Thank you so much! I think I'm blushing!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow; really beautiful singing & playing
~amy
amccann7 2 years ago
thank you for your replay; don't blush.
You're touch and your vocalism is very fine.
I hope to see you soon with guitar. Hve a good week end.
brixia58 2 years ago
Absolutely Superb!
Beautiful Rendition!
Thank you very much!
Have a lovely day!
Best wishes
Phil
universe62 2 years ago
Hi Phil-You're so sweet to leave me such a comment. It made my day. Have a wonderful weekend.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Thank you so much for such an encouraging comment, Phil. Have a wonderful evening.-Melanie:)
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
great work! top*****
best regards, harmusic
harmusic 2 years ago
Thank you very much! Best wishes to you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
nice arrangement on this, I've heard so many versions, but this is traditional and one of my favorite!
magicalmerk 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Have a great weekend.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
OMG that is awesome!
really beautiful!
im also working on this song with a friend, but it's played on my guitar =D
you are awesome girl
keep it up
acousticanaetati 2 years ago
Cool. I'll look forward to hearing your version. I'm sure it will be great. Thanks for viewing/commenting. Have a great weekend!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
So very Beautiful...
reliablebow 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Have a good night.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Had to come back for seconds!
What a beautiful way to end my day...
God has truly blessed you child.
Thanks again for your generosity to the music world!
groberson2007 2 years ago
Hi George, You are such a sweetheart. I'm so glad you enjoyed this song. It's a pleasure for me to share my gifts. It warms my heart to think I might warm another's heart. Have a great day!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Beautiful, just Beautiful ! 100**s
Lisa3577 2 years ago
Thank you so much Lisa. My best wishes out to you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wonderful... I love this song, the music was lovely. *****
zazamaxi 2 years ago
Simply wonderful, Melanie. Coindidentally Dutch TV show X Factor winner, Lisa also sang it last Saturday in the finals. I watched a few interpretations on youtube and liked Jeff Buckley's best. Well, and yours, but as your fan I might be somewhat biased...just slightly.
evado68 2 years ago
Cool! Thank you for being my fan! You're too sweet. Have a great night!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Great Melanie, beautifull voice and great pianist!! congratulations, it´s a very special song for a very special voice!! regards, from argentina , Diana
dianabellone 2 years ago
Hi Diana, Thank you so much! Your encouraging words mean a lot to me!xx:)
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Good job.
jlspielman1 2 years ago
Thank you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
This lifted us to the stars!
5 *****s and more!
Thanks for sharing with the world...xxx...
groberson2007 2 years ago
I'm so happy you enjoyed it. Your kind words mean a lot to me. Best wishes.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
This is excellent *****
bigeeezy 2 years ago
Thank you so much! Have a great rest of the week.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
So worth the wait Melanie. Glad to see your doing well and your voice as strong and gorgeous as ever. Thank you for sharing this wonderful performance with us. Hope to hear more from you in the near future. Once again, amazing Melanie.
Mark
NikonPhoto07 2 years ago
Hi Mark, Thank you so much. You are always such an encouragment to me. -Melanie
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Absolutely gorgeous, Melanie.
spdrennan 2 years ago
Thank you so much!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Cool dress, lovely voice.
ShakespearesFool 2 years ago
Thank you! I'm glad you liked it.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
This is such a beautiful song! You did a great job.
sarahlacroixmusic 2 years ago
Thank you for checking it out and for your kind comment!:)
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Beautiful!!!!
RobertoFasciano 2 years ago
Thank you!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Wow! Just beautiful!!
Johnfern99 2 years ago
Thanks so much!
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
Great performance and beautiful woman.
ArthurClairFR 2 years ago
Thanks for your view and flattering comment. Best wishes.
melaniejsnow 2 years ago
OMG! I've been begging a few friends to do this on piano, so this was a Giant treat for me! Absolutely incredible Melanie! Your piano skills are extraordinary and your voice was tremendous, can you tell I loved it? :)
jugnutgut2 2 years ago
I'm so glad you liked this one, Rob. You are so kind. My best to you.-M
melaniejsnow 2 years ago